Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-07T07:14:37.018Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Slaves, Commoners and Landlords in Bulozi, c. 1875 to 1906

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

W.G. Clarence-Smith
W.G. Clarence-Smith
Affiliation:
University of York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The much-researched history of Bulozi in the late nineteenth century is re-assessed here from a marxist viewpoint. A hereditary class of landlords owned the principal means of production and extracted rent in labour services and in kind from the direct producers. Tribute was also paid to the king and royal family, in recognition of the ultimate royal ownership of the means of production. Surplus was employed to increase leisure time, to indulge in conspicuous consumption, to raise the level of the productive forces through investment, and to maintain repressive political and ideological apparatuses. The main weight of oppression fell on the slaves, with free commoners in an ambivalent position. Slaves were both economically exploited and socially discriminated against, and their position was analogous but by no means identical to that of European serfs. The evolution of class struggle was greatly affected by articulation with capitalism and colonialism. The first contacts stimulated exploitation by providing a larger market and more effective means of repression, but the colonial state later intervened to abolish slavery in order to intensify the flow of migrant labour to the capitalist heartlands of southern Africa.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 20 , Issue 2 , April 1979 , pp. 219 - 234
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Stokes, Eric, ‘Barotseland; the survival of an African state’, in Stokes, E. and Brown, R. (eds.), The Zambezian Past (Manchester, 1966), 261–301Google Scholar; Clay, Gervas, Your Friend Lewanika, Litunga of Barotseland, 1842–1916 (London, 1968Google Scholar); Caplan, G. L., The élites of Barotseland, 1878–1969 (London, 1970)Google Scholar; Mainga, Mutumba (Bull), Bulozi under the Luyana Kings, Political Evolution and State Formation in Pre-colonial Zambia (London, 1973)Google Scholar; Hermitte, Eugene, ‘An economic history of Barotseland, 1800–1940’ (Ph.D. Thesis, Northwestern University, 1973Google Scholar); Roberts, Andrew, A History of Zambia (London, 1976Google Scholar); van Horn, L., ‘The agricultural history of Barotseland, 1840–1964’, in Palmer, R. and Parsons, N. (eds.), The Roots of Rural Poverty in Central and Southern Africa (London, 1977), 144–169Google Scholar; Prins, G. I. T., ‘Bulozi during the period of primary European contact, 1876–1896’ (Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge University, 1978Google Scholar). In accordance with the wishes of Dr Prins, I have not used any of the information in his thesis, which is to be published shortly, and I have refrained from commenting on it.

2 This is particularly marked in Roberts, , History of Zambia (pp. 134–5Google Scholar, 141, 148, 181), and in Van Horn's article, whereas it emerges incidentally in the work of Mainga and Hermitte.

3 Gluckman, M., The Economy of the Central Barotse Plain (Livingstone, 1941Google Scholar; Lusaka, and Manchester, , 1968); Essays on Lozi Land and Royal Property (Livingstone, 1943Google Scholar; Lusaka, and Manchester, , 1968); ‘The Lozi of Barotseland in North-Western Rhodesia’, in Colson, E. and Gluckman, M., Seven Tribes of British Central Africa (London, 1951Google Scholar); The Judicial Process among the Barotse of Northern Rhodesia (Manchester, 1955; 2nd ed., Manchester, 1967)Google Scholar; The Ideas in Barotse Jurisprudence (Yale, 1965; 2nd ed., Manchester, 1972).Google Scholar

4 Frankenberg, R., ‘Economic anthropology or political economy: the Barotse social formation’, in Clammer, J. (ed.), The New Economic Anthropology (London, 1978), 31–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

5 The archives consulted were the National Archives of Zambia, Lusaka (henceforth NAZ), the Livingstone Museum Manuscript Collection, Livingstone (henceforth LM), and the Diaries and Journal of William Waddell, copy in the Royal Commonwealth Society in London (henceforth Waddell Diaries). A useful selection from the National Archives of Rhodesia, Salisbury (henceforth NAR) was provided by the Gervas Clay microfilm of documents relating to Barotseland in the library of the University of York. The central archives of the Sociétédes Missions Evangéliques in Paris were temporarily closed in August 1977, but the local archives were consulted in the Livingstone Museum collection. My thanks are due to the University of Zambia for providing funds for a research trip to Livingstone and Mongu.

