Article contents
Patterning in Recent Radiocarbon Dates from Southern Africa as a Reflection of Prehistoric Settlement and Interaction
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 January 2009
Extract
Radiocarbon dates published by southern African archaeologists since the last review in this journal (in 1980) illustrate an increasingly complex record of population movement and interaction. Substantial gaps in the distributions of dates reflect the ebb and flow of people in response to changing environmental and social circumstances. More interesting perhaps is the range of intergroup relations now emerging from the last two millennia with the appearance of pastoralists and agriculturalists. Radiocarbon dates, taken along with spatial and formal patterns in the archaeological record, show clearly that the distributions between hunters, herders and farmers and between Stone Age and Iron Age communities were blurred and flexible.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987
References
1 Previous reviews of southern African radiocarbon dates which have appeared in this Journal include those by Hall, Martin and Vogel, J. C. (XXI, iv, 1980, 431–55)Google Scholar, Maggs, Tim (XVII, ii,1977, 161–91),Google ScholarSoper, R. C. (xv, ii, 1974, 175–92),Google ScholarSutton, J. E. G. (XIII, i, 1972, 1–24)Google Scholar and Phillipson, D. W. (XI, I, 1970, 1–15).Google Scholar
2 Hall, Martin and Vogel, J. C., ‘Some recent radiocarbon dates from southern Africa,’ J. Afr. Hist., XXI, iv (1980), 431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
3 Freundlich, J. C., Schwabedissen, H. and Wendt, W. E., ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements II,’ Radiocarbon, XXII, i (1980), 68–81.CrossRefGoogle ScholarVogel, J. C. and Visser, Ebbie, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates II,’ Radiocarbon, XXIII, i (1981), 43–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
4 Denbow, J. R. and Wilmsen, E. N., ‘Iron Age pastoralist settlements in Botswana,’ S. Afr. J. Sci., XXIX (1983), 406.Google Scholar
5 Wilmsen, E. N., ‘The impact of land tenure policies on the future of the San’ (paper presented at the International Symposium on African Hunter Gatherers, Cologne, 1985), 2.Google Scholar
6 Denbow, J. R, ‘Cows and Kings: a spatial and economic analysis of a hierarchical Early Iron Age settlement system in Eastern Botswana’ in Hall, M., Avery, G., Avery, D. M., Wilson, M. L. and Humphreys, A. J. B. (eds.), Frontiers: Southern African Archaeology Today (British Archaeological Reports, International Series, 207) (Oxford, 1984), 24–39.Google Scholar
7 Denbow and Wilmsen, ‘Iron Age pastoralist settlements,’ 406.Google Scholar
8 Ibid
9 Alexander, J., ‘Early frontiers in southern Africa,’ in Hall et al., Frontiers, 12.Google Scholar
10 Wilmsen, ‘Impact of land tenure policies,’ 2.Google Scholar
11 Humphreys, A. J. B. and Thackeray, A. I., Ghaap and Gariep (South African Archaeological Society Monograph Series, 2) (Cape Town, 1983).Google Scholar
12 Deacon, J., ‘Patterning in the radio-carbon dates for the Wilton/Smithfield complex in southern Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXIX (1974), 3–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
13 Sampson, C. G., ‘The Stone Age industries of the Orange River scheme and South Africa,’ Memoirs of the National Museum (Bloemfontein), VI (1982), 1–288.Google Scholar
14 Humphreys, A. J. B., ‘The Holocene sequence in the northern Cape and its position in the prehistory of South Africa’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Cape Town, 1979).Google Scholar
15 Deacon, H. J., Where Hunters Gathered (South African Archaeological Society Monograph Series, 1) (Cape Town, 1976).Google Scholar
16 PTA-2140, PTA-2541, PTA-2542, PTA-2543, PTA-2544, PTA-2545, PTA-2546, PTA-2723, PTA-2727, PTA-2728, PTA-2729, PTA-2779, PTA-2785, PTA-2790, PTA-2797, PTA-2798, PTA-2852, SI-2030. Humphreys and Thackeray, Ghaap and Gariep, 45–6.Google Scholar
