Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T00:45:04.414Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Money with Dignity’: Migrants, Minelords and the Cultural Politics of the South African Gold Standard Crisis, 1920–33*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Keith Breckenridge
Keith Breckenridge
Affiliation:
University of Natal, Durban
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper takes as its point of departure a simple fact that has gone largely unnoticed in the historical and ethnographic literature of migrant mine labour: prior to 1933 mineworkers were paid in gold. It is argued that the ideas and practices associated with the control and transmission of metallic money were at the heart of the experience of migrant labour before the crisis and formed a major part of the self-definition of migrant gold miners during the 1920s. Moreover, both the practices and ideas of African mineworkers were reciprocally linked to the global political struggles taking place over the gold standard. From the First World War to the Christmas of 1932, the South African and Imperial states and mining capital were involved in a controversy over the form of the South African and international money supplies. Whilst in appearance an abstract and mysterious debate, the contest over the form of the money supply laid the foundations for a system of value that penetrated into the daily lives and politics of many southern Africans. Chief amongst these were hundreds of thousands of migrant mine-workers. Following from this, the paper posits a re-interpretation of the gold standard crisis. The turning point that coincided with the new year of 1933 was not merely an economic change; it constituted a major transformation of the form, value, velocity and politics of money throughout Southern Africa. Coincidently, the crisis was an economic and cultural transition for the mining industry itself and marked a dramatic re-definition of the terms of economic conflict between workers and managers. Finally, this paper calls for a new periodization of capitalist development in Southern Africa that meshes together the cultural and economic dimensions of historical processes in a manner that foregrounds the experience of the African working class.

Type
South African History Reinterpreted
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 36 , Issue 2 , July 1995 , pp. 271 - 304
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Affidavit from Native Spatch, 27 Aug. 1920; Chairman, NRC to Prime Minister, 20 Aug. 1920; Secretary for Native Affairs to Secretary of Finance, 14 Sept. 1920; all in Transvaal Archives Depot [hereafter TAD] GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1) Export of Gold over Inland Borders: Question of Payment to Natives of Paper Currency, 1919–22.

2 Appadurai, A., ‘Introduction’, in Appadurai, A. (ed.), The Social Life of Things:Commodities in Cultural Perspective (Cambridge, 1986), 14CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ferguson, J., ‘Cultural exchange: new developments in the anthropology of commodities’, Cultural Anthropology, III (1988), 492–4.Google Scholar

3 Chanock, M., Unconsummated Union: Britain, Rhodesia and South Africa (Manchester, 1977), 33.Google Scholar

4 Arndt, E., Banking and Currency Development in South Africa, 1652–1927 (Cape Town, 1928), 66, 93–122Google Scholar; Dalgaard, B., South Africa's Impact on Britain's Return to Gold, 1925 (New York, 1981), 34.Google Scholar

5 Gold: A Reprint of the Special Number of the Times: Tuesday, June 20, 1933 (London, 1933), 66.Google Scholar

6 Marks, S. and Trapido, S., ‘Lord Milner and the South African state’, in Bonner, P. (ed.), Working Papers in Southern African Studies: Volume 2 (Johannesburg, 1981), 58–61.Google Scholar

7 Ally, R., ‘War and gold: the Bank of England, the London gold market and South Africa's gold, 1914–19’, J. Southern Afr. Studies, XVII (1991), 224–38Google Scholar, and Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact.Google Scholar

8 Eichengreen, B., Golden Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919–1939 (Oxford, 1992), 230–84, 319–32.Google Scholar

9 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, xi.Google Scholar

10 Keynes was practically alone in publicly opposing the restoration of the pre-War value of sterling in 1925. Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 163.Google Scholar

11 Clarke, S., Central Bank Cooperation, 1924–31 (New York, 1967), 27.Google Scholar

12 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 29Google Scholar; Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 1.Google Scholar

