Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-07T04:23:58.020Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Tribal Boundaries and Border Wars: Nuer–Dinka Relations in the Sobat and Zaraf Valleys, c. 1860–19761

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Douglas H. Johnson
Affiliation:
Southern Regional Records Office, Juba

Extract

Nuer–Dinka relations are usually described as being based on constant mutual hostility. An examination of Nuer–Dinka relations along the Sobat and Zaraf valleys since the beginning of Nuer eastward expansion in the nineteenth century reveals a different pattern. Conflict during the immediate Nuer conquest of Dinka territory was followed by assimilation of individual Dinka into the Nuer social and political system. Through kinship ties connecting both communities a number of Nuer segments began to have closer relations with various Dinka groups than they had with related but more distant Nuer segments. Such relations inhibited the expansion of hostilities, and Nuer raids against the Dinka became increasingly selective. By the end of the nineteenth century a number of religious leaders deliberately fostered the growth of a Nuer–Dinka community. With the arrival of the Anglo-Egyptian administration an attempt was made to separate the Nuer and Dinka into discrete political units, and this policy exacerbated tensions between some of the neighbouring Nuer and Dinka settlements. The policy of separation ultimately failed due to the strength of the ties linking the two peoples. The model of structural opposition between Nuer and Dinka which Evans-Pritchard presented is based on data gathered during the early 1930s when separation was in force. It must now be modified by an examination of evidence covering a longer historical period.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Johnson, D. H., ‘The Fighting Nuer: primary sources and the origins of a stereotype,’ Africa, LI, i (1981), 508527.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 Evans-Pritchard, E. E., The Nuer (Oxford, 1940), 122–3, 129132.Google Scholar

4 P. Coriat to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 28 November 1931, Province Archives, Malakal [PAM] 66.B.ii. Evans-Pritchard, E. E., ‘The Nuer: tribe and clan’, Sudan Notes and Records [SNR], xvi, i (1933), 5, 53.Google ScholarCrazzolara, J. P., Zur Gesellschaft und Religion der Nueer (Vienna, 1953), 36.Google Scholar

5 Evans-Pritchard, , ‘The Nuer’ (1933), 51–3Google Scholar; The Nuer, 221–5; ‘Kinship and local community among the Nuer’, in African Systems of Kinship and Marriage, ed. Radcliffe-Brown, A. R. and Forde, D. (London, 1950)Google Scholar; Kinship and Marriage among the Nuer (Oxford, 1951).Google Scholar

6 Evans-Pritchard, , The Nuer, 123, 130–2.Google Scholar

7 Ibid., 130–2.

8 The Equatorial Nile Project and Its Effects on the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, I (Khartoum, 1954), 22, 207–8.Google Scholar Mar Kutien (BG), 16 April 1976. Kulang Majiok (BG), 13 April 1981. The majority of interviews on which this paper is based were conducted in 1975–6. All informants are identified by the following notations: (BG) Bar Gaawar, (RG) Radh Gaawar, (GL) Gun Lou, (ML) Mor Lou, (TN) Thiang Nuer, (GaJ) Gaajak Jikany, (GoJ) Gaajok Jikany, (ND) Nyarraweng Dinka, (RD) Rut Dinka, (TD) Twij Dinka. The date of the interview is given, but where only one interview is cited, the date is omitted after the first citation.

9 The Equatorial Nile Project, I, 208. Cuol Kai (TN), 16 Nov. 1980. Howell, P. P.: ‘The Zeraf Hills,’ SNR, XXVI, ii (1945), 320Google Scholar; and ‘Appendix to chapter ii’ in Lienhardt, R. G., Divinity and Experience (Oxford, 1961), 98.Google Scholar

10 Jok Jang and Gac Ruea (GaJ), 14 June 1976. Tierney, ‘Legendary history of the Jikany’, Southern Regional Records Office, Juba [SRRO], UNP 66.A.6/4. Coriat, ‘Report on Eastern District (Nuer), Bahr el Ghazal Province’, 1931, Eastern Nuer District, Nasir [END] 66.A.i.