17 PTA-2447, PTA-2448, PTA-2490; Ibid, 175.
18 Hall and Vogel, ‘Recent radiocarbon dates’.Google Scholar
19 Deacon, Where Hunters Gathered, 222.Google Scholar
20 Sampson, C. G., Stone Age Archaeology of Southern Africa (New York, 1974), 331.Google Scholar
21 Ibid
22 Ibid
23 Bakker, E. M. van Zinderen, ‘Comparison of Late Quaternary climatic evolutions in the Sahara and the Namib—Kalahari region,’ Palaeoecology of Africa, XII (1980), 390.Google Scholar
24 Humphreys and Thackeray, Ghaap and Gariep, 94–5.Google Scholar
25 PTA-2835, 2840: Ibid, 103.
26 PTA-186: Ibid
27 Previous estimates of about 400 years before the present appear in Humphreys, ‘The Holocene sequence,’Google Scholar and in Klein, R. G., ‘Palaeoenvironmental and cultural implications of late Holocene archaeological faunas from the Orange Free State and north-central Cape Province, South Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXIV (1979), 34–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
28 Humphreys and Thackeray, Ghaap and Gariep, 175.Google Scholar
29 PTA-1621, 1759, 2095: Ibid, 205.
30 PTA-3413, 3412: Ibid, 159.
31 Stow, G. W., The Native Races of South Africa (London, 1905; reprinted New Haven, 1977);Google ScholarDeacon, H. J., Deacon, J., Brooker, M. and Wilson, M. L., ‘The evidence for herding at Boomplaas Cave in the southern Cape, South Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXIII (1978), 39–65;CrossRefGoogle ScholarRobertshaw, P. T., ‘The origin of pastoralism in the Cape,’ S. Afr. Hist. J., X (1978), 117–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
32 Elphick, R., Khoikhoi and the Founding of White South Africa (Johannesburg, 1985).Google Scholar This interpretation has been supported, on linguistic grounds, by Ehret, C., ‘The first spread of food production in southern Africa,’ in Ehret, C. and Posnansky, M. (eds.), The Archaeological and Linguistic Reconstruction of African history (Berkeley, 1982), 158–81.Google Scholar
33 Beaumont, P. B., ‘On the origins of Hottentot culture in southern Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Soc. Newsletter, III, i (1980), 2–3.Google Scholar
34 Beaumont, P. B. and Vogel, J. C., ‘Spatial patterning of the ceramic Later Stone Age in the northern Cape Province, South Africa’ in Hall, et al. (eds.), Frontiers, 80–95.Google Scholar
35 PTA-3359: Rudner, I. and Rudner, J., ‘Wilton sand-dune sites in north-western Cape and South Vest Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XIV (1959), 142–5;CrossRefGoogle ScholarBeaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 94.Google Scholar
36 PTA-3088: Beaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 94.Google Scholar
37 PTA-3093: Ibid
38 PTA-3094: Ibid, 95.
39 PTA-964: Ibid, 94.
40 PTA-3357: Rudner and Rudner, ‘Wilton sand-dune sites’;Google ScholarBeaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 92.Google Scholar
41 PTA-3109: Beaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 94.Google Scholar
42 PTA-3417: Ibid, 93.
43 PTA-2833, 2841, 3419: Thackeray, A. I., Thackeray, J. F. and Beaumont, P. B., ‘Excavations at the Blinkklipkop specularite mine near Postmasburg, northern Cape,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXVII (1983), 17–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