13 Hume, D., ‘On the balance of trade’, in Eichengreen, B. (ed.), The Gold Standard in Theory and History (London, 1985), 39–48Google Scholar; see also Kemmerer, D. W., Gold and the Gold Standard (New York, 1944), 180–1.Google Scholar

14 Eichengreen, , ‘Editor's introduction’Google Scholar, in idem (ed.), Gold Standard, 7Google Scholar; Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 58.Google Scholar

15 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 65.Google Scholar

16 Ibid. 10.

17 Ibid. 6, 9, 24, 92.

18 Wolpe, H., ‘Capitalism and cheap labour power in South Africa: from segregation to apartheid’, Economy and Society, 1 (1972), 425–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Yudelman, D., The Emergence of Modern South Africa: State, Capital and the Incorporation of Organized Labour on the South African Gold Fields, 1902–1939 (Cape Town, 1984), 257–61.Google Scholar

19 The most important examples are: Davies, R., Kaplan, D., Morris, M. and O'Meara, D., ‘Class struggle and the periodisation of the State in South Africa’, Review of African Political Economy, VII (1976), 4–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O'Meara, D., ‘The 1946 African mineworkers' strike’, Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, XII (1975), 146–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Simkins, C., ‘Agricultural production in the African reserves of South Africa, 1918–1969’, J. Southern Afr. Studies, VII (1981), 257–83Google Scholar; Wolpe, , ‘Capitalism and cheap labour power’.Google Scholar

20 The best account of the ferocity of class conflict in the deflation-plagued agricultural sector can be found in Bradford, H., A Taste of Freedom: The ICU in Rural South Africa, 1924–1930 (New Haven, 1987), 21–62.Google Scholar

21 Index of retail prices: food, Union Statistics for Fifty Years (Pretoria: 1961), h–24.Google Scholar

22 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 102Google Scholar; Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 46.Google Scholar

23 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters 82, 165–99.Google Scholar

24 Ibid. 216–84.

25 Report of Meeting held in the Transvaal Chamber of Mines on Friday, 3 Oct. 1919, TAD Government Native Labour Bureau [hereafter GNLB] 251, 340/16/90(1) Export of Gold over Inland Borders, 1919–22.

26 Ibid. I am estimating the total number of gold and silver coins in public circulation at about 10,000,000. See Pearson, to Harris, , 16 05 1929Google Scholar, Central Archives Depot [hereafter CAD] South African Mint [hereafter SAM] 190, 7/6/3.

27 Manager, ERPM, to Secretaries, Rand Mines, 21 April 1920; Mine Secretary, Crown Mines, to Secretary, Rand Mines, 29 April 1920; in Barlow Rand Archives [hereafter BRA] Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856.

28 Report of the Meeting held in the Transvaal Chamber of Mines, Friday 3 Oct. 1919, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

29 Inspector, NAD, Witbank to Director of Native Labour, 19 Feb. 1920, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

30 Chairman, NRC to Prime Minister, 20 Aug. 1920, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

31 Abantu Batho, 29 07 1920.Google Scholar

32 Umteteli wa Bantu, 7 08 1920Google Scholar; see also Abantu Batho, 26 08 1920Google Scholar; for the political turmoil surrounding the 1920 suspension of the gold standard, see Bonner, P., ‘The Transvaal Native Congress 1917–1920: the radicalisation of the black petty bourgeoisie on the Rand’, in Marks, S. and Rathbone, R. (eds.), Industrialisation and Social Change in South Africa: African Class Formation, Culture and Consciousness 1870–1930 (London, 1982), 270–313.Google Scholar

33 Secretary of Native Affairs to Secretary of Finance, 14 Dec. 1920, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

34 Town Inspector, NAD, to Director of Native Labour, 17 Dec. 1920, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

35 Acting Manager, New Modderfontein, to Secretary, Rand Mines, 23 April 1920, BRA Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856.

36 Gemmill, Secretary NRC, circular to all mine managers, 15 Dec. 1920, BRA, Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856.

