Hostname: page-component-f554764f5-sl7kg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-04-12T07:10:48.880Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Devil or Angel? The Role of Speculation in the Recent Commodity Price Boom (and Bust)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 January 2015

Scott H. Irwin ,
Dwight R. Sanders  and
Robert P. Merrin
Scott H. Irwin
Affiliation:
Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics at the University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
Dwight R. Sanders
Affiliation:
Department of Agribusiness Economics at Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Illinois
Robert P. Merrin
Affiliation:
Department of Finance at Universiteit Maastricht, The Netherlands
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

It is commonly asserted that speculative buying by index funds in commodity futures and over-the–counter derivatives markets created a “bubble“ in commodity prices, with the result that prices, and crude oil prices, in particular, far exceeded fundamental values at the peak. The purpose of this paper is to show that the bubble argument simply does not withstand close scrutiny. Four main points are explored. First, the arguments of bubble proponents are conceptually flawed and reflect fundamental and basic misunderstandings of how commodity futures markets actually work. Second, a number of facts about the situation in commodity markets are inconsistent with the existence of a substantial bubble in commodity prices. Third, available statistical evidence does not indicate that positions for any group in commodity futures markets, including long-only index funds, consistently lead futures price changes. Fourth, there is a historical pattern of attacks upon speculation during periods of extreme market volatility.

