Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T19:12:16.688Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Dynasties of the Mutapa-Rozwi Complex

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Edward A. Alpers
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The two most obvious conclusions to be drawn from this material are that interlocking relationships and reasonably accurate dating are most reliably established for the very early and the very recent periods. The eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, in particular, seem to be a period of confusion. Even in the best of circumstances this result might reasonably be expected as a consequence of the telescoping of events in a coherent body of genealogical evidence. In this instance, coincidentally, the hiatus in knowledge from traditional sources corresponds to a parallel decline in contemporary Portuguese knowledge of the region. More positively, on the basis of Abraham's scattered notes, there does seem to be a solid base line linking the ‘princely’ dynasties which were established in the eastern part of this zone to the parent Mwene Mutapa dynasty. The mfekane, too, constitutes a major point of reference in a great many of the traditions analysed above. If more dynastic traditions and genealogies can be systematically collected, evaluated, and published for the Mutapa–Rozwi complex, the original goal of this inquiry may yet be fulfilled.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 11 , Issue 2 , April 1970 , pp. 203 - 220
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For a more detailed outline of the historical development of these States, see Ranger, T. O. (ed.), Aspects of Central African History (London, 1968), 1–17112–53.Google Scholar

2 See, for example, George, McCall Theal, Records of South-Eastern Africa, 9 vols. (London, 1898–1903);Google ScholarDocumentos sobre os Portugueses em Moçambique e na África Central, 1497–1840/Documents on the Portuguese in Mozambique and Central Africa, 1497–1840, 4 vols. (Lisboa, 1962–), in progress.Google Scholar

3 Roger, Summers, Zimbabwe—A Rhodesian Mystery (Cape Town, 1963),Google Scholar is an excellent guide to both the findings and bibliography of the relevant archaeological research, as is Brian, M. Fagan, Southern Africa during the Iron Age (London, 1965).Google Scholar For an important recent addition to the existing literature, see Garlake, P. S., ‘The value of imported ceramics in the dating and interpretation of the Rhodesian Iron Age’, J. Afr. Hist. IX, no.2 (1968), 13–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Abraham, D. P., ‘The Monomotapa dynasty’, NADA, 36 (1959), 59–86.Google Scholar

5 Abraham, , ‘The early political history of the kingdom of Mwene Mutapa (850–1589)’, in Historians in Tropical Africa, Proceedings of the Leverhulme Inter-Collegiate History Conference (Salisbury, 1962), 61–91;Google Scholar ‘Maramuca: an exercise in the combined use of Portuguese records and oral tradition’, J. Afr. Hist. II, no. 2 (1961), 211–25;Google Scholar ‘Ethnohistory of the empire of Mutapa: problems and methods’, in Vansina, J., Mauny, R. and Thomas, L. V. (eds.), The Historian in Tropical Africa (London, 1964), 104–126;Google Scholar ‘Tasks in the field of early history’, in Conference of the History of the Central African Peoples (Lusaka, 1963), unpaginated; ‘The roles of “Chaminuka” and the Mhondoro-cults in Shona political history’,Google Scholar in ric, Stokes and Richard, Brown (eds.), The Zambesian Past— Studies in Central African History (Manchester, 1966), 28–46;Google ScholarSmith, H. Stanford, ‘Monomotapas’, NADA, 35 (1958), 84-6.Google Scholar

6 Abraham, , ‘Early political history’, 67; Antònio Pinto de Miranda, ‘Memòria sobre a Costa de África (c. 1766)’,Google Scholar in Antònio, Alberto de Andrade, Relaçōes de Moçambique Setecentista (Lisboa, 1955), 303.Google Scholar

7 Abraham, , ‘Maramuca’, 253–14.Google Scholar

8 Abraham, ‘Chaminuka’, 43, n. 3, cont. 44.

9 Eric, Axelson, Portuguese in South-East Africa, 1600–1700 (Johannesburg, 1960).Google Scholar

10 Abraham, , ‘Early political history’, 86, n. 60.Google Scholar

11 Abraham, , ‘Monomotapa Dynasty’, 82.Google Scholar

12 Ibid. 81; Fritz, Hoppe, Portugiesisch-Ostafrika in der Zeit des Marquês de Pombal (1750–1777) (Berlin, 1965), 282, n. 249. See also Miranda's reference (c. 1766) that a certain Goniavazi s/o Chicoca was one of the two powers supporting the reigning Mwene Mutapa Zeze (?Dehwe, d. 1759)Google Scholar in Andrade, , Relaçōes, 305.Google Scholar

13 Filipe, Gastão de Almeida de Eça, Història das Guerras no Zambeze, I (Lisboa, 1953), 393 and 395, 82, 115–16. Antònio Norberto de Barbosa de Vilasboas Truão was installed as Captain of the Rivers of Sena at Moçambique Island in August 1803 and arrived at Sena in February 1804.Google Scholar

14 Francisco, Santana (ed.), Documentação Avulsa Moçambicana do Arquivo Històrico Ultramarino, II (Lisboa, 1967), 443.Google Scholar

15 Ibid., I (Lisboa, 1964), 518–19, 726–7, 922; ibid., 11, 330, 572, 649, 650.

16 Abraham, , ‘Monomotapa dynasty’, 82.Google Scholar

17 Almeida, de Eça, Guerras, 1, 256;Google ScholarDavid, Livingstone, Missionary Researches and Travels in South Africa… (New York, 1858), 660, 671, 687.Google Scholar

