Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T13:43:39.501Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Operation Abolition: Defending the Civil Liberties of the “Un-American,” 1957–1961

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 July 2013

RUTH MARTIN
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In response to the House Un-American Activities Committee's attacks on legal defenders of political nonconformists, the six-year-old Emergency Civil Liberties Committee organized a publicity and test-case campaign to highlight the dubious constitutionality of HUAC's methods. Their drive to abolish HUAC helped to transform the defence of the constitutional rights of suspected subversives or “un-Americans” by undermining the governmental structures of the Second Red Scare. The ECLC's activity also prompted a shift in the policy of the nation's largest civil liberties group, the American Civil Liberties Union, in favour of abolition. HUAC's response of a mass propaganda campaign represented the culmination of a period when they sought to crush “un-American” dissent, inadvertently elevating the ECLC to a position of national prominence in the struggle for Cold War civil liberties.

Type
Un-American Articles
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 47 , Issue 4: The “Un-American” , November 2013 , pp. 1043 - 1063
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 “Maps Wide Inquiry into Propaganda,” New York Times, 19 June 1938, 26.

2 Sabin, Arthur J., In Calmer Times: The Supreme Court and Red Monday (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1999), 26Google Scholar.

3 Alien Registration (Smith) Act, 18 U.S. C. §2385 (1940).

4 “Resolution adopted by the Board of Directors and National Committee of the ACLU at Annual meeting of National Committee at Town Hall, 5 Feb. 1940,” NA-HUAC 451: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1940–1941.”

5 Press release, 8 Oct. 1951, RBML-NECLC 25: “1951–2.”

6 Reeves, Thomas C., Freedom and the Foundation: The Fund for the Republic in the Era of McCarthyism (New York: Fund for the Republic, 1969)Google Scholar.

7 FFR Board of Directors, 29 Jan. 1953, MML-FFR 1: 1, 2.

8 Stouffer, Samuel A., Communism, Conformity, and Civil Liberties: A Cross-Section of the Nation Speaks Its Mind (Garden City, NY: Transaction Publishers, 1955)Google Scholar. See also Cogley, John, Report on Blacklisting (New York: Fund for the Republic, 1956)Google Scholar.

9 ECLC, Testimony of Clark Foreman in Response to Questions of the Committee on Un-American Activities of the House of Representatives, June 12, 1956 (New York: ECLC, 1956)Google Scholar; “Committee to Probe Fund for the Republic,” Lewiston Morning Tribune, 11 June 1956, 2.

10 Robert M. Hutchins, president, FFR, to Francis E. Walter, chairman, HUAC, 10 July 1956, MML-FFR 5: 2.

11 Robert M. Hutchins to all grantees, 17 July 1956, MML- FFR 5: 2.

12 “House Group Favors Citing Robeson,” New York Times, 13 June 1956.

13 “Liberties Unit Head Lashes Probe Group,” Denver Post, 10 Oct. 1957.

14 Simmons, Jerold, Operation Abolition: The Campaign to Abolish the House Un-American Activities Committee 1938–1975 (New York: Garland, 1986)Google Scholar; Simmons, , “The Origins of the Campaign to Abolish HUAC, 1956–1961, the California Connection,” Southern California Quarterly, 64 (1982), 141–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Henry Schwarzschild, assistant to the executive director, to Irving Ferman, 8 April 1954. “American Committee for Cultural Freedom – File Room Copy Committee on Un-American Activities”; “ECLC – Prepared by the Research Staff of the American Jewish Committee – NOT FOR ATTRIBUTION!”, 11 March 1954, 1–5, 1, NA-HUAC 539: “Org/ Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1954.”

16 Parson, Don, Making a Better World: Public Housing, the Red Scare and the Direction of Modern Los Angeles (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2005)Google Scholar, 206; Tevelan, Dale E., “Interviewing a Close Friend, First Amendment Activist Frank Wilkinson,” Journal of American History, 85 (1998), 611–19Google Scholar; director, FBI from SAC LA, 3 Nov. 1952, TAM-R&B 61: 6.

