Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T18:33:07.524Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The New Constitution of Nigeria, 1979: “The Washington Model”?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

James S. Read
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The end of almost fourteen years of military government, with the restoration of civilian rule in Nigeria on 1st October, 1979, would inevitably have been a landmark of great significance for Africa and the Commonwealth. What has given it quite exceptional importance is the fact that Nigeria, turning its back on Westminster, has chosen to adopt a new constitutional structure which can aptly be regarded as a version of “the Washington model”. This appears as a striking and innovative departure among Commonwealth constitutions which, despite the proliferation of republican systems, including executive presidencies and, in Africa, the spread of one-party models, generally preserve—in theory at least—certain basic features of “the Westminster model”: hence the preference for a parliamentary executive, in many states combined with presidential rule, however unrealistic in practice the notion of ministerial responsibility to parliament may have become. The new Nigerian Constitution has no place for such terms as “parliament”, “cabinet” or “prime minister”, yet the transition from the Westminster to a Washington model is a logical, predictable one likely to prompt imitation elsewhere: indeed, the new Constitution of Ghana, where military government also came to an end in 1979, has taken the same path.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of African Law , Volume 23 , Issue 2 , Autumn 1979 , pp. 131 - 174
Copyright
Copyright © School of Oriental and African Studies 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

1 See Robert, Martin, “Legislatures and economic development in Commonwealth Africa”, [1977] Public Law 48–83.Google Scholar
2Nigeria (Constitution) Order in Council 1960, S.I. 1960 No. 1652.Google Scholar
3Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1963, Act No. 20.Google Scholar
4Constitution (Suspension and Modification) Decrees 1966.Google Scholar
Constitution (Repeal and Restoration) Decree 1967.Google Scholar
Constitution (Miscellaneous Provisions) Decrees 1967, Nos. 20 and 27.Google Scholar
Federal Military Government (Supremacy and Enforcement of Powers) Decree 1970 No. 28.Google Scholar
Constitution (Basic Provisions) Decree 1975, No. 32.Google Scholar
5Constitution (Amendment) Decree 1974, No. 33.Google Scholar
6e.g. Constitution (Financial Provisions, etc.) Decree 1975, No. 6;Google Scholar
Constitution (Amendment) Decrees 1976, Nos. 4 and 42; etc.Google Scholar
7See especially Mackinstosh, John P., Nigerian Government and Politics (London, 1966, Allen and Unwin Ltd.)Google Scholar
8[1962] W.N.L.R. 185, 197; [1962] 1 All N.L.R. 442.Google Scholar
9[1962] W.N.L.R. 203; [1962] 1 All N.L.R. 465; [1963] A.C. 614; [1963] 3 All E.R. 544.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
10Constitution of Western Nigeria (Amendment) Law No. 1, 1963.Google Scholar
11West Africa, 6th October, 1975.Google Scholar
12States (Creation and Transitional Provisions) Decree 1976, No. 12; Federal Capital Territory Decree 1976, No. 6.Google Scholar
13Report of the Constitution Drafting Committee, Lagos, 1976, Federal Ministry of Information.Google Scholar
14Ibid., Volume I, xli-xliii.Google Scholar
15Ibid., para. 3.2–3.Google Scholar
16Ibid., para. 3.7.Google Scholar
17Ibid., para. 3.6.Google Scholar
18No. 6. See [1978] J.A.L. 136–60.Google Scholar
19Report, Vol. 1, para. 3.5.Google Scholar
19AS.203(1)(b).Google Scholar
20Ibid., para. 4.3.Google Scholar
21Ibid., para. 6.2.Google Scholar
22Ibid., para. 6.4.Google Scholar
23Allocation of Revenue (Constitutional Amendment) Act 1965.Google Scholar
24See Adebayo, Adedeji, Nigerian federal finance (London, 1969, Hutchinson Educational Ltd.)Google Scholar
25Ibid., p. 254.Google Scholar
26Figures given are quoted from Nigeria: Recurrent and Capital Estimates of the Government of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (Lagos, annually, Federal Ministry of Information).Google Scholar
27Constitution (Financial Provisions etc.) Decree 1975, No. 6.Google Scholar
28Report, para 7.4.Google Scholar
29Commodity Boards Decree 1977, No. 29.Google Scholar
30Report, para. 6.8.Google Scholar
31Exclusive Legislative List, Item 59.Google Scholar
32Report, para. 6. 11.Google Scholar
33Ibid., para. 7.1–5.Google Scholar
34Ibid., para. 7.1–9.Google Scholar
34AFederal Court of Appeal Decree 1976, No. 43. Constitution (Amendment) (No. 2) Decree 1976, No. 42.Google Scholar
35Constituent Assembly Decree 1977, No. 50.Google Scholar
36Federal Electoral Commission Decree 1977, No. 41.Google Scholar
37West Africa, 19th June, 1978.Google Scholar
38No. 73.Google Scholar
39West Africa, 16 January 1978.Google Scholar
