Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T07:25:57.088Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Judicial Regulation and Administrative Control: Customary Law and the Nuer, 1898–1954

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Douglas H. Johnson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Administrative commitment to customary law among the Nuer wavered under British rule. Its value was first briefly appreciated as a means of obtaining the effective submission of the people to government authority. By igio dissatisfaction with the rate of progress of submission led provincial officials to abandon active involvement in the settlement of internal disputes among the Nuer, but in doing so they ceased to have any real contact with the peoples they tried to govern. Withdrawal from settlement of internal cases made it impossible for administrators to arbitrate external disputes between the Nuer and their neighbours. In the 1920s government supervision of the settlement of disputes once again became a central part of administrative policy, and by the end of that decade customary law and leaders were subordinated to government control. Innovations from the 1920s to the 1940s were concerned mainly with procedure and enforcement. By the last decade of Anglo-Egyptian rule in the Sudan the administration of law had become the main function of Nuer administration, and reforms in the legal procedure meant reforms in the administrative structure.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 27 , Issue 1 , March 1986 , pp. 59 - 78
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Coriat, P., ‘Notes on a paper on the Nuer read by Mr. D. [sic] Evans-Pritchard’, 1931, National Records Office, Khartoum [NRO], Dakhlia I 112/13/87Google Scholar; Howell, P. P., A Manual of Nuer Law (London, 1954), 2.Google Scholar

2 Howell, , Nuer Law, 2, 27.Google Scholar

3 Such a study is currently being undertaken by Sharon Hutchinson.

4 Evans-Pritchard, Cf. E. E., The Nuer (Oxford, 1940), 150–176,Google Scholar and Nuer Religion (Oxford, 1956), 107–112, 165–173, 293–200Google Scholar; Howell, , Nuer Law, passimGoogle Scholar; Corfield, F. D., ‘Note on the origin of native authority among the Nuer with particular reference to the Jekany Dor’, 1935, NRO UNP 1/51/4Google Scholar; Alban, A. H. A., ‘Note on the indigenous basis of the present administrative system’, 26, 1935, Southern Records Office, Juba [SRO] UNP 32.B.I.Google Scholar

5 Evans-Pritchard, , Nuer Religion, 109.Google Scholar

6 Evans-Pritchard, , The Nuer, 163–164.Google Scholar

7 O'sullivan, H. E. D., ‘Dinka laws and customs’, J. Royal Anthropological Inst., XL (1910), passimGoogle Scholar; Jackson, H. C., ‘The Nuer of the Upper Nile Province’, Sudan Notes and Records [SNR], vi, i (1923), 100.Google ScholarHowell, ( Nuer Law, 26) doubts that this was the case in homicide compensation.Google Scholar

8 Johnson, D. H., ‘Tribal boundaries and border wars: Nuer-Dinka relations in the Sobat and Zaraf valleys, c. 1860–1976’, Afr. Hist., xxiii (1982), 187–189.Google Scholar

9 Johnson, D. H., ‘The fighting Nuer: primary sources and the origins of a stereotype’, Africa, LI, i (1981), 514–516.Google Scholar

10 W. L. Sherratt, A/DC Zeraf Valley District to the governor, Malakal, 2 Nov. 1935, SRO UNP 32.B.I.

11 Johnson, , ‘Tribal boundaries and border wars’, 189–190.Google Scholar

12 H. E. D. O'Sullivan, ‘Lau Nuers, 1906’ in D. H. Johnson (ed.), Conquering the Nuer: Documents in the Pacification of the Southern Sudan (forthcoming).

13 Warburg, G., The Sudan under Wingate (London, 1971), ch. 7.Google Scholar

14 Ibid., 133–136.

15 O'Sullivan, , ‘Lau Nuers’, and ‘Dinka laws and customs’, 175.Google Scholar

16 Sudan Intelligence Report [SIR] 72 (July-August 1900), 2.

17 Blewitt, , quoted in Johnson, D. H., ‘Ngundeng and the “Turuk”: two narratives compared’, History in Africa, ix (1982), 124–125.Google Scholar

18 Matthews, G. E., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1902’, Reports on the Finance, Administration and Condition of the Sudan [hereinafter GGR], 1902, 346Google Scholar; ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1908’, GGR 1908, 665.