17 SAC LA to FBI director, 3 Nov. 1952, TAM-R&B, 61: 6; “Meeting – ‘The Menace to Labor of All Un-American Committees,’ sponsored by the CCPAF, March 27, 1953,” NA-HUAC (Wheeler Investigative Files) 2: “Citizens Committee to Preserve American Freedoms, 1953.”

18 CCPAF, Courage is Contagious: The Bill of Rights versus the Un-American Activities Committee (Huntington Park: CCPAF, 1953)Google Scholar; Robert Halbeisan to Norman Thomas, 22 Feb. 1957, TAM-NT Reel 57, 0545.

19 Investigation of Communist Activities in the Los Angeles Area – Part 2: Hearings before the Committee on Un-American Activities House of Representatives, Eighty-Third Congress, First Session, March 26, 27 and 28, 1953 (Washington, DC: HUAC, 1953), 455.

20 Clark Foreman to Frank Wilkinson, 13 April 1954; Frank Wilkinson to Clark Foreman, 7 June 1954, RBML-NECLC 73: “CCPAF”; Gene Hagberg to Congressman Jackman, 13 Aug. 1954, “Committees of Correspondence and Resistance Jointly Sponsored by the ECLC and CCPAF – File Room Copy, Committee on Un-American Activities.” NA-HUAC 539: “Org/ Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1954.”

21 Clark Foreman to Frank Wilkinson, 24 Aug. 1956, RBML-NECLC 73: “CCPAF (1956).”

22 Louis J. Russell to Richard Arens, “Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, Dorothy Marshall and Frank Wilkinson,” 28 March 1957, 1–3, 3, NA-HUAC (Wheeler Investigative Files) 2: “Citizens Committee to Preserve American Freedoms, 1957”; HUAC, Report on Civil Rights Congress as a Communist Front Organization: Investigation of Un-American Activities in the United States, Committee on Un-American Activities, House of Representatives, Eightieth Congress, First Session (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1947)Google Scholar.

23 Irving Ferman to L. B. Nichols, 13 March 1957, FBI: “ACLU,” Part 5, 1.

24 Watkins v. United States, 354 US 178 (1957).

25 Yates v. United States, 354 US 298 (1957).

26 “Demands Ban on High Court Red Decisions: Warren Lashed by Sen. Jenner,” Chicago Daily Tribune, 27 July 1957, 1; Sabin, In Calmer Times.

27 ECLC, The Watkins Decision of the United States Supreme Court, June 17, 1957: An Historic Rebuke to the Committee on Un-American Activities of the House of Representatives U. S. (New York: ECLC, 1957)Google Scholar.

28 “Leftists Open Drive to End House Group,” New York Times, 21 Sept. 1957, 8.

29 “Supreme Court Decision and Concurring and Dissenting Opinions in Watkins case,” New York Times, 18 June 1957, 21.

30 “Lawyers from Two Nations Revere One Law: American and British Bars Meet in London and Hear Brownell's Challenge to Create a World Order,” Life, 5 Aug. 1957, 23.

31 HUAC, The Communist Party's Cold War against Congressional Investigation of Subversion Report, and Testimony of Robert Carrillo Ronstadt, House of Representatives, Eighty-Seventh Congress, Second Session, October 10, 1962 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1962)Google Scholar.

32 O'Connor, Harvey, For Abolition of the Inquisitorial Committees of Congress (New York: ECLC, 1957)Google Scholar.

33 Boudin, Leonard, “Congress vs. Supreme Court: Recent Decisions Attacked, ” Rights, Oct.–Nov. 1957, 5Google Scholar.

34 “Abolition Campaign Progresses as Un-Americans Transgress,” Rights, Oct.–Nov. 1957, 3.

