Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T18:30:20.776Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Pakistani Urdu Creative Writing on National Disintegration: The Case of Bangladesh

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Muhammad Umar Memon
Get access

Abstract

In 1947, when Pakistan was created, scarcely any attention was paid to resolving the problems inherent in a culturally plural society. Existing institutions proved inflexible and new ones did not evolve to respond to the aspirations of the Bengali people. As a result, Pakistan was dismembered within twenty-four years of its birth. Contrary to expectations, Pakistan's national disintegration failed to generate analysis or debate among intellectuals. Via thematic analysis of a cross-section of Urdu creative writing about the events of 1971, the author of this article probes the mentality of selected writers, searching for their response to the disintegration of their nation. What is the meaning of Pakistani nationhood? How do the writers interpret the breakup of 1971? And what implications do their attitudes have for the issue of regional versus national identity? The author concludes that the ethos of the writers scarcely differs from that of their society—it is an ethos that might well have precipitated the 1971 crisis.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 43 , Issue 1 , November 1983 , pp. 105 - 127
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Ashcar, Mascūd. 1974. Āṅkhōṅ par dōnōṅ hāth [Eyes covered with both hands]. Multan: Khallāqīn.Google Scholar
Ashcar, Mascūd. 1974a. “Apnī apnī saĉĉā'iyāṅ” [Each has his truth]. Pp. 11–22 in Ashcar 1974.Google Scholar
Ashcar, Mascūd. 1974b. “Dukh jō mittî nē diyē” [Sorrows given by the land]. Pp. 23–37 in Ashcar 1974.Google Scholar
Ashcar, Mascūd. 1974c. “Dāb aur bi'yar kī thandī bōtal” [Coconut and a chilled beer bottle]. Pp. 38–59 in Ashcar 1974.Google Scholar
Ashcar, Mascūd. 1974d. “Bailā nā'ī rē joldī joldī” [Snatch from a Bengali folk song, meaning “hurry, there isn't time”]. Pp. 60–71 in Ashcar 1974.Google Scholar
Ashraf, Syed Ali, ed. 1973. Homage to Qazi Nazrul Islam on His Seventy-fourth Birthday. Karachi: University of Karachi, Bengali Literary Society.Google Scholar
Askari, M. H. 1973. “The Writers Condemn Themselves.” In Morning News (Karachi). July 11.Google Scholar
Bārī, Nadīm. 1975. “Dhākē kī baitī” [Daughter of Dacca]. Pp. 13–21 in his Vafā kt khushbū [The scent of loyalty]. Lyallpur: Aūj Publishers.Google Scholar
Ĉhandr, Krishan. 1959. “An-dātā” [Absolute lord]. Pp. 9–61 in his An-dātā [Absolute lord]. Delhi: Asia Publishers.Google Scholar
Fātima, Altāf. 1972. “Uskā jahannam-zār” [His/her hell]. In Sīp (Karachi), Pp. 34–48.Google Scholar
Haldar, Gopal. 1973. Kazi Nazrul Islam. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.Google Scholar
Hamaish, Ahmad. 1981. “Pākistān mēn unnīs sō sattar kē bacd kī na'ī urdū kahānī” [The new Urdu short story in Pakistan after 1970]. Pp. 525–35 in Urdū afsāna: rivāyat aur masā'il [Urdu short story: Tradition and problems], ed. by C¯, Gōpī and Nārang, . Delhi: Educational Publishing House.Google Scholar
The Hindustan Times. 1971. “Symposium Urges India to Help Bangla Desh.” April 1.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1973. shahr-e-afsōs [The city of sorrow]. Lahore: Maktaba-e-Kārvān.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1973a. “shahr-e-afsōs” [The city of sorrow]. Pp. 249–70 in Husain 1973.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1973b. “Vōh jō khō'ē ga'ē” [Those who got lost]. Pp. 9–28 in Husain 1973.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1981. Kaĉhvē [The turtles]. Lahore: Matbūcāt.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1981a. ‘Asīr” [Prisoner/s]. Pp. 46–54 in Husain 1981.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1981b. “Hindustān sē ēk khatt” [A letter from India]. Pp. 55–66 in Husain 1981.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1981c. “Kaĉhvē” [The turtles]. Pp. 73–92 in Husain 1981.Google Scholar
