Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T16:05:20.678Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Madagascar and the Slave Trade, 1810–18951

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Gwyn Campbell
Gwyn Campbell
Affiliation:
Coleg Prifysgol Cymru, Abertawe/University College of Wales, Swansea
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The distinguishing feature of the Malagasy slave trade in the nineteenth century was the co-existence of two competitive slave networks, the one feeding Malagasy slaves to meet the demand of long-distance and regional markets in the western Indian Ocean, and the other channelling Malagasy war captives and East African slaves on to the markets of Imerina. The export of slaves from Madagascar had long existed, but the import of slaves was a new and distinctly nineteenth-century phenomenon, the result of the rise of the Merina empire, whose economy was based on a huge, unremunerated and servile labour force. As the empire expanded, so its labour requirements grew, to conflict sharply with the increasing demand for labour on the neighbouring plantation islands as they shifted over to the production of sugar. Creole merchants found themselves obliged to find alternative labour supplies, and from the 1830s they were moving rapidly down the west coast of Madagascar, where they purchased slaves from chiefs independent of Merina control. Until the outbreak of the Franco-Merina war of 1882–5, the slave-trade networks remained remarkably stable, despite local rivalries. This was due largely to the presence of the Arab Antalaotra, an experienced body of middlemen, and the Indian Karany who supplied the capital for the trade. The war effectively broke the power of the Merina regime, and as the imperial economy crumbled, so security of trade collapsed across the island. Though the disruption of legitimate commerce initially spurred the slave trade, it also strengthened creole calls for French intervention. This occurred in 1895, and the following year the French authorities abolished slavery in Madagascar. This, and the effective military occupation of the island by the French, reduced the Malagasy slave trade to a trickle by the first years of the twentieth century.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 22 , Issue 2 , April 1981 , pp. 203 - 227
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Toussaint, Auguste, La route des îles – contribution à l'histoire maritime des Mascareignes (Paris, 1967)Google Scholar; Filliot, J. M., La traite des esclaves vers les Mascareignes (Paris, 1974)Google Scholar; for the east coast trade up to the 1820s, see Valette, Jean, Etudes sur le règne de Radama Ier (Antananarivo, 1962)Google Scholar and ‘Etude de la correspondance de Jean René et SirFarquhar’, R. T., BAM, xlv (1967), 71–98Google Scholar; Munthe, L., Ravoajanahary, C. and Ayache, S., ‘Radama Ier et les Anglais: les négotiations de 1817 d'après les sources malgaches (“Sorabe” inedits)’, Omaly sy Anio, iii–iv (1976), 9–104.Google Scholar For some aspects of the slave trade of the north-west coast before the rise of the Merina empire see Alpers, E. A., ‘Madagascar and Mozambique in the nineteenth century: the era of the Sakalava raids (1800–1820)’, Omaly sy Anio, v–vi (1977), 37–53.Google Scholar

3 . The only works covering slavery in Madagascar after 1820 in any depth deal only with the institution of slavery, and not the slave trade; see J. B. Piolet, De l‘esclavage à Madagascar (1896), André, E.C., De l'esclavage à Madagascar (Paris, 1899)Google Scholar, and B. Domenichini-Ramiaramanana and J.-P. Domenichi, ‘Questions relatives à l'esclavage en Imerina d'après les édits des souverains’, paper presented at the Colloque d'histoire, Mantasoa (1980). The slave trade of the western Indian Ocean was of far greater dimensions and of a radically different structure in the nineteenth century than in previous centuries, as Alpers stresses for East Africa: Alpers, E. A., ‘The French slave trade in East Africa’, Cahiers d'études africaines, x, 37 (1970), 80–125CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, Ivory and slaves in East Central Africa (London, 1975), ch. 7; idem.The East African slave trade (Nairobi, 1967). See also Owen, W. F. W., Narrative of voyages to…Africa, Arabia and Madagascar (London, 1833)Google Scholar, and below, notes 39 and 41.