44 PTA-3444, 3462, 3462: Beaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 95.Google Scholar
45 PTA-186, 3089: Ibid, 92.
46 PTA-2452: Ibid, 91.
47 PTA-3401: Humphreys, ‘The Holocene sequence’.Google Scholar
48 PTA-1621: Ibid
49 PTA-1759, 2095: Ibid
50 PTA-3367, 3421: Beaumont and Vogel, ‘Spatial patterning,’ 95.Google Scholar
51 PTA-1483: Ibid, 93.
52 Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements’;Google ScholarVogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates’Google Scholar. See also Wendt, W. E., ‘Preliminary report on an archaeological research programme in South West Africa,’ Cimbebasia B, II (1972), 1–61.Google Scholar
53 Wendt, W. E., ‘Ein Rekonstruktionsversuch der Besiedlungsgeschichte des west-lichen Gross-Namalandes seit dem 15. Jahrhundert,’ J. S. W. Afr. Sci. Soc., XXIX (1975), 23–56.Google Scholar
54 Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 44.Google Scholar
55 Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 70.Google Scholar
56 PTA-1011, 1012, 1013, 1347, 1348, 1536: Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 56.Google Scholar
57 KN-1 .624, PTA-1202: Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 74;Google ScholarVogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 48.Google Scholar
58 KN-2142, KN-2143, PTA-1185, PTA-1186: Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 76;Google ScholarVogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 51.Google Scholar
59 KN-1 .631, KN-1 .632, KN-1.633, PTA-2662: Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 77;Google ScholarVogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 52.Google Scholar
60 PTA-1046, 1050, 1751: Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 49.Google Scholar
61 PTA-1927, 2650: Ibid, 50.
62 PTA-2075, 2077, 2082: Ibid, 55.
63 PTA-1185, KN-2142: Ibid, 51; Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 76.Google Scholar
64 Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates’;Google ScholarFreundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements’.Google Scholar
65 KN-1 .460, KN-1 .461. KN-1 .729, KN-1 .730, KN-1.731, KN-1.732: Freundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 78.Google Scholar
66 Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 59.Google Scholar
67 Ibid, 58–9. Earlier work at Big Elephant Shelter has been reported in Clark, J. D. and Walton, J., ‘A Late Stone Age site on the Erongo Mountains, South West Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXI (1976), 146,Google Scholar and by Wadley, L., ‘Big Elephant Shelter and its role in the Holocene prehistory of central South West Africa,’ Cimbebasia B, III, i (1979), 2–75.Google Scholar
68 KN-1 .636, KN-1 .637, KN-1 .638, KN-1 .639, PTA-2681: Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 59;Google ScholarFreundlich, Schwabedissen and Wendt, ‘Köln radiocarbon measurements,’ 79–80.Google Scholar
69 PTA-1295: Vogel and Visser, ‘Pretoria radiocarbon dates,’ 61.Google Scholar
70 PTA-1546, 1547, 1550, 1773, 1776, 1777: Ibid, 61–2.
71 Bakker, E. M. van Zinderen, ‘Comparison,’ 390.Google Scholar
72 Ibid
73 Deacon, J., ‘Patterning in the radiocarbon dates’.Google Scholar
74 PTA-2250, 2422: Smith, A. B. and Rip, M. R., ‘An archaeological reconnaissance of the Doorn/Tanqua Karoo,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXIII (1978), 118–33, and pers. comm.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
75 Vogel, J. C., pers. comm.Google Scholar
76 PTA-3766, 3768, 3783: Kaplan, J., ‘Renbaan Cave: stone tools, settlement and subsistence’ (Honours dissertation, University of Cape Town, 1984).Google Scholar
77 Parkington, J., ‘Time and place: some observations on spatial and temporal patterning in the Later Stone Age sequence in southern Africa,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXXV (1980), 73–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