40West Africa, 14th November, 1977.Google Scholar
41Ibid., 17th April, 1978.Google Scholar
42Dent, M. J., “Dangers of polarity in religious matters”, West Africa, 24th April 1978.Google Scholar
43West Africa, 24th April, 1978.Google Scholar
44Ibid., 28th August, 1978.Google Scholar
45The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1978 (Lagos 1978, Federal Ministry of Information). See also Constituent Assembly: Decisions of the Constituent Assembly on the Draft Constitution and The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1978: Explanatory Note and Comparative Table (Lagos, 1978, Federal Ministry of Information).Google Scholar
46Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (Enactment) Decree 1978, N o. 25, Preamble.Google Scholar
47S. 274.Google Scholar
48Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (Certain Consequential Repeals) Decree 1978, No. 26.Google Scholar
49S. 274 (5).Google Scholar
50S. 1 (2).Google Scholar
51S. 2 (I).Google Scholar
52S. 4–6, 8 and 9.Google Scholar
53S. 10.Google Scholar
54S. 13–22.Google Scholar
55S. 30–42.Google Scholar
56S. 31 (2) (d) (iii).Google Scholar
57S. 32.Google Scholar
58S. 33.Google Scholar
59Report, para. 4.5–2.Google Scholar
60S. 34.Google Scholar
61S. 35 (4).Google Scholar
62S. 37Google Scholar
63S. 39 (1).Google Scholar
64S. 39 (2).Google Scholar
65Report, para. 4.8.Google Scholar
66No. 6 of 1978; [1978] J.A.L. 136–60.Google Scholar
67S.40 (1).Google Scholar
68S. 40 (3).Google Scholar
69S.41.(1).Google Scholar
70S. 41 (2).Google Scholar
71S. 265.Google Scholar
72S. 42.Google Scholar
73Constitution (Amendment) Decree 1974, No. 33.Google Scholar
74Report, para. 5.2.Google Scholar
75Chapter III, ss. 23–29.Google Scholar
75AS. 268.Google Scholar
76Chapter V, Part I, ss. 43–83.Google Scholar
77S. 54.Google Scholar
78Author's term. Section 55 refers to Appropriation bills and bills for the imposition, increase, reduction or withdrawal of any tax, duty etc.Google Scholar
79S. 64 (1) (g).Google Scholar
80S. 37, proviso (b).Google Scholar
81Chapter V, Part II, ss. 84–121.Google Scholar
82S. 91.Google Scholar
83S. 71 (2), 109 (2) and 124 (5).Google Scholar
84S. 4 (5).Google Scholar
85By the Prisons Decree 1972, No. 9.Google Scholar
86S. 12.Google Scholar
87Items 14, 55 and 56 of the Exclusive Legislative List.Google Scholar
88S. 150.Google Scholar
89Constitution (Financial Provisions etc.) Decree 1975, No. 6, replacing section 140 of the Constitution of 1963.Google Scholar
90S. 149.Google Scholar
91Ibid.Google Scholar
92S. 272.Google Scholar
93S. 151.Google Scholar
94Concurrent Legislative List, Item D.Google Scholar
95Para. 6.7.Google Scholar
96Ibid.Google Scholar
97Chapter VI, Part I, A, ss. 122–139.Google Scholar
98S. 126.Google Scholar
99No. 73, as amended by the Electoral (Amendment) Decree 1979, No. 32.Google Scholar
100S. 132.Google Scholar
101S. 133.Google Scholar
102S. 171.Google Scholar
103S. 63.Google Scholar
104S. 76.Google Scholar
105S. 135.Google Scholar
106S. 14(3).Google Scholar
107S. 138. He is in control of public prosecutions under Federal laws: s. 160.Google Scholar
108S. 139.Google Scholar
109Myers v. United States (1926), 272 U.S. 52; Morgan v. T.V.A. (1941), 312 U.S. 701. The untrammelled power of removal does not extend to officials who do not exercise executive powers vested in the President: Humphrey's Executor v. U.S. (1935), 295 U.S. 602; Wiener v. U.S. (1958), 357 U.S. 349.Google Scholar
110Constitution of Ghana 1979, article 69; the President of Ghana is also expressly empowered to remove a Minister: article 68. The Constitution of Nigeria recognises the right of any person to resign from an office to which he has been appointed or elected: section 266.Google Scholar
111Chapter VI, Part I, B, ss. 140–148 and Third Schedule, Part I.Google Scholar
112S. 193.Google Scholar
113Although the actual registration of births, deaths—and marriages—is one of the “main functions of a local government council” prescribed by the Fourth Schedule.Google Scholar
114Chapter VI, Part II, A, ss. 162–177.Google Scholar
115S. 173.Google Scholar
116S. 14 (4).Google Scholar
117S. 176. He controls public prosecutions under State laws: section 191.Google Scholar
118S. 177.Google Scholar
119Chapter VI, Part II, B, ss. 178–186 and Third Schedule, Part II.Google Scholar
120Chapter VI, Part III, D, ss. 201–209.Google Scholar
121Chapter VI, Part I, D (Federal Public Service), ss. 156–159; Part II, C (State Public Services), ss. 187–190.Google Scholar
122Chapter VI, Part III, B, ss. 194–196.Google Scholar
123Chapter VI, Part III, C, ss. 197–200.Google Scholar
124S. 200.Google Scholar
125Report, para. 7.5.Google Scholar
126S. 158 and 189 require persons in the Federal or a State public service respectively to observe and conform to the Code of Conduct.Google Scholar
127Chapter VII, ss. 210–260.Google Scholar
128S. 9.Google Scholar
129S. 8.Google Scholar
130Under s. 9 (3).Google Scholar
131S. 7 (1).Google Scholar
132Fourth Schedule.Google Scholar