Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 January 2009
There are signs that the familiar bias towards research on the Later Stone Age of the southern Sahara and Sahel and on the Iron Age of other parts of West Africa is beginning to be redressed, although Nigeria and Ghana still furnish the vast majority of dates from the southern coastal states. Historical and protohistorical archaeology is becoming increasingly popular, and some areas, for example southern Mali, are receiving serious attention for the first time. Dates are now appearing in large numbers; this paper reports on 355 new radiocarbon and thermoluminescence dates.
Multi-disciplinary research has helped to clarify the Holocene environmental and cultural-stratigraphic sequence in several areas, including the Aïr and Ténéré in Niger and coastal Mauretania and Senegal. There is now strong evidence of a centre of copper metallurgy in the Azelik region of Niger in the 1st millennium b.c. which may well have facilitated the spread of iron working to Nigeria. At the same time, new dates from Mali may indicate a second diffusion route through the western Sahara. In Nigeria, new and early dates for the Nok culture are supported by thermoluminescence dating. Recent work on the later Metal Age of Senegal has permitted the description of four partially overlapping zones, and should soon lead to understanding of their internal and external relationships. Similarly, a substantial body of data has been accumulated, though not yet published, on the Iron Age of the Inland Niger delta. In the more southerly parts of West Africa, several new dates from just north of the forest refer to the emergence of the earliest Akan groups in Ghana and of Oyo in Nigeria. Previously reported dates from Ife and Benin have now been supplemented by a series of thermoluminescence dates.
1 Willett, F., ‘A survey of recent results in the Radiocarbon Chronology of Western and Northern Africa’, J. Afr. Hist., xii (1971), 339–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Flight, Colin, ‘A survey of recent results in the radiocarbon chronology of northern and western Africa’, J. Afr. Hist., xiv (1973), 531–54,CrossRefGoogle Scholar and Posnansky, Merrick and McIntosh, Roderick, ‘New radiocarbon dates for northern and western Africa’, J. Afr. Hist., xvii (1976), 161–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
2 Olsson, Ingrid U., ‘The radiocarbon dating of Ivory Coast shell mounds’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., iii (1973), 215–20.Google Scholar
3 Dates known to have been corrected are so noted in the Appendix (pp. 22–29).Google Scholar
4 The calibration used is that of Clark, R. M., ‘A calibration curve for radiocarbon dates’, Antiquity, xlix, 196 (1975), 251–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
5 Rognon, P., ‘Essai d'interprétation des variation climatiques au Sahara depuis 40,000 ans’, Rev. Géogr. phys. Géol. dynam., xviii (1976), 251–82,Google Scholar and Street, A. F. A. and Grove, A. T., ‘Environmental and climatic implications of Late Quaternary lake-level fluctuations in Africa’, Nature, cclxi (1976), 385–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
6 Talbot, M. R. and Delibrias, G., ‘Holocene variations in the level of Lake Bosumtwi, Ghana’, Nature, cclxviii (1977), 722–4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
7 Maley, J., ‘Mécanisme des changements climatiques aux basses latitudes’, Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, xiv (1973), 193–227,CrossRefGoogle Scholar and ‘Les variations du Lac Tchad depuis un millénaire: conséquences paléoclimatiques’, Palaeoecology of Africa, IX (1976), 44–7,Google Scholar and personal communication. In attempting to interpret Maley's curve it should be remembered that: (a) the peaks are flattened since, when the lake stands at +286 m., there is continuous overflow down the Bahr-el-Ghazal; (b) the chronology is still approximate and further oscillations will be recognized; (c) although the broader trends established are likely to reflect climatic events affecting the whole of West Africa, smaller oscillations will not necessarily be paralleled outside the basin; and (d) minor climatic variation, whether it occurs in drier or wetter periods, may be as significant a factor in history as the grosser trends.