4 CFM; FO 84/858 (X/J 7300).

5 Andre, , De l'esclavage, 1–21Google Scholar; Callet, R. P., Histoire des Rois (Tananarive, 1974 ed.), I, 62–3, 655; iii–iv, 267Google Scholar; also Thompson, A., ‘The role of firearms and the development of military techniques in Merina warfare, c. 1785–1828’, Revue française d'histoire d'outremer, lxi, 224 (1974), 417–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Alpers, East African Slave Trade; Freeman-Grenville, G. S. P., The French at Kilwa Island (Oxford, 1965).Google Scholar

6 RA 67–74; CFM; Toussaint, La route des îies; Hafkin, N., ‘Trade, society and politics in Northern Mozambique, c. 1753–1913’ (Ph.D. thesis, Boston University, 1973)Google Scholar; Curtin, Philip D., The Atlantic slave trade (Madison, 1969), 231–284Google Scholar; see also Jackson, Mabel (Haight), European Powers and south-east Africa, 1796–1856 (London, 1942; second edition, 1967)Google Scholar; and Graham, G. S., Great Britain in the Indian Ocean, 1810–1850 (Oxford, 1967).Google Scholar

7 Ellis, W., History of Madagascar (London, 1838), 11, 243, 246–7Google Scholar; Munthe et al., ‘Radama I’; Valette, Etudes.

8 See Fig. 2. which is based on the following sources: Frederic Surtees (Cape Town) to Palmerston, 1 March 1851, FO 84/833 (ERD/1144). Jules Xaver (Mahanora) to Pakenham, 6 Jan. 1865, FO 84/1249 (ERD/1142); Ader, R. L., ‘Tulear et sa région économique’ (thèse de 3e cycle, n.p., n.d., AAM), 43Google Scholar; AHVP c. 281, C. 28h, c. 35, sect. 11 34 d; Archives de Maurice, HB 16/13; CFM, 18 Jan. 1873; Ellis, , History, 11, 153Google Scholar; Freeman, J.J. and Johns, D., A narrative of the persecution of the Christians in Madagascar (London 1840), 161, 191Google Scholar; Fontoynont, M. and Nicol, Dr., Les traitants français de la côte est de Madagascar de Ranavalona I à Radama II (Mémoire de l'Académie Malgache, Tananarivo, 1940)Google Scholar; Griffiths, D., Hanes Madagascar (Machynlleth, 1840), 73, 80–1Google Scholar; GM 1–33; Larsen, Ludwig, Livet før Døden (Christiania, 1894), 298Google Scholar; Little, H. W., Madagascar, its history and people (London, 1884), 38Google Scholar; Madagascar Times, July–Nov. 1886; McMahon, E. O., ‘First visit of a European to the Betsiriry tribe’, AAMM, xv (1891)Google Scholar; Mullens, Joseph, Twelve months in Madagascar (London, 1875), 324Google Scholar; Piolet, , De l'esclavage, 462Google Scholar; Rasoamiaramanana, M., ‘Aspects économiques et sociaux de la vie à Majunga entre 1862 et 1881’ (thesis, Université de Madagascar, 1974), 81Google Scholar; Resident, A., Madagascar Past and Present (London, 1847), 82, 86, 144Google Scholar; RH 70–110; Boudou, R. P. A., ‘La Côte ouest de Madagascar en 1852. Notes d'Edmond Samat’, BAM, xv (1932)Google Scholar; Thompson, , ‘The role of firearms’, 224Google Scholar; A. Walen, ‘Masinandraina; Ms. FLM/NMS, Bks. 420A.

9 Valette, , Etudes, 8–10.Google Scholar

10 Oliver, S. P., ‘General Hall and the export slave-trade from Madagascar. A statement and a vindication’, AAMM, xii (1888), 678Google Scholar; Graham, , Great Britain, 58–72.Google Scholar

11 Oliver, , ‘General Hall’, 688Google Scholar, and idem, ‘Sir Robert Townsend Farquhar and the Malagasy slave trade’, AAMM, xv (1891), 319–21.

12 Ellis, , History, 11, 175.Google Scholar

13 RH, 93–4.

14 Ellis, , History, 11, 219, 231, 247Google Scholar; see also Fig. 2.

15 Oliver, , ‘General Hall’, 678Google Scholar; Ellis, , History, 11, 16, 198Google Scholar; RH, 82; Leminier, N., ‘Notes sur une excursion faite dans l'intérieur de l'île de Madagascar en 1825’, Bulletin de Madagascar, 292 (1970), 797.Google Scholar