35 Patrick Murphy Malin to ACLU affiliates, 18 July 1957, CAM-ACLU, Reel 23.

36 Minutes, ACLU Board meeting, 23 Sept. 1957, 2, CAM-ACLU Reel 14, s.1957.

37 Corliss Lamont to Alexander Meiklejohn, 6 Nov. 1957, RBML-NECLC 15: “Meiklejohn”; Minutes, ACLU Board meeting, 2 Dec. 1957, CAM-ACLU Reel 14, s.1957.

38 Transcript, Clark Foreman and Harvey O'Connor, radio show, c.1961, RBML-NECLC, 20, “Speeches.”

39 HUAC, “Operation Abolition”: The Campaign against the House Committee on Un-American Activities, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Government Security Program by the Emergency Civil Liberties Committee and its Affiliates (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1957)Google Scholar.

40 J. Edgar Hoover to Honorable Francis E. Walter, 12 Nov. 1957, NA-HUAC 538: “Org/Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1957.”

41 “Operation Abolition,” Telegraph-Herald, 13 Nov. 1957, 4.

42 William Wheeler to Richard Arens, “CCPAF,” 20 Nov. 1957, NA-HUAC (Wheeler Investigative Files) 2: “Citizens Committee to Preserve American Freedoms, 1957.” Sherrill, Robert, First Amendment Felon (New York: Nation, 2005), 146Google Scholar.

43 Frank Wilkinson, CCPAF to Edgar Bundy, Church League of America, 27 Oct. 1958, NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./ Complaints – Abolition 1955–1958”; CCPAF, Operation Un-American: A Handbook of Information on the House Un-American Activities Committee (Los Angeles: CCPAF, 1958)Google Scholar.

44 Clark Foreman and Corliss Lamont to Congressman Francis E. Walter, 21 Feb. 1957, NA-HUAC 538: “Org/Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1957”; HUAC, Annual Report for 1958 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1959), 34–35Google Scholar.

45 Braden v. United States, 365 US 431 (1961).

46 “H. Res J. 29565 – In the House of Representatives, August 1958, 85th Congress, 2nd Session,” NA-HUAC (Investigative Section) 126: “Braden, Carl and Anne”; “Proceedings against Frank Wilkinson, Committee Print, 85th Congress, 2nd Session, House of Representatives,” NA-HUAC (Investigative Section) 195: “Wilkinson, Frank.”

47 O'Connor, Jessie Lloyd, O'Connor, Harvey and Bowler, Susan M., Harvey and Jessie: A Couple of Radicals (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1988), 248–49Google Scholar.

48 “O'Connor Victory,” Rights, 12, 4 (June 1965), 2–3.

49 Woods, Jeff, Black Struggle, Red Scare: Segregation and Anti-Communism in the South, 1948–1968 (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 2004), 40Google Scholar.

50 Clark Foreman to Leonard Boudin, 26 Oct. 1959, RBML-NECLC 50: “Leonard Boudin 1953–1959.”

51 “ACLU Marks Gains in 1957 Fights,” Daily Worker, 6 Jan. 1958, 3. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1958.”

52 “Civil Liberties Union Fights Congress,” Counterattack, 12 Dec. 1958. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1958”; “ACLU Opens Drive to Dissolve HUAC: Calif., National Offices Disagree on Way to Destroy Anti-Reds,” The Tablet, 27 Dec. 1958. NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1955–1958.”

53 “A Better Way to Fight the Communist Conspiracy,” Congressional Record – House, 27 Jan. 1959, 1112. NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1959”; Richard Arens to Chairman Walter, Congressmen Moulder, Doyle, Willis, Took, Jackson & Scherer, 8 Jan. 1959, NA-HUAC 451: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union (Southern California branch) (1 of 2).”

54 “Address to be delivered in House of Representatives by Hon. Francis E. Walter,” 15 Jan. 1959; “Extension of Remarks of Hon. Gordon H. Scherer in the House of Representatives, Thursday, January 15, 1959: ‘The Enemy grows bolder’,” Congressional Record – Appendix, 15 Jan. 1959, A236–38, 237. NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1959.” NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1955–1958.”

55 “Walter Cites Campaign to Abolish Committee Power,” Washington Observer, 12 Jan. 1959, 6.

