Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-02T21:30:36.577Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Kirk and the Egyptian Invasion of East Africa in 1875: A Reassessment

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

E. R. Turton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper attempts to reassess the importance of the McKillop expedition of 1875 and also to re-examine Kirk's role in securing its withdrawal, which, according to the thesis associated with Coupland, was thought to have been crucial. This paper shows that Kirk did not secure McKillop's return, but that he played an important part in the formation of the policy that was adopted towards the expansion of Egypt in Africa, which was a direct result of the Egyptian invasion down the east coast. This invasion is placed not merely within the context of Ismail's designs in the Interlacustrine area but also of his designs in Somalia as well. The impact of the expedition is also considered, its effect on the slave-trade, on the religious attitudes of Muslims on the coast, and as a final factor stimulating the attempted formation of an East African Company.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 11 , Issue 3 , July 1970 , pp. 355 - 370
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Coupland, R., The Exploitation of East Africa 1856–1890 (London, 1939), chap. xiii, ‘The Egyptian invasion, 1875–1876’, 293.Google Scholar

2 See, for instance: Langer, W. L., The Diplomacy of Imperialism, 1890–1902 (New York, 1965), 103;Google ScholarJohn, Flint, ‘The wider background to partition and colonial occupation’, in History of East Africa, I (Oxford, 1963),Google Scholar ed. Oliver, R. and Mathew, G.; Sir, John Gray, ‘Sir John Kirk and Mutesa’, U.J. XV (1951);Google Scholarde Kiewiet, M. J., ‘History of the Imperial British East Africa Company’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis (London, 1956).Google Scholar

3 Ismail to McKillop, 17 September 1875; Ismail to Gordon, 17 September 1875, translated from the French by Col., E. A. Stanton in ‘Secret letters from the Khedive Ismail in connection with an occupation of the East Coast of Africa’, J. Roy. Afr. Soc., XXXIV (1935), 271, 279.Google Scholar

4 The exact figure was nearer 450 miles, but it appears that at the time Gordon was using a defective French map which showed Lake Victoria as extending to within 80 miles of Mt. Kenya, see Lt.-Col., F. W. Moffitt, ‘Some dispatches from Khedive Ismail to Major General Charles Gordon’, J. Afr. Soc., XXXIV (1935), 113.Google Scholar

5 Gordon was certainly thinking along these lines by December 1874, if not before (see his letter to Watson, C. M. of 28 12 1874Google Scholar in Lane-Poole, S., Watson Pasha (London, 1919), 61, quoted by Coupland, Exploitation of E. Africa, 274),Google Scholar and a proposal had been made in this vein to the Khedive by January 1875 (see Allen, B. M., Gordon and the Sudan (London, 1931), 37; also Gordon to Derby, 20 03 1876, F.O. CP. 3090).Google Scholar

6 Coupland, , Exploitation of E. Africa, 275.Google Scholar

7 Sabry, M., L'Empire égyptien sous Ismail et l'ingérence Anglo-Française 1863–1879 (Paris, 1933), 396.Google Scholar See also Coupland, , Exploitation of E. Africa, 278.Google Scholar

8 Khedive to Gordon, 17 September 1875, in Stanton, ‘Secret letters’, 277.

9 It is worth noting that Gordon disregarded the Khedive's instructions to march to the coast on the grounds that Ismail had not followed his advice by sending McKillop to the Juba. See Coupland, , Exploitation of E. Africa, 278,Google Scholar who quotes Sabry, , L'Empire égyptien, 488–9. The choice of the Juba as a destination also puzzled Chaillé Long, who accompanied McKillop, and he noted that Gordon had made other suggestions (My Life in Four Continents (London, 1912), 175).Google Scholar

10 An Arab Governor had been appointed to Kismayu in 1870 and by November 1874 he had built a small fort at the mouth of the river Juba, though without informing Barghash (Holmwood, F., ‘Tour to the North Coast of Zanzibar’, 11 1874, F.O. 84/1423).Google Scholar The fact that Ismail fused two plans has also been noted by Salim, A. I., ‘The Swahili- speaking communities of the Kenya Coast’ (Ph.D. thesis, London, 1968), 80.Google Scholar

11 Ismail to Gordon, 17 11 1875, in Stanton, , ‘Secret letters’, 278–9.Google Scholar

12 The cession was made on 27 May (State Papers, LVI, 1167).

13 Cherif, Pasha to Col, Stanton, 1 06 1870, F.O. 78/3186.Google Scholar See David, Hamilton, ‘Imperialism ancient and modern: a study of English attitudes to the claims of sovereignty to the northern Somali coast-line’, Journal of Ethiopian Studies, v, no. 2 (1967), 19.Google Scholar