Keywords

commodityfuturesindex fundmarketspeculationQ11Q13
Type
Invited Paper Sessions
Information
Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics , Volume 41 , Issue 2 , August 2009 , pp. 377 - 391
Copyright
Copyright © Southern Agricultural Economics Association 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Aulerich, N.M., and Irwin, S.H. “Direct Evidence on the Relationship between Daily Positions of Index Traders and Price Changes in Commodity Futures Markets.” Paper to be presented at the NCCC-134 Conference on Applied Commodity Price Analysis, Forecasting, and Market Risk Management, St. Louis, Missouri, April 20-21, 2009.Google Scholar
Bryant, H., Bessler, D.A., and Haigh, M.S. “Causality in Futures Markets.” Journal of Futures Markets 26(2006): 1039–57.Google Scholar
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). “CFTC Emergency Authority Background.” Washington D.C, 2008a. Internet Site: http://cftc.gov/stellent/groups/public/@newsroom/documents/file/cftcemergencyauthoritybackgrou.pdf (Accessed June 26, 2008).Google Scholar
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). “Staff Report on Commodity Swap Dealers & Index Traders with Commission Recommendations.” Washington, DC, 2008b. Internet Site: http://www.cftc.gov/stellent/groups/public/@newsroom/documents/file/cftcstaffreportonswapdealers09.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Cooper, R.N., and Lawrence, R.Z. “The 1972–75 Commodity Boom.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 3(1975:671–723.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis, A. “Cargill's Inside View Helps It Buck Downturn.” The Wall Street Journal, January 14, 2009. Internet Site: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123189501407679581.html?mod=rss_whats_ news_us (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
De Long, J.B., Shleifer, A., Summers, L.H., and Waldmann, R.J. “Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets.” The Journal of Political Economy 98(1990:703–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engelke, L., and Yuen, J.C. “Types of Commodity Investments.” The Handbook of Commodity Investing. Fabozzi, FJ, Fuss, R, and Kaiser, D, eds., pp. 549–69. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, 2008.Google Scholar
Fishe, R.P.H., and Goldberg, L.G. “The Effects of Margins on Trading in Futures Markets.” Journal of Futures Markets 6(1986):261–71.Google Scholar
Garbade, K.D., and Silber, W.L. “Price Movements and Price Discovery in Futures and Cash Markets.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 65(1983:289–97.Google Scholar
Gheit, F. “Testimony before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations of the Committee on Energy and Commerce, U.S. House of Representatives.” Internet Site: http://energycom-merce.house.gov/cmte_mtgs/110-oi-hrg.062308.Gheit-testimony.pdf (Accessed June 23, 2008).Google Scholar
Good, D., and Irwin, S. “Implications of Credit Market Problems for Crop Prices.” Illinois Farm Economics Update 2008-03, Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2008. Internet Site: http://www.farmdoc.uiuc.edu/IFEUAFEU_08_03/IFEU_08_03.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Gorton, G.B., Hayashi, F., and Rouwenhorst, K.G. “The Fundamentals of Commodity Futures Returns.” National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Working Paper No. 13249, July 2007.Google Scholar
Grossman, S.J “An Analysis of “Insider Trading” on Futures Markets.” Journal of Business 59(1986):S129-46.Google Scholar
Hamilton, J.D Time Series Analysis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1994.Google Scholar
Hamilton, J.D “Understanding Crude Oil Prices.” Working Paper. Department of Economics, University of California—San Diego, 2008. Internet Site: http://dss.ucsd.edu/~jhamilto/understand_oil.pdf (Accessed May 22, 2008).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hardouvelis, G.A., and Kim, D. “Price Volatility and Futures Margins.” Journal of Futures Markets 16(1996:81–111.3.0.CO;2-D>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hartzmark, M.L “Returns to Individual Traders of Futures: Aggregate Results.” The Journal of Political Economy 95(1987): 1292–306.Google Scholar
Hieronymus, T.A. Economics of Futures Trading for Commercial and Personal Profit. 2nd ed. New York, NY: Commodity Research Bureau, 1977.Google Scholar
Interagency Task Force on Commodity Markets (ITFCM). “Interim Report on Crude Oil.” Washington D.C., 2008. Internet Site: http://www.cftc.gov/stellent/groups/public/@newsroom/documents/file/itfinterimreportoncrudeoil0708.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Irwin, S.H., Garcia, P., Good, D.L., and Kunda, E.L. “Recent Convergence Performance of CBOT Com, Soybean, and Wheat Futures Contracts.” Choices, 2nd Quarter, 23(2008): 16–21. Internet Site: http://www.choicesmagazine.org/magazine/article.php?article=26 (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Jacks, D.S “Populists versus Theorists: Futures Markets and the Volatility of Prices.” Explorations in Economic History 44(2007):342–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Krugman, P. “More on Oil and Speculation.” New York Times, May 13, 2008. Internet Site: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/05/13/more-on-oil-and-speculation/ (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Labys, W.C., and Thomas, H.C. “Speculation, Hedging and Commodity Price Behavior: An International Comparison.” Applied Economics 7(1975:287–301.Google Scholar
Masters, M.W “Testimony before the Committee on Homeland Security and Government Affairs, U.S. Senate.” Internet Site: http://hsgac.senate.gov/public/_files/052008Masters.pdf (Accessed May 20, 2008).Google Scholar
Masters, M.W., and White, A.K. “The Accidental Hunt Brothers: How Institutional Investors are Driving up Food and Energy Prices.” 2008. Internet Site: http://accidentalhuntbrothers.com/ (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Meyer, G., and Cui, C. “U.S. Oil Fund Finds Itself at the Mercy of Traders.” The Wall Street Journal, March 6, 2009. Internet Site: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123629874701846317.html (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Patel, J., Zeckhauser, R., and Hendricks, D. “The Rationality Struggle: Illustrations from Financial Markets.” The American Economic Review 81(1991:232–36.Google Scholar
Peck, A.E “Reflections of Hedging on Futures Markets.” Food Research Institute Studies 17(1979-1980):327–49.Google Scholar
Peck, A.E., and Budge, C. “The Effects of Extraordinary Speculative Margins in the 1947–48 Grain Futures Markets.” Food Research Institute Studies 20(1987): 165–80.Google Scholar
Petzel, T.E. “A New Look at Some Old Evidence: The Wheat Market Scandal of 1925.” Food Research Institute Studies 18(1981): 117–28.Google Scholar
Rainbolt, J.V “Regulating the Grain Gambler and His Successors.” Hofstra Law Review 6(1977): 1–25.Google Scholar
Sanders, D.R., Boris, K., and Manfredo, M. “Hedgers, Funds, and Small Speculators in the Energy Futures Markets: An Analysis of the CFTC's Commitments of Traders Reports.” Energy Economics 26(2004):425–45.Google Scholar
Sanders, D.R., Irwin, S.H., and Merrin, R.P. “The Adequacy of Speculation in Agricultural Futures Markets: Too Much of a Good Thing?” Marketing and Outlook Research Report 200802. Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2008a. Internet Site: http://www.farmdoc.uiuc.edu/marketing/morr/mori_08-02/morr_08-02.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Sanders, D.R., Irwin, S.H., and Merrin, R.P. “Smart Money? The Forecasting Ability of CFTC Large Traders.” Working Paper. Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign, 2008b. Internet Site: http://www.farmdoc.uiuc.edu/irwin/research/SmartMoneyCFTCTradersl.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Shleifer, A., and Summers, L.H. “The Noise Trader Approach to Finance.” The Journal of Economic Perspectives 4(1990): 19–33.Google Scholar
Stout, L.A “Why the Law Hates Speculators: Regulation and Private Ordering in the Market for OTC Derivatives.” Duke Law Journal 48(1999:701–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Streeter, D.H., and Tomek, W.G. “Variability in Soybean Futures Prices: An Integrated Framework.” Journal of Futures Markets 12(1992): 705–28.Google Scholar
Stulz, R.M “Rethinking Risk Management.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 9(1996): 8–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tomek, W.G “Margins on Futures Contracts: Their Economic Roles and Regulation.” Futures Markets: Regulatory Issues. Peck, A.E., ed., pp. 143–209. Washington D.C: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, 1985.Google Scholar
Trostle, R. “Global Agricultural Supply and Demand: Factors Contributing to the Recent Increase in Food Commodity Prices.” Outlook Report No. WRS-0801. Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, May 2008. Internet Site: http://www.ers.usda.gov/Publications/WRS0801/WRS0801.pdf (Accessed April 2, 2009).Google Scholar
Williams, J. Manipulation on Trial: Economic Analysis and the Hunt Silver Case. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1995.Google Scholar
Working, H. “Speculation on Hedging Markets.” Food Research Institute Studies 1(1960): 185–220.Google Scholar
Working, H. “Futures Markets Under Renewed Attack.” Food Research Institute Studies 4(1963): 13–24.Google Scholar
Zulauf, C.R., and Irwin, S.H. “Market Efficiency and Marketing to Enhance Income of Crop Producers.” Review of Agricultural Economics 20(1998:308–331.Google Scholar