Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T00:52:52.393Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

African and European Cocoa Producers on Fernando Póo, 1880s to 1910s

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

W. G. Clarence-Smith
W. G. Clarence-Smith
Affiliation:
School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The decline of the Creole or Fernandino planters of Fernando Póo came later and was less severe than has sometimes been said, while the indigenous Bubi inhabitants played a far greater role in the development of the cocoa economy than has usually been acknowledged. Social discrimination against Creoles and Bubi was of little significance. The re-direction of Fernandian exports to Spain from the 1890s had no negative effect on African producers, and Creoles and Spaniards united to fight tariff policies detrimental to their interests. Bubi suffered severely from land alienation, but they kept sufficient land to be able to participate fully in the cocoa boom. Creoles lost land through debt, but so did Spaniards. The beneficiaries of land transfers were black as well as white, and a map from around 1913 shows a roughly even mix of Spanish and Creole landowners. Black and white planters were united in every aspect of labour which involved relations with the authorities. Attempts to force poor Bubi into plantation labour collapsed quickly, and wealthy Bubi cultivators had little difficulty in finding labour to employ. Access to credit was equal for all landowners, and the evidence for Africans being more spendthift than Europeans is of dubious validity. The thesis of African decline becomes more plausible from the mid-1920s, due to Spanish immigration, the formation of joint-stock companies, and accentuated social discrimination, but the extent of that decline remains to be determined. The roughly tripartite equilibrium between Bubi, Creole and European cocoa producers in the early 1910s contrasts with descriptions of other cocoa-growing areas in western Africa, suggesting the need for a re-examination of the evidence for the Creole role in cocoa cultivation and for Creole economic decline from the 1890s in West Africa.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 35 , Issue 2 , July 1994 , pp. 179 - 199
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Sundiata, I. K., ‘The Fernandinos: labour and community in Santa Isabel de Fernando Póo, 1827–1931’ (Ph.D. thesis, Northwestern University, 1972)Google Scholar; ‘Prelude to scandal: Liberia and Fernando Po, 1880–1930’, J. Afr. Hist., xv (1974), 97–112Google Scholar; ‘Creolization on Fernando Po: the nature of society’, in Kilson, M. L. and Rotberg, R. I. (eds.), The African Diaspora: Interpretive Essays (Cambridge, Mass., 1976), 391–413CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Equatorial Guinea: Colonialism, State Terror, and the Search for Stability (Boulder, CO, 1990).Google Scholar

2 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 355.Google Scholar

3 Gil-Delgado, C. Crespo (de Castillo-Fiel, Conde), Notas para un estudio anlropológico y etnológico del Bubi de Fernando Póo (Madrid, 1949), 189.Google Scholar

4 de Teran, M., Sintesis geográfica de Fernando Póo (Madrid, 1962).Google Scholar

5 Casas, G. Sanz, ‘Politica colonial y organización del trabajo en la isla de Fernando Póo, 1880–1930’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Barcelona, 1983)Google Scholar; Rodríguez, T. Pereira, ‘El colonialismo español en el Golfo de Guinea: aspectos socio-económicos, 1900–1930’ (Trabajo de Investigación, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia, Madrid, 1989)Google Scholar; Rodríguez, T. Pereira, ‘Aspectos maritimo-comerciales del colonialismo español en el Golfo de Guinea, 1900–1930’, in Lezcano, V. Morales (ed.), Segunda Aula Canarias y el Noroeste de Africa (1986) (Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, 1988)Google Scholar; Bidyogo, D. Ndongo, Historia y tragedia de Guinea Ecuatorial (Madrid, 1977)Google Scholar; Liniger-Goumaz, M., La Guinél'e Equatoriale, an pays méconnu (Paris, 1979)Google Scholar; Liniger-Goumaz, M., Small is Not Always Beautiful: The Story of Equatorial Guinea (London, 1988).Google Scholar

6 Lynn, M., ‘Commerce, Christianity and the origins of the “Creoles” of Fernando Poo’, J. Afr. Hist., xxv (1984), 257–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 1/4, T. Holt to J. Holt, 20 Aug. and 6 Nov. 1874.

8 Sundiata, , Equatorial Guinea, 24Google Scholar; Teran, , Sintesis, 84.Google Scholar

9 Baumann, O., Eine afrikanische Tropen-Insel: Fernando Póo und die Bube [sic] (Vienna and Olmütz, 1888), 134, 136.Google Scholar

10 UA, United Africa Company Papers, Safe 1, Top shelf right, Box File A, Chairman's speech to the African Association, 28 Feb. 1895.