14 Hertslett, E., ‘Memorandum on Turkish claims to sovereignty over the Soumali territory’, 18 07 1871, F.O., 78/3186.Google Scholar

15 Merewether to Sec. Bombay Government, 24 02 1866, F.O. 78/3186.Google Scholar

16 Memorandum by Mr, Badger on a conversation with M., de Rémusat and Servar, Pasha, the Ottoman Ambassador to France, 1872, F.O. 78/3186;Google ScholarHertslett, , ‘Memorandum on the Turkish claims to sovereignty over the Eastern shores of the Red Sea… and of the Egyptian claim to the whole of the western shore of the same area, including the African coast from Suez to Cape Guardafui’ (1874. F.O. 78/3187).Google Scholar

17 The Political Resident Aden to India Office, 1808 1870, F.O. 78/3186.Google Scholar

18 Stanton to Derby, 1509 1874, F.O. 78/3187.Google Scholar

19 Minutes, n.d., by Tenterden, and Derby, on S. to D., 15 09 1874, F.O. 78/3187.Google Scholar

20 I.O. to F.O., 25 09, 1874,Google Scholar F.O. 78/3187; I.O. to Lord, Derby, 25 03 1875; Disraeli, Minute, 27 08 1875, F.O. 78/3188.Google Scholar

21 Schneider to Gonne, 6 October 1874, F.O. CP. 3568. However, he had Socotra in mind rather than East Africa.

22 Stanton to Derby, 11 11 1875, no. 112, F.O. 78/2405.Google Scholar For the background to the clash between Egypt and Ethiopia in the 1870s see Abir, M., ‘Ethiopian–Egyptian border problem’, J. Afr. Hist. VIII, no. 3 (1967).Google Scholar A description of the conflict in the 1870s itself can be found in an article by Robinson, A. E., ‘The Ethiopian–Abyssinian war of 1874–1876’, J. Afr. Soc. XXVI (1926).Google Scholar

23 Stanton to Derby, 1111. 1875, no. 113, F.O. 78/3188.Google Scholar

24 Stanton to Derby, 2411, no. 116, 1875, F.O. 141/94.Google Scholar See also Hoskins, H. L., ‘British policy in Africa 1873–1877: a study in geographical politics’, Geographical Review, XXXII (1942).Google Scholar

25 Wylde, , Minute, 2 12 1875, F.O. 84/5425.Google Scholar

26 Chaillé, Long, My Life, 1, 275.Google Scholar Robinson maintains that McKillop set out on 17 September with a force of 1,000 men. But Chaillé Long's figures are on this occasion more reliable and are corroborated from other sources (Robinson, ‘The Ethiopian–Abyssinian War’, 270).Google Scholar

27 I. to McK., 2910. 1875Google Scholar in Stanton, , ‘Secret Letters’, 281.Google Scholar

28 Stanton to Derby, 11 November 1875, no. 113, F.O. 78/3188.

29 Idem, footnote 27.

30 Chaillé, Long, My Life, I, 178.Google Scholar

31 McKillop to Gordon, in Kirk to Derby, 202 1876, F.O. 84/1452.Google Scholar

32 Stanton to Derby, 1111, nos. 112 and 113, 14 11 no 116, F.O. 78/3188.Google Scholar

33 Stanton to Derby, 2511 1875, F. O. 141/94; Governor of Bombay to F.O., 26 11 1875, F.0. 78/3188.Google Scholar

34 I.O. to F.O., 2911 1875, F. O. 78/3188.Google Scholar

35 Derby, and Tenterden, , Minutes, 30 11 1875, on Stanton to Derby, 14 11 1875, no. 116, F.O. 78/3188.Google Scholar

36 An old friend of Said Barghash, Badger had accompanied Coghian on the Muscat–Zanzibar Arbitration Commission of 1861 and had been Secretary and Confidential Adviser to Sir Bartle Frere on his Mission to East Africa in 1873. He was a noted Arabist and had published a translation of Salil ibn Raziq, History of the Imams and Seyyids of Oman (1871). In 1881 he published an Arabic Dictionary.Google Scholar

37 Badger to Derby, 2911 1875, F.O. 84/1425.Google Scholar

38 The telegram had also been published in the Pall Mall Gazette on 30 11.Google Scholar (see Richard, Gray, A History of the Southern Sudan, 1839–1889 (Oxford, 1961), 179).Google Scholar