78 Andrews, W. R. H. and Hutchings, L., ‘Upwelling in the southern Benguela current,’ Prog. Oceanogr., IX (1980), 1–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
79 Fluctuation in near coastal seeps is one explanation of the sedimentological sequence recently exposed at Spring Cave near the mouth of the Verloren Vlei. These sediments have been examined by N. Lancaster (pers. comm.).Google Scholar
80 Parkington, J., ‘Landscape and subsistence changes since the last glacial maximum along the western Cape coast,’ in Soffer, Olga (ed.), Regional Perspectives on the Pleistocene Prehistory of the Old World (1986, in press).Google Scholar
81 Deacon, J., The Late Stone Age of southernmost Africa (British Archaeological Reports International Series, 213) (Oxford, 1984), 1–441.Google Scholar
82 Scheitzer, F. R. and Wilson, M. L., ‘Byneskranskop I. A late Quaternary living site in the southern Cape Province, South Africa,’ Ann. S. Afr. Mus. LXXXVIII, i (1982), 1–203.Google Scholar
83 Louw, J. T., ‘Prehistory of the Matjes River rock shelter,’ Memoirs of the National Museum (Bloemfontein) I (1960), 1–143.Google Scholar
84 Thackeray, J. F. and Feast, F. C., ‘A midden burial from Cape St Francis, eastern Cape Province,’ S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull., XXIX (1974), 92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
85 Singer, R. and Wymer, J., The Middle Stone Age of Klasies River Mouth in South Africa (Chicago, 1982).Google Scholar
86 Parkington, ‘Landscape and subsistence changes’.Google Scholar
87 There is considerable discussion in the literature as to whether Holocene features around the shores of southern Africa lying 2–3 metres above present sea-level result from a higher stand of the sea or an emergence of the land. The most general model is given by Clark, J. A., Farrell, W. E. and Peltier, W. R., ‘Global changes in post-glacial sea level: a numerical calculation,’ Quaternary Research, IX (1978), 265–87;CrossRefGoogle Scholar and by Clark, J. A. and Lingle, C. S., ‘Predicted relative sea-level changes (18000 years BP to Present) caused by late-glacial retreat of the Antarctic ice sheet,’ Quaternary Research, XI (1979), 279–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
88 Manhire, A. H., Parkington, J. E. and Robey, T. S., ‘Stone tools and sandveld settlement,’ in Hall, et al. (eds.), Frontiers, 111–120.Google Scholar
89 Smith, A. B., ‘Prehistoric pastoralism in the Southwestern Cape, South Africa,’ World Archaeology, xv, i (1983), 79–89;CrossRefGoogle ScholarSmith, A. B., ‘Adaptive strategies of prehistoric pastoralism in the south-western Cape,’ in Hall, et al. (eds.), Frontiers, 131–42.Google Scholar
90 Robertshaw, P. T., ‘Coastal settlement, freshwater fishing and pastoralism in the later prehistory of the western Cape, South Africa’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, 1979).Google Scholar
91 PTA-3641, 3711, 3737, 3742, 3747, 3785, 3787, 3788: A. B. Smith, pers. comm.Google Scholar
92 Smith, A. B. and Klein, R., pers. comms.Google Scholar
93 Moll, E. J. and Jarman, M. L., ‘Is fynbos a heathland?,’ S. Afr. J. Sci., LXXX, viii (1984), 352–4.Google Scholar
94 E. Moll, pers. comm.Google Scholar
95 N. Penn, pers. comm.Google Scholar
96 T. Maggs, pers. comm.Google Scholar
97 Maggs, T., ‘The Iron Age south of the Zambezi,’ in Klein, R. G. (ed.), Southern African Prehistory and Palaeoenvironments (Rotterdam, 1984).Google Scholar
98 Exceptions are Maggs, T., ‘The Iron Age sequence south of the Vaal and Pongola Rivers: some historical implications,’ J. Afr. Hist., XXI, i (1980), 1–15;CrossRefGoogle ScholarHall, M., Settlement Patterns in the Iron Age of Zululand (British Archaeological Reports International Series, 119) (Oxford, 1981), 1–191;Google Scholar and Jones, Peta, ‘Mobility and migration in traditional African farming and Iron Age models,’ in Hall, et al. (eds.), Frontiers, 289–96.Google Scholar
