Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rcrh6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T14:16:47.407Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“On Fire with Hope”: African American Classical Musicians, Major Bowes’ Amateur Hour, and the Hope for a Colour-Blind Radio

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2012

DAVID GOODMAN
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Amateur talent shows were among the most popular programs on mid-1930s network radio, but for African Americans they had an importance that went beyond entertainment. These shows attracted considerable attention in the black press and from black audiences because they held out the promise of escape from the constraints of Jim Crow into a colour-blind national public sphere. This article explores the participation of African American performers on the most popular of the radio amateur shows, Major Bowes’ Original Amateur Hour. It focusses particularly on two black classical performers on the Amateur Hour – singers Otis Holley and La Julia Rhea – contrasting their success on the radio show with the obstacles they encountered in the segregated world outside the studio. Radio did stimulate hope about the possibility of a race-free sound world, a new sense that such a thing could be possible. That the first generation to test the idea – gifted performers such as Holley and Rhea – often failed to translate radio success into mainstream acceptance, should not lead us to neglect the increase in hope that the early mass media provoked among African Americans.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 47 , Issue 2: Special Collection: Art Across Frontiers , May 2013 , pp. 475 - 494
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Dr. William Pickens, “‘Colourless’ Radio Wave,” Afro-American, 13 March 1926, 5.

2 Smith, Lucy Harth, “Negro Musicians and Their Music,” Journal of Negro History, 20 (1935), 428–32, 431CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Ronald Radano and Philip V. Bohlman , “Introduction,” in Radano and Bohlman, eds., Music and the Racial Imagination (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2001), 1–53, 5, 37.

4 Miller, Karl Hagstrom, Segregating Sound: Inventing Folk and Pop Music in the Age of Jim Crow (Raleigh: Duke University Press, 2011), 188Google Scholar, 221, 194–96.

5 Suisman, David, Selling Sounds: The Commercial Revolution in American Music (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2009), 234–35Google Scholar.

6 Cohen, Lizabeth, Making a New Deal: Industrial Workers in Chicago, 1919–1939 (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1990), 129–43Google Scholar; Vaillant, Derek, “Sounds of Whiteness: Local Radio, Racial Formation, and Public Culture in Chicago, 1921–1935,” American Quarterly, 54 (2002), 25–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Vaillant, 29, 35.

8 “Commercial Radio Won't Hire Coloured,” Afro-American, 23 Aug. 1941, 13.

9 Barlow, William, Voice Over: The Making of Black Radio (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1999), 27–28Google Scholar.

10 Douglas, Susan J., Listening In: Radio and the American Imagination (New York: Times Books, 1999), 94Google Scholar.

11 “‘Band Wagon’ Stalled by Racial Prejudice,” Pittsburgh Courtier, 26 Aug. 1939, 20.

12 Barlow, 27–28. It is, however, important to remember that both radio listening and network programmes were scarcer in the South than elsewhere: Michael Socolow, “To Network a Nation: N.B. C., C.B. S., and the Development of National Network Radio in the US, 1925–1950,” PhD dissertation, Georgetown University, 2001, 112–29.

13 “Radio News,” Atlanta Daily World, 26 Nov. 1935, 2.

14 Folder 19, Box 35, NBC papers, Wisconsin Historical Society (WHS).

15 “Amateur Hour,” New York Times, 23 June 1935, SM8; Macdonald, J. Fred, Don't Touch That Dial! Radio Programming in American Life, 1920–1960 (Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1979), 335Google Scholar; Cooper, Ralph and Dougherty, Steve, Amateur Night at the Apollo: Ralph Cooper Presents Five Decades of Great Entertainment (New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 1990), 84Google Scholar.

16 Loviglio, Jason, Radio's Intimate Public: Network Broadcasting and Mass-Mediated Democracy (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2005), 39–45Google Scholar.

