Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T08:18:13.159Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

BEING KIKUYU IN MERU: CHALLENGING THE TRIBAL GEOGRAPHY OF COLONIAL KENYA*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 April 2012

TIMOTHY PARSONS
TIMOTHY PARSONS*
Affiliation:
Washington University
*
Author's email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Faced with a confusing range of fluid ethnicities when they conquered Kenya, colonial officials sought to shift conquered populations into manageable administrative units. In linking physical space to ethnic identity, the Kenyan reserve system assumed that each of these ‘tribes’ had a specific homeland. Yet the reserves in the central Kenyan highlands soon became overcrowded and socially restive because they could not accommodate population growth and private claims to land for commercial agriculture. Although colonial officials proclaimed themselves the guardians of backward tribal peoples, they tried to address this problem by creating mechanisms whereby surplus populations would be ‘adopted’ into tribes living in less crowded reserves. This article provides new insights into the nature of identity in colonial Kenya by telling the stories of two types of Kikuyu migrants who settled in the Meru Reserve. The first much larger group did so legally by agreeing to become Meru. The second openly challenged the colonial state and their Meru hosts by defiantly proclaiming themselves to be Kikuyu. These diverse ways of being Kikuyu in the Meru Reserve fit neither strict primordial nor constructivist conceptions of African identity formation. The peoples of colonial Kenya had options in deciding how to identify themselves and could assume different political and social roles by invoking one or more of them at a time and in specific circumstances.

Keywords

Kenyacolonial administrationethnicity
Type
Politics of Ethnic Identity Formation
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 53 , Issue 1 , March 2012 , pp. 65 - 86
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to Richard Waller and the members of the International and Area Studies Migration and Identity Worskhop at Washington University for their comments on this article.

References

1 Kenya National Archives (KNA) Nairobi, PC CP 9/21/1/53a, Kiambu local native council (LNC) minutes, Nov. 1947.

2 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/58, District Commissioner (DC) Meru to Provincial Commissioner (PC) Central Province (CP), 29 Dec. 1947; KNA OPE 1/354/87/1, DC Meru to PC CP, 22 Apr. 1948. I am grateful to Patrick Thimangu for the translations and suggested etymology of the Meru terms.

3 Lambert, H. E., Kikuyu Social and Political Institutions (London, 1965), 1–2Google Scholar.

4 Iliffe, J., A Modern History of Tanganyika (New York, 1979), 324CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Southall, A. W., ‘The illusion of tribe’, Journal of Asian and African Studies, 5:1–2 (1970), 28CrossRefGoogle Scholar; L. Vail, ‘Introduction: ethnicity in Southern African history’, in L. Vail (ed.), The Creation of Tribalism in Southern Africa (London, 1989), 11.

6 J. Lonsdale, ‘Writing competitive patriotism in Eastern Africa’, in D. Peterson and G. Macola (eds.), Recasting the Past: History Writing and Political Work in Modern Africa (Athens, OH, 2009), 260.

7 Willis, J., Mombasa, the Swahili, and the Making of the Mijikenda (Oxord, 1993)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lynch, G., I Say to You: Ethnic Politics and the Kalenjin in Kenya (Chicago, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Spear, T., ‘Neo-traditionalism and the limits of invention in British colonial Africa’, Journal of African History, 44:1 (2003), 18CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 J. Lonsdale, ‘Moral and political argument in Kenya’, in B. Berman, D. Eyoh, and W. Kymlicka (eds.), Ethnicity & Democracy in Africa (Oxford, 2004), 78.

10 Anthias, F., ‘Where do I belong?: narrating collective identity and translocational positionality’, Ethnicities, 2:4 (2002), 494–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Lugard, F., The Dual Mandate in British Tropical Africa (5th edn. London, 1965), 618–19Google Scholar.

12 Hailey, W. M., Native Administration in the British African Territories, Part I (London, 1950), 117, 120Google Scholar; Lambert, Kikuyu Social and Political Institutions, 1–2.

13 Bernard, F. E., East of Mount Kenya: Meru Agriculture in Transition (Munich, 1972), 48Google Scholar.

14 Lambert, H. E., ‘The systems of land tenure in the Kikuyu land unit: part I, history of the occupation of the land’, Communications from the School of African Studies (Cape Town, 1949)Google Scholar, reprinted 1959, front matter.