8 Clark, J. D., Williams, M. A. J. and Smith, A. B., ‘The geomorphology and archaeology of Adrar Bous, Central Sahara: a preliminary report’, Quaternaria, xvii (1973), 245–97,Google Scholar and three papers in the Proceedings of the Panafrican Congress on Prehistory and Quaternary Studies, VIIth session, Abebe, B., Chavaillon, J. and Sutton, J. E. G. (eds) (Addis Ababa, 1976):Google ScholarClark, J. D., ‘Epipalaeolithic aggregates from Greboun Wadi, Aïr, and Adrar Bous, north-western Ténéré, Republic of Niger’, pp. 67–78Google Scholar; Smith, A. B., ‘A microlithic industry from Adrar Bous, Ténéré Desert, Niger’, pp. 181–96Google Scholar; and Williams, M. A. J., ‘Upper Quaternary stratigraphy of Adrar Bous, Republic of Niger, south-central Sahara’, pp. 435–41.Google Scholar
9 Clark, , in Abebe et al., Proceedings (1976), 76Google Scholar. See also Camps, G., Les Civilisations préhistoriques de l'Afrique du Nord et du Sahara (Paris, 1974), 157 and 200.Google Scholar
10 Sutton, J. E. G., ‘The aquatic civilization of Middle Africa’, J. Afr. Hist., xv (1974), 527–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11 Fairhall, A. W., Young, A. W. and Erickson, J. L., ‘University of Washington Dates IV’, Radiocarbon, xviii (1976), 221–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar. We have not been able to consult two articles by Maître, J.-P. relevant to this locality, ‘Inventaire préhistorique de l'Ahaggar: III’, Libyca, xvi (1968), 29–54,Google Scholar and ‘Inventaire préhistorique de l'Ahaggar: IV’, Libyca, XX (1972), 103–23.Google Scholar
12 A date of 3720±? b.c. quoted by Smith (op. cit. 190) was run on bone lying on the surface of the diatomites but is considered definitely anomalous.
13 Smith, , in Abebe et al., Proceedings (1976), 191.Google Scholar
14 For these dates we are grateful to M. Henri Lhote.
15 Roset, J.-P., ‘Une meule néolithique ornée du Ténéré (Sahara Nigérien)’, Archaeologia, lviii (1973), 66–8.Google Scholar
16 For this date and those reported below from In Talaylen and Teguef-n'Agar and for accompanying notes, we are grateful to Danilo Grébénart. A paper by P. L., Gouletquer and D. Grébénart entitled ‘Figurines en terre cuite du néolithique de la région d'Agadez (République du Niger)’ is in the press (Bull. Soc. préhist. française).
17 York, R. N., ‘Excavations at Dutsen Kongba, Plateau State, Nigeria’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., vii (1978Google Scholar), forthcoming, in which difficulties in interpreting the dates are exhaustively discussed.
18 Four papers, by Fagg, B., Eyo, Ekpo, Rosenfeld, A. and Fagg, A., dealing with the 1944 and 1964 excavations and with the microlithic industries and the pottery respectively, were published together in W. Afr. J. Archaeol. ii (1972), 1–38Google Scholar. More recently the site has been re-excavated by N. David, and the material as a whole reconsidered. Further samples have been sent for radiocarbon dating, but the results had not been received by the time this article went to press.
19 Hartle, D., ‘Archaeology in eastern Nigeria’, Nigeria Magazine, xciii (1967), 134–43,Google Scholar and, ‘Archaeology east of the Niger, a review of cultural–historical developments’ (Nsukka, 1972)Google Scholar, mimeo.
20 Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971), 353Google Scholar, and Davies, O., West Africa before the Europeans (London, 1967), 281.Google Scholar
21 Shaw, Thurstan, ‘Finds at the Iwo Eleru rock shelter, Western Nigeria’, in Hugot, H. J. (ed.), Actes du VIe Congrès Panafricain de Préhistoire et de l'Etude du Quaternaire (Chambéry, 1972).Google Scholar
22 Hartle, , Nigeria Magazine (1967).Google Scholar
23 Andah, B. W. & Anozie, F., ‘Preliminary report on the prehistoric site of Afikpo (Nigeria)’, paper presented at the Inaugural Session of the West African Archaeological Association, Enugu 1976.Google Scholar
24 We are grateful to Dr V. E. Chikwendu, for information on these dates.
25 Andah, and Anozie, , ‘Preliminary report’ (1976), 17.Google Scholar
26 Hartle, D., Archaeology East of the Niger, 6.Google Scholar
27 Marliac, A. & Gavaud, M., ‘Premiers éléments d'une séquence paléolithique au Cameroun septentrional’, ASEQUA Bull. Liaison, xlvi (1975), 53–66,Google Scholar and personal communication from Alain Marliac.
