Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T08:27:28.490Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

FRATERNAL FRIENDS: SOUTH AFRICAN COMMUNISTS AND CZECHOSLOVAKIA, 1945–89

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 July 2020

Tom Lodge Open the ORCID record for Tom Lodge [Opens in a new window]  and
Milan Oralek
Tom Lodge
Affiliation:
University of Limerick
Milan Oralek
Affiliation:
Victoria University of Wellington
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Czechoslovak ‘people's democracy’ supplied a model for the development of a South African notion of a ‘national democratic’ revolution as well as providing key skills and resources. Czechoslovak support for this project in the 1960s and 1970s was both a source of confidence and fragility for South African Communists, boosting morale but confirming their subordinate status in their partnership with African nationalism. Drawing upon Czech archival materials as well as memoirs and interviews, this paper explores encounters and connections between South African Communists and the Czechs against the backdrop of the broader strategic concerns that shaped Soviet and Eastern European support for South African liberatory politics.

Keywords

South AfricaSouthern AfricadiasporadiplomacyapartheidmilitaryAfrican modernitiescivil wars
Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 61 , Issue 2 , July 2020 , pp. 219 - 239
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The authors presented an earlier draft of this paper at the Czech Association of Social Anthropology's Gellner Seminar, 14 May 2019.

References

1 For example, Coker, C., ‘Pact, pox or proxy: Eastern Europe's security relationships with Southern Africa’, Soviet Studies, 40 (1988), 573–84Google Scholar.

2 On the East German Stasi's role in building the Ethiopian Derg's intelligence services, see Wiebel, J. and Admasie, S., ‘Rethinking the Ethiopian Red Terror: approaches to political violence in revolutionary Ethiopia’, The Journal of African History, 60:3 (2019), 471–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Pinnock, D. (ed.), Ruth First (2nd edn, Pretoria, 2012), 9Google Scholar.

4 Interview with Rowley Arenstein by Iain Edwards, Durban, 1986.

5 Kathrada, A., No Bread for Mandela: Memoirs of Ahmed Kathrada (Lexington, KY, 2010), 90Google Scholar.

6 Storm, W. and Storm, B., We Meet the Czechoslovaks (Prague, 1948), 5Google Scholar.

7 Ibid. 8.

8 Clingman, S., Bram Fischer: Afrikaner Revolutionary (Cape Town, 1998), 205Google Scholar.

9 Joseph, P., Slumboy from the Golden City (London, 2018), 91–2Google Scholar.

10 Pike, H., A History of Communism in South Africa (Germiston, South Africa, 1988), 303Google Scholar.

11 McGee, H., Radical Antiapartheid Internationalism and Exile: The Life of Elizabeth Mafeking (Abingdon, UK, 2019), 43–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Forman, S. and Odendaal, A., A Trumpet from the Housetops: The Selected Writings of Lionel Forman (London, 1992), 167–9Google Scholar.

13 Forman, S., Lionel Forman: A Life Too Short (Alice, South Africa, 2008)Google Scholar.

14 Ibid. 199.

15 Forman and Odendaal, A Trumpet, 167–9.

16 Heimann, M., Czechoslovakia: The State that Failed (New Haven, 2011), 204Google Scholar.

17 Forman, Lionel Forman,199.

18 Storm and Storm, We Meet the Czechoslovaks, 39.

19 Forman, Lionel Forman, 187.

20 Ibid. 191.

21 Interview with Albie Sachs by Milan Oralek, 27 Sept. 2014

22 Forman and Odendaal, Trumpet, 15–6.

23 Ibid. 182.

24 Storm and Storm, We Meet the Czechoslovaks, 44.

25 Skilling, G. H., Czechoslovakia's Interrupted Revolution (Princeton, 1976), 23–5Google Scholar.

26 For the Czechoslovak Party's moral authority during the 1950s, see Spurný, M., Making the Most of Tomorrow (Prague, 2019), 76–84Google Scholar.

27 Kotane, M., ‘South Africa's way forward’, in Bunting, B. (ed.), South African Communists Speak: Documents from the History of the South African Communist Party (London, 1981 [1954]), 231–41Google Scholar.

28 Turok, B., Nothing but the Truth (Johannesburg, 2003), 59Google Scholar.

29 Historical Papers, William Cullen Library, University of the Witwatersrand (WHP) A1812, Eq. 10.5.5, ‘Treason Trial evidence’.

