Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dsjbd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T06:16:37.573Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Political Rhetoric and Policy-Making: James G. Blaine and Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2009

Mike Sewell
Mike Sewell
Affiliation:
Selwyn College, Cambridge CB3 9DQ, Englandand a Staff Tutor at the Cambridge University Board of Extra-mural Studies. He wishes to thank Dr John Thompson of St Catharine's College, Cambridge, for his many helpful suggestions about this article.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

James Gillespie Blaine has been seen by his contemporaries and historians alike as the archetypal late nineteenth-century politician. Acclaimed by supporters as the “Plumed Knight” and derided by opponents as the “continental liar from the state of Maine,” his political career was impressive. He was Speaker of the House of Representatives, Senator from Maine, came within 2,000 New York votes of winning the Presidency in 1884, and was twice Secretary of State. But his reputation endures mainly as a corrupt and unscrupulous politico. Historians have labelled him immoral, demagogic and “openly anti-British.” They have depicted him as a spokesman for a “seething” late nineteenth–century Anglophobia who was “excessively political, notably in his penchant for cultivating the Irish at Great Britain's expense.” This aspect of Blaine's reputation has been misinterpreted. However, he can still stand as the personification of politics at a time when the spread-eagle rhetoric of campaigns co-existed with pragmatism in policy formulation.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 24 , Issue 1 , April 1990 , pp. 61 - 84
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Morgan, H. Wayne, From Hayes to McKinley: National Party Politics, 1877–1896 (Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1969), 152.Google Scholar See also Morison, Samuel Eliot, Commager, Henry Steele and Leuchtenberg, William E., The Growth of the American Republic 2nd. ed., (New York: Oxford University Press, 1942), vol. 11, 217Google Scholar; Bailey, Thomas A., A Diplomatic History of the American People, 2nd. edn., (New York: Crofts, 1945), 433Google Scholar; Allen, Harry C., Great Britain and the United States (London: Odhams, 1954), 523Google Scholar; Knapland, Paul and Clewes, Carolyn M., “Private letters from the British Embassy in Washington to Lord Granville, 1881–1885,” Proceedings of the American Historical Association for the Year 1941, (Washington D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1942), 86.Google Scholar

2 Crapol, Edward P., America for Americans. Economic Nationalism in the Late Nineteenth Century (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood, 1973), 209Google Scholar, more generally, 67–87: he describes the combination of hostility and admiration for British economic power as, “a central characteristic of American leaders” between the Civil War and 1900; Campbell, Charles S., The Transformation of American Foreign Relations, 1865–1900 (New York: Harper, 1976), 92–93.Google Scholar

3 Langley, Lester D., “James Gillespie Blaine. The ideologue as diplomatist” in Merli, Frank J. and Wilson, Theodore A. (eds.), Makers of American Diplomacy (New York: Scribner's, 1974), vol. I, 266–7.Google Scholar

4 Ibid., 267; Pletcher, David M., The Awkward Years, Diplomacy under Garfield and Arthur (Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1962), 14–15, 41–42Google Scholar, but also 238–239, 264 on Blaine's “chronic Anglophobia.”

5 A more favourable view of Blaine was evident in early biographies: Stanwood, Edward, James Gillespie Blaine (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1905), 361–6Google Scholar; Tyler, Alice Felt, The Foreign Policy of James G. Blaine (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1927), 11–21, 360–9Google Scholar; Latané, John H., A History of American foreign Policy (New York: Doubleday, 1927), 519–26Google Scholar; Lockey, Joseph B., “James Gillespie Blaine” in Bemis, Samuel Flagg (ed.), American Secretaries of State and their Diplomacy (New York: Knopf, 1928), vol. VII, 263–97, vol. VIII, 184.Google Scholar

6 McCormick, Richard L., “The Party Period and Public Policy,” in McCormick, , The Party Period and Public Policy (Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press, 1987), 197–227.Google Scholar

7 “Table Talk,” Appleton's Journal, 5, no. 104, (25 03, 1871), 324.Google Scholar

8 Blaine, James Gillespie, Twenty Years of Congress: From Lincoln to Garfield (Norwich, Conn.: Henry Bill, 1884), vol. I, 584.Google Scholar

9 Ibid., 587 on the Queen, vol. II, 498 on the arbitration; Gresham, Matilda, Life of Walter Quintin Gresham (Books for Libraries Press: Freeport, N.Y., 1970 reprint of 1919 edition), vol. II, 786.Google Scholar See also the quotation below at page 75, footnote 50.

