Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T18:15:20.027Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Secrecy, Spooks and Ghosts: Memoirs and Contested Memory at the CIA

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 January 2020

RICHARD ALDRICH  and
JULES GASPARD
RICHARD ALDRICH
Affiliation:
PaIS, University of Warwick. Email: [email protected].
JULES GASPARD
Affiliation:
Strand Campus, King's College London. Email: [email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The CIA is increasingly symbolic of major controversies in American foreign policy. It also presents the academic researcher with a fascinating paradox – since it is simultaneously secret and yet high-profile. In part, this is due to the CIA's willingness to allow former operatives to write memoirs. We argue that the memoir literature, authored by CIA personnel both high and low, together with others who worked alongside them, is now so dense that this allows us a degree of triangulation. Yet these memoirs are increasingly collective productions, involving censors, ghostwriters and teams of researchers, introducing conflicting voices into the text, and adding layers of separation between author and reader. We suggest that these ghosted memoirs, therefore, operate on several levels. For good or ill, these books shape the American public's perception of the CIA and should be studied closely, especially by those interested in the subjectivities of image management. This essay seeks to explore these issues by comparing four memoirs by CIA directors and acting directors who have served since 9/11.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 55 , Issue 3 , July 2021 , pp. 551 - 575
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press and British Association for American Studies 2020

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See Omand, David and Phythian, Mark, Principled Spying: The Ethics of Secret Intelligence (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Karabell, Zachary and Naftali, Timothy, “History Declassified: The Perils and Promise of CIA Documents,” Diplomatic History, 18, 4 (1994), 615–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Troy, Thomas F., “Writing History in CIA: A Memoir of Frustration,” International Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence, 7, 4 (1994), 397–411CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 By contrast, the history of the early CIA is increasingly driven by forensic archival research. See, for example, Wilford, Hugh, America's Great Game: The CIA's Secret Arabists and the Shaping of the Modern Middle East (New York: Basic Books, 2013)Google Scholar; Mistry, Kaeten, The United States, Italy, and the Origins of Cold War: Waging Political Warfare (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 See Dulles, Allen, Craft of Intelligence (New York: Harper & Row, 1965)Google Scholar.

5 Wark, Wesley K., “Struggle in the Spy House: Memoirs of U.S. Intelligence,” in Egerton, George, ed., Political Memoir: Essays on the Politics of Memory (London: Frank Cass, 1994), 302–29, 315Google Scholar.

6 Moran, Christopher R. and Willmetts, Simon D., “Secrecy, Censorship, and Beltway Books: The CIA's Publications Review Board,” International Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence, 24, 2 (2011), 239–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Moran, Christopher R., “From Confession to Corporate Memory: The Memoirs of CIA Director Richard M. Helms,” International History Review, 36, 1 (2014), 70–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Moran, Christopher R., Company Confessions: Revealing CIA Secrets (London: Biteback Publishing, 2015)Google Scholar.

9 Dulles, ix

10 Tim Shorrock, “What You Won't Find in the Ex-CIA Chief's Book: George Tenet Cashes in on Iraq”, Der Speigel, 8 May 2007, at www.spiegel.de/international/what-you-won-t-find-in-the-ex-cia-chief-s-book-george-tenet-cashes-in-on-iraq-a-481674.html, accessed 5 April 2019.

11 Schlesinger, Robert, White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2008)Google Scholar.

12 Moran, “From Confession to Corporate Memory,” 85.

13 Anne VanderMey, “It's a Great Time to Be a Ghostwriter,” Fortune Magazine, 5 Dec. 2015, at https://fortune.com/2015/12/05/ghostwriting-books, accessed 3 March 2019.

14 See Paul Farhi, “Who Wrote That Political Memoir? No, Who Actually Wrote It?”, Washington Post, 9 June 2014, at www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/who-wrote-that-political-memoir-no-who-actually-wrote-it/2014/06/09/8e89ccae-f00a-11e3-9ebc-2ee6f81ed217_story.html, accessed 14 March 2019. Hillary Clinton's approach recalls that of Churchill, Eden and Macmillan, who employed teams of researchers to produce fifteen volumes of memoirs between them.

15 Philip Bump, “‘Hard Choices’ Is a Good Example of Why Publishers Don't Disclose Advances,” New York Times, 26 June 2014, at www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/06/26/hard-choices-is-a-good-example-of-why-publishers-dont-disclose-advances, accessed 28 March 2019.

16 George Packer, “Can You Keep a Secret?”, New Yorker, 7 March 2016, at www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/03/07/michael-hayden-comes-out-of-the-shadows, accessed 23 Nov. 2018.

