Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T19:08:45.388Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Revisionism Reconsidered: Kang Youwei and the Reform Movement of 1898

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Young-Tsu Wong
Get access

Extract

The reform movement of 1898 sought to move the Qing empire toward comprehensive and unprecedented institutional change and thus was a critical event in modern Chinese history. Had it succeeded, China could have, like Meiji Japan, entered the modern era without revolutions. Yet, however determined and daring its leaders, the historic effort was suddenly and tragically cut short by a coup.

The standard view of the Reform Movement has been that, in reaction to China's repeated defeats and humiliation as well as the inadequacy of the Self-strengthening Movement, the reform-minded Kang Youwei (illustration 1) and Liang Qichao finally won support for change from a sympathetic Guangxu Emperor. The reformers then managed to put into effect a nationwide reform program through imperial decrees. But the movement, which lasted barely over one hundred days, came to an abrupt end when the Empress Dowager Cixi and her conservative supporters recaptured political power, executed or imprisoned many of the reformers, and placed the emperor under permanent house arrest.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 51 , Issue 3 , August 1992 , pp. 513 - 544
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Yongnian, Bi. 1986. “Guimou zhiji” [A plain account of the plot], 1–4 in Jindai shi ziliao [Sources on modern history], 63 (December).Google Scholar
Hao, Chang 1980. “Intellectual Changes and the Reform Movement, 1890–98,” 274–338, in The Cambridge History of China, 11.2, ed. Fairbank, John K. and Liu, Kwang-Ching. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Hao, Chang 1987. Chinese Intellectuals in Crisis: Search for Order and Meaning, 1890—1911. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
CFHA [Chinese First Historical Archives, or Zhongguo diyi lishi dang’an guan]. The archives used for this paper include Wuxu bianfa zhuanti dang [The special archive on 1898 reform] in six bundles of large envelopes; lufudang [Duplication archive]/ waijiao lei [Diplomacy]/junji chu [Grand council]/shangyu [Decrees]; and suishou dengjidang [Constant recording archive] /waijiao lei [Diplomacy] Ijunji chu [Grand Council]/shangyu [Decrees]. These archival sources will be cited as CFHA followed by date and the name of the subarchive.Google Scholar
Huaxin, Chen 1985. “Kang Youwei Riben bianzheng kao de jige wenti” [Several questions concerning Kang Youwei’s Reform of Meiji Japan], 269—90, in Lun wuxu weixin yundong ji Kang Youwei Liang Qichao [On the reform movement of 1898 and Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao], Guangzhou: Guangdong renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Kuilong, Chen 1953. “Mengjiao ting zaji” [Miscellaneous writings from the Mengjiao Pavilion], 497—86, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 2, comp. by Jian Bozan et al.Google Scholar
Zhanbiao, Chen 1989. “Xinxue weijing kao chukan nian wenti” [Question about the first edition of the forged classics of the Xin Dynasty], 290–91, in Jindai shi yanjiu [Studies in modern history], 49 (January).Google Scholar
Wenjiang, Ding, comp. 1972. Liang Rengong nianpu changbian [The drafted chronological biography of Liang Qichao], 2 vols. Taibei: Shijie shuju.Google Scholar
Delin, Fang 1983. “Wuxu zhengbian shishi kaobian” [Studies in some historical facts about the coup of 1898], 235–83, in Wuxu weixin yundong shi lunji [Collected essays on the reform movement of 1898], ed. Shengwu, Hu. Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Guojia Dang’an JU [National archives]. 1958. Wuxu bianfa dang’an shiliao [Historical sources of the 1898 reform]. Beijing: Guojia dang'an ju.Google Scholar
Hsiao, Kung-Chuan. 1957. “Weng T’ung-ho and the Reform Movement of 1898,” 111—243. Tsing Hua Journal of Chinese Studies, New Series 1, No. 2 (April).Google Scholar
Hsiao, Kung-Chuan. 1975. A Modern China and a New World: K’ang Yu-wei, Reformer and Utopian, 1858–1927’. Seattle and London: University of Washington Press.Google Scholar
Sheng, Hu. 1981. Cong yapian zhanzheng dao wusi yundong [From the Opium War to the May Fourth movement], 2 vols. Beijing: Renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Hu Suing. 1953. “Wuxu lishuang lu” [The agony of 1898], 357–406, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 1, comp. Jian Bozan et al.Google Scholar