37 McKenzie, S., Chief Compound Manager to Evans, 9 03 1929Google Scholar, CAD SA38, C2/57.

38 Inspector, Springs NAD, to Director of Native Labour, 21 Dec. 1920; Gemmill to Director of Native Labour, 18 Dec. 1920, all in TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1)

39 Report of the Meeting held in the Transvaal Chamber of Mines, Friday 3 Oct. 1919, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1)

40 Junod, H. A., The Life of a South African Tribe (New York, 1962), 275–8.Google Scholar

41 Harries, P., ‘Kinship, ideology and the nature of pre-colonial labour migration: labour migration from the Delagoa Bay hinterland to South Africa, up to 1896’Google Scholar, in Marks, and Rathbone, (eds.), Industrialisation and Social Change, 151–3.Google Scholar

42 Acting Manager, New Modderfontein to Secretary, Rand Mines, 30 Aug. 1920; Gemmill to Rand Mines, 6 Sept. 1920; Compound Manager to Manager, Modderfontein B, 24 Jan. 1921, in BRA Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x 1920–42, 856.

43 Gemmill, W. N. L. A. to Manager, Modderfontein B, 11 02 1921Google Scholar, BRA Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856.

44 McKenzie, to Evans, , 9 03 1929, CAD SAM 38, c2/57.Google Scholar

45 Gemmill, Circular 6/22; Gemmill to Manager, Modderfontein B, 11 Feb. 1921, in BRA Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856; Manager, Randfontein Estates to JCI, to TCM [Transvaal Chamber of Mines], 16 Oct. 1931, Chamber of Mines Archive [hereafter CMA] Gold Standard, 1931.

46 Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 102.Google Scholar

47 Ibid. 72–97.

48 Evans, to Phillips, , 23 07 1924Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 170, July–Sept. 1924; see Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 125, on German inflation.Google Scholar

49 Evans, to SirReginald, , 4 11 1925Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 174, Sept.–Dec. 1925; Evans, to Phillips, , 24 09 1924Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 170, July–Sept. 1924.

50 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 155.Google Scholar

51 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 159.Google Scholar

52 Evans, to Phillips, , 24 02 1923, BRA Evans Letterbooks.Google Scholar

53 Evans, to ffennell, , 18 03 1925Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 172, Jan.–April 1925.

54 Evelyn Wallers noted that ‘Keynes' book seemed to have produced little short of panic in Evans' mind’ in 1923. Wallers to Phillips, BRA Directors' Confidential Letters, May 1924–Feb. 1929.

55 B. Warner, Extract of evidence before the Kemmerer-Vissering Commission, 10 Dec. 1924, CAD SAM 38, c2/57. For the fiscal background to the commission, see De Kock, G., A History of the South African Reserve Bank (Pretoria, 1954), 67–78Google Scholar, and for state politics see Ally, R., ‘Currency, banking and politics: the Bank of England, sterling and South Africa's monetary system, 1914–25’ (African Studies Institute Seminar, University of the Witwatersrand, 1991), 27–30.Google Scholar

56 Inspector N. A. D. Witbank to Director of Native Labour, 19 Feb. 1920, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1).

57 McKenzie, to Evans, , 9 03 1929, CAD SAM 38, C2/57.Google Scholar

58 Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 160Google Scholar; De Kock, , South African Reserve Bank, 70.Google Scholar

59 Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 163.Google Scholar

60 Evans, to ffennell, , 18 03 1925Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 172, Jan.–April 1925.

61 De Kock, , South African Reserve Bank, 12–13Google Scholar; Dalgaard, , South Africa's Impact, 53.Google Scholar

62 Evans, to SirReginald, , 4 11 1925Google Scholar, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 174, Sept.–Dec. 1925.