17 Hunter Davies, “Kiss and Tell,” The Guardian, 17 May 2008.

18 Ibid.

19 McKenna, Christopher D., “Writing the Ghost-Writer Back In: Alfred Sloan, Alfred Chandler, John McDonald and the Intellectual Origins of Corporate Strategy,” Management & Organizational History, 1, 2 (2006), 107–26, 108CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20 Schlesinger, Robert, White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008)Google Scholar.

21 Ibid.

22 Harlow notes if you submit a novel in 2018 the PRB write back saying it will get back to you in a year's time. David Priess interview with Marie Harf and Bill Harlow, 19 Feb. 2019, at www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-marie-harf-and-bill-harlow-cia-public-relations.

23 Leffler, Melvyn P., “The Foreign Policies of the George W. Bush Administration: Memoirs, History, Legacy,” Diplomatic History, 37, 2 (2013), 190–218CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 See, for example, chapter 27, “Special Operations,” in Rumsfeld, Donald, Known and Unknown: A Memoir (London: Penguin, 2011), 367–78Google Scholar.

25 Davies, Philip H. J., “Spies as Informants: Triangulation and the Interpretation of Elite Interview Data in the Study of the Intelligence and Security Services,” Politics, 21, 1 (2001), 73–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 See the optimistic note struck in Dujmovic, Nicholas, “Getting CIA History Right: The Informal Partnership between Agency Historians and Outside Scholars,” Intelligence and National Security, 26, 2–3 (2011), 228–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For a less optimistic view see Balaghi, Shiva, “Silenced Histories and Sanitized Autobiographies: The 1953 CIA Coup in Iran,” Biography, 36, 1 (2013), 71–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For more on triangulation in intelligence studies see Davies, “Spies as Informants”; and Gaspard, Jules J. S., “The Hidden Origins of Intelligence History: Rehabilitating the ‘Airport Bookstall’,” History, 102 (2017), 639–660CrossRefGoogle Scholar

27 On the CIA and film see Willmetts, Simon, In Secrecy's Shadow: The OSS and CIA in Hollywood Cinema 1939–1979 (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jenkins, Tricia, The CIA in Hollywood: How the Agency Shapes Film and Television (Houston: University of Texas Press, 2014)Google Scholar.

28 Fenster, Mark, “The Implausibility of Secrecy,” Hastings Law Journal, 65, 2 (2014), 15–41Google Scholar.

29 Melley, Timothy, The Covert Sphere (New York: Cornell University Press, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

30 Priess interview with Harf and Harlow.

31 Harlow has also served as assistant White House press secretary for foreign affairs and national security during both the Reagan and George H. W. Bush administrations.

32 Shorrock, “What You Won't Find in the Ex-CIA Chief's Book.”

33 See Zegart, Amy B., Spying Blind: The CIA, the FBI, and the Origins of 9/11 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Riebling, Mark, Wedge: From Pearl Harbor to 9/11 – How the Secret War between the FBI and CIA Has Endangered National Security (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2004)Google Scholar.

34 Moran, “From Confession to Corporate Memory,” 70.

35 Tenet, George with Harlow, Bill, At the Centre of the Storm: My Years at the CIA (New York: HarperPress, 2007)Google Scholar.

36 Willmetts, Simon, “The Burgeoning Fissures of Dissent: Allen Dulles and the Selling of the CIA in the Aftermath of the Bay of Pigs,” History, 100, 340 (2015), 167–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Richard J. Aldrich, “American Journalism and the Landscape of Secrecy: Tad Szulc, the CIA and Cuba,” ibid., 189–209.

37 Bob Woodward, “What We Have Here Is a Failure to Communicate”, Washington Post, 6 May 2007.

38 Michael F. Scheuer, “Tenet Tries to Shift the Blame. Don't Buy It,” Washington Post, 29 April 2007.

39 Ibid.

40 Feith, Douglas J., War and Decision: Inside the Pentagon at the Dawn of the War on Terrorism (New York: HarperCollins, 2008)Google Scholar.

41 Scheuer, Michael, Imperial Hubris: Why the West Is Losing the War on Terror (Washington, DC: Potomac Books, 2004)Google Scholar. See also Scheuer, “Tenet Tries to Shift the Blame.”

42 See Clarke, Richard, Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror (New York: The Free Press)Google Scholar; Berntsen, Gary, Jawbreaker: The Attack on Bin Laden and Al Qaeda. A Personal Account by the CIA's Key Field Commander (New York: Random House, 2005)Google Scholar; and Baer, Robert, See No Evil: The True Story of a Ground Soldier in the CIA's War against Terrorism (London: Arrow Books 2002)Google Scholar.