11 Evans-Pritchard, : ‘The Nuer: tribe and clan’, SNR, xvii, ii (1934), 22Google Scholar; and ‘Kinship and local community’, 366. Chatterton, B. J.: ‘Jekaing Nuer and Rueng Dinka’ (1933)Google Scholar, PAM 66.A.4; and ‘Rueng Dinka’ (1934), PAM 66.E.4 Crazzolara, J. P., The Lwoo, ii (Verona 1951), 151–2.Google Scholar

12 Chatterton, as cited in note ii.

13 Jok Jang and Gac Ruea (GoJ). Duop Biciuk (GaJ), 20 October 1976. Hofmayr, F., Die Schilluk (Vienna, 1925), 94–5.Google ScholarCrazzolara, , The Lwoo, ii, 153.Google Scholar

14 Werne, F., Expedition to Discover the Sources of the White Nile, ii (London, 1849), 232, 240, 246.Google ScholarGifoon, Ali Effendi, ‘Memoirs of a Sudanese soldier’, Cornhill Magazine, 3rd series, i (1896), 34.Google Scholar

15 Wilson, H. H., ‘Report on the Dinkas of the White Nile’, Sudan Intelligence Report [SIR], 104 (March 1903), 13, 17.Google Scholar ‘Patrol in Dunjol Dinka Country East of Kodok’ (1915), SRRO UNP SCR 39/i. Johnson, D. H., ‘History and prophecy among the Nuer of the Southern Sudan’ (Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles, 1980), 98100, 394–6.Google Scholar

16 J., and Poncet, A., Le Fleuve Blanc (Alexandria, 1937), 4950.Google Scholar

17 ‘Extract from Western Nuer monthly diary for January 1934’, END 66.A.i.

18 Evans-Pritchard, , Kinship and Marriage, 157–8, 162–7.Google ScholarLienhardt, R. G., ‘The Western Dinka,’ in Tribes Without Rulers, ed. Middleton, J. and Tait, D. (London, 1958), 119–20.Google Scholar

19 Deng, F. M., Africans of Two Worlds: The Dinka of the Afro-Arab Sudan (New Haven, 1978), 215–16.Google Scholar

20 Howell, , ‘Appendix to chapter ii’, 9899.Google ScholarWyld, J., ‘Report and notes on Bor-Duk District’ (November 1930)Google Scholar, Central Records Office, Khartoum [CRO] Civsec 57/2/8. Makor Guot and Malual Amol (ND) 29 April 1976.

21 Poncet, , Fleuve Blanc, 46, 118.Google ScholarLejean, G., Voyage aux Deux Nils (Paris, 1865), 81.Google ScholarHowell, , ‘Zeraf Hills,’ 320.Google Scholar

22 Petherick, J., Travels in Central Africa, I (London, 1869) 105.Google ScholarMarno, E., ‘Der Bahr Seraf’, Petermann's Mittheilungen, XIX (1873), 132.Google ScholarEvans-Pritchard, , The Nuer, 224.Google Scholar

23 Evans-Pritchard, , ‘The Nuer’ (1933), 51–2Google Scholar; and The Nuer, 221–3.

24 Evans-Pritchard, , ‘The Nuer’ (1933), 53Google Scholar; The Nuer, 223–4, 227; ‘Kinship and local community’, 379, 383; Kinship and Marriage, 19–20.

25 Gany Car Koryom (GL), 17 July 1975.

26 Marno, E., Reisen im Gebiet des Blauen und Weissen Nil (Vienna, 1874), 394.Google ScholarHill, G. B., Colonel Gordon in Central Africa, 1874–1879 (London, 1881), 21.Google ScholarShukry, M. F., Equatoria under Egyptian Rule (Cairo, 1953), 157–9, 219–23.Google Scholar

27 Ruot Yuot (RG) 12 April 1975.

28 Malual Mayom and Ruot Rom (RG), 27 March 1975. Kulang Majiok (BG) 7 June 1975. Ruot Yuot (RG), 12 April 1975. Ruot Diu (BG), 16 April 1976. Struvé, K. C. P., in Report by His Majesty's Agent and Consul-General on the Finances, Administration, and Condition of the Sudan [GGR] (1908), 656.Google Scholar Makor Guot (ND).