6 See Clarence-Smith, W. G., ‘For Braudel: a note on the Ecole des Annales and the historiography of Africa’, in History in Africa, iv (1977), 275–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar, for ‘deep structures’.

7 Especially Hindess, B. and Hirst, P. Q., Pre-capitalist Modes of Production (London, 1975Google Scholar); for a recent bibliographical review of the literature see Law, Robin, ‘In search of a marxist perspective on pre-colonial tropical Africa’, in J. Afr. Hist., xix, 111 (1978), 441–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 Gluckman, , Ideas, 75–8.Google Scholar

9 Gluckman, , Essays, 13–20.Google Scholar

10 Ibid.; Gluckman, , Ideas, chapter 3.Google Scholar

11 Liénard, J., Lettres et fragments (Cahors, 1902), 122Google Scholar; Holub, E., Seven Years in South Africa, ii (London, 1881), 160–1.Google Scholar

12 Gluckman, , Economy, 69–70.Google Scholar

13 Liénard, , Lettres, 200Google Scholar; see also Gluckman, , Economy, 26.Google Scholar

14 Mainga, , Bulozi, 136–7.Google Scholar

15 Gluckman, , Ideas, 98.Google Scholar

16 Ibid.

17 Ibid. 103.

18 Gluckman, , Essays, 28.Google Scholar

19 Gluckman, , Ideas, 98Google Scholar, 118, 161–2, 188.

20 Ibid. 80; Dècle, L., Three Years in Savage Africa, 2nd ed. (London, 1900), 73Google Scholar, confirms that every inhabitant had his plot of land.

21 Gluckman, , Ideas, 80.Google Scholar

22 Gluckman, , Economy, 32–3.Google Scholar

23 NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington.

24 Gluckman, , Essays, 25.Google Scholar

25 Gluckman, , Economy, 73Google Scholar, 76, 92–3; Essays, 25; Ideas, 46–7.

26 Livingstone, D., Livingstone's African Journals, 1853–1856, ii (London, 1963), 299Google Scholar, 318–9; Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 209–10Google Scholar; Mainga, , Bulozi, 138–9, 148–9Google Scholar; see also Horn, Van, ‘Agricultural history’, 147.Google Scholar

27 Gluckman, , Essays, 33–44Google Scholar; this argument is repeated in many places in his works.

28 Ibid. 36.

29 NAR, HC 1/2/5, 4149/05, Coryndon 22 Nov. 1905.

30 Ibid.; Mainga, , Bulozi, 148–9.Google Scholar

31 Nouvelles du Zambèze, iv, 11 (1901), 56–7.Google Scholar

32 Caplan, , Elites, 21, 99.Google Scholar

33 Ibid. 21; Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 225Google Scholar, n. 9.

34 Stevenson-Hamilton, J., The Barotseland Journals of James Stevenson-Hamilton, 1898–1899 (London, 1953), 182.Google Scholar

35 Diaries, Waddell, iv, 31 Oct. 1886Google Scholar, and vi, 14 Nov. 1892; NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington.