11 de los Monteros, A. Ramos Espinosa, España en Africa (Madrid, 1903), 67.Google Scholar

12 Great Britain, Foreign Office, Historical Section, Spanish Guinea (London, 1919), 55.Google Scholar

13 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 92.Google Scholar

14 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 231–2Google Scholar; ‘Prelude’, 97.

15 Fernández, , Misiones, 484–6, 494–6, 544, 549–51, 582, 717.Google Scholar

16 SOAS, MMSA, 1154, mf 199, Banham, ‘Re Mr Bell's document’, c. 1903.Google Scholar

17 Espinosa, Ramos, España, 47Google Scholar, citing López Vilchez, c. 1900.

18 Piera, P. Ferrer, Fernando Póo y sus dependencias (descriptión, producciones y estado sanitario) (Barcelona, 1900), 115.Google Scholar

19 AGA, C-148, E-6, GG to Min., 30 Oct. 1906.

20 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Laka letter, 12 May 1909.

21 Fernández, , Misiones, 527.Google Scholar

22 AGA, C-148, E-6, GG to Min., 28 Nov. 1910.

23 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 21 Dec. 1910.

24 Tessmann, G., Die Bubi auf Fernando Poo; völkerkundliche Einzelbeschreibung eines westafrikanisches Negerstammes (Darmstadt, 1923), 216.Google Scholar

25 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politics colonial’, 108.Google Scholar

26 AGA, C-144, E-11, Astrell, J. Coll y, ‘Fernando Póo’, 1905.Google Scholar

27 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 324.Google Scholar

28 Serralta, M. Lozano, La nacionalidad en los territorios dependientes (Madrid, 1955), 67–8.Google Scholar

29 Baumann, , Eine afrikanische Tropen-lnsel, 132–9.Google Scholar

30 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 216Google Scholar, discussing the case of William Barleycorn.

31 Fernández, , Misiones, 728ff.Google Scholar

32 Rodríguez, Pereira, ‘Aspectos’, 248–9.Google Scholar

33 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 21 Sept. 1906.

34 Fernández, , Misiones, 675ffGoogle Scholar

35 Sundiata, ‘The Fernandinos’, chs. 6 and 9.

36 Serralta, Lozano, La nacionalidad, 68.Google Scholar

37 Rodríguez, Pereira, ‘El colonialismo’, 65.Google Scholar

38 AGA, C-144, E-II, J. Dougan to Min., 29 Apr. 1906.

39 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 341.Google Scholar

40 Magdalena, D. Saavedra y, España en el Africa Occidental: Río de Oro y Guinea (Madrid, 1910), 111–14.Google Scholar

41 .Carbonel, J. Bravo, Fernando Póo y el Muni; sus misterios y riquezas; su colonización (Madrid, 1971), 44–7.Google Scholar

42 Serralta, Lozano, La nacionalidad, 68Google Scholar; Liniger-Goumaz, , La Guinée, 395, 404Google Scholar

43 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 318–19, 351.Google Scholar

44 AHU, P-507, Governor to Overseas Minister, 30 Apr. 1874.

45 Clarence-Smith, W. G., ‘The Portuguese and Spanish roles in the scramble for Africa’, in Förster, S. et al. , (eds.), Bismarck, Europe and Africa: the Berlin West African Conference and the Onset of Partition (Oxford, 1988), 215–27.Google Scholar

46 Hahs, B. G., ‘Spain and the scramble for Africa: the “ Africanists” and the Gulf of Guinea’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of New Mexico, 1980), 278.Google Scholar

47 AGA, C-144, E-11, ‘Apuntes’, 20 Jun. 1903.

48 AGA, C-682, E-6,? to Min., 26 Apr. 1902.

49 Labra, R. M. de [y Cadrana], Nuestras colonias de Africa (Madrid, 1898), 17.Google Scholar

50 SOAS, MMSA, 1153, mf 182, W. Barleycorn to Mr Smith, 18 Apr. 1896; SOAS, MMSA, 1156, mf 238, Minutes of the Council of Missionaries, San Carlos, 12 Feb. 1900.

51 SOAS, MMSA, 1156, mf 238, T. C. Showell to Mr Burnett, 27 Feb. 1900.

52 SOAS, MMSA, 1156, mf 238, Council of Missionaries, San Carlos, 12 Feb. 1900.

53 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 21 Feb. 1910.