15 T. Spear, ‘Introduction’, in T. Spear and R. Walker (eds.), Being Maasai (London, 1993), 1–2.

16 Fadiman, J., When We Began, There Were Witchmen: An Oral History from Mount Kenya (Berkeley, CA, 1993), 5, 63–4Google Scholar, 91–2.

17 Lambert, H. E., ‘The use of indigenous authorities in tribal administration: studies of the Meru in Kenya colony’, Communications from the School of African Studies, new series no. 16 (April 1947), 45Google Scholar.

18 Peterson, D., Creative Writing: Translation, Bookkeeping, and the Work of Imagination in Colonial Kenya (Portsmouth NH, 2004), 10–13Google Scholar; Muriuki, G., A History of the Kikuyu, 1500–1900 (Nairobi, 1974), 29Google Scholar; Fadiman, When We Began, 5.

19 Orde-Browne, G. St. J., The Vanishing Tribes of Kenya, A Description of the Manners & Customs of the Primitive & Interesting Tribes Dwelling on the Vast Southern Slopes of Mount Kenya, & their Fast Disappearing Native Methods of Life (Westport, 1925), 5Google Scholar.

20 Hailey, Native Administration, 124.

21 Colony and Protectorate of Kenya, The Kikuyu Lands (Nairobi, 1941), 67Google Scholar; Maini, K., Land Law in East Africa (Nairobi, 1967), 10–11Google Scholar.

22 Berman, B., Control and Crisis in Colonial Kenya: The Dialectic of Domination (Nairobi, 1990), 134Google Scholar; S. S. S. Kenyanchui, ‘European Settler Agriculture’, in W. R. Ochieng' and R. M. Maxon (eds.), An Economic History of Kenya (Nairobi, 1992), 111–13.

23 The National Archives of Great Britain, London (TNA) CO 533/395/2/25a/23, Hilton Young, Chair Commission on Closer Union, to Colonial Secretary, 15 June 1928; Hailey, W. M., An African Survey: A Study of Problems Arising in Africa South of the Sahara (London, 1938), 749Google Scholar.

24 Hailey, An African Survey, 748; Great Britain, Kenya Land Commission, Report of the Kenya Land Commission (London, 1934), 26Google Scholar.

25 Maher, C., Soil Erosion and Land Utilization in the Embu Reserve, I (Nairobi, 1938), 18Google Scholar.

26 Kitching, G. N., Class and Economic Change in Kenya: The Making of an African Petite Bourgeoisie (New Haven, CT, 1980), 31–2Google Scholar, 36; Kershaw, G. C., Mau Mau from Below (Oxford, 1997), 148–9Google Scholar; Robertson, C. C., Trouble Showed the Way: Women, Men, and Trade in the Nairobi Area, 1890–1990 (Bloomington, IN, 2007), 78–9Google Scholar.

27 TNA CO 1018/28, Kenya Colony and Protectorate, The Problem of the Squatter, 19 Mar. 1946.

28 Kenya Land Commission, Report of the Kenya Land Commission, 104; Hailey, Native Administration, 187–9; Lambert, ‘Systems of Land Tenure’, 1; Colony and Protectorate of Kenya, Native Lands Trust Ordinance (Chapter 100) (Nairobi: Government Printer, 1949)Google Scholar.

29 KNA DC MRU 4/5; H. E. Lambert, ‘Disintegration and reintegration in the Meru tribe’, unpublished manuscript, 9 Jan. 1940, 2–5, 11–15.

30 Kenya Land Commission, Report, 374; Britain, Great, Kenya Land Commission Report: Summary of Conclusions Reached by His Majesty's Government (London, 1934), 3–4Google Scholar.

31 Maher, C., Soil Erosion II, 47Google Scholar.

32 KNA OPE 1/470/7, Chief Native Commissioner (CNC) to Chief Secretary, 29 Apr. 1941; Colony and Protectorate of Kenya, Kikuyu Lands, 61.

