Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T15:31:13.221Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Purge of Christians at Mwanga's Court

A reassessment of this episode in Buganda history

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

J. A. Rowe
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Mwanga's persecution of the Christians in 1886 was an isolated event, but it set the seal of judgement on subsequent interpretations of his character, his policy and his reign. He was said to have an anti-Christian policy which could be variously ascribed to religious traditionalism, or the political danger of an organized Christian party, or external threats of European encroachment. But closer examination reveals two apparent anomalies. Most Christians were spared during the brief persecution, including many prominent leaders. And shortly afterwards these same Christians were given extraordinary powers which they exercised, with the Kabaka's warm approval, at the expense of the traditional chiefs. The conclusion reached is that while Mwanga had no very consistent policy, he did have a consistently strong motivation—the desire to achieve a secure position of authority independent of those powerful old chiefs who had placed him on the throne. In this he saw the ambitious young Christians as a useful ally. Thus, despite the persecution, during part of his reign Mwanga was, for his own purposes, not anti-Christian but pro-Christian.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 5 , Issue 1 , March 1964 , pp. 55 - 72
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1964

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Mackay of Uganda, by his sister (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1890), 276–7.Google Scholar

2 Nicq, Abbé, Le Père Siméon Lourdel (3rd ed. rev., Algiers: Maison-Carrée, 1932), 340.Google Scholar

3 Faupel, J. F., African Holocaust (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1962), 157; also Mackay to Stock, 26 June 1886, Church Missionary Society Archives G3A5/03.Google Scholar

4 See Mackay's 112-page letter, Mackay to Lang, so Dec. 1885, CMS Archives G3AS/03, much of which was reprinted in The Church Missionary Intelligencer, June 1886.Google Scholar

5 Lugard, F. D., The Rise of Our East African Empire (London: Blackwood, 1893), II, 24;Google ScholarPerham, M., The Diaries of Lord Lugard (London: Faber & Faber, 1960), II, 29 entry for 19 Dec. 1890.Google Scholar

6 For recent examples see: Marsh, Z. and Kingsnorth, G., An Introduction to the History of East Africa (Cambridge: University Press, 1965), 128–30;Google ScholarMatheson, E., An Enterprs So Perilous (London: Mellifont, 1962), 64–8;Google ScholarMoorehead, A., The White Nile (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1960), 289–98.Google Scholar

7 Thoonen, J. P., Black Martyrs (London: Sheed & Ward, 1942), 285.Google Scholar

8 Faupel lists fifty-one known victims, of whom forty-six were Christians, and estimates perhaps another fifty killed, including many non-Christians, throughout the country. Faupel, African Holocaust, 217.Google Scholar

9 Saza chiefs: Zakariya Kizito Kisingiri, Samweli Mukasa Naganafa, André Kiwanuka, Paulo Bakunga, Joswa Kate, James Miti (holding a saza in Bunyoro), Nikodemu Sebwato, Alexis Sebbowa, Isaya Mayanja, Matthew Kisule. Katikkiros: Honorat Nyonyintono, Apolo Kagwa. (An examination of the Lukiiko Land Allotment List, Land and Surveys Office, Kampala, shows a great many other survivors occupying prominent positions in 1900.)Google Scholar

10 Kagwa, Apolo, Ebika Bya Buganda (Mengo: privately printed, 1912), my typescript copy—p. 73, but pages vary with different editions.Google Scholar

11 Miti, James, ‘History of Buganda’ (unpublished manuscript, Makerere College Library, 1938;Google Scholar copy also at S.O.A.S. Library, Univ. of London, chapter 21); Ashe, Robert, Two Kings of Uganda (London: Sampson Low, 1889), 228–30;Google ScholarJournal, Ashe, 27 June 1886, CMS Archives G3A5/o3, extracts reprinted in C.M.I., 1886.Google Scholar

12 Miti, ch. 21; Ashe Journal, 27 May–28 June 1886; Ashe to Lang, 12 July 1886, CMS Archives G3A5/o3;Google ScholarKagwa, Ebika, 74; Mackay, 365–6.Google Scholar

13 Miti, ch. 21.Google Scholar

14 Kagwa, Ebika, 71–2;Google ScholarKagwa, Apolo, Bassekabaka Be Buganda (London: Sheldon Press, 1927), 141;Google Scholar Ashe to Wigram, no date, CMS Archives G3A5/o3, also reprinted in The Church Missionary Gleaner, Dec. 1886, p. 137. (The Uganda Society has copies of the Gleaner.)Google Scholar

15 Letter from Mgr Livinhac, 29 Sept. 1886, printed in Annales de Ia Propagation de la Foi, 1887, 217; Nicq, Père Lourdel, 344.Google Scholar

16 Thoonen, Black Martyrs, 262; Ashe Journal, 7 June 1886, CMS Archives G3A5/o3; C.M.I., 1886; Miti, ch. 2i; Ashe, Two Kings, 222–3.Google Scholar