Mingtong, Huan G and xizhao, wu, eds. 1988. Kang Youwei caoqi yigao shuping [Critical studies of Kang Youwei’s early writings]. Guangzhou: Zhongshan daxue chubanshe.Google Scholar
Zhangjian, Huang 1970. Wuxu bianfa shi yanjiu [Studies in the history of 1898 reform]. Nangang: Zhongyang yanjiu yuan lishi yuyan yanjiu suo.Google Scholar
Zhangjian, Huang 1974. Kang Youwei wuxu zhen zouyi [The authentic 1898 memorials of Kang Youwei]. Taibei: Zhongyang yenjiu yuan.Google Scholar
Zhangjian, Huang 1988. “Zaitan wuxu zhengbian” [Discuss the 1898 coup again], in Dalu zazhi, Vol. 77, No. 5, pp. 193–99Google Scholar
Zhangjian, Huang 1989. “Zhuozhu wuxu bianfa shi yanjiu de zai jiantao” [Re-examination of my study on the history of 1898 reforms], pp. 729–68, in Zhongyang yanjiu yuan dierjie guoji hanxue huiyi lunwenji [Proceedings of the second international sinological conference hosted by the Academia Sinica]. Taibei: Zhongyang yanjiu yuan.Google Scholar
Jian, Bozan Et Al., comp. 1953. Wuxu bianfa [The reform movement of 1898], 4 vols. Shanghai: Shenzhou guoguang she.Google Scholar
Guilin, Jiang 1978. Wanmu caotang yigao waibian [Supplementary volumes of Kang Youwei’s manuscripts], 2 vols. Taibei: Chengwen chubanshe.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1897. Shang Qingdi diwushu [The fifth memorial to the Qing Emperor]. Beijing: Block-printed edition. Rare edition can be found in Beijing Library and the library of Peking University.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1898. Jieshi shangshu huilu [Collected memorials by a distinguished scholar], 2 vols. Unpublished. Library of Palace Museum, Beijing. See also PML.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1911. Wuxu Zougao [The draft memorials of 1898], Mai Zhonghua, comp. Yokohama, Japan.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1967. “Chronological Autobiography of K’ang Yu-wei,” 17–174, in K’ang Yu-wei: A Biography and a Symposium, ed. Lo, Jung-pang. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1976. Kang Nanhai xiansheng yizhu huibian [Collected works of Kang Youwei], 22 vols. Taibei: Hongye shuju.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1981. Kang Youwei zhenglun xuanji [Kang Youwei’s political writings], 2 vols., Zhijun, Tang, comp. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang 1986. “Kang Youwei disanci shang Qingdishu yuanben” [The original version of Kang Youwei’s third memorial to the Qing Emperor], in Lishi dang’an [Historical archives], No. 1, pp. 40—50.Google Scholar
Xiangji, Kong 1986. “Weng Tonghe yu bairi weixin guanxi tanxi” [An examination of Weng Tonghe’s relations with the Hundred Days’ Reform], 80–88. Qinghai shehui kexue [Qinghai social sciences], Vol. 6. Xi’ning.Google Scholar
Xiangji, Kong 1988a. Kang Youwei bianfa zouyi yanjiu [Studies in Kang Youwei’s reform memorials]. Shengyang: Liaoning jiaoyu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Xiangji, Kong 1988b. Wuxu weixin yundong xintan [New studies on the 1898 Reform Movement], Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Kwong, Luke. 1984. A Mosaic of the Hundred Days: Personalities, Politics, and Ideas of 1898. Cambridge, Mass.: Council on East Asian Studies, Harvard University.Google Scholar
Wenhai, Li and Xiangji, Kong. 1986. “Jian’guo yilai wuxu bianfa shi yanjiu gaishu” [A general discussion of studies in the history of 1898 Reform since 1949], 1–65, in Wuxu bianfa [The Reform of 1898], ed. Wenhai, Li and Xiangji, Kong. Chengdu: Bashu shushe.Google Scholar
Qichao, Liang 1936. Wuxu zhengbian ji [On the coup of 1898]. Shanghai: Zhonghua shuju.Google Scholar
Keguang, Lin 1990. Gexinpai juren Kang Youwei [The great reformer Kang Youwei]. Beijing: Zhongguo renmin daxue chubanshe.Google Scholar
Danian, Liu 1982. “Wuxu bianfa de pingjia wenti” [Questions concerning the interpretation of the 1898 Reform], 131–61, Jindai shi yanjiu 4 Beijing.Google Scholar
Honglin, Ma. 1988. Kang Youwei dazhuan [A large biography of Kang Youwei]. Shenyang: Liaoning renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
PML [Palace Museum Library, or Gugong bowuyuan tushu guan] Possesses the unpublished copy of eighteen memorials presented by Kang in 1898, which was originally compiled, presumably when they were received, by the Imperial Household in three thread-bound volumes entitled Jieshi shangshu huilu [Memorials of a distinguished scholar]. It was first discovered inside the Zhaoren Hall, the Guangxu Emperor’s study. The Sixth Memorial is among them. All memorials i n this set were arranged in a chronological order. This source is cited in this paper as PML followed by date and number of juan.Google Scholar