63 Pearson, to Robertson, , 21 12 1929, CAD SAM 34, c2/39.Google Scholar

64 Pretoria, Pearson to Johnson, , Royal Mint, 6 04 1925Google Scholar; Evans, , ‘Memorandum on the future of the Mining Industry’, 21 12 1925, both in CAD SAM 38, c2/57; De Kock, South African Reserve Bank, 78; Johnson to Pearson, 10 Mar. 1925, CAD SAM 38, C2/37.Google Scholar

65 Executive Committee, TCM, to Secretary to Treasury, 4 Feb. 1925, CAD SAM 34, C2/39; Rogers to London, 31 Mar. 1926, BRA Directors' Confidential Letters, May 1924–Feb. 1929.

66 Pearson, to Robertson, , 21 12 1929Google Scholar, CAD SAM 34, c2/39.

67 Vilar, , History of Gold, 131–8.Google Scholar The low grade of gold-bearing ore and the vigilance with which the Chamber of Mines and the police prosecuted those dealing in the sale of illicit gold ensured that the monetary role of gold remained stable.

68 Table dated 16 Sept. 1927, CMA Native Labour Miscellaneous, 1927; Union Statistics for Fifty Years (G–5).

69 Pearson, to Harris, , 16 05 1929, CAD SAM 190, 7/6/3Google Scholar; Peason, to de Waal, , 4 06 1929, loc. cit.Google Scholar

70 Territorial analysis of desertions, 21 Mar. 1928, CMA Native Labour-Miscellaneous 1, 1929.

71 Hunter, M., Reaction to Conquest: Effects of Contact with Europeans on the Pondo of South Africa (London, 1936), 193.Google Scholar

72 Report of Meeting held in the Transvaal Chamber of Mines on Friday, 3 Oct. 1919, TAD GNLB 251, 340/16/90(1), Export of Gold over Inland Borders, 1919–22.

73 On the expansion of cattle holdings in Pondoland, see Beinart, W., The Political Economy of Pondoland 1860–1930 (Johannesburg, 1982), 81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

74 Over the course of the last year, with the help of Jones Dingiwonga Mzayifani and the members of his household, we were able to collect rich life histories from a small number of these men. The transcripts of these interviews are presently in the possession of the author. They will be placed on deposit at the African Studies Institute at the University of the Witwatersrand. Interview of Johannes Dlamza by Mzayifani, Jones and Breckenridge, Keith, 17 10 1992.Google Scholar

75 Interview of Johannes Mdlamza by Mzayifani and Breckenridge, 17 10 1992.Google Scholar

76 Interview of Ngilambi Sohlathi by Mzayifani and Breckenridge, 7 01 1992.Google Scholar

77 Ibid.

78 Ibid.; discussion with Mzayifani, Jones, 24 05 1992.Google Scholar Hunter noted that homestead heads might occasionally give money to their wives to prevent its being spent but that ‘the woman has no right to use any part of it without his consent’. Hunter, M., ‘The effects of contact with Europeans on the status of Pondo women’, Africa, VI (1933), 270.Google Scholar

79 Nor is this a feature unique to the Transkei. Such tales are ubiquitous in the townships of the Witwatersrand. For one example, see Mattera, D., Sophiatown: Coming of Age in South Africa (Boston, 1989), 8.Google Scholar

80 Interview of Ngilambi Sohlathi by Mzayifani, and Breckenridge, , 7 01 1992Google Scholar; interview of Johannes Mdlamza by Mzayifani and Breckenridge, 17 Oct. 1992; see, on a similar theme, Beinart, W., ‘Joyini inkomo: cattle advances and the origins of migrancy from Pondoland’, J. Southern Afr. Studies, V (1979), 199–219.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

81 Hunter, , Reaction to Conquest, 284, 496.Google Scholar

82 Interview of Kathazo Sodladla by Mzayifani and Breckenridge, 16 Oct. 1992; interview of Johannes Mdlamza by Mzayifani and Breckenridge, 17 Oct. 1992.