17 Recording of Major Bowes’ Original Amateur Hour, 24 March 1935.

18 Eleanor Shoemaker, “Major Bowes Speaking,” Oakland Tribune, 8 Dec. 1935, 10.

19 Morris Markey, “A Reporter at Large,” New Yorker, 4 Jan. 1936, 24.

20 “Bowes Inc.,” Time, 22 June 1936, 63; Melnick, Ross, “Reality Radio: Remediating the Radio Contest Genre in Major Bowes’ Amateur Hour Films,” Film History, 23 (2011), 331–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Melnick, 335–36.

22 Clara Beranger, “Behind the Scenes with Major Bowes,” Liberty, 9 Nov. 1935; “Life in a Major Bowes Unit,” Radio Guide, 14 March 1936, 7.

23 Radio Guide, 29 Feb. 1936, 14.

24 Markey, 25.

25 Ibid., 26.

26 Robinson, Elsie, “Let Us Believe Again,” Rochester Journal, 6 April 1936, 9Google Scholar.

27 “Listener Interest Widely Increased,” Broadcasting, 15 Sept. 1939, 40.

28 Lazarsfeld, Paul F., Radio and the Printed Page (New York: Duell, Sloan and Pearce, 1940), 23Google Scholar.

29 Radio Guide, 15 Feb. 1936, 22 Feb. 1936, 29 Feb. 1936, 7 March 1936, 14 March 1936, 21 March 1936.

30 “Exploding the Major Bowes Myth,” Radio Guide, 22 Feb. 1936, 5.

31 Ibid., 5; “Stranded Radio Amateurs Relief Problem,” New York Times, 5 Oct. 1935, 8; J. C. Furnas, “Our Country,” Life, Nov. 1936, 8–12.

32 “Backstage at a Major Bowes Audition,” Radio Mirror, March 1936, 4.

33 Eleanor Shoemaker, “Major Bowes Speaking,” Oakland Tribune, 8 Dec. 1935, 10.

34 “Says Maj. Bowes Gains His Fame through Fairness,” Chicago Defender, 2 Nov. 1935, 2.

35 “3 College Girls Star in Major Bowes’ Stage Unit,” Chicago Defender, 1 Feb. 1936, 9.

36 Hilmes, Michele, Radio Voices: American Broadcasting, 1922–1952 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1997), 93Google Scholar.

37 The Library of Congress (LOC) Amateur Hour collection has seven thousand applications from contestants who appeared between 1934 and 1948. I have not attempted to calculate the proportion of black contestants; some black contestants (identifiable from the accompanying letter) did not have their application marked “Negro.”

38 Transcribed from recording of the first NBC Bowes show, 24 March 1935. I have been able to listen to recordings of about ten Amateur Hour broadcasts.

39 “The Kitchen Trio,” Afro-American, 23 May 1936, 4.

40 Boxes 2, 3, 11, Amateur Hour collection, Music Division, LOC.

41 “Praise and Criticism,” Kansas Plain Dealer, 2 April 1937, 3.

42 “Seek Major Bowes’ Unit,” Baltimore Afro-American, 6 Nov. 1937, 11.

43 “Major Bowes’ Amateur Revue Withdrawn from Va. Theatres,” Pittsburgh Courier, 23 Oct. 1937, 20; “Major Bowes Coloured Unit on Apollo Bill,” New York Amsterdam News, 7 May 1938, 16.

44 Willis Charles Patterson, “A History of the National Association of Negro Musicians: The First Quarter Century, 1919–1943,” PhD dissertation, Wayne State University, 1993; Schenbeck, Lawrence, Racial Uplift and American Music 1878–1943 (Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, chapter 5.

45 Schenbeck, 8–10, makes the uplift and elite-defining argument, but also eloquently puts the case for a sympathetic “measured re-evaluation” of the musical ideals of the African American proponents of the European classical music tradition.

46 Vaillant, “Sounds of Whiteness,” 39.

47 See www.nanm.org/AboutUs.html.

48 Levine, Lawrence W., Highbrow/Lowbrow: The Emergence of Cultural Hierarchy in America (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1988)Google Scholar; Horowitz, Joseph, Classical Music in America: A History of Its Rise and Fall (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2005)Google Scholar.