43 Clinton, Bill, My Life (London: Arrow Books, 2005)Google Scholar; Bush, George, Decision Points (London: Virgin Books, 2010)Google Scholar; Cheney, Dick, Cheney, with Liz, In My Time: A Personal and Political Memoir (New York: Threshold Editions, 2012)Google Scholar; Powell, Colin, Koltz, with Tony, It Worked for Me: In Life and Leadership (New York: Harper Perennial, 2012)Google Scholar; Rice, Condoleezza, No Higher Honor: A Memoir of My Years in Washington (New York: Broadway Books, 2012)Google Scholar. See also the official releases like the 9/11 Commission's report. See National Commission on Terrorist Attacks, The 9/11 Commission Report: Final Report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks upon the United States (authorized edn) (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2011)Google Scholar.

44 Tenet, Center of the Storm, 375–81. The word “unfortunately” appears frequently in the text.

45 Drumheller, Tyler, Monaghan, with Elaine, On the Brink: An Insider's Account of How the White House Compromised American Intelligence (New York: Carol & Graf, 2006)Google Scholar.

46 Jeffrey Goldberg, “Woodward vs. Tenet: The New Intelligence War,” New Yorker, 21 May 2007.

47 Best, Richard Jr., “What the Intelligence Community Got Right about Iraq,” Intelligence and National Security, 23, 3 (2008), 289–302CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48 Tenet, Center of the Storm, 434, 440.

49 The parallels between Schlesinger and Goss as unpopular White House political appointees are fascinating.

50 David Stoutmay, “C.I.A. Director Goss Resigns,” New York Times, 5 May 2006.

51 Hayden, Michael, Playing to the Edge: American Intelligence in the Age of Terror (New York: Penguin Press, 2016)Google Scholar.

52 Ibid., 20. On the CIA and state–private networks see Lucas, Scott, “Mobilizing Culture: The State–Private Network and the CIA in the Early Cold War,” in Carter, Dale and Clifton, Robin, eds., War and Cold War in American Foreign Policy 1942–1962 (New York: Palgrave, 2002), 83–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lucas, Scott, “Total Culture and the State–Private Network: A Commentary,” in Gienow-Hecht, Jessica and Schumacher, French, eds., Culture and International History (New York: Berghan, 2003) 206–14Google Scholar; Laville, Helen and Wilford, Hugh, eds., The US Government, Citizen Group and the Cold War: The State–Private Network (London: Routledge, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Packer, “Can You Keep a Secret?”.

54 Hayden, 348.

55 Ibid., 125.

56 Ibid.

57 See Gardner, Lloyd C., The War on Leakers: National Security and American Democracy, from Eugene V. Debs to Edward Snowden (New York: The New Press), 272Google Scholar.

58 Hayden, 220–22.

59 Rizzo, John, Company Man: Thirty Years of Controversy and Crisis at the CIA (New York: Scribner, 2014), 244–48Google Scholar.

60 Goldsmith, Jack, The Terror Presidency: Law and Judgment inside the Bush Administration (New York: Norton, 2007)Google Scholar. See also Goldsmith, , Power and Constraint: The Accountable Presidency after 9/11 (New York: Norton, 2012)Google Scholar.

61 Goldsmith, Power and Constraint, 219.

62 Hayden, 92–117.

63 Ibid., 103–4.

64 Ibid.

65 Panetta, Leon, with Newton, Jim, Worthy Fights Memoir of Leadership in War and Peace (New York: Penguin, 2014), 249–63Google Scholar. See also Felicia Schwartz, “Panetta Faults White House on Iraq Troop Presence,” Wall Street Journal, 2 Oct. 2014.

66 Panetta.

67 Ibid., 189.

68 Ibid., 201.

69 Ibid., 204–5, 272–73.

70 Ibid., 12–16.

71 Russell, J. A., “Innovation in War: Counterinsurgency Operations in Anbar and Ninewa Provinces, Iraq, 2005–2007,” Journal of Strategic Studies, 33, 4 (2010), 595–624CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

72 Panetta, 286, 415–18.

73 Carle, Glenn L., The Interrogator (New York: Nation Books, 2011)Google Scholar; Kiriakou, John, The Reluctant Spy (New York: Bantam, 2009)Google Scholar.

74 Panetta, 225–27, 229.

75 Ibid., 315–31.

76 Deanna Paul, “These Former Agents Say the CIA and NSA Are Censoring Them. Now They're Suing,” Washington Post, 2 April 2019.