28 Nygaard, S. & Talbot, M., ‘First dates from the coastal sites near Kpone, Ghana’, Nyame Akuma, xi (1977), 29–30,Google Scholar and M. R. Talbot and J. Dombrowski, personal communications.
29 Smith, A. B., ‘Radiocarbon dates from Bosumpra Cave, Abetifi, Ghana’, Proc. Prehist. Soc., xli (1975), 179–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
30 Posnansky, and McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976), 187.Google Scholar
31 Wai-Ogosu, B. (now Andah), ‘Preliminary Report on the Prehistoric Site of Rim (Upper Volta)’, in B. Abebe et al., Proceedings (1977), 273–82, andGoogle ScholarAndah, B. W., ‘Excavations at Rim, Upper Volta’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., viii (1978Google Scholar), forthcoming.
32 Delibrias, G., Ortlieb, L. and Petit-Maire, N., ‘New C14 data for the Atlantic Sahara (Holocene): tentative palaeoclimatic interpretations’, J. Human Evolution, v (1976), 535–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
33 Carbonnel, J.-P., ‘Structure et paléo-environnement d'un site néolithique Mauretanien: Ksar el Jmel (Tintane)’, Notes Africaines, cxxxvi (1973), 1–6,Google Scholar and Petit-Maire, N., ‘Découvertes de nécropoles néolithiques en Mauretanie occidentale’, Palaeoecology of Africa, vi (1972), 215–18.Google Scholar
34 See dates and discussion in Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971), 345–7Google Scholar, and Flight, , J. Afr. Hist. (1973), 543–4.Google Scholar
35 Diop, Cheikh Anta, ‘Datations par la méthode du radiocarbone: série III’, Bull. IFAN (sér. B), xxxiv (1972), 687–701,Google Scholar and Monod, Th., ‘Lapis-lazuli en Mauretanie’, Notes africaines, cxix (1968), 92–4.Google Scholar
36 Elouard, P., Faure, H. and Hebrard, L., ‘Variations du niveau de la mer au cours des 15,000 dernierès années autour de la presqu'île du Cap Vert’, ASEQUA Bull. Liaison, i. (1977), 29–49.Google Scholar
37 C. Descamps, D. Demoulin and A. Abdallah, ‘Données nouvelles sur la préhistoire du Cap Manuel (Dakar)’, in Hugot, H. J., Actes du VIe Congrès, 130–4.Google Scholar
38 Evin, J., Marien, G. and Pachiaudi, Ch., ‘Lyon natural radiocarbon measurements: VI’, Radiocarbon, xviii (1976), 60–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
39 Ravisé, A., Thilmans, G. and Marius, C., ‘Etude d'une squelette néolithique dans la région de Saint-Louis (Sénégal)’, Bull. IFAN (sér. B), xxxvii (1975), 687–701,Google Scholar and Diop, Cheikh Anta, ‘Institut Fondamental d'Afrique Noire, radiocarbon dates II’, Radiocarbon, xix (1977), 161–4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
40 Diop, C. A., ‘Série III’, (1972).Google Scholar
41 Elouard, P.et al., ASEQUA Bull. (1977), 37, andGoogle ScholarEvin, E. J. et al. , Radiocarbon (1976), 68Google Scholar, and Elouard, P., Evin, J. and Hebrard, L., ‘Observations et résultats des mésures au radiocarbone sur les cordons littoraux coquillers du Lac Retba – Sénégal’, ASEQUA Bull. Liaison, xlvi (1975), 15–20.Google Scholar
42 Linares de Sapir, Olga, ‘Shell middens of Lower Casamance and problems of Diola prehistory’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., i (1971), 23–54.Google Scholar
43 See discussion in de Maret, P., van Noten, F. and Cahen, D., ‘Radiocarbon dates for West Central Africa: a synthesis’, J. Afr. Hist., xviii (1977), 481–505.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
44 de Maret, P.et al., J. Afr. Hist. (1977), 492.Google Scholar
45 We are grateful to P. L. Gouletquer of the Programme archéologique d'urgence In Gall – Teguidda n'Tesemt (I.R.S.H., Niamey) for dates and extensive comments on copper-working in the Azelik region.