49 “Bouquet for Major,” Afro-American, 14 Dec. 1935, 9

50 Sample of 53 applications marked “Negro” from Boxes 1 to 3 of the Library of Congress Amateur Hour collection.

51 Best, Wallace D., Passionately Human, No Less Divine: Religion and Culture in Black Chicago, 1915–1952 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2007), 100–4Google Scholar; Baldwin, Davarian L., Chicago's New Negroes: Modernity, the Great Migration, & Black Urban Life (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2007), 158–62Google Scholar.

52 Allen, Ray and Cunningham, George P., “Cultural Uplift and Double Consciousness: African American Responses to the 1935 Opera Porgy and Bess,” American Musics, 88 (2006), 342–69, 346Google Scholar.

53 Boxes 1 and 2, Amateur Hour collection, LOC. Wade did win on Amateur Hour and toured South America and the Caribbean with a Bowes unit. Chicago Defender, 7 Nov. 1936, 7.

54 “Swingin’ the News,” Chicago Defender, 8 June 1940, 20.

55 Transcribed from the recording held in the Recorded Sound Reference Center, LOC.

56 Folder 4, Box 6, Amateur Hour collection, LOC.

57 Folder 19, Box 35, NBC papers, WHS.

58 “Otis Holley, Promising Soprano,” Amsterdam News, 6 June 1936, 13; E. Frenche Monroe, “Chattanooga, Tenn.,” Baltimore Afro-American, 21 March 1925, 17.

59 Quoted in Radio Guide, 29 Feb. 1936, 14.

60 “Miss Holley,” Chicago Defender, 1 Aug. 1931, 5.

61 “Golden Voice of Southern Girl Lifts Her from Kitchen,” Norfolk New Journal and Guide, 6 July 1935, 1; “Otis Holley, Promising Soprano.”

62 Ibid., 13.

63 “New York City,” Philadelphia Tribune, 17 March 1932, 15.

64 “Announce Winners in Poetry Contest,” Amsterdam News, 13 April 1932, 11.

65 Mark Hellinger, “All in a Day,” San Mateo Times, 29 Jan. 1936, 6; Radio Guide, 29 Feb. 1936, 14.

66 “Dishing the Dirt,” Afro-American, 9 June 1934, 9; “Music News,” Amsterdam News, 7 April 1934, 7; “Radio Review,” Afro-American, 24 March 1934, 8; “Radio Review,” Afro-American, 30 June 1934, 8.

67 “Otis Holley, Promising Soprano.”

68 Radio Guide, 29 Feb 1936, 14.

69 Ibid., 13.

70 White to Bowes, 4 Nov. 1935. NAACP Administrative File – Discrimination, NAACP records microfilm E 5 Pt.11A reel 23.

71 Bowes to White, 6 Nov. 1935, in ibid.

72 White to Holley and Holley to White, 8 Nov. 1935, in ibid.

73 Walter White memo to Roy Wilkins, 13 Nov. 1935, in ibid.

74 White to Bowes, 22 Nov. 1935, in ibid.

75 “Protests Barring of Amateur Hour,” Pittsburgh Courier, 23 Nov. 1935, 3.

76 Undated letter in NAACP Holley file.

77 “Otis Holley, Promising Soprano.”

78 Frances Moss Mann, “Music Notes,” Amsterdam News, 20 April 1935, 4.

79 “Rosenwald Fund Makes 30 Awards,” New York Times, 1 May 1937, 21; Julius Rosenwald Fund: Review for the Two-Year Period 1936–1938 (Chicago, 1938), 21; Schenbeck, Racial Uplift, chapter 6, discusses the work of the fund in supporting African American classical music performers.

80 “Otis Holley Pleases in Musical Recital,” Amsterdam News, 20 March 1937, 11.

81 “Soprano in Debut,” Afro-American, 14 Oct. 1944, 12.

82 1930 US Census.