30 Opršal, Z., Harmacek, J., and Syrovátka, M., ‘The allocation of Czech foreign aid to sub-Saharan Africa’, International Journal of Economic Policy in Emerging Economies, 9:4 (2016), 325–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Schmidt, E., ‘Cold War in Guinea: the Rassemblement Démocratique Africain and the struggle over Communism, 1950–1958’, The Journal of African History, 48:1 (2007), 110–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Mandela, N., Long Walk to Freedom (Randburg, South Africa, 1995), 289Google Scholar. The Czech gesture was all the more generous, for the Czechs had been printing Guinean banknotes since Guinea's departure from the French CFA currency zone, probably producing a surplus for their own use. They certainly were in no need of extra supplies of syli, the Guinean currency.

33 Beck, C. T., ‘Czechoslovakia's penetration of Africa, 1955–1962’, World Politics, 15:3 (1963), 415–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Hilger, A., ‘Communism, decolonization and the Third World’, in Naimark, N., Pons, S., and Judge, S. Quinn (eds.), The Cambridge History of Communism, Volume II (Cambridge, 2017), 329–30Google Scholar.

35 Muehlenbeck, P., Czechoslovakia in Africa, 1945–1968 (Basingstoke, UK, 2016), 44CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36 Sieber, K. and Zídek, P., Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika v letech 1948–1989 (Prague, 2007), 99Google Scholar.

37 ‘Memorandum from the Czechoslovak Consul-General in Cape Town reporting on his meeting at the Department of External Affairs of the Union of South Africa, 22 July 1958’, in Archives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Twenty-Five Documents from the Czech Archives published on the 25th Anniversary of the Establishment of Diplomatic Relations between Czechoslovakia and the Republic of South Africa (Prague, 2016), 37Google Scholar.

38 ‘Internal Memorandum for the Czecholsovak Ministry of Foreign Affairs concerning the unrest in South Africa, 26 March 1960’, in Archives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Twenty-Five Documents, 47–9.

39 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 100.

40 Ibid.

41 Though Czechoslovak officials denied they ever sold military weapons to South Africa, an internal report admitted ‘certain goods arrive in RSA through re-export through Western companies’. See Czech National Archives (CNA) Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962– 66., sv. 25, aj. 27, b. 7.

42 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 101.

43 Muehlenbeck, Czechoslovakia in Africa, 46.

44 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 102.

45 Ibid. 103.

46 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962–66, sv. 25, aj. 27, b. 7.

47 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 105.

48 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962–66, sv. 51, aj. 53, b. k inf. 2.

49 ‘Memorandum from the Czechoslovak Embassy in London concerning the ANC's request for scholarships, 6 September 1962’, Archives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Twenty-Five Documents, 62.

50 Mufamadi, T., Raymond Mhlaba's Personal Memoirs: Reminiscing from Rwanda and Uganda (Pretoria, 2001), 118Google Scholar.

51 Ibid.

52 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 106.

53 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962–66, sv. 30, aj. 32, b. 12.

54 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962–66, sv. 28, aj. 29, b. 16.

55 Vinson, R. T. and Carton, B., ‘Albert Luthuli's private struggle: how an icon of peace came to accept sabotage in South Africa’, The Journal of African History, 59:1 (2018), 69–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

56 Dubow, S., ‘Were there political alternatives in the wake of the Sharpeville-Langa violence in South Africa, 1960?’, The Journal of African History, 56:1 (2015), 119–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1962–66, sv. 112, aj 115, b. k. inf. 3.

58 CNA Předsednictvo UV KSC 1962–66, sv. 28, aj. 29, b. 16.

59 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 107.

60 Ibid. 107–8.

61 As Ben Turok learned when he met Kotane in Dar es Salaam in 1965; see Turok, B., Nothing but the Truth (Johannesburg, 2003), 199Google Scholar.

62 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 108. Lockman did return to Tanzania but he would desert in 1968, travelling to Zambia and becoming a businessman. See Macmillan, H., The Lusaka Years: The ANC in Exile in Zambia (Johannesburg, 1978), 59Google Scholar.

63 Cajee, A., Fordsburg Fighter: The Journey of an MK Volunteer, (Paarl, South Africa, 2016), 80–1Google Scholar.

64 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 109.

65 Cajee, Fordsburg Fighter, 62–3.

66 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 109.

67 Muehlenbeck, Czechoslovakia in Africa, 175–6.

68 Zelani Mkhonzo was especially likely to encounter intrusive curiosity and more occasionally hostility from people who had never met a black person before. At around about this time, African students at the University of November 17 were often encountering more aggressive and violent expressions of local xenophobia.

69 Cajee, Fordsburg Fighter, 72.

70 Ibid. 73.

71 Ibid. 77.

72 Macmillan, H., Chris Hani (Auckland Park, South Africa, 2014), 28Google Scholar.

73 Cajee, Fordsburg Fighter, 70.

74 African Communist, 35:4 (1968), 94–7.

75 Mngqikana, S., ‘I remember Chief’, in Jordan, P. (ed.), Oliver Tambo Remembered (Johannesburg, 2007), 139Google Scholar.