19 Matthews, G. E., ‘Note on the Nuer question’, SIR 120 (July 1904), Appendix C., 7.Google Scholar

20 Matthews, G. E., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1905’, GGR 1905, 151Google Scholar; Cameron, A. to Wilson, H. H., 9 May 1905, SIR 130 (May 1905), App. B., 6Google Scholar; Matthews, G. E., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1906’, GGR 1906, 727.Google Scholar

21 H. H. Wilson, ‘Report by El Kaimakam H. H. Wilson Bey on a march from the Sobat (mouth of the Filus) to Bor’, 1905; G. E. Matthews, ‘Report on journey up the Zeraf valley to visit Nuer chief Diu’, 1907, and K. C. P. Struvé, ‘Report on administrative boundaries between the Twi Dinkas and Nuers (Mongalla and Upper Nile Province)’, all in Johnson, Conquering the Nuer.

22 Struve, ‘Report on administrative boundaries’.

23 Matthews, , ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1908’, 663.Google Scholar

24 Johnson, , ‘Tribal boundaries and border wars’, 191–198.Google Scholar

25 P. Coriat, A/DC Lau to governor Upper Nile Province, 30 June 1926; DC Bor to DC Lau Nuer, 7 April 1936, both in SRO BD 66.8.3.

26 Woodward, F. W., ‘Annual report, Upper Nile Province, 1911’, GGR 1911, vol. 2, 247Google Scholar; Willis, C. A., ‘Handing over notes’, 12 March 1931,Google Scholar NRO Civsec 57/2/8.

27 A. H. Alban, DC Pibor to DC Bor, 26 November 1941, SRO BD 66.8.3.

28 See above, note 19.

29 Matthews, ‘Report on journey up the Zeraf valley to visit Nuer chief Diu’.

30 O'Sullivan, ‘Lau Nuers’.

31 Angus Cameron could report some thirty cases of bridewealth heard during a visit to the Khor Fullus Dinka (Cameron to Wilson, SIR 130 (May 1905), Appendix B). Woodward complained that on a tour of the Sobat Nuer he was able to hear only two cases, but he really heard the same case twice (Woodward, ‘Report on patrol in the Nuer country’, SIR 153 (April 1907) Appendix A.)

32 Matthews, , ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1905’, 149Google Scholar; ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1906’, 725.

33 Matthews, , ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1907, GGR 1907, 408Google Scholar; ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1908’, 664; Struvé, K. C. P., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1909’, GGR 1909, 801.Google Scholar

34 O'Sullivan, , ‘Dinka laws and customs’, 175.Google Scholar

35 Struvé, , ‘Annual Report. Upper Nile Province, 1909’, 801.Google Scholar

36 O'Sullivan, ‘Lau Nuers’.

37 Matthews, , ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1906’, 727–728Google Scholar; ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1907’, 402.

38 Woodward, F. W., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1911’, 247.Google Scholar

39 C. H. Stigand to inspector, Nasser, 18 May 1918, Nasir office archives ENRC 66.A/2.

40 F. W. Woodward to Civil Secretary, 28 Oct. 1913, NRO UNP 1/12/101.

41 C. H. Stigand, ‘Report on Sobat valley Nuer’, May 1916, in Johnson, Conquering the Nuer.

42 Intelligence Department, ‘Note on military action and administration in the Nuer country’, 23 Nov. 1927, NRO Dakhlia 112/13/87.

43 For surveys of the development of native courts in the Sudan see: Cooke, B. K., ‘Native administration in practice: historical outline’, in Hamilton, J. A. Dec. (ed.), The Anglo-Egyptian Sudan from Within (London, 1935)Google Scholar; Nuer, M. I. El, ‘The role of the native courts in the administration of justice in the Sudan’, SNR, XLI (1960)Google Scholar; Collins, R. O., Shadows in the Grass (New Haven, 1983), 53–62, 101–104.Google Scholar

44 Hamilton, J. A. Dec., ‘Devolutionary principles of native administration’, in Hamilton, (ed.), The Anglo-Egyptian Sudan from Within, 181–186.Google Scholar

45 ‘Policy of the Southern Sudan’, Civil Secretary to governor, Upper Nile Province, 1922, SRO UNP 66.E.4. The language is essentially that of ‘General statement of the policy in the Southern Sudan with regards to administration, religion and education’, 14 March 1927, NRO Civsec 1/9/31, quoted in Collins, 58.