54 AGA, C-104, E-3 ‘Exportación de cacao, 1904–1914’.

55 SOAS, MMSA, 1153, mf 185, W. Barleycorn to Mr Guttery, 18 Dec. 1912; UBL, Cadbury Papers, 304, ‘Highest cocoa prices paid by Cadbury, 1880–1911 ’.

56 Escarra, E., Le développetnent industriel de la Catalogne (Paris, 1908), 197.Google Scholar

57 Great Britain, Spanish Guinea, 40.Google Scholar

58 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, H. M. Cook to General Missionary Committee, June 1915.

59 AGA, C-104, E-3, ‘Exportacion de cacao, 1904–14’.

60 AGA, C-104, E-3 ‘Exportación de cacao, 1904–14’

61 Vivar, L. Ramos-lzquierdo y, Descriptión geográfica, gobierno, administratión y colonizatión de las colónias españolas del Golfo de Guinea (Madrid, 1912), 205.Google Scholar

62 SOAS, MMSA, 11577, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

63 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Laka letter, 6 Oct. 1908.

64 Carbonel, Bravo, Fernando Póo, 57–8, 123.Google Scholar

65 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 9 Apr. 1907.

66 Der Gordian, 1 03 1899, 1, 622.Google Scholar

67 Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 47, 178–9.Google Scholar

68 SOAS, MMSA, 1154, mf 199, Bell, J. ‘Fernando Po Missions’, c. 1903.Google Scholar

69 AG, A, C-152, E-i, ‘Bases para la reorganización del registro de la propiedad’, 12 July 1926.

70 SOAS, MMSA, 1155, mf 228, Mrs Showers to Rev. Guttery, 6 May 1910.

71 Fernández, , Misiones, 674.Google Scholar The date to which this document refers is uncertain.

72 Baumann, , Eine afrikanische Tropen-Insel, 80, 84, 88, 134Google Scholar; Piera, Ferrer, Fernando Póo, 185.Google Scholar

73 John Clarke's map is reproduced in Molino, A. Martin del, Los Bubis, ritos y creencias (Madrid and Malabo, 1989), 11.Google Scholar

74 AGA, C-152, E-I, ‘Bases para la reorganización del registro de la propiedad’, 12 July 1926.

75 Coll, A., Segunda memoria de las misiones de Fernando Póo y sus dependencias (Madrid, 1899), 13Google Scholar; Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 235.Google Scholar

76 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 105, 115, 228.Google Scholar

77 AGA, C-974, E-25, Navarra, L., ‘Consideraciones’, 1 01 1888.Google Scholar

78 Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 47, 50, 178, 228.Google Scholar

79 AGA, C-2, E-5, GG to Min, 13 Oct. 1911.

80 AGA, C-2, E-5, ‘Bando sobre el trabajo de los Bubis’, 26 July 1912.

81 RH, Mss. Afr. s 1525, 13/7, Holt to Huelín, 13 Feb. 1913.

82 Fernandez, , Misiones, 484–5, 526, 582.Google Scholar

83 AGA, C-148, E-6, GG to Min., 15 and 30 Oct. 1910.

84 ACG, ‘Relación de los terrenos concedidos’, 1909–16.Google Scholar

85 AGA, C-152, E-I, ‘Bases para la reorganizacion del registro de la propiedad’, 12 July 1926.

86 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

87 Fernandez; Misiones, 528.

88 Lynn, , ‘Commerce’, 264.Google Scholar

89 AGA, C-152, E-I, ‘Bases para la reorganización del registro de la propiedad’, 12 July 1926.

90 AGA, C-152, E-7, ‘Relación de los Sres. Propietarios en esta Ysla que efectuaron el pago de la contribucion territorial?’, 1891–2.

91 ACG, ‘Relación de los terrenos concedidos’, 1909–16.Google Scholar

92 AGA, C-794, E-25, Navarra, L., ‘Consideraciones’, 1 01 1888.Google Scholar

93 AGA, C-152, E-7, ‘Notarremitida aS. M. elRey’, 1911; AGA, C-152, E-1, ‘Bases para la reorganizatión del registro de la propiedad’, 12 July 1926.

94 Gaceta de Madrid, 17 09 1891, 915–16.Google Scholar

95 Ramos-Izquierdo, , Descriptión, 210–12.Google Scholar

96 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 294Google Scholar, citing 1913 a British Foreign Office document.