Husain, Intizār. 1981d. “Nīnd” [Sleep]. Pp. 67–72 in Husain 1981.Google Scholar
Islam, Nasir. 1981. “Islam and National Identity: The Case of Pakistan and Bangla Desh.” International Journal of Middle East Studies 13:55–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jahan, Rounaq. 1972. Pakistan: Failure in National Integration. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Jamāl, Akhtar. 1971. “Dūsrī hijrat” [A second migration]. In Funūn (Dec.):37–46.Google Scholar
Jamāl, Akhtar. 1973. “Pas-e-dīva]-e-zindāṅ” [Behind the prison wall]. In Funūn (Sept.-Oct.):24–32.Google Scholar
Jāvaid, Yūnus. 1967. “Us rāt kā dard” [The pain of that night]. Pp. 1–16 in his Tēz havā kā shōr [The howls of gusting wind]. Lahore: Kitābiyāt.Google Scholar
Jāvaid, Yūnus. 1974. “Kāṅĉ kā pul” [The bridge of glass]. In Savērā no. 47 (Jan.-Mar.): 79–88.Google Scholar
Kāmrānī, shāhid. 1972. “Sangam sē sangam tak” [From confluence to confluence]. In Sīp (Karachi), Pp. 184–90.Google Scholar
Khan, Fazal Muqeem. 1973. Pakistan's Crisis in Leadership. Karachi and Lahore: National Book Foundation.Google Scholar
Malik, Hafeez, ed. 1971. Iqbal: Poet-Philosopher of Pakistan. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Manzar, shahzād. 1972. “Yūtōpiā” [Utopia]. In Sīp (Karachi), Pp. 127–36.Google Scholar
Manzar, shahzād. 1980. “Dushman” [Enemy]. Pp. 590–96 in Takhlīqī Adab, pahlī kitāb [Creative literature: Book one]. Karachi: cAsrī Matbūcāt.Google Scholar
Memon, Muhammad Umar. 1978. “‘The Lost Ones’ (A Requiem for the Self) by Intizār Husain.” Edebiyāt, Ajournai of Middle Eastern Literatures 3, 2:139–56.Google Scholar
Memon, Muhammad Umar. 1980. “Partition Literature: A Study of Intizār Husain.” Modern Asian Studies 14:377–410.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Memon, Muhammad Umar. 1981. “Reclamation of Memory, Fall, and the Death of the Creative Self: Three Moments in the Fiction of Intizār Husain.” International Journal of Middle East Studies 13:73–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muftī, Mascūd. 1976. Ĉehrē [Faces]. Islamabad: Iqrā'.Google Scholar
Muftī, Mascūd. 1978a. Lamhē [Moments]. Islamabad: Iqrā'.Google Scholar
Muftī, Mascūd. 1978b. Rēzē [Smithereens]. Islamabad: Iqrā'.Google Scholar
Mujeeb, M. 1972. “Umrao Jan Ada.” Pp. 161–64 in his Islamic Influence on Indian Society. Meerut: Meenakshi Prakashan.Google Scholar
Parvīn, shugufta. 1979. ‘Alamiya-e-mashriqī pākistān kā asar urdū afsānē par” [The effects of East Pakistani tragedy on Urdu short story]. Master's thesis, University of Punjab.Google Scholar
Rahman, Mizanur. 1966. 3rd rev. ed. Nazrul Islam. Dacca: Tarun Pakistan Publishers.Google Scholar
Russell, Ralph. 1970. “The Development of the Modern Novel in Urdu.” Pp. 102–41 in The Novel in India, ed. Clark, T. W.. London: George Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Sadiq, Muhammad. 1964. A History of Urdu Literature. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Salik, Siddiq. 1977. Witness to Surrender. Karachi: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Sarvar, Parvīn. 1973(?). “Ghar āṅgan” [Home and courtyard]. In Nayā Daur (Karachi), nos. 63–64:151–82.Google Scholar
Sarvar, Parvīn. 1975(?). “Ĉirāghāṅ” [Illumination], In Nayā Daur (Karachi), nos. 69–70:158–77.Google Scholar
shahāb, Qudratu'l-Lāh. 1950. Nafsānē [Parody of afiānē, Urdu word for “short stories”]. Lahore: Maktaba-e-Jadīd.Google Scholar
shahāb, Qudratu'l-Lāh. 1961. Yā khudā [O God]. Karachi: Lark Publishers.Google Scholar
shahāb, Qudratu'l-Lāh. 1968. Māṅ-ji [Dear mother]. Lahore: Lahore Academy.Google Scholar
shahāb, Qudratu'l-Lāh. 1973. “Jangī qaidī aur adīb” [POWs and writers]. In Jang. July 6.Google Scholar
Suhail, Āghā. 1972(?). “Thikānā kahīn nahīn” [No place to go]. In Nayā Daur (Karachi), nos. 61–62:149–60.Google Scholar
Umm-e-cUmmāra, . 1973a. “Ba gunāh-e-bē-gunāhī” [Crime of innocence]. In Funūn (Jan.-Feb.): 107–16.Google Scholar
Umm-e-cUmmāra, . 1973b. “Kis kis kō apnāyā” [Whom did we not embrace]. In Funūn (July-Aug.): 81–90.Google Scholar