16 Farquhar, (Pt. Louis, Mauritius) to Bathurst, 18 Nov. 1817, quoted in Ellis, , History, 11, 192–5.Google Scholar

17 Griffiths, D., The persecuted Christians of Madagascar (London, 1841)Google Scholar, quoted in Cousins, W. E. ‘Madagascar in the year 1840’, AAMM, xix (1895), 342–4Google Scholar; see also RH, 132, and Ellis, History, 1, 347; 11, 329–30, 348, 359. For East African comparisons see Alpers, , East African Slave Trade, 18–25Google Scholar, and Pankhurst, R., Economic History of Ethiopia, 1800–1935 (Addis Ababa, 1968), 100–105.Google Scholar

18 See Fig. 2; Ellis, , History, I, 138Google Scholar; GM, 32; Leminier, ‘Notes’, 795; Pankhurst, , Economic History, 88.Google Scholar

19 RH, 112; cf. Hopkins, A. G., An Economic History of West Africa (London, 1973), 23–7, 225–8.Google Scholar

20 For the application of slave labour in the Merina empire, see Campbell, Gwyn, ‘Labour and the transport problem in imperial Madagascar, 1810–95’, Journal of African History, xxi, 3 (1980), 341–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ellis, , History, 1, 83–6, 193–4, 282–99, 329, 338Google Scholar; GM, 32.

21 RA, 269; Fontoynont et Nicol, Les traitants français, 24.

22 Andriamarintsoa, , ‘Le gouvernement de Tamatave de 1845 à 1865: développement économique’ (thesis, Université de Madagascar, 1973), 111–12Google Scholar; Burroughs, Peter, ‘The Mauritius rebellion of 1832 and the abolition of British colonial slavery’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, iv, 3 (1976), 243–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar For an East African comparison, see Graham, Great Britain, ch. 5.

23 Ellis, , History, 11, 464Google Scholar; ‘Madagascar’ in Notices statistiques sur les colonies françaises, iv (Paris, 1840)Google Scholar, AHVP, M. 711 26, 8.

24 Ellis, , History, 1, 378.Google Scholar

25 Prout, E., Madagascar: its mission and its martyrs (London, 1863), 90–1Google Scholar; N. de Lastelle to Pakenham, Antananarivo, 2 Dec. 1875, FO 84/1449 (ERD/2270).

26 RA, 25; RH, 111; Ellis, , History, 1, 13Google Scholar; 11, 25–6, 517–18, 522; Freeman and Johns, A narrative of the persecution, 26; Thompson, ‘The role of firearms’.

27 The French claimed Mayotte and Nosy Be in 1841, and declared Anjouan (Johanna) a protectorate: Graham, , Great Britain, 80–3Google Scholar; Coupland, R., East Africa and its Invaders (Oxford, 1938), 439–58.Google Scholar

28 N. de Lastelle to Pakenham, FO 84/1449 (ERD 2270); RA, 25–6, 379, 451; Samat, , ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8), 57Google Scholar; Finkelmeier (Tamatave) to Davis, 31 March 1870, USC 11, 519; Guillain, C., Documents sur l'histoire, la géographie et le commerce de la partie occidentale de Madagascar (Paris, 1845), 11, 217–18Google Scholar; Segre, D. A., ‘Madagascar: an example of indigenous modernisation of a traditional society in the nineteenth century’, in Kirkwood, K. (ed.), St. Antony's Papers, no. 21 (London, 1969), 79–81.Google Scholar

29 ‘Rapport de Alphonse Samat à l'Admiral Laguerre, sur son amitié avec le roi Rabouky de Baly’, 21 Nov. 1852, AHVP, C. 28e.

30 AHVP, 36b, C. 28f; GM, 10; A Resident, Madagascar, 231–2; Prud'homme, , ‘Considérations sur les Sakalaves’, Notes, reconnaissances et explorations, vi (1900), 271Google Scholar; Burroughs, ‘The Mauritius rebellion’.

31 ‘Rapport de A. Samat’ (cited in n. 29); ‘Report on the slave trade’, Cape Town, 25 April 1844, FO 84/515 (ERD/1144); Segre, , ‘Madagascar’, 69Google Scholar; Beachey, R. W., The Slave Trade of Eastern Africa (London, 1976), 30Google Scholar; Guillain, , Documents, 11, 273–82Google Scholar; Coupland, East Africa and its Invaders, ch. 14; Wastell, R. E. P., ‘British imperial policy in relation to Madagascar, 1810–96’ (Ph.D. thesis, London University, 1944).Google Scholar

32 P. Jouen aux supérieurs en France (1859), AHVP. C. 28i; GM, 10; Annales maritimes et coloniales, 11, 46 (1931), 91–108.