39 Minutes, n.d., on Badger's letter of 2911 1875, F.O. 84/1425.Google Scholar

40 Wylde, , Minute on Mr Dawes visit to the F.O., 2 12 1875, F.O. 84/1425.Google Scholar

41 Minute, 3 December 1875, F.O. 84/1425.

42 Wylde, , Minute, 2 12 1875, F.O. 84/1425; Stanton to Derby, 11 11 1875, no. 113, and 14 11, no. 116, F.O. 78/3188.Google Scholar See also, Hoskins, H. L., ‘British Policy’, 145–6. The telegram that was sent was Derby to Stanton, 3 12 1875, no. 92, F.O. 78/2403. It appears that upon the receipt of Kirk's telegram a further cable was sent to Cairo, though both are very similar.Google Scholar

43 Viceroy of India to F.O., F.O. 84/1423.

44 Kirk to Derby, 11 November 1875, no. 158. The other dispatches were dated 15 and 17 November 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

45 There seems to be an interesting parallel here with the experiences of another British Consul at Zanzibar. In 1847 Hamerton wrote: ‘From April to December it is not possible to obtain correct information (re. the Benadir coast)’. At that time it was feared that the French admiral Guillain was ‘tampering with the chiefs’ around Brava. Hamerton to Bombay, 2 may 1847, F.O. 54/12.

46 Kirk to Derby, 4 April 1875, quoted by Coupland, R. (1939), 251.Google Scholar

47 Kirk's, Cf. remark in a letter to Derby on 17 11 1875, ‘I have from the very beginning most carefully avoided expressing an opinion or holding out to His Highness the smallest assurances of British intervention’, F.O. 84/1417.Google Scholar

48 Kirk to Derby, 17 November 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

49 Derby to Stanton, 3 December 1875, no. 93, F.O. 141/91 and F.0. 78/2403. There is a small discrepancy in these two copies as to the time the telegram was sent.

50 Cave was the Postmaster General and his Mission was a financial one.

51 Derby to Kirk, 5 December 1875, F.O. 84/1414.

52 Schneider, to Stanton, , 8 12 1875, F.O. 141/93; I.O. to F.O., 6 12 1875 and Schneider to Viceroy, 27 12 1875, F.O. 84/1423. No explanation was given by the Resident at Aden for his curious action in forwarding the telegram to McKillop. Perhaps he wished to let McKillop know that hostilities should cease, being unable to inform Kirk of this.Google Scholar

53 Derby to Kirk, 3 December 1875, F.O. 84/1414.

54 The mail steamer did not return to Aden until 30 Dec. The mail was not sent by dhow presumably because of the risk (F.O. to I.O., 29 December 1875, F.O. 84/1423).

55 The first dispatch Kirk received was Derby's no. 50 of 5 Dec. which arrived with his telegrams of 30 and 31 Dec. (F.O. 84/1414); on the same day Kirk also received Stanton's letter of 28 Dec. telling him of the withdrawal of the Egyptians.

56 Kirk to Derby, 15 and 17 November 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

57 I.O. to F.O., 3 December 1875 and Viceroy of India to F.O., 27 December 1875, F.O. 84/1423.

58 Kirk to Salisbury, 18 November 1875, I.O. Political Department/I (India Office Archives).

59 Derby to Kirk, 31 December 1875, no. 58, F.O. 84/1414.

60 Coupland, R., Exploitation of E. Africa, 280–2.Google Scholar

61 Capt. Ward's account of this trip can be found in ‘Visits to ports North of Zanzibar’, 10 December 1875, F.O. 84/1457. Kirk's can be found in Kirk to Derby, 29 November and 2 December 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

62 Founder of the C.M.S. Mission at Freretown, Mombasa, in 1874.

63 Price to Kirk, 18 December, in Kirk to Derby, 25 December 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

64 Viceroy of India to F.O., 27 December encloses message from Kirk, n.d., F.O. 84/1423.

65 Kirk to Aitchison, 10 December 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

66 Tenterden, Minute, 13 January 1876, on Kirk's no. 174 of 8 Dec.; Derby, Minute, 18 January 1876 on Kirk to Derby, 14 December 1875 F.O. 84/1417.