56 Clark Foreman, ECLC mailing, 15 June 1960, NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1960.”

57 “Straight from the Horse's Mouth!”, Congress and Your Rights 14 (21 April 1959). NA-HUAC 538: “Org/Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1959.” Chicago Committee to Defend Democratic Rights reprint: “Un-American Activities Unit Is Most Un-American: Truman,” Chicago Sun-Times, 30 April 1959. NA-HUAC 1040: “Com./Complaints – Abolition 1955–1958.”

58 Eason Monroe to Alan Reitman, 4 Nov. 1958, “Southern California Petition Campaign to Eliminate the House Committee on Un-American Activities”; James Roosevelt to Willard Carpenter, associate director, SCACLU, 30 Oct. 1958, NA-HUAC 451: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union (Southern California Branch) (1 of 2)”; “Southern Cal. Congressmen Urged to Nix Un-Americans,” People's World, 15 Nov. 1958, 3. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1958.”

59 Barenblatt v. United States, 360 US 109 (1959).

60 Leonard Boudin, “The Bill of Rights in the Supreme Court, 1958 Term,” c.1958, RBML-NECLC 102: “1958 Legal Reports.”

61 Periodical, Counterattack, 12 June 1959. NA-HUAC 538: “Org/Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1959.”

62 ECLC, Dissents in the United States Supreme Court by Justice Hugo Black with Chief Justice Warren and Justice Douglas Concurring and by Mr Justice Brennan. Lloyd Barenblatt, Petitioner v. United States of America, June 8, 1959 (New York: ECLC, 1959)Google Scholar.

63 Honorable James Roosevelt, “The Dragon Slayers,” 25 April 1960, Congressional Record: Proceedings and Debates of the 86th Congress, Second Session. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1960.”

64 “ACLU Asks Abolition of House Probe Unit,” New York Post, 25 April 1960, 11; “Ask Un-American Group's Abolition,” Detroit News, 25 April 1960, 6; “ACLU Asks End to House Inquiry,” New York Times, 25 April 1960.

65 Heale, M. J., “Red Scare Politics: California's Campaign against Un-American Activities, 1940–1970,” Journal of American Studies, 20 (1986), 5–32, 30CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 FBI, Communist Target – Youth: Communist Infiltration and Action (A Report by J. Edgar Hoover, Director of the FBI, Illustrating Communist Strategy and Tactics in the Rioting Which Occurred during House Committee on Un-American Activities Hearings, San Francisco, May 12–14, 1960 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1960), 6Google Scholar.

67 Patrick Murphy Malin to Francis E. Walter, 27 Dec. 1960, NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1960.”

68 Fulton Lewis Jr., “Washington Report,” Reading Eagle, 17 July 1961, 4.

69 Smallwood, James, Reform, Red Scare, and Ruin: Virginia Durr, Prophet of the New South (Philadelphia: Xlibris, 2008), 176Google Scholar.

70 FBI, J. F. Bland to A. H. Belmont, 21 March 1961, TAM: R&B, 61:6.

71 “View from Hill: Scripts Prepared for ACLU Mock HUAC Session,” Forty-Niner, 7 Dec. 1960; “Shows up to Tape Meeting: Woman Ejected as Students Study Probers,” (Southland) Independent, 3 Dec. 1960. NA-HUAC 451: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union (Southern California branch) (1 of 2).”

72 “2 Congressmen Join Roosevelt Move to Abolish Committee,” People's World, 17 Dec. 1960, 2. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1960.”

73 “ACLU Seminar on House Group: 1000 Roast Red Hunters,” San Francisco Chronicle, 12 March 1961. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, March 1961.”

74 “Religious Students Picket ACLU,” San Francisco News, 11 March 1961. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, March 1961.”

75 Bogle, Lori Lyn, The Pentagon's Battle for the American Mind (College Station: Texas A & M University Press, 2004), 150–51Google Scholar; ACLU San Diego Chapter, “Study of Military Role in Circulation of “Operation Abolition,” undated. NA-HUAC 448: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, April–Dec. 1961.”