33 Quoted in R. M. Breen, ‘The politics of land: the Kenya Land Commission (1932–33) and its effects on land policy in Kenya’ (unpublished PhD thesis, Michigan State University, 1976), 178; Maher, Soil Erosion, I, 137–8.

34 KNA DC NGONG 1/1/22, Officer-in-Charge Masai EPD to PC Central Province, 29 Oct. 1936; KNA DC NGONG 1/1/22, Memorandum by DC Kiambu, Landless Kikuyu, Oct. 1936; TNA CO 1018/27/1, Report by E. A. Sweatman, 3 Nov. 1947; For the authoritative account of Kikuyu ‘interpenetration’ in the Maasai reserve, see R. Waller, ‘Acceptees and aliens: Kikuyu settlement in Maasailand’, in Being Maasai.

35 KNA OPE 1/460/1, Native Intelligence Safari Report, Sept. 1940; KNA OPE 1/460/2, PC Nyanza Province to Chief Secretary, 18 Oct. 1940; Rhodes House, Bodleian Library Oxford (RH) MS Africa. s. 6630, Embu Handing Over Report, by I. R. Gillespie, 1939.

36 Kenya Land Commission, Evidence and Memoranda, Volume I (London, 1934), 256–7Google Scholar.

37 Fadiman, When We Began, 186, 231–5, 284; Lambert, ‘Systems of land tenure’, 71; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/35, Memorandum of Baraza at Chuka, 27 June 1939.

38 Maher, C., Preliminary Notes on Land Utilisation and Soil Erosion in the Meru Reserve (Nairobi, 1938), 13Google Scholar, 15; B. M. K. Mbae, ‘The history of the coffee industry in Meru, 1934–1973’ (University of Nairobi History Department Student Research Seminar Paper, 5 Sept. 1973), 6–7; Bernard, East of Mount Kenya, 91.

39 Maher, Soil Erosion, I, 27.

40 Fadiman, When We Began, 343–5; Lambert, ‘Systems of land tenure’, 23.

41 Maher, Preliminary Notes, 69–73.

42 Maher, Soil Erosion, I, 139–40, 141, 156.

43 Maher, Soil Erosion, II, 48.

44 Maher, Soil Erosion, I, 137–8.

45 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/63, DC Kiambu to Shamsud-Deen, Member of Legislative Council (MLC), 2 Dec. 1939.

46 KNA OPE 1/354/124/1, Order Under Section 12 (1) of the Native Authority Ordinance, 1937.

47 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/7, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 17 Sept. 1938.

48 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/22a, Report by DC Meru, 25 Apr. 1939.

49 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/35, Memorandum of Baraza at Chuka, 27 June 1939; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/67, Legasi son of Mukua Kagembe, 29 Dec. 1939.

50 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/48a, Shamsud Deen, MLC to CNC, 18 Sept. 1939; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/59, Hezekiah Mundia to PC Central Province, 14 Nov. 1939; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/91, Harry Thuku to DC Meru, 13 Apr. 1940; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15, Unasked Legislative Council Question No. 17, June 1940.

51 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/22a, Report by DC Meru, 25 Apr. 1939; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/48, PC Central Province to Chief Secretary, 22 Sept. 1939; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/70, DC Meru to DC Kiambu, 18 Jan. 1940; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/78, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 21 Feb. 1940; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/84, PC Central Province to Chief Secretary, 9 March 1940; KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/92, DC Meru to Harry Thuku, 6 May 1940.

52 Fadiman, When We Began, 343–5; Lambert, ‘Systems of land tenure’, 71. Lambert also used the reconfigured Njuri Ncheke to discipline disruptive ‘women's cults’, see Thomas, L., Politics of the Womb: Women, Reproduction, and the State in Kenya (Berkeley, 2003), 43–4Google Scholar.

53 TNA CO 533/516, 38005, B Kimengi wa Muchema and Marius Karat to Colonial Secretary, 27 Mar. 1940.

54 KNA OPE 1/470/10, Governor Sir Henry Moore to CNC, 17 Sept. 1941; KNA OPE 1/354/23, Officer-in-Charge Masai EPD to Chief Secretary, 22 Aug. 1945.