10 Muzzey, David Saville, James G. Blaine, a Political Idol Of Other Times (New York: Dodd and Mead, 1943), 149ffGoogle Scholar; Stanwood, , Blaine, 107–120Google Scholar, stresses his reputation for energetic efforts to promote the influence of whatever office he held.

11 Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 121–133.Google Scholar

12 Brooks, Geo., “Anglophobia in the United States,” Westminster Review, 130 (12, 1888), 743–4.Google Scholar

13 Edwardes, to Barrington, , 26 08, 1889Google Scholar, Papers of the third Marquis of Salisbury, A/77, Hatfield House; also Pauncefote to Salisbury, 2; April 1890, Ibid.

14 Drummond, to Granville, , 24 10, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 150Google Scholar; a hint of Blaine's views on extradition can be found in Sackville West to Granville, 3 April 1883. Ibid., 175.

15 Blaine, to Lowell, , 22 11, 1881Google Scholar in Blaine, , Political Discussions (Norwich, Conn.: Henry Bill, 1887), 340–2.Google Scholar

16 First Executive Order, President Arthur, 19 October, 1881, in Richardson, James David (ed.), Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1898), vol. VIII, 37Google Scholar; for a fuller discussion see Sewell, Michael J., “All the English-speaking race is in mourning: the assassination of President Garfield in Anglo-American relations,” The Historical Journal (forthcoming).Google Scholar

17 Drummond, to Granville, , 24 10 and 1 11, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 149–52Google Scholar; West, Sackville to Granville, no. 338, 22 11, 1881Google Scholar, Drummond, to Granville, , no. 311, 24 10, 1881, FO5/1756.Google Scholar Foreign Office files, America, Public Record Office, London.

18 First Annual Message, President Arthur, 6 December, 1881 Richardson, , Messages and Papers, vol. VIII, 37–38.Google Scholar

19 West, Sackville to Granville, , no. 331, 8 11, 1881, FO5/1756.Google Scholar

20 Drummond, to Granville, , 25 08 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 147Google Scholar; for a similar comment from Blaine's second term see Francis Villiers to Cecil Spring Rice, 15 February, 1890, Spring Rice papers, 1/67, Churchill College Cambridge.

21 Thornton, to Salisbury, , 7 05, 1878, Salisbury papers, A/77.Google Scholar

22 Blaine papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C., container 17.

23 Carnegie, Andrew, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (London: Constable, 1920), 320–1, 341–57Google Scholar, quotation 353–5. Blaine presented a copy of one of his books to Gladstone, acknowledged in Gladstone, to Blaine, , 6 10, 1887Google Scholar, container 34, Blaine papers, “Autographs.”

24 Blaine's comments on the encouragement of American shipbuilding also fall into this category. He cast Britain as a rival and held that country responsible for the decline of the American merchant marine during the Civil War, Twenty Years, vol. II, 612–615Google Scholar; Political Discussions, 300–310Google Scholar; proofs of a speech to the New York Chamber of Commerce in 1879, Blaine Papers, container 29.

25 Thornton, to Granville, , 22 03, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private Letters,” 122Google Scholar; Boutwell, George S., Reminiscences of Sixty Years in Public Affairs (New York: Greenwood, 1968 reprint of 1902 edition), vol. II, 263–4.Google Scholar Blaine's concern about American prestige and businesslike priorities led him to seek to abandon “republican simplicity” in suggesting that the United States should appoint and receive Ambassadors, Thornton, to Granville, , 31 03, 1881Google Scholar, Drummond, to Granville, , 7 09, 1881Google Scholar also reported American indignation that Thornton had been promoted to St. Petersburg, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 135, 148.Google Scholar The United States first accredited and received Ambassadors in 1893.

26 Keller, Morton, Affairs of State: Public life in Late Nineteenth Century America (Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 1977), 239–58, 540CrossRefGoogle Scholar on the retreat from ideological politics and sacrifice of consistency to a “mosaic of interests” and readiness to meet opponents halfway; Marcus, Robert, Grand Old Party: Political Structure in the Gilded Age (New York: Oxford University Press, 1971), 36Google Scholar describes Blaine as “ever willing to accept political counsel.”