77 Jeff Stein, “What Former CIA Head Leon Panetta Says Now about Torture,” Newsweek, 9 Oct. 2014.

78 Panetta, 222–23.

79 Morell, Michael, Harlow, with Bill, The Great War of Our Time: The CIA's Fight Against Terrorism – From Al Qa'ida to ISIS (New York: Twelve, 2015)Google Scholar.

80 See Helms, Richard and Hood, William, A Look over My Shoulder: A Life in the Central Intelligence Agency (New York: Random House, 2003)Google Scholar; Colby, William and Forbath, Peter, Honorable Men: My Life in the CIA (New York: Simon Shuster, 1978)Google Scholar.

81 Morell, Michael J., “The Turn to War: 11 September 2001. With the President,” Studies in Intelligence, 50, 3 (2014), 23–34Google Scholar.

82 David Sanger, “Ex-C.I.A. Official Rebuts Republican Claims on Benghazi Attack,” New York Times, 3 May 2015.

83 Entman, Robert and Stonbely, Sarah, “Political Scandals as a Democratic Challenge: Blunders, Scandals, and Strategic Communication in US Foreign Policy. Benghazi vs. 9/11,” International Journal of Communication, 12 (2018), 24–26Google Scholar.

84 Morell, The Great War of Our Time, 176–90.

85 Kaplan, Fred, Dark Territory: The Secret History of Cyber War (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2016), 239–55Google Scholar.

86 Morell, The Great War of Our Time, 282–301.

87 Scott Shane, “Acting C.I.A. Director, Michael J. Morell, Criticizes ‘Zero Dark Thirty’,” New York Times, 23 Dec. 2012.

88 Rodriguez, José, Hard Measures: How Aggressive CIA Actions after 9/11 Saved American Lives (New York: Threshold Editions, 2012)Google Scholar.

89 Mitchell, James E. and Harlow, Bill, Enhanced Interrogation: Inside the Minds and Motives of the Islamic Terrorists Trying to Destroy America (New York: Penguin, 2016)Google Scholar.

90 Hammond, Andrew, “Through a Glass, Darkly: The CIA and Oral History,” History, 100, 340 (2015), 311–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

91 “Dianne Feinstein Slam's Mike Morrell's New Book for Defending CIA's Use of Torture,” Associated Press, 11 May 2015.

92 Morell, The Great War of Our Time, 6.

93 Harlow quoted in Jenkins, The CIA in Hollywood, 44.

94 Hedley, John Hollister, “Three Memoirs from Former CIA Officers,” Studies in Intelligence, 49, 3 (2007)Google Scholar, available at www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intelligence/csi-publications/csi-studies/studies/vol49no3/html_files/Three_Memoirs_10.htm.

95 See Newton, Jim, Justice for All: Earl Warren and the Nation He Made (New York: Riverhead Books, 2006)Google Scholar; Newton, , Eisenhower: The White House Years (New York: Doubleday, 2011)Google Scholar.

96 Broadwell, Paula, with Loeb, Vernon, All In: The Education of General David Petraeus (New York: Penguin, 2012)Google Scholar.

97 Adam Goldman, “How David Petraeus Avoided Felony Charges and Possible Prison Time,” Washington Post, 25 Jan. 2016.

98 Hayden, Playing to the Edge, 220.

99 Rumsfeld's 800-page memoir was also undertaken without a ghostwriter; see Matthews, Lloyd J., “Known and Unknown: A Memoir,” Parameters, 41, 1 (2011), 150–52Google Scholar.

100 Wark, “Struggle in the Spy House,” 315.

101 Hayden, xiv.

102 Egerton, George, “Politics and Autobiography: Political Memoir as Polygenre,” Biography, 15, 3 (1992), 221–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

103 Moran, “From Confession to Corporate Memory,” 74.

104 Wark, 302.

105 Priess interview with Harf and Harlow.

106 Stamatatos, Efstathios, “A Survey of Modern Authorship Attribution Methods,” Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 60, 3 (2009), 538–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

107 Maddrell, Paul, “What We Have Discovered about the Cold War Is What We Already Knew: Julius Mader and the Western Secret Services during the Cold War,” Cold War History, 5, 2 (2005), 235–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

108 Harrison, E. D. R., “More Thoughts on Kim Philby's My Silent War,” Intelligence and National Security, 10, 3 (1995), 514–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 Davies, “Spies as Informants,” 78.

110 Hedley, “Three Memoirs from Former CIA Officers,” 2.