46 Posnansky, and McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976), 184.Google Scholar
47 Quéchon, G. and Roset, J.-P., ‘Prospection archéologique du massif du Termit (Niger)’, Cah. O.R.S.T.O.M. (Sci. Hum.), xi (1974), 85–104.Google Scholar
48 A possible parallel is a date of 2940±120 b.c. from a ‘pre-Islamic’ burial at Hidden Valley, Adrar Bous (Yamasaki, F., Hamada, C. and Hamada, H., ‘Riken natural radiocarbon measurements: VII’, Radiocarbon, xiv (1972), 223–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar. According to J. D. Clark (ibid. 230–1), the charcoal came from a hearth 61 cm. below the base of a ‘chouchet’-type cairn and 30 cm. above and immediately north-east of the burial – ‘Presumably, it dates wood used for probable funeral fire’.
49 A date of 90±? b.c. mentioned by Mauny, R. in Nyame Akuma, x (1977), 63Google Scholar, relating to copper mines and furnaces discovered in Niger by P. Gouletquer seems to be in error.
50 Burleigh, R., Hewson, A. & Meeks, N., ‘British Museum natural radiocarbon measurements: IX’, Radiocarbon, xix (2) (1977), 154–5.Google Scholar
51 A sample from a mass of charcoal in the Nok occupation level at Katsina Ala gave the anomalous date of a.d. 1566±45 (ibid. 155). We are grateful to Mr J. Jemkur for providing us with information on the Nok culture thermoluminescence dates. Samples were sent to the Oxford Research Laboratory to date sites for which there were no radiocarbon age determinations; and to determine to what extent there might be mixed cultural material at sites like Katsina Ala where spindle whorls were found, and Taruga which produced a smoking pipe in level 3 (radiocarbon dated 440±140 b.c. and 280±120 b.c.). Most of the Nok culture thermoluminescence dates have been quoted to us in b.p. form. Their translation into a.d./b.c. is calculated from a ‘present’ of 1975. There is, however, some confusion about the Chado dates. On the figures received from Mr Jemkur, the ‘present’ from which the ages of the samples would be calculated in a.d. terms ranges over a decade within the 1960s and 1970s. Dr Fleming of the Oxford Research Laboratory for Archaeology has subsequently requested that these dates should not be published for the time being. They will be incorporated in the next survey of West African dates.
52 We are grateful to Dr B. W. Andah for information on these dates. There is some disagreement between the results of the Harwell and Rikagsku dates and HAR-1569 is anomalous.
53 Marliac and Gavaud, op. cit. 55, and personal communication from A. Marliac. Three thermoluminescence samples from the Tsanaga II site gave dates ranging from the 11th to 19th centuries a.d. but showed an unusually high level of inherent radioactivity. The M.A.S.C.A. laboratory of the University of Pennsylvania therefore has no confidence in the series, which should be ignored.
54 Connah, Graham, ‘The Daima sequence and the prehistoric chronology of the Lake Chad region of Nigeria’, J. Afr. Hist., xvii (1976), 321–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
55 The site covers several hectares. A 6 m.2 test excavation revealed the presence of a workshop area for the manufacture of stone axes but, as already seen in the case of Tsanaga II, such axes are not necessarily Neolithic. Batalimo was excavated by de Bayle des Hermens, R. and described by him in Recherches préhistoriques en République Centrafricaine (Paris, 1975).Google Scholar
56 David, N. and Vidal, P., ‘The Nana-Modé village site (Sous-Préfecture de Bouar, Central African Republic) and the prehistory of the Ubangian-speaking peoples”. W. Afr. J. Archaeol., vii (1977Google Scholar). forthcoming.