27 Keller, , Affairs of State, 561.Google Scholar

28 Ibid., 297; McCormick, , Party Period, 14–15, 197–198, 214–216.Google Scholar

29 Crapol, , America for Americans, 68.Google Scholar

30 Thornton, to Granville, , 8 02, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 116.Google Scholar

31 West, Sackville to Granville, , 3 08, 1884, no. 252, FO5/1871Google Scholar; similarly on the Democrats, No. 329, 16 November, 1884, FO5/1872.

32 Albany Argus, 9 07, 1890Google Scholar quoted in Pauncefote to Salisbury, 10 July, 1890, Salisbury papers, A/77, see also letters of 6 June and 27 June, Ibid.

33 Editorial, New York Evening Post, 2 08, 1884.Google Scholar

34 Lyon Playfair to the editor, The Times, 25 12, 1895.Google Scholar

35 Blaine, , Twenty Years, vol. I, 51–2.Google Scholar

36 Ibid., 52–4.

37 Ibid., 54–6.

38 Blaine quoted in Pletcher, , Awkward Years, 42Google Scholar; remarks reported by West, Sackville to Granville, , 27 04, 1882, no. 192, FO5/1786.Google Scholar

39 West, Sackville to Granville, , 19 11 and 21 12, 1881Google Scholar in Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 159–60.Google Scholar

40 Drummond, to Granville, , 1 11, 1881Google Scholar, West, Sackville to Granville, , 28 12, 1881Google Scholar, Ibid., 151, 160.

41 Thornton, to Granville, , 14 03, 1881Google Scholar, Ibid., 121.

42 Godkin, to Bryce, James, 28 02, 1882Google Scholar, in Armstrong, William M. (ed.), The Gilded Age Letters of E. L. Godkin (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1974), 281.Google Scholar

43 Blaine, to Harrison, , no. 283, 6 03, 1892Google Scholar in Volwiler, Albert T. (ed.), The Correspondence Between Benjamin Harrison and James G. Blaine, 1882–93 (Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1940), 242–3Google Scholar; in a letter of 23 July, 1890, no. 121, Ibid., 112 Blaine stressed public appearances as a major consideration in any policy.

44 Blaine, to Harrison, , no. 26, 9 11, 1888Google Scholar, Ibid., 41; see also no. 70, 26 August, 1889, and letters from Edwardes, to Salisbury, , 30 05, and 26 08, 1889Google Scholar, Salisbury papers, A/77. Sackville West became Baron Sackville in September, 1888, he was sent his passports in the last days of the election campaign after publication of a private letter in which he seemed to endorse Cleveland.

45 Blaine, , Political Discussions, 477–85Google Scholar, Twenty years, vol. II, 485–488Google Scholar; Marcus, , Grand Old Party, 92–93Google Scholar on Republican efforts to woo Irish voters; West, Sackville to Granville, , 10 06, 1884Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 178.Google Scholar

46 Sackville, Lord, My Mission to the United States (London: privately published, 1893), 3–9, 23–26.Google Scholar

47 West, Sackville to Granville, , 1 05, 1882Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 168.Google Scholar

48 Thornton, to Granville, , 19 04, 1881 and 5 04, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 127, 130Google Scholar; Thornton, to Granville, , 29 06, 1881Google Scholar, FO5/1863; also West, Sackville to Granville, , 12 02, 1882Google Scholar, FO5/1816 about how Blaine had told the mother of one prisoner that he would not challenge British law; see also Sewell, Michael J., “Rebels or revolutionaries? Irish-American nationalism and American diplomacy, 1865–85,” The Historical Journal, 29 (09, 1986), 726–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Blaine's critics stressed that he had failed to protect the rights of Irish-Americans, McCarthy, J., “Among our diplomats,” Catholic World, 36 (02, 1883) 609–612Google Scholar; Strobel, Edward H., Mr Blaine and his Foreign Policy (Boston: H. Hall, 1884), 20–24Google Scholar; Democratic Party Campaign Books for 1882 and 1884 elections; in 1891 Blaine thwarted an amendment to the extradition agreement which would have benefitted Irish agitators.