29 Coriat, P., The Gaweir Nuer (Khartoum, c. 1923), 3.Google Scholar

30 Matthews, G. E., in GGR (1904), 133.Google Scholar

31 Ruot Rom (RG). Ruot Yuot (RG), 12 April 1975. Kulang Majiok (BG), 7 June 1975. Ruot Diu (BG).

32 He may have been apprehensive about his future. Gordon reported that a Nuer chief allied to the slavers complained that with the merchants gone the local tribes would turn on him: Hill, , Colonel Gordon, 21–2.Google Scholar

33 Makor Guot (ND). Ruot Diu (BG). Gel Paker Mer (RD), 4 May 1976.

34 Ruot Yuot (BG), 12 April 1975. Diu Garadin (BG), 28 April 1975. Matit Kal and Cuol Macar Diu (BG), 15 April 1976. Ruot Diu (BG).

35 Wyld, ‘Report and notes on Bor-Duk District.’ ‘Panyok Meeting’ (8 Feb. 1944), PAM 66.B.5/4.

36 Cuol Puyu (ML) 27 June 1975.

37 Deng Bor Ngundeng (GL), 25 June 1975. Bil Peat (GL), 11 July 1975. Macar Ngundeng (GL), 28 June 1975. Cuol Dual Diu (BG), 3 May 1976. Makor Guot (ND). Gac Ruea (GoJ), 1 July 1976. Deng, F. M., The Dinka and Their Songs (Oxford, 1973), 208.Google ScholarEvans-Pritchard, , ‘The Nuer’ (1934), 22.Google Scholar

38 Lienhardt, , Divinity and Experience, 157–8, 206.Google Scholar

39 Johnson, , ‘History and prophecy among the Nuer’, 189–91, 248–50.Google Scholar

40 Wan Deang (RD-BG) 13 June 1975. Cuol Dual Diu (BG). D. C. Zeraf Valley District to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 31 May 1932, PAM 66.B.ii. Kulang Majiok (BG)7June 1975. Struvé, K. C. P.: ‘Report on Khor Atar District’, SIR 153 (April 1907), 10Google Scholar; and in GGR (1908), 656.Google ScholarSchweitzer, G., Emin Pasha, His Life and Work, i (London, 1898), 184.Google ScholarLiddell, J. S., ‘Report on march fromTaufikia to Twi’, SIR 119 (June 1904), 5.Google Scholar

41 Ruot Yuot (RG), 12 April 1975.

42 Matit Kal and Cuol Macar Diu (BG). Ruot Diu (BG). Cuol Dual Diu (BG).

43 Cuol Macar Diu, Ruot Rom and Gai Thany (BG and RG), 12 April 1981.

44 ‘Return of prominent persons in Upper Nile Province,’ (1909), SRRO UNP (unnumbered). Liddell, , ‘Report’, 6.Google ScholarWilson, H. H., ‘March from the Sobat…to Bor’, SIR 128 (March 1905), 6, 8.Google Scholar

45 Malual Mayom (RG). Kulang Majiok (BG), 24 April 1975. Mar Kutien (BG).

46 Sparkes, W. S., ‘Patrol from Fashoda to the Bahr al Zeraf’, SIR 62 (16 Feb. to 30 April 1899), 10.Google ScholarSIR 72 (9 July to 6 August 1900), 2.Google ScholarBlewitt, A., ‘Diary of march to Akik’, SIR 94 (May 1902), 9.Google Scholar

47 O'Sullivan, H. D. E., ‘Lau Nuers’ (1906)Google Scholar, CRO Dakhlia I 112/13/87. Woodward, F. W., ‘Report on Patrol in the Nuer Country’, SIR 153 (April 1907), 6.Google ScholarWilson, , ‘March from the Sobat’, 68.Google ScholarLiddell, , ‘Report’, 46.Google ScholarStruvé, , ‘Report on Khor Atar’, 10.Google Scholar

48 Evans-Pritchard, : ‘The Nuer’ (1934), 2, 22Google Scholar; ‘The Nuer; Age-Sets’, SNR, xix, ii (1936), 236.Google Scholar (Anon.) ‘Lau Nuer’ (1931), END 66.A.i.