57 Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971), 368.Google Scholar
58 Posnansky, and McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976), 165.Google Scholar
59 Posnansky, and McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976), 171Google Scholar, and Sutton, J. E. G., ’Iron working around Zaria’, Zaria Archaeological Papers, viii (1976).Google Scholar
60 We are grateful to John Sutton for extensive comments on these dates.
61 Posnansky, & McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976), 165.Google Scholar
62 We are grateful to E. Effah-Gyamfi for information on this date.
63 Atherton, J., ‘Excavations at Kamabai and Yagala rock shelters, Sierra Leone’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., ii (1972), 39–74.Google Scholar
64 P. J. & Munson, C. A., ‘Nouveaux chars à boeufs rupestres du Dhar Tichit’, Notes africaines, cxxii (1969), 62–63.Google Scholar
65 We are grateful to Susan McIntosh for information and comments on the dates from this site.
66 Wai-Ogosu (now Andah), in Abebe, B.et al., Proceedings (1977).Google Scholar
67 Yamasaki, F., Hamada, C. & Hamada, T., ‘Riken natural radiocarbon measurements: IX’, Radiocarbon, xix (1977), 62–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
68 We are grateful to Bedaux, R. M. A. for information and comments on these and other dates and for his Tellem; een bijdrage tot de geschiednis van de Republiek Mali (Afrika Museum, Berg en Dal, 1977).Google Scholar
69 C. Descamps, ‘Le Sénégal de l'Age de la Pierre à l'Age des Métaux, L'Archéologie et l'Histoire en l'Afrique de l'Ouest, Documents pédagogiques audiovisuels (Paris, Audecam).
70 He defines the ‘protohistoric’ period (Descamps, Sénégal, 22Google Scholar) as lasting from the 1st millennium B.C. to the 10th to 14th centuries A.D.
71 Linares de Sapir, Olga, W. Afr. J. Archaeol. (1971).Google Scholar
72 Descamps, C., Thilmans, G. & Thommeret, Y., ‘Données sur l'édification de l'amas coquiller de Dioron Boumak (Sénégal)’, ASEQUA Bull. Liaison, 41 (1974), 67–83.Google Scholar
73 série, Diop III, Bull. IFAN, (1972), 688–90.Google Scholar
74 Elouard, P., Evin, J., Martin, V. & Becker, Ch., ‘Kjökkenmodding de Bangalère, Région de Saloum – Sénégal’, ASEQUA Bull. Liaison, xli (1974), 85–87,Google Scholar and Descamps, C.et al., ASEQUA Bull., 1974, 74.Google Scholar
75 C. A. Diop, ‘Méthodes utilisées au laboratoire’, in Abebe, B.et al., Proceedings (1977), 351–7Google Scholar, and Linares, O., W. Afr. J. Archaeol. (1971), 46.Google Scholar
76 Diop, , in Abebe et al., Proceedings, 354Google Scholar, and Elouard, P. et al. , ASEQUA Bull. (1974), 43.Google Scholar
77 série, Diop III, Bull. IFAN, (1972), 688.Google Scholar
78 série, Diop III, Bull. IFAN, 690Google Scholar, and Descamps, Sénégal, 27–9.Google Scholar
79 Joire, J., ‘Découvertes archéologiques dans la région de Rao (Bas-Sénégal)’, Bull. IFAN (sér. B), xvii (1955), 249–333Google Scholar. This article does not specify from which of the many tumuli excavated came the single ostrich egg found in the course of the excavations.