97 von Puttkamer, J., Gouverneursjahre in Kamerun (Berlin, 1912), 249.Google Scholar

98 AGA, C-152, E-7, ‘Relatión de los Sres. Propietarios en esta Ysla que efectuaron el pago de la contribution territorial’, 1891–2.

99 Navarro, F. Quintana, Barcos, negocios y burgueses en el Puerto de la Luz, 1883–1913 (Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, 1985), 112 and n. 94Google Scholar; AGA, C-144, E-1 1, J. Coll y Astrell article, 1905.

100 AGA, C-144, E-II, J. Coll y Astrell, ‘Fernando Poo’, 1905.

101 Piera, Ferre, Fernando Póo, 196.Google Scholar

102 Clarence-Smith, W. G., ‘Plantation versus smallholder production of cocoa: the legacy of the German period in Cameroun‘, in Geschiere, P. and Konings, P. (eds.), Itinéraires d'accumulation au Cameroun (Paris, 1993), 187–216.Google Scholar

103 Sundiata, , Equatorial Guinea, 36.Google Scholar

104 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 255.Google Scholar

105 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 1 Mar. 1909 and 21 Jan. 1910.

106 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 7 Oct. 1910.

107 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 250Google Scholar, and ‘Prelude’, 100–1.

108 Fernández, , Misiones, 739–40.Google Scholar

109 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 296–7.Google Scholar

110 AGA, C-660, E-10, F. Romera and J. Coll y Astrell to Min., 7 Nov. 1903.

111 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 108–10.Google Scholar

112 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 24 Dec. 1905.

113 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 11 Sept. 1910, and 7 Oct. 1910.

114 Ramos-Izquierdo, , Description, 205.Google Scholar

115 Piera, Ferrer, Fernando Póo, 52.Google Scholar

116 AGA, C-144, E-11, Astrell, J. Coll y, ‘Fernando Poo’, 1905.Google Scholar

117 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, J. Cottrell to J. Holt, 31 Oct. 1906.

118 Duke, Adolf Friedrich of Meckleburg, From the Congo to the Niger and the Nile (London, 1913), vol. 2Google Scholar, chapter by J. Mildbraed, 251.

119 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

120 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 344–7Google Scholar; Liniger-Goumaz, , La Guinée, 266–8Google Scholar; Pelissier, R., ‘Fernando Poo un archipel hispano-guinéen’, Revue Française d'Etudes Politiques Africaines, xxxiii (1968), 95–6.Google Scholar

121 AGA, C-152, E-7, ‘Relación de los Sres. Propietarios en esta Ysla que efectuaron el pago de la contribución territorial’, 1891–18792

122 Moreno, A. Moreno, Reseña histórica de la presentia de España en el golfo de guinea (Madrid, 1952), 85, n. 118.Google Scholar

123 ACG, ‘Relación de los terrenos concedidos’, 1909–16.Google Scholar

124 Enciclopedia Universal Ilustrada Europeo-Americana 23, 835. The volume was published at some time in the 1920s, but the railway on the map serves to date it.

125 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 45–70, 238.Google Scholar

126 Holsoe, S., ‘Slavery and economic change among the Vai’, in Miers, S. and Kopytoff, I. (eds.), Slavery in Africa: Historical and Anthropological Perspectives (Madison, 1977), 297–8Google Scholar; Phillips, A., The Enigma of Colonialism: British Policy in West Africa (London, 1989), 34–6.Google Scholar

127 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 53–4.Google Scholar

128 AGA, C-675, E-23, Delegado de Gobernación to Min., 11 May 1879.

129 AHSTP, i-a-A, Cx-430, P-2, A. Barrera, 16 Nov. 1910, and other documents.

130 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

131 ACG, ‘Relacion de los terrenos concedidos’, 1909–16Google Scholar

132 SOAS, MMSA, 1155, mf 225, F. Pickering and W. Barleycorn to General Missionary Committee, 11 July 1892; LCL, 380 HOL-I, 1/8, R. Holt to J. Holt, 15 Dec. 1899.

133 AGA, C-219, E-2, GG to Min., 15 June 1900.

134 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 245, n. 3.Google Scholar

135 AGA, C-148, E-7, GG to Min., 31 July 1913, and 31 Aug. 1913.

136 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 239.Google Scholar

137 AGA, C-148, E-7, ‘Convenio’, 24 Aug. 1905.

138 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonia’, 224.Google Scholar

139 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 25 Sept. 1906.