83 The GPC, which came into existence after the 1922 strike, was composed of representatives of the six major mining houses. The Committee effectively controlled the Chamber of Mines and oversaw almost all of its activities. For most of this period it was dominated by Rand Mines-Central Mining and their allies in the Union Corporation.

84 Minutes of the GPC, 24 Oct. 1927, CMA Native Labour Miscellaneous, 1927; Rand Daily Mail, 11 11 1927Google Scholar; Rand Daily Mail, 16 11 1927.Google Scholar

85 Rand Daily Mail, 22 11 1927, 26 11 1927.Google Scholar

86 Rand Daily Mail, 11 11 1927.Google Scholar

87 Rand Daily Mail, 11 11 1927, 16 11 1927Google Scholar; discussion with Mzayifani, J. D., 25 05 1992.Google Scholar For a history of the struggles between the Chamber and recruiters over advances in Pondoland before 1930, see Beinart, W., ‘Joyini inkomo’Google Scholar; Taberer, to Gemmill, , 16 09 1924Google Scholar, CMA Native Labour Miscellaneous-1924/5; Hunter, , Reaction to Conquest, 143Google Scholar, and CAD NTS 7239, 167/326 Transkeian Territories Co-operative Credit Societies.

88 Proceedings of the United Transkeian Territories General Council, 16 April 1932 (Government Printer, Cape Town, 1933).

89 Magistrate, Mount Fletcher to Director of Native Labour, 2 June 1932, CMA Native Labour Supply, 1932.

90 Gemmill to GPC Members, 26 May 1932, CMA Native Wages, 1932; Martin to London Directors, 17 Aug. 1932, BRA Private Letters from Johannesburg, 195. The bonus had been introduced in 1919 to encourage workers to extend their contracts, and was heavily supported by those who argued for a trained workforce and the introduction of scientific management in the late 1920s.

91 Rand Daily Mail, 22 09 1931Google Scholar; Star, 21 Sept. 1931; Eichengreen, , Golden Fetters, 284.Google Scholar

92 TCM Secretaries, 1 Oct. 1931; Minutes of the GPC, 12 Oct. 1931; Randfontein Estates to JCI to Gemmill, 16 Oct. 1931; Gemmill to GPC, 13 Oct. 1931, all in CMA Gold Standard-1931; emphasis in the original, Secretary, Rand Mines, Circular No. 104/31, BRA Method of paying natives paper currency, 1473x, 1920–42, 856.

93 The London directors of Central Mining were concerned with the uncertainty that would arise on the London stock market if dividends and share values were published in a currency different from sterling. CMIC, Ecliptic Cable, London to CMIC, Johannesburg, 24 Sept. 1931, BRA Gold Standard, 1931, 252; Martin to CMIC, London, 14 Oct. 1931, BRA London Letters Directors' Confidential, 1929–35.

94 Equinox Cable CMIC, Johannesburg to London, 25 Sept. 1931, BRA Gold Standard, 1931, 252; Martin to Wallers, 4 Nov. 1931, BRA London Letters Directors' Confidential 1929–35; Extracts from chairman's address Ordinary Meeting of the Chamber, 28 Sept. 1931, CMA Gold Standard, 1931.

95 Martin, to Wallers, , 4 11 1931Google Scholar, BRA London Letters Directors' Confidential 1929–35. For an account of the black and white miners' strikes of the early 1920s, see Johnstone, , Class, Race and Gold, 93–104, 180–4Google Scholar; Yudelman, , Emergence, 135–59Google Scholar; Bonner, P., ‘The 1920 black mineworkers strike: a preliminary account’, in Bozzoli, B. (ed.), Labour, Townships and Protest (Johannesburg, 1979), 273–97.Google Scholar

96 Martin, to Wallers, , 4 11 1931Google Scholar, BRA London Letters Directors' Confidential 1929–35; Anderson, to Gemmill, , 16 10 1931, CMA Gold Standard, 1931.Google Scholar

97 Cables exchanged between Australian Mines and Metals Association and Gemmill, 15 Oct. 1931 and 18 Dec. 1931, CMA Gold Standard 1931; Evans, to Gemmill, , 4 11 1931Google Scholar, BRA Gold Standard, 1931, 252.