46 Governor, Upper Nile Province, to Civil Secretary, 18 Feb. 1929, NRO UNP 1/44/329.

47 Struvé, K. C. P., ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1925’, Reports of Governors of Provinces for the Year 1925 (Khartoum, 1926), 414Google Scholar; Coriat, , ‘Notes on a paper on the Nuer’. Cf. also Johnson, ‘The fighting Nuer’, 514.Google Scholar

48 K. C. P. Struvé to Civil Secretary, 2 December 1922, NRO Civsec 1/2/6, and ‘Annual Report. Upper Nile Province, 1925’, 414.

49 Sudan Monthly Intelligence Report 343 (February 1923), 4.

50 Coriat, P., ‘The Gaweir Nuers’ (Khartoum, n.d. [1923]), 6–7.Google Scholar

51 Ibid., passim.

52 Percy Coriat, A/DC Lau, to governor Upper Nile Province, 30 June 1926, SRO BD 66.8.3.

53 ‘Précis of information concerning Gwep [sic] of Dengkur’, January 1921, NRO Dakhlia I 112/13/87; H. C. Jackson to Butts, 1927, in Johnson, Conquering the Nuer; Governor Upper Nile Province to senior inspector, 17 Jan. 1921, SRO UNP SCR 14.

54 K. C. P. Struve to Civil Secretary, 2 Dec. 1922, NRO Civsec 1/2/6.

55 Struve, ‘Annual report. Upper Nile Province, 1925’, 414–415.Google Scholar

56 Johnson, D. H., ‘C. A. Willis and the “Cult of Deng”: a falsification of the ethno-graphic record’, History in Africa, XII (1985).Google Scholar

57 P. Coriat, ‘General report. Patrol S8 (Lau Nuer) 1928’, in Johnson, Conquering the Nuer.

58 Howell, , Nuer Law, 2–3.Google Scholar

59 C. Armine Willis, governor Upper Nile Province, 20 April 1928, Nasir office archives, END I.F.I&2, vol. I.

60 Evans-Pritchard, E. E., ‘The Nuer: tribe and clan’, SNR, xvii, i (1934) 37–57; xviii, i (1935).Google Scholar

61 Jackson, H. C., ‘The Nuer of the Upper Nile Province’Google Scholar; Coriat, , ‘The Gaweir Nuers’.Google Scholar

62 Corfield, F. D., ‘Note on the origin of native authority among the Nuer’Google Scholar; W. L. Sherratt, A/DC Zeraf Valley District to governor Malakal, 2 Nov. 1935; Winder, J., ‘Note on the evolution of policy in regard to chiefs, sub-chiefs & headmen’, 1942, Nasir office archives, END I.F.I & 2 vol. iGoogle Scholar; Alban, A. H. A., ‘Note on the indigenous basis of the present administrative system’Google Scholar; Coriat, P., ‘Western Nuer District’, 1931,Google Scholar NRO Civsec 57/2/8.

63 Corfield, ‘Note on the origin of native authority among the Nuer’; Sherratt to governor Malakal, 2 Nov. 1935; Upper Nile Province Diary February-April 1935, January 1936, SRO BD 57-C.I; Coriat, P., ‘Southern (Abwong) District. Handing over notes’, 6 May 1929, Mss, Coriat., Rhodes House, OxfordGoogle Scholar; Coriat, P., ‘Western Nuer District’Google Scholar; [Romilly?] ‘Report Western Nuer 1929–1934’, Nasir office archives, END 66.A.I; ‘Nuer District Commissioners' Meeting, February 1st 1943’, (draft minutes), P. P. Howell, private papers.