76 “To Replace HUAC Film,” Michigan Daily, 13 July 1961, 11.

77 “Gene Schroeder, “The Capitol Scene: The ‘Communism on the Map’ Controversy, (Michigan) Owosso Argus-Press, 8 April 1961, 1; “Legion Protests Swainson's Ban on ‘Abolition’ Showing,” Milwaukee Sentinel, 8 April 1961, 34; “‘Operation Abolition’ Film Showings by State Police Stopped in Mich.,” The Worker, 19 April 1961, 3.

78 ACLU, “Testing Whether That Nation”: 41st Annual Report, July 1, 1960 to June 30, 1961 – Defense of the Bill of Rights (New York: ACLU, 1961)Google Scholar, 40. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1960.”

79 “Turbulent World of Un-Americans: Films Stir a Storm of Protest as Churches, Educators Flay HUAC,” People's World, 11 Feb. 1961, 2; “Statement of American Civil Liberties Union of Washington on Films ‘Operation Abolition’ and ‘Communism on the Map,’ undated; “ACLU Aide to Explain Film Stand,” Wilmington Morning News, 1 March 1961. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, March 1961.” Bay Area Student Committee for the Abolition of the House Committee on Un-American Activities, In Search of Truth: An Analysis of the HCUA Propaganda Film “Operation Abolition” (Berkeley, 1960)Google Scholar. NA-HUAC (Wheeler Investigative Files) 2: “CCPAF, 1960.”

80 Foreman, Clark, “Operation Abolition – Deceitful Documentary,” Rights, 8 (1961), 3–4, 3Google Scholar.

81 “ACLU Revises ‘Operation Abolition’: House Unit's Film Stirred Controversy,” Toledo Blade, 1 Dec. 1961, 2; “New Version Prepared of ‘Abolition’ Film,” Youngstown Vindicator, 1 Dec. 1961; “New Version of Controversial Film,” St Joseph News-Press, 1 Dec. 1961, 9.

82 “New Controversy Erupts over City Hall Riot Film,” San Francisco Chronicle, 4 Jan. 1962, 10. NA-HUAC 448: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, 1962.”

83 Braden v. United States, 365 US 431 (1961), 4; Douglas, William O., The Court Years, 1939–1975: The Autobiography of William O. Douglas (New York: Random House, 1981), 99Google Scholar.

84 Southern Conference Educational Fund Press Release, 7 Oct. 1961, reproduced in NCAHUAC, A Collection of Editorials and Resolutions in Opposition to the Un-American Activities Committee, January 1962 (Los Angeles, 1962), 11Google Scholar.

85 “Extension of Remarks of Hon. Thomas B. Curtis of Missouri in the House of Representatives, Wednesday, March 29, 1961, “The St. Louis Globe-Democrat Comments on Efforts to Discredit the Un-American Activities Committee’,” Congressional Record – Appendix, A2258. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, March 1961.”

86 Robert Henry Goldsborough, investigator, to Frank S. Tavenner, director, “Anti-HCUA Meeting of the Maryland Civil Liberties Union,” 6 March 1961. NA-HUAC 449: “Org/American Civil Liberties Union, March 1961”; ACLU Press Release, 8 March 1961, CAM-ACLU, Reel 16, s. “Press Releases.”

87 Wesley, David and ECLC, Hate Groups and the Un-American Activities Committee (New York: ECLC, 1961), 4Google Scholar; Roosevelt, Eleanor, “Sees Eichmann Trial as Lesson against Prejudice,” Capital Times, 12 April 1961, 9Google Scholar.

88 “HUAC Fronts for Hate Groups,” Congress and Your Rights, 2, 8 (15 March 1960); ECLC reproduction of “Un-American Unit Director Is Paid Consultant for ‘Genetics’ grants,” Gazette and Daily, York, Pa., 4 March 1960. NA-HUAC 538: “Org/Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1960.”