49 Wilson, , ‘March from the Sobat’, 5, 8.Google Scholar

50 Ibid., 8. Mier Deng Reng (ND–GL), 28 April 1976. SIR 165 (April 1908) 3. Atem Yaak (TD) i Sept. 1977. Charles Manyang (ND), personal communication.

51 Cuol Thijiok Dul (GL), 1 July 1975.

52 Stephen Ciec Lam (GL), 23 August 1977.

53 Wyld, ‘Report and notes on Bor-Duk District’, Atem Yaak (TD).

54 Liddell, , ‘Report’, 6.Google ScholarWilson, , ‘March from the Sobat’, 8.Google Scholar Wyld, ‘Report and notes on Bor-Duk District.’

55 Deng Macot, Anyang Goc (ND), 29 April 1976.

56 Struvé, : ‘Report on a tour in the Nuer Country’, SIR 163 (February 1908), 7Google Scholar; and ‘Report on Administrative Boundaries between Twi Dinkas and the Nuers’, SIR 177 (April 1909), 16.Google Scholar

57 Wilson, H. H.: ‘Report on the situation in the Sobat Valley’, SIR 117 (April 1904), 9Google Scholar; and ‘March from the Sobat’, 7.

58 Matthews, G.E., ‘Inspection in the Nuer country’, SIR 152 (March 1907), 6.Google Scholar O'Sullivan, ‘Lau Nuers.’

59 Wilson, , ‘Situation in the Sobat’, 910Google Scholar; and ‘March from the Sobat’, 7–8. Struvé, , ‘Report on a tour in Nuer country,’ 78.Google Scholar

60 Owen, R. C. R., in GGR (1908), 609.Google Scholar

61 Struvé, , ‘Report on Administrative Boundaries,’ 1617Google Scholar. SIR 189 (April 1910), 45.Google ScholarO'Sullivan, in GGR (1910), 407.Google Scholar

62 R. C. R. Owen to Civil Secretary, 1 Aug. 1910, CRO Mongalla i/i/4. G. B. Wahab [Wauhope] to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 29 June 1910, SRRO UNP GO CRR 34.

63 Owen, , in GGR (1910), 340.Google Scholar Owen to Civil Secretary, 1 August 1910. C. Little, Commanding Duk Fadiat Patrol, 2 July 1910, CRO Mongalla i/i/4. O'Sullivan, , in GGR (1910), 407.Google Scholar O'Sullivan to Civil Secretary, 10 July 1910, SRRO UNP GO CRR 34.

64 G. B. Wauhope to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 22 April 1913, CRO UNP 1/12/101.

65 Marwood, B. V., ‘Handing over notes on Bor’ (1938), CRO UNP 1/51/3.Google Scholar

66 G. B. Wauhope, 22 April 1913, as in n. 64.

67 G. B. Wahab [Wauhope], ‘Instructions to Maur [sic] Duk Fadiet’, 23 June 1910, SRRO UNP GO CRR 34.

68 G. B. Wauhope, 22 April 1913, as in n. 64.

69 J. Stevenson-Hamilton to Godwin, 14 April 1918, PAM SCR 14.A.

70 ‘Transfer of Barr Gaweir to Zeraf Valley District’ (1926), PAM 66.B. 10.‘Settlement of 01 Dinka–Gaweir Nuer boundary dispute’ (1926), PAM 66.B.11.

71 SIR 187 (February 1910), 4. O'Sullivan, , in GGR (1910), 92–4.Google Scholar F. M. Woodward to Civil Secretary, 28 Oct. 1913, CRO UNP 1/12/101.

72 SIR 152 (March 1907), 6. Wilson, , ‘March from the Sobat’, 7.Google Scholar SIR 212 (March 1912), 3. ‘Report on Lau Patrol 1917’, SRRO UNP GO 15/10. SIR 163 (February 1908), 7. Correspondence in CRO UNP 1/12/101: Governor, Upper Nile Province to Civil Secretary, 20 May 1916; J. A. Pollock to Officer Commanding Sobat Pibor District, 6 May 1913; Koebel, , ‘Jekaing Nuer tribute 1914–1915’, 22 Nov. 1914Google Scholar; Stigand, C. H., ‘Report on Sobat Valley Nuers’, May 1916.Google Scholar

73 SIR 224 (March 1913), 3. SIR 240 (July 1914), 4–5. SIR 241 (August 1914), 5. SIR 252 (July 1915), 4. ‘Report on Lau Patrol 1917’.