67 Lister, Minute, n.d. on Kirk to Derby, 14 December 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

68 Wylde, , Minute, 11 01 1876, on Kirk to Derby, 2 12 1875, F.O. 84/1417.Google Scholar

69 The exception was Derby's first telegram to Kirk of 3 Dec., F.O. 84/1414. Other warnings were given in Derby to Kirk, 31 December 1875, no. 59, F.O. 84/1414; Derby to Kirk, 30 December 1875 tele., F.O. 84/1423; Derby to Kirk, 14 January 5876, F.O. 84/1451.

70 Sir, Charles Eliot, The East Africa Protectorate (London, 1893), 23.Google Scholar See also Lugard, F. D., The Rise of our East African Empire, II (London, 1893), 610;Google ScholarRobinson, A. E. ‘Ethiopian–Abyssinian war’, 260.Google Scholar

71 Coupland, , Exploitation of E. Africa, 292;Google ScholarFlint, ‘The wider background’, 359.Google Scholar

72 Khedive to McKillop, 17 November 1875, in Col. E. A. Stanton, ‘Secret Letters’.

73 Gordon to Burton, 17 July 1875, in Wilkins, W. H., The Romance of Isabel Lady Burton, II (London, 1897), 646–50.Google Scholar

74 Stanton to Derby, 5 December 1875, F.O. 141/93.

75 Nubar Pasha, Memorandum, 7 December 1875, F.O. 740/93.

76 Wylde, Minute, 27 December 1875, on Stanton to Derby, 5 December 1875, F.O. 78/3188.

77 Derby to Stanton, 4 Feburary 1876, F.O. CP. 3090.

78 Stanton to Derby, 9 Januray 1876, F.O. 403/8; Cave to Derby, 5 January 1876, F.O. CP. 3090.

79 Memorandum, 6 July 1876, Frere Papers, British Museum MSS.

80 Derby to Stanton, 4 February 1876, F.O. 84/1451; Wylde, Minute, 27 December 1875, F.O. 78/3188. Also a marginal note by Tenterden on a letter from Cookson to D., 8 Aug. 1876, is revealing: ‘It is absurd to talk of taking away territory which belongs to Zanzibar in order to give it to Egypt.’

81 Kirk to Derby, 6 April 1876, F.O. 84/1453.

82 Kirk to Granville, 31 May 1873, F.O. 84/1374.

83 Wylde's Minute, and Lord Salisbury's suggestion are quoted by Richard Gray (Oxford, 1961), 182.

84 Gordon to Derby, 20 March 1876, F.O. CP. 3090.

85 Stanton to Derby, 7 March 1876, F.O. 403/8.

86 Kirk, to Derby, , 15 12 1875, F.O. 84/1417.Google Scholar

87 Kirk to Derby, 8 December 1875, F.O. 84/1417.

88 Kirk to Derby, 15 April 1876, F.O. 84/1453.

89 Holmwood to Prideaux, 17 November 1874, F.O. 84/1400.

90 Kirk to Derby, 15 April 1876, F.O. 84/1453.

91 Kirk to Derby, 16 Augest 1876, F.O. 84/1454.

92 Kirk to Derby, 11 December 1876, F.O. 84/1454.

93 Kirk, , ‘Memorandum on the seizure of Brava by the Egyptians and the position of British subjects there’, n.d., F.O. 84/1417.Google Scholar

94 Holmwood's, ‘Tour to the north coast of Zanzibar’, 11 1874, F.O. 84/1423.Google Scholar

95 Kirk to Derby, 6 April 1876, F.O. 84/1453.

96 Lamb, F. W., ‘History of Gobwen and adjacent country and events leading to its occupation’, 30 09 1911, DC/KISM/3/1. (District Records, Kismayu, Nairobi Archives.)Google Scholar

97 Richard, Gray (Oxford, 1961), 183.Google Scholar

98 Coupland, (1939), 301.Google Scholar

99 Coupland, (1939), 279.Google Scholar See also, Martin, B. G., ‘Muslim politics and resistance to Colonial rule: Shaykh Uways B. Muhammad Al Barawi and the Qadiriya brotherhood in East Africa’, J. Afr. Hist. X, no. 3 (1969).Google Scholar

100 Révoil, G., Voyage au Cap des Aromates (Paris, 1880), 81, 89.Google Scholar

101 Wheeler, O. E., Somaliland (Simla, Government Central Branch Press, 1884), 16.Google Scholar

102 Kirk to Derby, 19 February 1877, enclosing Steere to U.M.C.A. Committee, 27 July 1876. Quoted from Oliver, R., The Missionary Factor in East Africa (London, 1952), 102.Google Scholar

103 Coupland (1939), 301.