98 Evans, to Kemmerer, , 18 01 1932Google Scholar, BRA Gold Standard, 1932.

99 Chairman's address, 21 Dec. 1931, CMA Gold Standard, 1931. For a discussion of the Lucas Awards, see Davies, R., Capital, State and White Labour in South Africa 1900–1960 (Atlantic Highlands NJ, 1979), 184–8.Google Scholar

100 Special Meeting on the Gold Standard, 13 Nov. 1931, CMA Gold Standard, 1931.

101 Martin, to Wallers, , 23 03 1932Google Scholar, BRA London Letters Directors' Confidential, 1929–35; Martin, to Wallers, , 21 12 1932Google Scholar, BRA Private Cables 1932–33; Martin, to Wallers, , 22 12 1932, BRA Private Cables 1932–33.Google Scholar

102 Union statistics for fifty years; Transvaal Chamber of Mines Annual Report, 1950.

103 See Havenga's dramatic and vengeful budget speech. Budget Statements 1933–4, 30 May 1933, CMA Taxation (1), 1933.

104 Interview of Mdumani Dzingwe by Mzayifani, and Breckenridge, , 22 08 1992.Google Scholar

105 Rand Daily Mail-Mining and Finance News, 14 11 1933.Google Scholar

106 See Appadurai, , (ed.), Social Life of ThingsGoogle Scholar; Comaroff, J. and Comaroff, J. L., ‘Goodly beasts, beastly goods: cattle and commodities in a South African context’, American Ethnologist, XVII (1989), 195–215Google Scholar; Cronon, W., Nature's Metropolis: Chicago and the Great West (New York, 1991)Google Scholar; Ferguson, J., ‘The bovine mystique: power, property and livestock in rural Lesotho’, Man, XX (1985), 647–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ferguson, J., ‘Cultural exchange: new developments in the anthropology of commodities’, Cultural Anthropology, III (1988), 488–513CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mintz, S., Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar in Modern History (New York, 1985).Google Scholar

107 Ferguson, , ‘Cultural exchange’, 490.Google Scholar As Ferguson has also noted, much of the space for this interpenetration of analytical boundaries has been opened up by Baudrillard, J., For a Critique of the Political Economy of the Sign (St Louis, 1981).Google Scholar

108 See also ‘The madman and the migrant: work and labor in the historical consciousness of a South African people’, American Ethnologist, XIV (1982), 191–209Google Scholar, and Comaroff, J. and Comaroff, J. L., Of Revelation and Revolution: Christianity, Colonialism and Consciousness in South Africa (Chicago, 1991).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

109 Marx, K., The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (New York, 1967).Google Scholar

110 Comaroff and Comaroff, Of Revelation and Revolution, 30.Google Scholar

111 My thanks to John Comaroff for this idea. The centrality of cattle in the maintenance of the social and symbolic integrity of most of Southern Africa for most of this century is not in question. Indeed, old male informants interviewed for this study stressed the importance of investing in cattle as one of the primary uses of money, whether gold or paper. Comaroff and Comaroff ‘Goodly beasts, beastly goods’, 210Google Scholar; Ferguson, ‘Bovine mystique’.Google Scholar

112 Comaroff and Comaroff, ‘Goodly beasts, beastly goods’, 200–1.Google Scholar

113 Ferguson, ‘Bovine mystique’, 649.Google Scholar

114 Beinart, , Political Economy of Pondoland, 8.Google Scholar A similar trend took place in Lesotho after the large wage increases on the Orange Free State gold mines in the 1970s: Ferguson, , ‘Bovine mystique’, 659.Google Scholar