80 Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates II’, 1977, 161.Google Scholar
81 Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates II’, 1977, 161.Google Scholar
82 Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates II’, 1977, 161.Google Scholar
83 Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates II’, 1977, 161–2Google Scholar, and Descamps, Sénégal, 33.Google Scholar
84 Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates II’, 1977, 161.Google Scholar
85 Posnansky, and McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist., (1976), 182Google Scholar, and série, Diop III, Bull. IFAN (1972), 692–4Google Scholar, and Diop, , Méthodes (1976), 356–7Google Scholar, and Diop, , ‘Radiocarbon dates: II’ (1977), 162.Google Scholar
86 For present purposes we have made use of Robert's, D.S. summary, ‘Les fouilles de Tegdaoust’, J. Afr. Hist., xi (1970), 471–93,CrossRefGoogle Scholar and comments on the dates given in the listings.
87 série, Diop III, Bull. IFAN (1972), 691–2.Google Scholar
88 Flight, C. R., ‘Gao 1972: First Interim Report. A Preliminary Investigation of the Cemetery at Sané’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol. v (1975), 81–90,Google Scholar and ‘Gao 1974: Second Interim Report: Excavations in the Cemetery at Sané’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., forthcoming.
89 We thank R. M. A. Bedaux for dates and comments. See also Barth, H. K., ‘Zum Alter der Grab- und Siedlungshügel im Binnendelta des Niger, Mali’, Paideuma, xxii (1976), 231–5.Google Scholar
90 Mauny, Raymond, ‘Tableau géographique de l'Ouest africain au Moyen Age’ (Dakar, Paris, 1961), 524–5Google Scholar
91 We thank G. Liesegang for information and for his ‘Grabungen an eisenzeitlichen Fundstellen bei Dogo im süd-westlichen Mali (Westafrika) in den Jahren 1973 und 1974’, Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, sup p. III, 2 (1977), 1416–30.Google Scholar
92 We thank Wladyslaw Filipowiak for allowing us to make use of his ‘Chronology of Niani in radiocarbon dating’, W. Afr. J. Archaeol., ix (1980Google Scholar, forthcoming), in advance of publication.
93 Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971), 368–9.Google Scholar
94 R. M. A. Bedaux, op. cit., 77. The dates are not available to us at the time of writing.
95 Posnansky, M., ‘Debibi (Dapaa)’, Nyame Akuma, viii (1976), 26.Google Scholar
96 Ansah, J. Boachie, ‘Excavations at Bonoso and Ahwene Koko: a preliminary report’, Nyame Akuma, viii (1976), 27–31.Google Scholar
97 Ansah, J. Boachie, ‘Excavations’ (1976Google Scholar), and Daaku, K. Y., ‘A note on the fall of Ahwene Koko and its significance in Asante history’, Ghana Notes and Queries, x (1968), 40–44.Google Scholar
98 We are grateful to E. Effah-Gyamfi for information and comments on these dates.
99 See, for example, Ozanne, P. C., ‘Notes on the early historic archaeology of Accra’, Trans. Hist. Soc. Ghana, vi (1962), 51–70.Google Scholar
100 York, R. N., Mathewson, R. D., Calvocoressi, D. & Flight, C. R., ‘Archaeology in the Volta Basin, 1963–66’, Archaeology Dept., University of Ghana, 1967Google Scholar, and Davies, O., ‘Archaeology of the Flooded Volta Basin’, Archaeology Dept., University of Ghana, Occasional Paper i (1971).Google Scholar
101 Posnansky, M., ‘Early development of trade in West Africa’, Ghana Soc. Sci. Jl, ii (2) (1972), 87–100Google Scholar, and ‘Aspects of early West African trade’, World Archaeology, v (1973), 149–62.Google Scholar
102 Ozanne, , T. Hist. Soc. Ghana, (1962Google Scholar), and ‘Notes on the later pre-history of Accra’, J. Hist. Soc. Nigeria, iii (1) (1964), 3–24.Google Scholar
103 Ozanne, P. C., ‘Ladoku; an early town near Prampram’, Ghana Notes and Queries, vii (1964), 6–7.Google Scholar
104 We are grateful to J. Anquandah for information on these dates.
105 Ozanne, ., J. Hist. Soc. Nigeria, (1964).Google Scholar
106 Dombrowski, J., ‘A preliminary note on excavations at a shell midden near Tema, Ghana’, Nyame Akuma, x (1977), 31–4,Google Scholar and personal communication.