33 RA, 369; Ellis, History, 11, 519; Samat, ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8), 62; GM, 9, 23–4; Denieau, P., ‘Lettre’ (Toulia, 4 Sept. 1847)Google Scholar, AHVP C. 35; Larsen, , Livet før Døden, 296–8Google Scholar; Ader, R. L., ‘Les traitants de Nosy-Vé, Tulear à la fin du XIXe siècle’, Etudes Tuléariennes, 11 (Dec. 1970)Google Scholar; Guerret, Abbé (ed. Génin, E.), Trois mois autour de Madagascar (Douai, 1883), 52–4.Google Scholar

34 Mullens, , Twelve months, 318Google Scholar; Richardson, J., Lights and shadows (Antananarivo, 1877), 30–57Google Scholar; see also above, notes 20, 26.

35 Granville's correspondence, 31 Oct.–9 Nov. 1872, CFM.

36 Le Moniteur de La Réunion, 30 Jan. 1877; Ch. Finkelmeier to Hunter, Tamatave, 3 Nov. and 30 Dec. 1874, and Robinson to Hunter, Tamatave, 11 Aug. 1876 and 28 Jan. 1877 in USC, 11; Rainilaiarivony to Pakenham, Antananarivo, 24 May 1876 and to Earl of Derby, 28 Dec. 1876, FO 84/1449 (ERD/2270); Kestell-Cornish, R. K., ‘A short cruise to the north-western coast of Madagascar’, AAMM iii (1877), 273Google Scholar; see also Fig. 1.

37 Letter from L. Street in The English Independent, 15 and 22 Nov. 1877; Cousins, W. E., ‘The abolition of slavery in Madagascar’, AAMM, xx (1896), 446–50Google Scholar; cf. Mutibwa, P. M., The Malagasy and the Europeans (London, 1974), 348.Google Scholar

38 The price of a slave in Imerina was, according to my calculations (see references cited in note 8 above), about two-thirds more than on the west coast, and one-third less than on the east coast, which reflects the availability of supplies.

39 See Ellis, History, which was largely compiled from manuscripts supplied by the early missionaries, especially Griffiths. The ‘unification theory’ has been popularized by major historians of Madagascar, notably Deschamps, Hubert, Histoire de Madagascar (Paris, 1972)Google Scholar, and idem, ‘Tradition and change in Madagascar, 1790–1870’ in J. E. Flint (ed.), Cambridge History of Africa, v (1976), 393–417. It has recently been reiterated by Simon Ayache in ‘Pouvoir central et provinces sous la monarchic Merina au XIXe siècle. Une theme de recherche’ (MS kindly lent the author by S. Ayache); see also Mutibwa, The Malagasy and the Europeans.

40 Pioneering work was done on the Sakalava in the first half of the nineteenth century by Noel, Vincent, ‘Ile de Madagascar: recherches sur les Sakalava’, Bulletin de la société de geographie (1843)Google Scholar, and Guillain, Documents (1845), but only very recently has the ‘provincial’ history of Madagascar become the subject of serious and regular attention by historians; see, for example, Ader, ‘Tulear’ and ‘Les traitants’; Esoavelo-mandroso, Manassé, ‘Problèmes de police et de justice dans le gouvernement de Tamatave à l'époque de Rainandriamampandry, 1882–95’, Etudes Historiques (Université de Madagascar, 1974)Google Scholar; and idem, ‘La région du Fiheregna à la veille de la conquête française’ (paper presented at the Colloque d'histoire, Toliara, 1979).

41 See, for example, Beachey, Slave Trade, 211, 262; Richardson, J., ‘Lettre au sujet de la libération des Mozambiques’, BAM, xviii (1935), 12–15Google Scholar; The author has utilized largely unexploited sources such as USC, RA and RH, FLM/NMS and GM, in addition to the more familiar British sources, to shed light on the slave trade of the west coast and interior of Madagascar in the nineteenth century. For the British naval attitude see Colomb, Captain, Slave-catching in the Indian Ocean (London, 1873; reprinted 1968), 298–503Google Scholar; see also Hafkin, , ‘Trade’, 290–1.Google Scholar

42 Rasoamiaramanana, , ‘Aspects’, 10–11, 35, 54Google Scholar; Noel, , ‘He de Madagascar’, 19, 27–38, 93, 99Google Scholar; GM, 28.