17 Miti, ch. 21; Gordon to Mackay, 31 Dec. 1887, CMS Archives G3A5/o5.Google Scholar

18 Kagwa, Ebika, 7 Miti, ch. 21; Mackay to Stock, 6 March 1887, CMS Archives G3A5/04. (Sematimba went to Kabula, where he was joined by Christians retreating from the Muslim victory at Mengo at the start of the civil wars, Sept. 1888.)Google Scholar

19 Mackay Papers: Journal, 26 and 31 May 1886, CMS Archives U/A6; Taylor, John, The Growth of the Church in Uganda (London: SCM Press, 1958), 57;Google Scholar Miti, ch. 21; Ashe Journal Extracts, CMS Archives G3A5/o3; Livinhac letter, 29 Sept. 1886, Annales, 1887, 225; Zimbe, B., Buganda Ne Kabaka (Mengo: Gambuze Press, 1939), 107.Google Scholar

20 Miti, ch. 21; Kagwa, Ebika, 74.Google Scholar

21 Miti, ch. 21; Kagwa, Ebika, 74.Google Scholar

22 This fact, which explains why Mwanga's anger was so great, we owe to the researches of Father Faupel. Faupel, African Holocaust, 137–8.Google Scholar

23 For both incidents: Thoonen, Black Martyrs, 73;Google ScholarFaupel, African Holocaust, 33, 213;Google ScholarTaylor, The Growth of the Church, 265.Google Scholar

24 Livinhac's letter of 29 Sept. 1886 in Annales began this traditional interpretation, which was continued by Abbé Nicq, and recently by Thoonen and Faupel. The researches of the latter two have led to some qualifications, but the basic interpretation appears the same.Google Scholar

25 Ashe, Two Kings, 73;Google ScholarO'Flaherty to Wigram, 12 Oct. 1884, CMS Archives G3A6/02.Google Scholar

26 Mackay to Wigram, May 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02.Google Scholar

27 Ashe, Two Kings, 211–12.Google Scholar

28 Mackay to Wigram, May 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02; entry in Journal letter as of 30 Jan. 1885.Google Scholar

29 O'Flaherty to Lang, 26 July 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02.Google Scholar

30 Mackay to Wigram, May 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02; entry in Journal letter as of 9–17 May 1885.Google Scholar

31 Mackay to Wigram, May 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02; entry in Journal letter as of 31 Jan. 1885.Google Scholar

32 Kagwa, Bassekabaka, 211–21;Google ScholarNsimbi, M. B., Amannya Amaganda N'Ennono Zaago (Kampala: Uganda Society, 1956), 46;Google ScholarGollock, G. A., Lives of Eminent Africans (London: Longmans, 1928), 78.Google Scholar

33 Mukasa, H., Simuda Nyuma: Ebiro Bya Mutesa (London: SPCK, 1938), 39–23; Kagwa, Ebika, 67.Google Scholar

34 Faupel, African Holocaust, 217.Google Scholar

35 Ashe, Two Kings, 106; Mackay, 264; O'Flaherty to Lang, 26 July 1885, CMS Archives G3A6/02.Google Scholar

36 Nicq, Pére Lourdel, 306–7, 349; Livinhac letter, 29 Sept. 1886 in Annales, 1887, 218;Google ScholarAshe, Two Kings, 151; Miti, ch. 19 Mackay to Wigram, May 1886, CMS Archives G3A5/02; entry in Journal letter 22–7 Feb. 1885.Google Scholar

37 Mackay to Lang, 10 Dec. 1885, CMS Archives G3A5/03; entry in Journal letter under 28 Oct. 1885. Also printed in C.M.I., 1886.Google Scholar

38 Mackay to Lang, 27 Dec. 1886, CMS Archives G3A5/04.Google Scholar

39 Kagwa, Bassekabaka, 142–3;Google ScholarNsimbi, Amannya Amaganda, 104–5;Google ScholarZimbe, Buganda Ne Kabaka, 114–22; Miti, ch. 23.Google Scholar

40 Mackay, Journal extracts, II June 1887 entry; CMS Archives G3A/04.Google Scholar

41 Zimbe, Buganda Ne Kabaka, 120–1;Google ScholarKagwa, Apolo, Ekitabo Kye Kika Kya Nsenene (Mengo: privately printed, no date), 14.Google Scholar

42 Zimbe, Buganda Ne Kabaka, 121–2.Google Scholar

43 Miti, ch. 23.Google Scholar

44 Two studies which have noted the favoured position occupied by the young converts in the new regiments are: Southwold, M., Bureaucracy and Chiefship in Buganda (East African Studies No. 14) n.d., 15–16,Google Scholar and Wrigley, C., ‘The Christian Revolution in Buganda’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, II (10. 1959), 41.Google Scholar