49 Blaine, , Twenty Years, vol. II, 622–37Google Scholar; Political Discussions, 176–185.Google Scholar

50 Ibid., 493–500, quotation 499–500.

51 Pletcher, , Awkward Years, 42.Google Scholar

52 Blaine, , Political Discussions, 411–19.Google Scholar

53 Garfield, inaugural address in Richardson, , Messages and papers, vol. VIII, 11.Google Scholar

54 Blaine, to Lowell, , no. 329, 24 06, 1881Google Scholar, in Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States, 1881–82 (Washington, D.C.: GPO, (1882), 537–40Google Scholar; on the Colombian overtures, Annual Message, Ibid., vi–vii, and Tyler, , Foreign Policy, 33–41.Google Scholar

55 Hoppin, to Blaine, , no. 335, 11 11, 1881Google Scholar, Foreign Relations, 549.Google Scholar

56 Blaine, to Lowell, , nos. 338 and 341, 19 and 29 11, 1881Google Scholar, Foreign Relations, 554–59, 563–69.Google Scholar

57 Blaine, to Lowell, , 19 11, 1881Google Scholar, Ibid., 557–9.

58 E. Hertslet memorandum, 26 12, 1881, FO881/4569.Google Scholar

59 Tyler, , Foreign Policy, 40Google Scholar; Blaine, to Lowell, , 29 11 1881Google Scholar, Foreign Relations, 568–9.Google Scholar

60 Gladstone, to Granville, , 23 12, 1881, no. 591Google Scholar in Ramm, Agatha (ed.), The Political Correspondence of Mr. Gladstone and Lord Granville 1876–1886, vol. 1 1876–1882 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1962), 321–322Google Scholar; also Granville's reply of 25 December, no. 593, and Gladstone, to Granville, ,; 07, 1882, no. 741, 385–86.Google Scholar

61 B[ergne], J. B. memorandum on the projected Nicaragua canal, dated 2 05 1872, FO5/1381.Google Scholar

62 Bryce, James, The American Commonwealth, 2nd ed., (London: Macmillan, 1893), vol. II, 523Google Scholar; also the comments of Charles Wentworth Dilke, another Undersecretary in 1881, reported in Tyler, Foreign Policy, 43, footnote 42.Google Scholar

63 The Spectator, 29 10, 1881, 1359Google Scholar; 17 December, 1881, 1599; 24 December, 1881, 1634–1639.

64 The Economist, 24 12, 1881, 1583.Google Scholar

65 The Times quoted in Pletcher, Awkward Years, 67Google Scholar; The Saturday Review 29 10 1881, 528–9Google Scholar; 3 December, 1881, 687–8; 24 December, 1881, 778–9 stressed concern about commercial discrimination not strategic considerations.

66 MrsBlaine, to M[argaret Blaine], 24 12, 1881Google Scholar, Beale, Harriet S. Blaine (ed.), Letters of Mrs. James G. Blaine (New York: Duffield, 1908), vol. I, 277Google Scholar, and to Blaine, Walker, 22 02, 1882, 313Google Scholar on how her husband's policies were “so American.”

67 Salisbury, to Pauncefote, , telegram, 25 12, 1891, Salisbury papers, A/78.Google Scholar

68 Blaine, to Comly, , 19 11, 1881Google Scholar in Political Discussions, 390–3.Google Scholar

69 Blaine to Comly, supplementary despatch, Ibid., 394–6.

70 Ibid., 396.

71 Morgan, William Michael, “The anti-Japanese origins of the Hawaiian Annexation treaty of 1897,” Diplomatic History, 6 (Winter 1982), 23–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

72 Thornton, to Granville, , 10 05, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 131.Google Scholar

73 Thornton, to Granville, , 17 05, 1881Google Scholar, Ibid., 133.

74 Blaine, , Twenty Years, vol. I, 29–40, quotation 40.Google Scholar

75 Ibid., vol. I, 596–97, 600–1.

76 Ibid., vol. II, 483–4.

77 Ibid., vol. II, 493–9.

78 MrsBlaine, to Blaine, Walker, 1 05, 1872Google Scholar, Beale, Blaine, Mrs. Blaine, vol. I, 123–4.Google Scholar

79 Thornton, to Granville, , 14 06, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 137Google Scholar commented on Blaine's intention to “do his utmost to prevent Great Britain from gaining a foot of ground upon this continent.”

80 New York Daily Tribune, 23 06, 1882Google Scholar, and conversation reported by West, Sackville to Granville, , 26 06, 1881Google Scholar, Knaplund, and Clewes, , “Private letters,” 171.Google Scholar