36 Luck, R., A Visit to Lewanika King of the Barotse (London, 1902), 56–7Google Scholar, for extent of supervision.

37 Bégum, E., Les Ma Rotsé, étude géographique et ethnographique du Haut-Zambèze (Lausanne, 1903), 109.Google Scholar

38 Ibid. 100, 104, 109; Nouvelles du Zambèze, ix, 111 (1906), 93.Google Scholar

39 Frankenberg, ‘Economic anthropology’, passim.

40 Diaries, Waddell, 111, 28 Jan. 1886; Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxxix, 1 (1904), 28.Google Scholar

41 Gibbons, A., Africa from South to North through Marotseland (London, 1904), i, 271Google Scholar; Luck, , Visit, 53.Google Scholar

42 Bertrand, A., Au pays des Ba-Rotsi, Haut-Zambèze (Paris, 1898), 297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

43 NAR, HC 1/2/5, 4149/05, Coryndon 22 Nov. 1905.

44 Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxix (1894), 119.Google Scholar

45 Horn, Van, ‘Agricultural history’, 151–5Google Scholar. However, Van Horn seems rather to underestimate the importance of this market.

46 Gluckman, , Essays, 16, 45.Google Scholar

47 Holub, E., Eine Culturskizze des Marutse-Mambunda Reiches in Süd-Central-Afrika (Vienna, 1879), 165–72.Google Scholar

48 Cf. map in Roberts, , History of Zambia, 128Google Scholar. For eastward expansion see Gibbons, A. St. H., Exploration and Hunting in Central Africa, 1895–1896 (London, 1898), 184Google Scholar. For westward expansion see Portugal: Portugues, Governo, Questão do Barotze. Memória do governo portugues para recurso á arbitragem de Sua Majestade o rei de Itália (Lisbon, 1903Google Scholar), copy in Special Collections, Library of the University of Zambia. This publication includes several sworn statements by traders active in south-eastern Angola around 1900; one was van der Kellen, who led an expedition for the Mossamedes Company as far as the Zambezi. In addition, this publication includes material from Silva Porto's diaries relating to his visit to Lewanika in 1883–4.

49 Liénard, , Lettres, 194.Google Scholar

50 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 104.Google Scholar

51 Ibid. 102; A. and Jalla, E., Pionniers parmi les Ma-Rotse (Florence, 1903), 195–6.Google Scholar

52 Luck, , Visit, 57Google Scholar; Stevenson-Hamilton, , Barotseland journals, 102.Google Scholar

53 LM, M/73/25, Rapport Lealui 1925–1926.

54 Liénard, , Lettres, 200.Google Scholar

55 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 104Google Scholar; Gluckman, Judicial Process and Ideas.

56 Gluckman, , Economy, 34–5.Google Scholar

57 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 120–2Google Scholar; Dècle, , Three Years, 74–5.Google Scholar

58 Mainga, , Bulozi, 143–7.Google Scholar

59 Nar, Waddell Papers, WA/1/1/3, Description of Lewanika; Holub, , Culturskizze, 13.Google Scholar

60 Mainga, , Bulozi, 145.Google Scholar

61 Ibid. 145–6; Gluckman, , Essays, 35Google Scholar, and Economy, 70.

62 Naz, Kde 2/44/12, F. Worthington, ‘Notes on the population of the Barotse Valley’.

63 Mainga, , Bulozi, 50Google Scholar, refutes Gluckman's claim that regiments were not geographically based.

64 Dècle, , Three Years, 81Google Scholar; Johnston, J., Reality versus Romance in South Central Africa (London, 1893), 135–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jalla, , Pionniers, 99–100.Google Scholar

65 Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 135–7Google Scholar; Caplan, , Elites, 104.Google Scholar

66 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 99–100.Google Scholar

67 Gluckman, , Economy, 29–30Google Scholar, and Ideas, 9.

68 Jalla, , Pionniers, 224.Google Scholar

69 Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 214Google Scholar. This point is not specifically footnoted.

70 Nar, Hc 1/2/6, 4677/06, News from Barotsiland, Jan. 1907Google Scholar; Naz, Kde 2/44/12, F. Worthington, ‘Notes on the population of the Barotse Valley’.

71 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 13Google Scholar; LM,M/73/25, Rapport Lealui 24 April 1905; for estimates in restricted areas, see Depelchin, H. and Croonenberghs, C., Trois ans dans l'Afrique Australe, 1879–1881 (Brussels, 1882–1883), ii, 362Google Scholar; Arnot, F., From Natal to the Upper Zambezi, 3rd ed. (Glasgow, 1884), 59Google Scholar; Luck, , Visit, 40, 57Google Scholar. However these estimates do not distinguish between the mass of captives and the élite of child slaves paid as tribute by the free population.