74 SIR 215 (June 1913), 3. SIR 226 (May 1913), 3. SIR 227 (June 1913), 3. Bimbashi Fairbairn to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 30 Dec. 1913, SRRO UNP SCR 14.1. SIR 233 (December 1913), 3–4. Ruot Diu (BG).

75 G. B. Wauhope, 22 April 1913, as in n. 64.

76 SIR 233 (December 1913), 4. SIR 234 (January 1914), 4. SIR 235 (Febuary 1914), 3. SIR 236 (March 1914), 4. Kulang Majiok (BG): 28 April 1975 and 13 April 1981. Ruot Diu (BG). One of the Mongalla Governor's complaints against the Upper Nile Province administration was that their seizure of Macar's cattle drove him to raid Mongalla Province: Governor, Mongalla Province, to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 17 June 1915, SRRO UNP SCR 14.4.

77 Kulang Majiok (BG), 28 April 1975. Ruot Diu (BG). Ruot Yuot (RG), 13 April 1975. Matit Kal (BG), 12 June 1975. Sanduk Tawfikia to Governor Malakal, 7 June 1914, SRRO UNP SCR 14.1. SIR 239 (June 1914), 4–6. SIR 240 (July 1914), 4. SIR 245 (December 1914), 3.

78 Stigand, ‘Report on Sobat Valley Nuers.’ Bramble to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 6 Jan. 1917, CRO UNP 1/12/101.

79 SIR 262 (May 1916), 4. SIR 263 (June 1916), 3. SIR 265 (August 1916), 3–4. SIR 271 (February 1917), 3. SIR 274 (May 1917), 3. ‘Report on Lau Patrol 1917.’ ‘Diary – Nyerol–April 1917,’ and ‘Monthly Report – Nyerol – May 1917,’ both in PAM SCR 14.A. Tut Jiak Gai (ML), who was a grown man at the time, claimed the Lou raids were retaliation for Bor cattle thefts (3 July 1975). Stephen Ciec Lam (GL), whose father, Lam Liew, was one of the organizers of the raids, claimed that the sole motive was the desire for Bor cattle (14 Nov. 1980).

80 J. L. F. Tweedie to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 8 Jan. 1914, PAM SCR 14.A. Anyang Goc and Makor Guot (ND). Mier Deng Reng (ND-GL). Stevenson-Hamilton to Godwin, 14 April 1918. Reports in CRO Intel 2/48/408: Supplementary Mongalla Province Monthly Intelligence Report (March 1919); Mongalla Province Monthly Intelligence Reports (May, July 1919). Car was accused by the government of raiding the Bor in 1914 and the Nyarraweng in 1928. One of his sons and two of his nephews (one Lou, the other Nyarraweng) deny this: Gany Car Koryom (GL), Mier Deng Reng (ND-GL), Gabriel Yoal (GL) 18 March 1981.

81 Governor, Upper Nile Province to Civil Secretary, 12 Dec. 1914; and Governor, Mongalla Province, to Civil Secretary 11 Jan. 1915, both in SRRO UNP SCR 14.4. Governor, Mongalla Province, to Civil Secretary, 10 May 1917, CRO UNP 1/13/118.

82 Mongalla Province Monthly Intelligence Report (September 1918), CRO Intel 2/48/408. Stevenson-Hamilton to Godwin, 14 April 1918. J. Stevenson-Hamilton to Governor, Mongalla Province, 14 Sept. 1918, PAM SCR 14.A.

83 Godwin to Governor, Malakal, 28 April 1918; ‘Monthly Report – Nyerol, April 1918,’ both in PAM SCR 14.A. SIR 288 (July 1918), 2.

84 Mongalla Province Monthly Intelligence Reports (August and December 1918), CRO Intel 2/48/408.

85 J. Stevenson-Hamilton to Governor, Mongalla Province, 3 September 1918, PAM SCR 14. A. Gaawar suspicion of government support for the Dinka during this period was repeated nearly seventy years later: Ruot Diu (BG).