43 Rasoamiaramanana, , ‘Aspects’, 19, 23, 25, 77–8Google Scholar; GM, 28; Guillain, , Documents, I, 89–100.Google Scholar

44 Noel, ‘He de Madagascar’, CFM.

45 Samat, , ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8), 62Google Scholar; Hall, W. H., Narrative of the voyages and services on the Nemesis (London, 1844).Google Scholar

46 CFM, 3 April 1873, enclosure 2, and 29 May 1873; ‘Report’, Cape Town, 1844, FO 84/515 (ERD/1144); Landmark, N., Det Norske missionsselskab (Kristiania, 1899), 169Google Scholar; Duffy, J., A Question of Slavery (Oxford, 1967), ch. 3.Google Scholar

47 CFM, 27 Feb. 1873; Beachey, Slave Trade, 33–4.

48 CFM, 12 March 1873; ‘Report’, Cape Town, 1844, FO 84/515 (ERD/1144); Pakenham (Tamatave) to Granville, 18 March and 10 June 1873, FO 84/1369 (ERD/1142); Hafkin, , ‘Trade’, 52–5.Google Scholar

49 Hafkin, , ‘Trade’, 233–54Google Scholar; CFM, 27 Feb. 1873; cf. Newitt, M. D. D., ‘Angoche, the Slave Trade and the Portuguese, c. 1844–1912’, Journal of African History, xiii, 4 (1972), 659–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar For East African comparisons, cf. Beachey, , Slave Trade, 24–5Google Scholar; Kirk to Granville, 5 March and 3 April 1872, Correspondence respecting the Slave Trade, c. 867 (Parl. Papers 1873, LXl); Duffy, , Question, 65–8.Google Scholar

50 At the end of the 1830s the French granted British authorities the right to search their ships, so slavers started using the flags of other nations. Use of the American flag was particularly popular, even though from 1863 the British navy was entitled to search American vessels in Malagasy waters: Curtin, , Atlantic slave trade, 79Google Scholar; Samat, , ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8), 67Google Scholar; Beachey, , Slave Trade, 23Google Scholar; see also the correspondence of Stanwood in USC.

51 Curtin, , Atlantic slave trade, 269, 273–6Google Scholar; CFM, 29 May 1873; see also Houlder, J. A., Narrative of a missionary tour (Antananarivo, 1877)Google Scholar; Morier to Braamcamp, 19 Aug. 1879 (encl. in Morier to Salisbury, 22 Aug. 1879), Corr. Slave Trade, c. 2720 (Parl. Pap. 1880, lxix); Duffy, , Question, 91–3.Google Scholar

52 GM, 37.

53 Pakenham (Tamatave) to Granville, 3 Jan. 1874, FO 84/1397, same to same, 19 Oct. 1876, FO 84/1474 (ERD/2270); Robinson (Tamatave) to Hunter, 21 Oct. 1879, USC 11, 52; GM, 22; Samat, ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8), 67; Colomb, , Slave-catching, 319–56.Google Scholar

54 Rasoamiaramanana, , ‘Aspects’, 40–54Google Scholar; Campbell, ‘Labour and the transport problem’.

55 Pakenham (Tamatave) to Derby, 30 Jan. 1877, FO 84/1474 (ERD/2270); Kestell-Cornish to Pakenham, ‘Tsoavan Andriana’, 26 Sept. 1876, FO 84/1474 (ERD/2270).

56 CFM; Hafkin, ‘Trade’, 85–8; Coupland, East Africa and its Invaders, chs. 5, 8–9.

57 Frere (Poona) to Granville, memo., 7 May 1873 (incl. I no. 53). CFM; Coupland, East Africa and its Invaders, chs. io, 15.

58 ‘Memo’, 31 March 1873, CFM.

59 Pakenham (Tamatave) to Stanley, 4 Feb. 1869, FO 84/1307 (ERD/1142); ‘Report’ of Capt. Malcolm of H.M.S. Briton, 17 Aug. 1873, FO 84/1397; see also ‘The English Blue Book’, 111, 8 no. 4, incl. 2 and 8, and no. 26, in the Madagascar Times, 1885–6.