72 Jalla, , Pionniers, 223Google Scholar; Naz, Kde 8/1/1, Report DC Barotse 1907; Gluckman, , Economy, 27Google Scholar, gives an average of eight families per settlement.

73 Gluckman, , Economy, 76Google Scholar; Caplan, , Elites, 98–9, 104.Google Scholar

74 Livingstone, , African journals, ii, 292–3Google Scholar, 299, 318–20; Livingstone, D., Livingstone's Private Journals, 1851–1853 (London, 1960), 154–5Google Scholar, 158, 238; da Silva Porto, A., Viagens e apontamentos de um Portuense em Africa (Lisbon, 1942), 114.Google Scholar

75 Nouvelles du Zambèze, ix, 111 (1906), 92–3Google Scholar, for one very good example of this problem.

76 Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 154Google Scholar, n. 59; Mainga, , Bulozi, 148–9.Google Scholar

77 Jalla, , Pionniers, 224Google Scholar; Naz, Kde 8/1/1, Report DC Barotse 1907.

78 Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 128.Google Scholar

79 Gibbons, , Exploration, 390Google Scholar; Jalla, , Pionniers, 224.Google Scholar

80 Jalla, , Pionniers, 223–4.Google Scholar

81 Arnot, F., Garenganze, or Seven Years Pioneer Mission Work in Central Africa (London, 1889), 92Google Scholar; Diaries, Waddell, v, 26 Aug. 1888.Google Scholar

82 Diaries, Waddell, VI, 10 07 1892.Google Scholar

83 Dècle, , Three Years, 73–4Google Scholar; Jalla, , Pionniers, 226.Google Scholar

84 Diaries, Waddell, 111, 30 Aug. 1885Google Scholar; Dècle, , Three Years, 74.Google Scholar

85 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 100Google Scholar; Nouvelles du Zambèze, ix, 111 (1906), 93.Google Scholar

86 Hermitte, , ‘Economic histor’, 130, 214Google Scholar; Diaries, Waddell, iii, 28 Jan. 1886.Google Scholar

87 NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington.

88 NAR, HC 1/3/3, 606/13, Worthington, F., ‘Domestic slavery in Northern Rhodesi’, 26 Jan. 1913.Google Scholar

89 Diaries, Waddell, IV, 31 Oct. 1886.Google Scholar

90 Coillard, F., Sur le Haut-Zambèze (Paris, 1899), 296Google Scholar; Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxxvi, 1 (1901), 310Google Scholar; Nouvelles du Zambèze, vii, 11 (1904), 50.Google Scholar

91 Jalla, , Pionniers, 224.Google Scholar

92 Béguin, , Les Ma Rotsé, 114Google Scholar; Liénard, , Lettres, 217Google Scholar; Statham, J., With My Wife across Africa (London, 1924), 225–6Google Scholar; Nar, Hc 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by Worthington, F.; NAZ, KDE 8/1/1, Report DC Barotse 1907.Google Scholar

93 Jalla, , Pionniers, 333–4Google Scholar; NAR, HC 1/2/5, 4456/05, Coryndon, 19 Dec. 1905.Google Scholar

94 Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxxvi, 1 (1901), 134–5.Google Scholar

95 Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxvii (1892), 70.Google Scholar

96 Dècle, , Three Years, 73Google Scholar; Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxxv, 1 (1900), 127–9.Google Scholar

97 Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxviii (1893), 28Google Scholar

98 Arnot, , Garenganze, 73Google Scholar; Diaries, Waddell, vi, 2 Oct. 1892.Google Scholar

99 Jalla, , Pionniers, 224.Google Scholar

100 Among the numerous references, see Diaries, Waddell, iv, 31 Oct. 1886 and 27 Feb. 1887Google Scholar; Goy, M., Alone in Africa, or Seven Years on the Zambezi, 2nd ed. (London, 1902), 45–6, 54–5.Google Scholar