140 AGA, C-148, E-7, GG to Min., 31 July 1913, and 31 Aug. 1913.

141 Baumann, , Eine afrikanische Tropen-Insel, 9, 38Google Scholar; AGA, C-219, E-2, GG to Min., 25 Feb. 1900.

142 SOAS, MMSA, 1153, mf 183, W. Barleycorn to Mr Burnett, 21 Sept. 1900; AGA C-148, E-6, GG to Min, 28 Nov. 1910.

143 SOAS, MMSA, 1154, mf 199, Banham, 4 May 1903.

144 Espinosa, Ramos, España, 49.Google Scholar

145 Kingsley, M., Travels in West Africa (London, 1982 [4th ed]), 62Google Scholar; LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Laka letter, 13 July 1906.

146 SOAS, MMSA, PM 1157, mf 256–7, Sta. Isabel Council, 9–10 Nov. 1916.

147 Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 216–17, 236–7.Google Scholar

148 AGA, C-148, E-6, GG to Min., 15 Sept. 1906, 1 Oct. 1906, and 13 Dec. 1906.

149 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 21 Oct. 1906 and 21 Nov. 1906.

150 Ramos-Izquierdo, , Descriptión, 264–6, 274–5.Google Scholar

151 SOAS, MMSA, 1154, mf 201, J. Bell to Mr Guttery, 24 and 25 July 1910.

152 AG A, C-2, E-5, ‘Bando sobre el trabajo de los Bubis’, 26 July 1912.

153 Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 217.Google Scholar

154 AGA, C-2I9, E-2, GG to Min., 25 Feb. 1900; SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

155 Tessmann, , Die Bubi, 174–6, 216Google Scholar; Gil-Delgado, Crespo, Notas, 154–6.Google Scholar

156 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 256, Sta. Isabel Council, 9–10 Nov. 1916.

157 Baumann, , Eine afrikanische Tropen-Insel, 101Google Scholar; Kingsley, , Travels, 70Google Scholar; Teran, , Sintesis, 50Google Scholar; Gil-Delgado, Crespo, Notas, 151, 160–1Google Scholar.

158 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 257, T. Stoner to Quarterly Committee, c. 1919.

159 AGA, C-148, E-6, GG to Min., 15 Oct. 1910.

160 AGA, C-660, E-10, F.Romera and J. Coll y Astrell to Min., 7 Nov. 1903.

161 AGA, C-104, E-3, Sabater, F., ‘Ensayo’, 1906.Google Scholar

162 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 21 Jan. 1910.

163 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 143–4.Google Scholar

164 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 199–203Google Scholar, for biographical details.

165 Fernández, , Misiones, 643, 648.Google Scholar

166 SOAS, MMSA, 1153, mf 185, Barleycorn, W., ‘Banni Mission account’, 12 1916.Google Scholar

167 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 223’4, 293 (n.2), 343Google Scholar; and‘Creolization’, 407–8.

168 Kingsley, , Travels, 72.Google Scholar

169 Baumann, , Eine afrikanische Tropen-Insel, 132–9.Google Scholar

170 RH, Ms. Afr. s 1525, 13/3, M. Gardner to J. Holt, 17 Feb. 1877.

171 SOAS, MMSA, 1157, mf 258, ‘Cocoa farming’, c. 1920.

172 Fernandez, , Misiones, 528, 643, 648.Google Scholar

173 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, J. Cottrell to J. Holt & Co, 31 Oct. 1906.

174 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 25 Sept. 1906.

175 AGA, C-104, E-3, GG to Min., 17 Mar. 1913.

176 SOAS, MMSA, 1156, mf 238, Council of Missionaries, San Carlos, 12 Feb.1900.

177 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1 (Sundries), Huelí'n letter, 9 Sept. 1906.

178 AGA, C-104, E-3, GG to Min., 17 Mar. 1913.

179 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, ‘Interview with Mr Maysmore’, 13 June 1899.

180 Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 168.Google Scholar

181 Banco Nacional Ultramarino, Relatórios (Lisbon, 1890), 283.Google Scholar

182 AHU, P-531, Governor to Overseas Minister, 31 Jan. 1909.

183 Fry, R., Bankers in West Africa: The Story of the Bank of British West Africa Limited (London, 1976), 62.Google Scholar The date is given as between 1905 and 1909.