64 Winder, ‘Note on the evolution of policy’. This system was extended to all Nuer districts, and the terminology was standardized only after the 1943 Nuer District Commissioners' meeting.

65 Howell, , Nuer Law, 37.Google Scholar

66 ‘Lou Nuer District. Handing over notes of Mr P. L. Roussel’, (1954), SRO LND 48.A.2; Roussel, P. L., ‘Some difficulties facing the establishment of local government among the Nuer people of the Sudan, with special reference to the Zeraf Island Rural District Council’, essay for Certificate of Public Administration [c. 1955], Tylor Library, Institute of Social Anthropology Oxford, PS.IV.F.2C.Google Scholar

67 Alban, ‘Note on the indigenous basis of the present administrative system’.

68 J. D. Tierney, A/DC Eastern District to the governor Malakal, 21 March 1932, NRO Dakhlia I 1/2/6; Corfield, , ‘Note on the origin of native authority among the Nuer’Google Scholar; Alban, , ‘Note on the indigenous basis of the present administrative system’Google Scholar; Sherratt to governor, 2 Nov. 1935.

69 Tierney to the governor, 21 March 1932; Alban, ‘Note on the indigenous basis of the present administrative system’; ‘Nuer District Commissioners Meetings, February 1st-5th 1943’, NRO Civsec 66/13/137.

70 ‘Extract from Zeraf Rural District Council Meeting held on 25.3.51’, SRO BD 66.8.3 (II).

71 Howell, , Nuer Law, 36–37.Google Scholar

72 Ibid., 231.

73 J. Winder, ‘Some aspects of the administration of the Nuer tribes in the Zeraf District of the Upper Nile Province of the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, 1938–42’, March 1978 (unpublished).

74 Howell, P. P., ‘A comparative study of customary law among cattle owning tribes in the Southern Sudan’ (D. Phil, thesis, Oxford University, 1949), ix.Google Scholar

75 Ibid., vii.

76 Howell, , Nuer Law, 27,Google Scholar and ‘A comparative study’, xvi-xvii.

77 Howell, , Nuer Law, 231.Google Scholar

78 Howell, , ‘A comparative study’, 636.Google Scholar

79 ‘The elders have cut the case, but people have not yet looked’, Godfrey Lienhardt, personal communication.

80 Lienhardt, R. G., ‘Getting your own back: themes in Nilotic myth’, in Beattie, J. H. M. & Lienhardt, R. G. (eds.), Studies in Social Anthropology (Oxford, 1975), 218–220.Google Scholar

81 Ibid., 217.

82 ‘Nuer district commissioners' meeting’, (draft minutes); Bazett Lewis to Paul Howell, 21.12.42, P. P. Howell, private papers.

83 DC Bor to DC Lau Nuer, 7 April 1936, SRO BD 66.8.3; DC Zeraf District to governor Upper Nile Province, 9 March 1940; ‘Report on tribal meeting held at Fangak between 27.8.41 & 3.9.41’; DC Western Nuer to governor Upper Nile Province, 12 March 1942; ‘Record of Dinka chiefs meetings held at Fangak on June 22–30 1942’, all in SRO UNP 66.G.3/3; Upper Nile Province Monthly Diary, March 1936, SRO BD 57.C.I.

84 Howell, , ‘A comparative study’, 653.Google Scholar

85 ‘Nuer district commissioners' meetings, February 1st-5th, 1943’, NRO Civsec 66/13/137, and ‘Nuer district commissioners' meeting’, (draft minutes).

86 B. A. Lewis, ‘The Nuer political problem’, December 1944, SRO UNP 66.G.3/3.

87 Extract from private letter from Mr B. A. Lewis to Mr J. W. Robertson, dated 17 July 1944, NRO Civsec 66/13/137.

88 Lienhardt, Godfrey, ‘The Sudan - Aspects of the South: Government among some of the Nilotic peoples, 1947–1952’, Journal of the Anthropological Society of Oxford, xii, iii (1981), 193–196.Google Scholar

89 Roussel, ‘Some difficulties facing the establishment of local government among the Nuer’.