101 Clark, P., The Autobiography of an Old Drifter (London, 1936), 149.Google Scholar

102 Nar, Hc 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington.

103 Journal des Missions Evangéliques, lxxxi, 11 (1906), 325–36.Google Scholar

104 NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington.

105 Ibid.; Holub, , Culturskizze, 6.Google Scholar

106 Diaries, Waddell, v, 26 Aug. 1888Google Scholar; LM, O/73/97, Lukona, Journal 4 03 1906 and 21 04 1906.Google Scholar

107 Nouvelles du Zambéze, viii, iv (1905), 118.Google Scholar

108 Mackintosh, C., The New Zambezi Trail (London, 1922), 57, 74–6.Google Scholar

109 Jalla, , Pionniers, 261.Google Scholar

110 NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4677/06, News from Barotsiland, Jan. 1907; Dècle, , Three Years, 78Google Scholar; Harding, C., In Remotest Barotseland, (London, 1905), 268.Google Scholar

111 Dècle, , Three Years, 74.Google Scholar

112 Hermitte, , ‘Economic history’, 194.Google Scholar

113 Holub, , Culturskizze, 167.Google Scholar

114 Jalla, , Pionniers, 226.Google Scholar

115 Methodist Missionary Archives, School of Oriental and African Studies, London, N/T 11Google Scholar, Journal of Arthur Baldwin, 11 Oct. 1893Google Scholar (photocopy courtesy of archivist).

116 Jalla, , Pionniers, 223, 236–7Google Scholar; Clay, , Your Friend, 140Google Scholar (for 1897); LM, M/73/25, Rapport Lealui 1925–1926 (for 1925); LM, M/73/25, Rapports Lealui 1904–1905 and 1905–1906; NAZ, KDE 8/1/1, Report DC Barotse 1907; NAR, HC 1/2/11, 631/11, Wallace, 24 03 1911.Google Scholar

117 Holub, E. (trans. Johns, C., ed. Holy, L.), Travels North of the Zambezi, 1885–1886 (Manchester, 1976), 279Google Scholar, for breaches of theoretical royal monopoly over ivory trade.

118 Ibid. 271–3; Holub, , Seven Years, 11, 142.Google Scholar

119 Van Horn, , ‘Agricultural history’, 151–5.Google Scholar

120 NAR, HC 1/2/6, 4308/06, Memorandum by F. Worthington; LM, G/19/6, Journal of Worthington, F., 1902Google Scholar; NAZ, BS2/246, File 4341/07.

121 Liénard, , Lettres, 195–6Google Scholar; Stokes, , ‘Barotseland’, 281–2.Google Scholar

122 Van Horn, , ‘Agricultural history’, 159.Google Scholar

123 Caplan, , Elites, 86–7, 98–9Google Scholar; on p. 86, Caplan erroneously states that the hut tax was fixed at ten shillings – see Nouvelles du Zambèze, viii, i (1905), 8, 19.Google Scholar

124 Clay, , Your Friend, 171–2Google Scholar, for text of proclamation.

125 Nouvelles du Zambèze, xi, i (1908), 8.Google Scholar

126 Caplan, , Elites, 87–8.Google Scholar

127 Naz, Kde 8/1/1, Report DC Barotse 1907; Nar, Hc 1/2/11, 924/11, ‘Mboo and the recent unrest in the Barotse Valley’.

128 Nar, Hc 1/3/3, 606/13. Worthington, F. ‘Domestic slavery in Northern Rhodesia’, 26 03 1913.Google Scholar

129 Horn, Van, ‘Agricultural history’, 157–8.Google Scholar

130 See Law, as cited in note 7, for bibliographical references.

131 Hindess and Hirst, Pre-capitalist Modes of Production, chapter 3.