60 GM, 26–8.

61 Stanwood, ‘Memo’ 2, 21 Aug. 1883 USC; Frere (Mozambique) to Granville, 27 Feb. 1873, CFM; see also n. 83 below. For details of the cholera epidemic see Coupland, R., The Exploitation of East Africa (London, 1939; 1968), 53–6.Google Scholar

62 GM, 22–3; Samat, , ‘Notes’, 65–6.Google Scholar

63 Rasoamiaramanana, , ‘Aspects’, 62.Google Scholar

64 ‘Memos’, 31 Mar. and 7 May 1873 (incl. 1, no. 52), CFM; ‘Report’, Cape Town, 1844, FO 84/515 (ERD/i 144); Hafkin, , ‘Trade’, 232–52Google Scholar; Kirk to Granville, 25 Jan. and 5 Mar. 1872, Corr. Slave Trade, c. 867 (Parl. Pap. 1873, lxi); Jackson, European Powers, chs. 3, 6.

65 ‘Memo’, 31 March 1873, CFM; Fontoynont et Nicol, Les traitants, 24; RA, 269.

66 Landmark, Det Norske, 160–301; Rostvig's correspondence, FLM/NMS Copibok, Tolia, 812 B; Rostvig, L., Sakalaverne og deres land (Stavanger, 1886)Google Scholar; GM, 26–8; Stanwood (Andakabe) to Robinson, 28 Aug. 1884, and Stanwood, ‘memo’ 1, in Stanwood to Robinson, 13 July 1884, USC iv.

67 E.g. King Maromiantia established his capital fifteen leagues into the interior from the mouth of the river Manambolo: GM, 26. See also Alfred, and Grandidier, Guillaume (eds.), Collection des ouvrages anciens concernant Madagascar (Paris, 1903), vols, iii, vGoogle Scholar; Guillain, , Documents, 11, 339.Google Scholar

68 GM, 24–5.

69 Stanwood (Morondava) to Robinson, 1 Dec. 1880, USC. For African comparisons see Beachey, , Slave Trade, 60Google Scholar; Pankhurst, , Economic History, 84–9.Google Scholar

70 The first ships from the Mascareignes generally arrived in June. GM, 8.

71 GM, 9, 14.

72 GM; Larsen, Livet; Rostvig's correspondence in FLM/NMS Copibok, Tolia; Stanwood's correspondence in USC.

73 Stanwood (Morondava) to Robinson, 23 Jan. 1881, USC iii; Robinson (Tamatave) to Adee, 22 Oct. 1884, USC iv; see also Richardson, Lights.

74 Robinson to Adee, 22 Oct. 1884, USC iv; Campbell (Tamatave) to Porter, 23 Aug. 1887, USC v, GM, 27.

75 GM, 9–20, 23, 28; Landmark Det Norske, 273–82; Campbell to Porter, 18 Oct. 1887; and Campbell (Tamatave) to Rives, 10 Feb. 1888: USC v.

76 Pakenham (Tamatave) to Derby, 21 Feb. 1876, FO 84/1369 (ERD/1142); Robinson (Tamatave) to Third Asst. Sec. of State, 22 May 1882, USC 111, no. 98; Samat, ‘Notes’ (cited in n. 8); Guerret, Trois mois, 37–54.

77 Campbell, ‘Labour’; Rainilaiarivony (Antananarivo) to Pakenham, 24 July 1868, FO 84/1291; Robinson (Tamatave) to Hunter, 28 June 1877, USC 11, no. 26.

78 Stanwood (Andakabe) to Whitney, 30 June 1883; Stanwood (Morondava) to Whitney and Robinson, 1 Aug. 1883; Robinson (Tamatave) to Adee, 22 Oct. 1884: USC iv; for arms smuggling in East Africa, see Beachey, R. W., ‘The arms trade in East Africa in the late nineteenth century’, Journal of African History, 111, 3 (1962), 451–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

79 See the correspondence of Stanwood, 25 Aug. to 27 Dec. 1887, USC v.

80 Stanwood (Andakabe) to Campbell, 20 Aug. 1887; Whitney, ‘Report’, Tamatave, 10 Sept. 1887; Stanwood (Andakabe) to Campbell, 17 Dec. 1887: USC v.

81 Whitney ‘Report’, 10 Sept. 1887, USC v; see also above, notes 50–51.

82 Rostvig, , Sakalaverne, 244Google Scholar; Pickersgill, S., ‘North Sakalavaland’, AAMM viii (1893), 29–43Google Scholar; Stanwood (Andakabe) to Robinson (incl. in Stanwood to Bayard, 31 Oct. 1886), USC iv; Esoavelomandroso, ‘Fiheregna’; Prud'homme, ‘Considerations’, 29.