184 Carbonel, Bravo, Fernando Póo, 270–1.Google Scholar

185 Espinosa, Ramos, España, 75.Google Scholar

186 Fernández, , Misiones, 598–9.Google Scholar

187 Casas, Sans, ‘Politica colonial’, 33Google Scholar (1923 whites only census); Dirección General de Marruecos y Colonias, Resumen estadístico de Africa Española (Madrid, 1954), 413–14.Google Scholar

188 Sundiata, , ‘Creolization’, 393.Google Scholar

189 Hopkins, A. G., ‘Richard Beale Blaize, 1854–1904, merchant prince of West Africa’, Tarikh, I (1966), 77–8.Google Scholar

190 ACG, ‘Relación de los terrenos concedidos’, 1909–16.Google Scholar

191 Liniger-Goumaz, La Guinée, entries for companies.

192 Nava, J. Nosti, Agricultura de Guinea, promesa para Españia (Madrid, 1948), 18.Google Scholar

193 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 349, 354.Google Scholar

194 Sundiata, , ‘The Fernandinos’, 314Google Scholar, citing La Voz de Fernando Póo, 1921.

195 LCL, 380 HOL-I, 9/1, Fernando Po letter, 24 Aug. 1906; Moreno, , Reseña, 85 n. 118.Google Scholar

196 J. Carbonel, Bravo, Guinea Española, los mil miliones de pesetas anuales (Madrid, 1926), 108–9.Google Scholar

197 Sundiata, , ‘Creolization’, 397.Google Scholar

198 Sundiata, , ‘Prelude to scandal’, III.Google Scholar

199 Anon., ‘Viaje a las posesiones Españolas del Golfo de Guinea, Abril-Septiembre de 1941’ (typescript in my possession), 80–1, 88–92Google Scholar, and map.

200 Anon., ‘ Viaje’, 100Google Scholar; Casas, Sanz, ‘Politica colonial’, 117Google Scholar; Barceló, J. L., Perspectivas económicas del Africa Ecuatorial Española (Madrid, 1947), 34.Google Scholar

201 Liniger-Goumaz, , La Guinée, 858, 134–5Google Scholar; Pélissier, , ‘Fernando Poo’, 99.Google Scholar

202 Gil-Delgado, Crespo, Notas, 191–2.Google Scholar

203 Hodges, T. and Nevvitt, M., São Tomé and Príncipe from Plantation Colony to Microstate (Boulder, 1988), ch. 2Google Scholar; de Cabinda, Companhia, Breve história da Companhia de Cabinda, 1903–1973 (Lisbon, 1973)Google Scholar; Michel, M., ‘Les plantations allemandes du Mont Cameroun 1885–1914’, Revue Française d'Histoire d'Outre-Mer, lxii (1969), 183–213Google Scholar; Chalot, C. and Luc, M., Le cacaoyer au Congo Français (Paris, 1906)Google Scholar; Claessens, J., ‘Note relative à la culture du cacaoyer au Mayumbe (Congo Beige)’, Bulletin Agricole du Congo Beige, v (1914), 214–46.Google Scholar

204 Hill, P., The Migrant Cocoa Farmers of Southern Ghana: A Study in Rural Capitalism (Cambridge, 1963)Google Scholar; Berry, S., Cocoa, Custom and Socio-Economic Change in Rural Western Nigeria (Oxford, 1975).Google Scholar

205 Hopkins, A. G., ‘Innovation in a colonial context: Nigerian cocoa farming 1880–1920’, in Dewey, C. and Hopkins, A. G. (eds.), The Imperial Impact: Studies in the Economic History of Africa and India (London, 1978), 83–96Google Scholar; Peel, J.Ijeshas and Nigerians: The Incorporation of a Yoruba Kingdom, 1890s–1970s (Cambridge, 1983), ch. 7Google Scholar; Webster, J. B., ‘The Bible and the plough’, Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria, xi (1963), 418–34.Google Scholar

206 Hill, , Migrant Cocoa-Farmers, 26, 172–3, 221–2, 225, 238–40.Google Scholar

207 Clarence-Smith, ‘Plantation versus smallholder production’.

208 Nogueira, A. F., A ilha de S. Thomé (Lisbon, 1893), 29Google Scholar; Mantero, F., A mão d'obra em S Thomé e Principe (Lisbon, 1910), annexes.Google Scholar

209 Wyse, A., The Krio of Sierra Leone: An Interpretative History (London, 1989), ch. 4Google Scholar; Spitzer, L., The Creoles of Sierra Leone: Responses to Colonialism, 1870–1945 (Madison, 1974).Google Scholar