83 “Grants Audition to Dramatic Soprano,” Amsterdam News, 7 April 1934, 7.

84 “Two Singers Get Roles in Opera Aida,” Chicago Defender, 30 Oct. 1937, 7.

85 “La Julia Rhea Gives Audition,” Afro-American, 7 April 1934, 9.

86 Peter Hudson, “Opera,” in Kwame Anthony Appiah and Henry Louis Gates Jr., eds., Africana: The Encyclopedia of the African and African American Experience, Volume IV (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), 287.

87 Biographical information from La Julia Rhea, “Many Years Ago,” typescript in Folder 1, Box 63, National Negro Opera Company (NNOC) papers, Music Division, LOC; Rhea, La Julia, America's First Black Artist to Star with a Major Opera Company (Chicago: self-published, 197?)Google Scholar, Folder 2, Box 63, NNOC papers, LOC; “House of Divine Design,” Chicago Tribune, 26 Feb. 1986, D1.

88 “Vote Tabulations for 8th Major Bowes’ Amateur Hour,” Folder 19, Box 35, NBC papers, WHS; Charles Bowen, “On the Air,” Afro-American, 7 Sept. 1935, 8.

89 “La Julia Rhea Is Acclaimed Operatic Star,” Chicago Defender, 8 Aug. 1936, 8.

90 “Back Door Stuff,” Chicago Defender, 14 Sept. 1935, 5.

91 “Major Bowes’ Amateur Show at Marbro,” The Garfieldian, 28 Nov. 1935, 1.

92 “La Julia Rhea Crashes Gate of Opera Fame,” Chicago Defender, 7 Sept. 1935, 18.

93 Ibid.

94 “Operatic Star Turns Down Bid to Go to Dixie,” Chicago Defender, 28 Dec. 1935, 5.

95 Rhea, America's First Black Artist.

96 “Ky. Singer Becomes First Colored Star to Enact ‘Aida’,” Atlanta Daily World, 30 Oct. 1937, 1.

97 Atlanta Daily World, 27 March 1945, 2.

98 “Opera Stars Score in ‘Aida’,” Atlanta Daily World, 29 Dec. 1937, 1.

99 Lee Pattison to La Julia Rhea, 22 July 1938, in Rhea, America's First Black Artist.

100 “La Julia Rhea Crashes Gate of Opera Fame”; “‘Aida’ Brilliant Climax,” Philadelphia Tribune, 6 Sept. 1941, 14.

101 Atlanta Daily World, 27 March 1945, 2, and 28 March 1945, 3; Afro-American, 3 Nov. 1945, 11; “Soloist with Chicago Symphony,” Afro-American, 11 Aug. 1945, 8.

102 “Chicago Group in Concert Business,” Amsterdam News, 20 Nov. 1948, 4.

103 “Opera Star Builds Home,” Chicago Tribune, 11 Sept. 1969, 2.

104 “A Month of Dreams and Courage,” Chicago Tribune, 31 Jan. 1986, A5.

105 Keiler, Allan, Marian Anderson: A Singer's Journey (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2002), 65Google Scholar.

106 “FCC Probes Radio Jim Crow System,” Chicago Defender, 15 Aug. 1942, 23.

107 “Move Blocked to Inject Jim Crow into Radio Show,” Atlanta Daily World, 2 July 1946, 1.

108 “Lena Horne Swats Radio's Jim Crow,” Chicago Defender, 20 Sept. 1947, 15.

109 Karpf, Juanita, “‘As with Words of Fire’: Art Music and Nineteenth-Century African-American Feminist Discourse,” Signs, 24 (1999), 603–32, 625CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 607.

110 W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk, in Eric J. Sundquist, ed., The Oxford W. E. B. Du Bois Reader (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996), 97–240, 157.

111 Bryant, Clora, Kelson, Jack, Tapscott, Horace and Wilson, Gerald, eds., Central Avenue Sounds: Jazz in Los Angeles (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998), 381–82Google Scholar.