76 African Communist, 35:4 (1968), 12.

77 South African Communist Party, ‘The road to South African freedom: the programme of the South African Communist Party’, in Bunting, B. (ed.), South African Communists Speak: Documents from the History of the South African Communist Party (London, 1981), 316Google Scholar.

78 Weider, A., Ruth First and Joe Slovo in the War against Apartheid (New York, 2013), 172–3Google Scholar.

79 Interview with Albie Sachs by Milan Oralek, 27 Sept. 2014.

80 Kasrils, R., Armed and Dangerous: From Undercover Struggle to Freedom (Johannesburg, 1998), 134Google Scholar.

81 WHP Michael Harmel Papers A3300, interview with Helen Lewis by Taffy Adler, 4 Oct. 1975.

82 Y. Dadoo, ‘Tribute to Michael Harmel: oration at funeral in Prague, June 24, 1974’, (https://www.sahistory.org.za/archive/tribute-michael-harmel-oration-funeral-prague-june-24-1974), 2012.

83 CNA Předsednictvo UV KSC 1962–66, sv. 111, aj. 0229, b. 208, Záznem o rozhovoru s členem ÚV Jihoafricke Komunistické Strany s. Michaelem Harmel, 12 July 1963.

84 WHP A3300 B2, Michael Harmel Papers, letters to Barbara Harmel, 28 Feb. and 24 Apr. 1974.

85 Lerumo, A., ‘Socialism: the live reality’, African Communist, 59:3 (1974), 89Google Scholar.

86 Interviews with Essop Pahad by Padraig O'Malley, 3 Sept. 1991, and Milan Oralek, 15 Jan. 2015.

87 Interview with Essop and Meg Pahad by Tom Lodge, 23 Sept. 2018.

88 Mtshali worked at the WFTU headquarters in the mid-1970s. Here he was probably referring to the reconstruction of regime-supportive trade unions after the forced dissolution in 1975 of the Confederation of Ethiopian Labour Unions (CELA) by the Derg. CELA had existed since 1962. See Wiebel and Admasie, ‘Rethinking the Ethiopian Red Terror’, 464–6.

89 Interview with Lyndal Shope by Milan Oralek, 29 Jan. 2015.

90 World Federation of Trade Unions, South African Workers and the WFTU: Shoulder to Shoulder (Athens, 2012), 90, 97Google Scholar.

91 Interview with Gertrude Shope by Milan Oralek, 29 Jan. 2015.

92 Devinatz, V., ‘A Cold War thaw in the international working-class movement?: the WFTU and the ICFTU, 1967–1977’, Science and Society, 77:3 (2013), 362CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

93 Waterman, P., ‘Hopeful traveller: the itinerary of an internationalist’, History Workshop, 35 (1993), 180–1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

94 Grest, A., ‘The free officers and the comrades: the Sudanese Communist Party and Nimeiri face to face, 1969–1971’, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 2 (1989), 404Google Scholar.

95 Ruth First was especially knowledgeable about the Sudanese Communist Party; she met several of its key personalities while researching her Power in Africa (Harmondsworth, South Africa, 1970), 272–7.

96 CNA Předsednictvo UV KSC, 1976–81, sv. 77, aj 81, b. 27.

97 The Czechs maintained an extensive network of Státní Bezpečnost personnel across Africa and recruited ‘contacts’ within certain liberation movements, see N. Telepneva, ‘Codename SEKRETÁŘ: Amilcar Cabral, Czechoslovakia and the role of human intelligence during the Cold War’, International Historical Review, (2019), https://doi.org/10/1080/07075332.2019.1678508.

98 Interview with Essop and Meg Pahad by Tom Lodge, 22 Sept. 2019,

99 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ 1976–81, sv. 77, aj. 81, b.27.

100 Sieber and Zídek, Ĉeskoslovensko a subsaharská Afrika, 110–1.

101 Mildernerová, K., ‘“I feel like two in one”: complex belongings among Namibian Czechs’, Modern Africa: Politics, History and Society, 6:2 (2018), 66Google Scholar.

102 Maloka, E., The South African Communist Party: Exile and After Apartheid (Auckland Park, South Africa, 2014), 84Google Scholar.

103 Radvani, J., Psychological Operations and Political Warfare in Long Term Strategic Planning (New York, 1990), 43–5Google Scholar.

104 CNA Předsednictvo ÚV KSČ, sv. 17, aj. 16, b 16.