86 J. Stevenson-Hamilton to Governor, Mongalla Province, 14 Sept. 1918, PAM SCR 14.A.

87 Struve, , in GGR (1909), 799.Google Scholar ‘Note on military action and administration in the Nuer country’, 23 November 1927, END 66.A.1.

88 ‘Settlement of Ol Dinka–Gaweir Nuer boundary dispute.’ ‘Transfer of Barr Gaweir to Zeraf Valley District’, as cited in n. 70.

89 K. C. P. Struvé, ‘Handing-over notes’, Sudan Archive, Durham, 212/9. Makor Guot (ND). Sudan Monthly Intelligence Report, 375 (October 1925), 5.Google Scholar

90 Struvé, ‘Handing-over notes.’

91 Johnson, D.H.: ‘Colonial policy and prophets: the “Nuer Settlement”, 1929–1930,’ Journal of the Anthropological Society of Oxford, x, i (1979)Google Scholar; and ‘History and Prophecy among the Nuer’, Ch 8.

92 ‘Statement of Dual Diu taken on February 3rd, 1930’, SRROUNP 5.A.3/43, which was corroborated by Matit Kal (BG) 12 June 1975, Kulang Majiok (BG) 28 April 1975, and Ruot Diu (BG). See also ‘Note by Mr Wedderburn-Maxwell on the Duk Faiyuil Affair, August 1928’, CRO Civsec 5/3/12, and B. A. Lewis to Marwood, 10 June 1936, PAM 66.B.11.

93 ‘Meeting of DCs Duk Faiyuil and Zeraf Valley Districts… May 4th to May 7th 1931’, PAM 66.B.11. Wyld, ‘Report on Duk Raid’, 10 Dec. 1928, CRO Civsec 5/3/12. Deng Bor Ngundeng (GL) 12 July 1975.

94 ‘Police operations subsequent to Patrol S.8’, CRO Civsec 5/3/12. C.A. Willis, ‘Nuer Settlement 1929’, 28 June 1929, CRO Civsec 1/3/8. Wyld, ‘Report on Duk Raid.’

95 Correspondence in PAM 66.B.ii: ADC Zeraf Valley to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 10 March 1931; ‘Meeting of DCs Duk Faiyuil and Zeraf Valley Districts….May 4th to May 7th, 1931’, DC Bor and Duk District to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 13 May 1931; DC Bor and Duk District to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 6 April 1933; DC Lau to Governor Upper Nile Province, 25 April 1933; DC Lau to Governor, Upper Nile Province, 14 Dec. 1931; DC Bor and Duk to Governor, ii March 1932; Governor, Upper Nile Province to DC Abwong, ii April 1933; ADC Zeraf Valley District to Governor 23 Jan. 1936. John Winder (former DC Zeraf Valley District), personal communication.

96 ‘Nuer District Commissioners Meeting’ (1943), CRO Civsec 66/13/37.

97 DC Lau Nuer to DC Bor, 22 June 1935; DC Bor to DC Lau Nuer, 18 May 1935, both in PAM 66.D.i.

98 ‘Personality reports, Upper Nile Province’, CRO UNP 1/34/276.

99 Hassan Dafalla, DC Zeraf District, 12 Feb. 1957, PAM 66.B.5/3. Ruot Diu (BG).

100 Moses Cot Dok (ML) and Abed Nego Maker (Executive Officer, Waat) 26 March 1981.

101 Charles Manyang (ND), personal communication.

102 ‘Bor-Lau Meeting held at Akobo on 6. 1. 1958…’, ‘The Inter District Meeting held between Lau Nuer, Zeraf and Bor Districts at Duk Fadiet on 3rd, 4th, 5th & 6th March 1959’, both in SRRO LND 66.B.4.

103 Stephen Ciec Lam (GL) and John Wicjaal Buom (then Assistant Commissioner, Upper Nile Province) 22 August 1977.

104 Evans-Pritchard, , The Nuer, 123, 129–30.Google Scholar

105 Ibid: 122–3.