107 We are grateful to M. R. Talbot for this date.
108 Shaw, Thurstan, ‘Preliminary report on archaeological work carried out in the Wushishi area, Dec. 1975 to March 1976’, Nyame Akuma, ix (1976), 35–7,Google Scholar gives a brief account of the first season's work at Rafin Ndoko. We are grateful to Professor Shaw for further information on these dates and on those from Kongon Makeri. There are disagreements between the series of dates processed by the Teledyne Isotopes and Rikagaku laboratories.
109 There are again differences between the results of the two laboratories.
110 Fagan, B. M., ‘Radiocarbon dates for sub-Saharan Africa: VI’, J. Afr. Hist., x (1969), 149–69,CrossRefGoogle Scholar and Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971Google Scholar), and Posnansky, & McIntosh, , J. Afr. Hist. (1976).Google Scholar
111 Willett, F. and Fleming, S. J., ‘A catalogue of important Nigerian copper-alloy castings dated by thermoluminescence’, Archaeometry, xviii (1976), 135–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Dates are calculated from a ‘present’ of 1975.
112 The last of these is believed by Willett to be contaminated.
113 Thermoluminescence dates for the terracotta sculpture and the associated pottery have been published in an earlier survey (Willett, , J. Afr. Hist. (1971), 367Google Scholar), but have been modified because of incorrect application of dose absorption factors arising from water retention in the clay fabric's pores; Willett, & Fleming, , Archaeometry (1976), 138.Google Scholar
114 We are grateful to Omotoso Eluyemi for information on these dates.
115 Willett, & Fleming, , Archaeometry (1976), 139.Google Scholar
116 Bradbury, R. E., ‘Chronological problems in the study of Benin history’, J. Hist. Soc. Nigeria, i (1959), 263.Google Scholar
117 Fagg, W. B., Divine Kingship in Africa (British Museum, 1970).Google Scholar
118 A short account of some of the work at Old Oyo is given in Soper, R., ‘Archaeological research at Old Oyo’, Nyame Akuma, xi (1977), 37–8Google Scholar. We are grateful to Robert Soper for further information.
119 We are grateful to Dr F. N. Anozie for information on there dates.
120 We are grateful to Dr V. E. Chikwendu for information on these dates.
121 We thank Alain Marliac for these dates and the following references: Delibrias, G., Muller, J.-P., Paris, F. & Siefferman, G., ‘Datation par la méthode du C14 d'un volcan situé près de Foumbot (Ouest-Cameroun) et du rajeunissement géomorphologique de cette région’, Communication au Colloque géomorphologique volcanique (Paris, 1975), andGoogle Scholar A. Marliac, ‘Prospections dessites néolithiques et postnéolithiques au Diamaré (Cameroun)’, Cah. O.R.S.T.O.M. (Sci. Hum.), à paraître.
122 See footnote 45. Another sample which gave a modern reading is presumably either contaminated or does not relate to the ancient copper workings, see série, Diop III, 1972, 696.Google Scholar
123 Lhote, H., ‘Datations par le carbone 14 de differents sites anciens de l'Aïr’, Notes africaines, clii (1976), 95Google Scholar, and ‘Nouvelle contribution à l'histoire des Sultans de l'Aïr’, Notes africaines, cxii. viii (1975), 102–109.Google Scholar
124 We are grateful to M. R. Talbot for these dates and comments.
125 série, Diop III, 1972, 696, andGoogle ScholarGado, B., ‘Tradition orale et archéologie: Introduction à la connaissance des sites archéologiques de la vallée du moyen-Niger’ (I.R.S.H., Université de Niamey, 1977Google Scholar, Mimeo).
126 Murdock, G. P., ‘Africa: Its People and Their Culture History (New York, 1959), p. 73.Google Scholar