55 KNA DC MRU 2/4/15/85, DC Embu to PC Central Province, 11 Mar. 1940.

56 KNA MAA/2/5/64/6, EA Military Records to Officer Commanding 1st Group EAMLS, 22 Oct. 1940.

57 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/2, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 2 Mar. 1944.

58 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/2a, Macharia wa Maina & Gachengiri wa Matu to PC Central Province, 22 Feb. 1944; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/2, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 2 Mar. 1944.

59 KNA VQ 1/24/28a, Chief Secretary Tanganyika to Chief Secretary Kenya, 14 Sept. 1940; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/12a, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 21 Nov. 1945.

60 Hailey, Native Administration, 200; Peterson, Creative Writing, 166.

61 KNA OPE 1/354/32, Memorandum by H. E. Lambert on Draft Rules Under the Native Lands Trust Ordinance, 10 Jan. 1946; KNA OPE 1/354/47, Secretariat Circular, Interpenetration and Infiltration in Native Land Units, 3 May 1946.

62 KNA OPE 1/354/56, Officer-in-Charge Masai EPD to Chief Secretary, 13 Oct. 1946; KNA OPE 1/354/71, Secretariat Circular, Statement of Government Interim Policy with Regard to Interpenetration and Infiltration in Native Land Units, 13 Aug. 1947; KNA OPE 1/354/107, Secretariat Circular, Interpenetration and Infiltration on Native Land Units, 8 July 1948.

63 See Parsons, T., ‘Local responses to the ethnic geography of colonialism in the Gusii highlands of British-ruled Kenya’, Ethnohistory, 58:3 (2011) 491–523CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/48, DC Embu to PC Central Province, 25 Aug. 1947; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/56, DC Embu to PC Central Province, 5 Dec. 1947; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/68, DC Embu to PC Central Province, 1 Apr. 1948.

65 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/50a , E. W. Mathu to CNC, 29 Sept. 1947.

66 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/36, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 16 May 1947; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/34; PC Central Province to DC Meru, 5 June 1947.

67 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/58, Kiambu LNC Minutes, Nov. 1947; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/53a, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 29 Dec. 1947.

68 KNA OPE 1/354/87/1, DC Meru to PC Central Province, 22 Apr. 1948; KNA PC CP 9/21/1/92g, Testimony vs. Stephen Karariga, 1 Sept. 1948.

69 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/198, DC Kiambu to PC Central Province, 28 Oct. 1949; Kenya Colony and Protectorate, Legislative Council Debates Official Report, vol. 35, 4th session, 2 Nov. 1949–27 Jan. 1950 (Nairobi, 1950)Google Scholar.

70 KNA PC CP 9/21/1/297, DC Embu to PC Central Province, 26 Jan. 1953; KNA DP 1/111/143, DC South Nyanza to DC Kiambu, 30 Mar. 1954.

71 Bernard, East of Mount Kenya, 101; Kershaw, Mau Mau from Below, 325; Anderson, D., Histories of the Hanged: The Dirty War in Kenya and the End of Empire (New York, 2005), 5Google Scholar, 315.

72 Northwestern University Library, Solomon Mwirichia, ‘Mau Mau in Meru’, unpublished manuscript, c. 1971; Interview with Kiraithe Nyaga, Nairobi, Jul. 1998.

73 KNA OPE 1/408/1/1, A. C. Small, Nairobi Extra-Provincial District 1956 Handing Over Report.

74 Kenya Colony and Protectorate, Legislative Council Debates Official Report, vol. 76, part 1, 2nd session, 15 Apr. – 4 June 1958, ‘The Native Lands Trust (Amendment) Bill’ (Nairobi, 1958); Branch, D., Defeating Mau Mau, Creating Kenya: Counterinsurgency, Civil War, and Decolonization (Cambridge, 2009), 102–3Google Scholar.

75 Thomas, Politics of the Womb, 84–5.

76 Colony and Protectorate of Kenya, A Plan to Intensify the Development of Agriculture in Kenya (Nairobi, 1955)Google Scholar.

77 Fadiman, When We Began, 336–9.

78 Anthias, ‘Where Do I Belong?’, 494.