99 For examples of this approach see Phillipson, D. W., The Later Prehistory of Eastern and Southern Africa (London, 1977);Google ScholarHuffman, T. N., ‘African origins,’ S. Afr. J. Sci., LXXV (1979), 233–7.Google Scholar
100 For a critique of this assumption see Hall, M. and Morris, A., ‘Race and Iron Age human skeletal remains from southern Africa: an assessment,’ Social Dynamics IX, ii (1983), 29–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
101 PTA-2824, 2825. Cable, J. H. C., Economy and Technology in the Late Stone Age of Southern Natal (British Archaeological Reports International Series, 201) (Oxford, 1984), 1–267.Google Scholar
102 PTA-2527, 2528: Robey, T., ‘Mpambanyoni: a Late Iron Age site on the Natal south coast,’ Ann. Natal Mus., XXIV, i (1980), 163.Google Scholar
103 Denbow and Wilmsen, ‘Iron Age pastoralist settlements’.Google Scholar
104 PTA-2017: Cronin, M., ‘Radiocarbon dates for the Early Iron Age in Transkei,’ S. Afr. J. Sci., LXXVII, i (1982), 38.Google Scholar
105 Voigt, E. and Bigalke, E. H., ‘The interdisciplinary aspect of a study of shellfish exploitation by indigenous coastal communities,’ S. Afr. Mus. Bull., x, vii (1973), 1–16.Google Scholar
106 Colson, E., ‘In good years and in bad: food strategies of self-reliant societies,’ J. Anthrop. Res., xxxv, i (1979), 18–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
107 PTA-1848, 2485, 2537: Hall, Settlement patterns, 1–191.Google Scholar
108 ST-8546, 8547, 8548: Morais, J., ‘Mozambican archaeology: past and present,’ Afr. Archaeol. Rev., ii (1984), 113–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
109 Cable, ‘Economy and technology’.Google Scholar
110 PTA-3268: T. Maggs, pers. comm.Google Scholar
111 Acocks, J. P. H., ‘Veld types of South Africa,’ Memoirs of the Botanical Survey of South Africa, XL (1975), map I.Google Scholar
112 Aron Mazel is currently exploring the interaction between hunters and farmers in his Natal research.Google Scholar
113 Maggs, T., ‘Msuluzi Confluence: a seventh century Early Iron Age site on the Tugela River,’ Ann. Natal. Mus., XXIV, i (1980), 111–45.Google Scholar
114 Mazel, A., ‘Through the keyhole: a preliminary peep at the lithic composition of Later Stone Age sites in the central and upper Tugela River basin, Natal,’ in Hall, et al. (eds.), Frontiers, 182–93.Google Scholar
115 PTA-2971, 2973, 3247: Ibid, 185.
116 PTA-3242, 3243, 3245: Ibid, 186.
117 PTA-3269, 3275, 3276, 3443, 3455, 3460: Ibid, 187.
118 Maggs, ‘Dates’; Hall and Vogel, ‘Recent radiocarbon dates’.Google Scholar
119 Daniel, G., A Hundred and Fifty Years of Archaeology (London, 1975).Google Scholar
120 Leacock, E. and Lee, R., Politics and History in Band Societies (Cambridge, 1982).Google Scholar
121 Alexander, ‘Early frontiers’.Google Scholar
122 Giliomee, H., ‘Processes in development of the southern African frontier,’ in Lamar, H. and Thompson, L. (eds.), The Frontier in History (New Haven, 1981).Google Scholar
123 For example, the Okiek: Blackburn, R. H., ‘In the land of milk and honey; Okiek adaptations to their forests and neighbours,’ in Leacock and Lee, Politics and History, 283–305.Google Scholar
124 Alexander, ‘Early frontiers’.Google Scholar
125 Bettinger, R. L. and Baumhoff, M. A., ‘The numic spread: Great Basin cultures in competition,’ American Anthropology, XLVII, iii (1982), 485–503.Google Scholar
126 See Blackburn, ‘In the land of milk and honey’;Google ScholarHoffman, C. L., ‘Punan foragers in the trading networks of south-east Asia,’ in Schrire, C. (ed.), Past and Present in Hunter-gatherer Societies (New York, 1984).Google Scholar
127 We would like to thank Curtis Marean, ‘T’ Farrar, Rob Blumenshine, Preston Miracle and Charles McNutt, all of Berkeley, and Royden Yates, Tony Manhire and Alyson Herlihy in Cape Town.Google Scholar
- 15
- Cited by