83 Stanwood, ‘Memo’ 2, 21 Aug. 1883; Stanwood to Robinson, 28 Aug. 1884: USC iv; see also n. 61 above.

84 Stanwood (Morondava) to Robinson, 13 July 1884, USC iv; Stanwood (Andakabe) to Pickersgill, 18 Aug. 1887, USC v; Kirk to Granville, 3 April 1872 (as cited in n. 49).

85 Stanwood, ‘Memo’, 2; Stanwood (Andakabe) to Third Asst. Sec. of State, 11 Feb. 1884; Stanwood, ‘Commercial Report’, 31 Dec. 1886: USC iv.

86 Stanwood, ‘Commercial Report’; Le Lyes, S. M., ‘Relation’, Annales maritimes et coloniales, xiv, 139 (1821), 652–64.Google Scholar

87 Stanwood (Andakabe) to Campbell, 25 Aug. 1887, USC v.

88 Walen, A., Madagaskars sydostkyst (Stavanger, 1888).Google Scholar

89 GM, 41.

90 Jouen, ‘Notes’ (n.d.), AHVP, c. 28b.; see also n. 26 above.

91 Walen, Madagaskars, 24–6; Piolet, De l'esclavage, 458–9; Those slavers in the extreme south-west of the island were mostly Creoles of French nationality: Rostvig, ‘Export of slaves from the south west coast of Madagascar’, letter to the Natal Mercury, 7 Aug. 1886, FLM/NMS Bks 812B.

92 Besson, L., ‘Voyage au pays des Tanala indépendants de la région d'Ikongo’ from Grandidier, A. (ed.), Les voyageursfrançais à Madagascar pendant les trente dernières années, (Paris, 1894).Google Scholar

93 The Antanosy emigrants fled some time between 1856 and 1866. Under their leader Zaomanery they established a capital at Kiliarivo (Salobe), 120 km east of St Augustine's Bay, and 300 km west of Taolanaro, on the plain between the Taheza and Sakamare tributaries of the Onilahy river: GM, 10–11; Richardson, , Lights, 40.Google Scholar

94 McMahon, , ‘First visit’, 280Google Scholar; Richardson, Lights.

95 David, Robert, Nosy-ve, islette australe et vice-résidence de France de 1888 à 1897 (Tananarive, 1939), 18Google Scholar; also see ‘Report’ of Rostvig to Captain Aldrick of H.M.S. Fawn, Tulear 25 Nov. 1882, FLM/NMS Tolia Copybok, 632–45.

96 See Stanwood (Andakabe) to Campbell, 27–31 Dec. 1887, USC v; and Rostvig's correspondence in FLM/NMS Copybok Tolia (1882–92), 812 B.

97 Dawson, E. W., Madagascar: its capabilities and resources (London, 1895)Google Scholar; Cousins, ‘The abolition’; The Lambert indemnity was for 180,000 dollars: Wastell, , ‘British imperial policy’, 370.Google Scholar

98 Mondain, ‘Un voyage’, mss FJKM.

99 ‘Isandra: ny distry Soatanana’, ms FLM/NMS 57–1; ‘letter’ to Rainilaiarivony, 10 Sept. 1890, FLM/NMS Bks 270H; Borchgrevink to Rainilaiarivony, Antsahananta, 14 Mar. 1894, FLM/NMS Bks 270 G; R. P. Fontaine, ‘Lettre’, Fianarantsoa, 2 June 1891, in Les missions catholiques (1891), 409–11; Knight, E. F., ‘From Fort Dauphin to Fianarantsoa’, AAMM xix (1895), 363–70Google Scholar and AAMM xx (1896), 396–401.Google Scholar

100 Laroche pronounced the decree abolishing slavery on 27 Sept. 1896. The slave trade in Madagascar did persist, but in a vastly reduced way: Cousins, , ‘The abolition’, 446–50Google Scholar; Marcuse, Walter, Through Western Madagascar in Quest of the Golden Bean (London, 1914), 116, 223.Google Scholar

101 Marcuse, , Through Western Madagascar, 45–62, 278–81, 341Google Scholar; Slawecki, L. M. S., French Policy Totvards the Chinese in Madagascar (1971), 78–100Google Scholar; Hafkin, , ‘Trade’, 363–402Google Scholar; André, , De l'esclavage, 71–2, 193–214Google Scholar; Piolet, , De l'esclavage, 472–9.Google Scholar