Price, Don. 1986. Review of A Mosaic of the Hundred Days by Luke S. K. Kwong. Journal of Asian Studies 45, 2: 381–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shilu. 1938. Daqing dezong jing huangdi shilu [The veritable records of the Guangxu Emperor]. Mukden: Manzhou guowu yuan.Google Scholar
Qinglan, Song 1983. Kang Youwei. Jiangsu: Renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Soothill, William E. 1926. Timothy Richard of China. London: Seeley Service and Co.Google Scholar
Jizu, Su. 1953 “Wuxu chaobian jiwen” [The 1898 coup I heard], 320–55, in Vol. 1, Wuxu bianfa, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Xiaoen, Sun 1985. Guangxu pingzhuan [A critical biography of the Guangxu Emperor]. Shengyang: Liaoning jiaoyu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Sitong, Tan 1979 Tan Sitong quanji [The complete works of Tan Sitong]. Taibei: Huashi chubanshe.Google Scholar
Zhijun, Tang 1981. Wuxu bianfa renwu zhuangao [Draft biographies of personalities related to the Reform of 1898], 2 vols. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.Google Scholar
Zhijun, Tang 1984. Wuxu bianfa shi [A history of the 1898 Reform]. Beijing: Renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Erming, Wang and Shanwei, Chen, comps. 1988. Jindai mingren shouzha zhenji [The facsimile letters of modern celebrities]. Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press.Google Scholar
Kangnian, Wang 1986. Wang Kangnian shiyou shuzha [Letters of Wang Kangnian’s teachers and friends]. 4 vols. Shanghai: Guji chubanshe.Google Scholar
Wang, Rongzu [Young-Tsu Wong]. 1982. “Lun wuxu bianfa shibai de sixiang yinsu” [The intellectual factors of the failure of the 1898 Reform], 143—60. Jindai shi yanjiu No. 13 (July).Google Scholar
Wang, Rongzu [Young-Tsu Wong]. 1988. Kang Zhang helun [A comparative study of Kang Youwei and Zhang Binglin]. Taibei: Lianjing chuban shiye gongsi.Google Scholar
Shi, Wang 1986. Weixin yundong [The Reform Movement]. Shanghai: Renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
Xiaoqiu, Wang 1984a. “Ping Kang Youwei de sanbu waiguo bianzheng kao” [Comments on Kang Youwei’s three works on reform in foreign countries], 3–9. Beifang luntan [North China Review], No. 6. Harbin.Google Scholar
Xiaoqiu, Wang 1984b. “Wuxu weixin qijian Kang Youwei zhengzhi zhuzhang de zai tantao” [A re-examination of Kang Youwei’s political views during the Reform of 1898]. Shehui kexue yanjiu [Social sciences studies], No. 4. Chengdu.Google Scholar
Wang, Zhao 1953a. “Ke Zhang Yinhuan zougao” [Draft memorial impeaching Zhang Yinhuan], 355–56, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 2, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Wang, Zhao 1953b. “Guanyu wuxu zhengbian zhi xin shiliao” (Some new sources concerning the coup of 1898),” in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 4, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Zhao, Wang. 1964. “Wuxu liuyue libu daidi zuogao” [The Memorial I asked the Board of Rites to deliver in June of 1898], ce 4, juan 1, 1–6, in Shuidong quanji [The complete works of Wang Zhao]. Taibei: Yiwen yinshuguan reprint.Google Scholar
Yuankuang, Wei 1953. “Weishi quanshu” [Mr. Wei’s works], 310–14, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 4, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Tonghe, Weng 1925. Weng Wengong gong riji [The diary of Weng Tonghe]. Shanghai. Taibei: Shangwu yinshu guan reprint, 20 volumes.Google Scholar
Wong, Young-Tsu. 1990. Rejuvenating a Tradition: Reform and Revolution in Modern China. New York: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Tianshi, Yang 1985. “Kang Youwei mouwei yiheyuan busha xitaihou quezheng” [Firm evidence about Kang Youwei’s anti-dowager plot], in Guangming ribao [The Guangming daily], September 4, p. 3.Google Scholar
Shikai, Yuan 1935. Yuan Shikai jiashu [Family letters of Yuan Shikai]. Shanghai: Zhongyang shudian.Google Scholar
Shikai, Yuan 1953. “Wuxu riji” [My 1898 diary], 549–56, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 1, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Yuding, Yun 1953. “Chonglin chuanxin lu” [A truthful account about the throne], 471–78, in Wuxu bianfa, Vol. 1, Jian Bozan et al., comp.Google Scholar
Xianpei, Zhong 1988. Kang Youwei sixiang yanjiu [Studies in Kang Youwei’s thought]. Guangzhou: Guangdong gaodeng jiaoyu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Zhuoan, Zhong 1986. “Wuxu bianfa zhong de Guangxu huangdi he Kang Youwei” [The Guangxu Emperor and Kang Youwei during the Reform of 1898, 283–301. In Li Wenhai and Kong Xiangji, eds., Wuxu bianfa.Google Scholar