18 Posselt, F. W. T., Fact and Fiction (Bulawayo, 1935), 144–51;Google ScholarSmith, ,‘Monomotapas’.Google Scholar

19 Nenguwo, S., ‘Oral work among the Rozvi: a few notes’, in Couf. Hist. C. Afr. Peoples, at 3.Google Scholar

20 See above, note 6, in Mwene Mutapa tie-ups.

21 Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 145.Google Scholar

22 Fortune, G., ‘A Rozvi text with translation and notes’ NADA, 33 (1956), 73,Google Scholar n. B; Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 145;Google ScholarHarald, van Sicard, ‘The Dumbuscya’, NADA, IX, 5 (1968), 22.Google Scholar

23 Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 145.Google Scholar

24 Abraham, , ‘Chaminuka,’ 42, n. I; 43, n. I and n. 3, cont. on 44.Google Scholar

25 Antònio, Rita-Ferreira, Agrupamento e caracterização étnica dos Indígenas de Moçambique (Lisboa, 1958), 46;Google ScholarAbraham, , ‘Early political history’, 82, n. 41 a; 84, n. 47.Google Scholar

26 Rita-Ferreira, , Agrupamento, 46;Google ScholarSantana, , Documentação, II, 215, 218, 222, 386–7.Google Scholar

27 Abraham, , ‘Early political history’, 67.Google Scholar

28 Axelson, , Portuguese, 186.Google Scholar

29 Gerhard, J. Liesegang, Beiträge zur Gesehithte des Reiches der Gaza Nguni im südlichen Moçambique, 1820–1895 (Cologne, 1968), 29, 186, no. 72–75.Google Scholar

30 Historical Archive of Goa, Panjim, Còdice 2323, fo. 85 r, Viceroy to King of Quiteve, Goa, 20 January 1736.

31 Liesegang, , Gaza Nguni, 28; see also Santana, , Documentação, 11, 215–16, 974, regarding the death of Jica, c. 1829, and the accession of Charinga in 1830.Google Scholar

32 Liesegang, , Gaza Nguni,Google Scholar 50; see also Santana, , Documentação, II, 216.Google Scholar

33 See, for example, Liesegang, , Gaza Nguni, 26–7.Google Scholar

34 Abraham, , ‘Early political history’, 67, 84, n. 47.Google Scholar

35 See Ranger, , ‘Revolt in Portuguese East Africa: the Makombe rising of 1917’, in Kirkwood, K. (ed.), St Antony's Papers, XV (London, 1963), 54–80.Google Scholar

36 João, de Azevedo Coutinho, ‘Noticia historica sobre o Barué’, Portugal em Africa, x, 115 (1903), 400–4;Google Scholarvan, Sicard, ‘The Rhodesian tally’, NADA, 31 (1954 52–4).Google Scholar

37 Caetano, Montez, ‘Documentos para a Història de Moçambique: Coroação de Um Rei do BÁruè em 1811’, Moçambique, XXVII (1941), 119Google Scholar see also Santana, , Documentação, II, 329, 346.Google Scholar

38 Abraham, ‘Tasks,’ 4, and ‘Early political history’, 65, 66, 82, n. 38.

39 Abraham, ‘Tasks’, 10, n. 33.

40 Montez, , ‘Documentos’, 118; Santana, Documentação, II, 445–7.Google Scholar

41 Arquivo Històrico Ultramarino, Lisboa, Moçambique, Caixa 66, José Francisco Alves Barbosa to João da Costa de Brito Sanches, [Tete,] 21 Sebtember 1820.

42 Santana, , Documentação, I, 329, 344, 346, 903;Google ScholarAlmeida, de Eça, Guerras, I, 279, 282, 284;Google ScholarLiesegang, , Gaza Nguni, 199–200, n. 214.Google Scholar

43 Coutinho, , ‘Noticia historica’, 400–1.Google Scholar

44 Van, Sicard, ‘Rhodesian tally’, 54, n. 30.Google Scholar

45 Coutinho, , ‘Noticia historica’, 400, 403–4.Google Scholar

46 Abraham, , ‘Early political history’, 83, n. 44.Google Scholar

47 Baker, R. H., ‘The Mutasa and Makoni dynasties’, NADA, 2 (1924), 85–7.Google Scholar

48 Posselt, , ‘The Banyemba legend and ceremony’, NADA, 2 (1924), 11–13.Google Scholar

49 Personal communication from Hazel Carter.

50 This paragraph is based upon Abraham, , ‘The principality of Maungwe: its history and traditions’, NADA, 28 (1951), 56–83.Google Scholar

51 This sequence conflicts with that given for the Rozwi–Changamire dynasty, which places the ‘Shangwa’ drought before Zwangendaba's invasion. See above, note 10.

52 Both Mutasa Mudyembewa and Matidya appear in Baker's geneaology.

53 Cf. the Manyika version of this problem cited above.

54 Abraham, , ‘Maungwe’, 56,Google Scholar citing Antònio, Bocarro, Década XIII da Historia da India (Lisboa, 1876).Google Scholar

55 Abraham, , ‘Chaminuka’, 43, n I.Google Scholar

56 This assumes, of course, that Abraham's account is completely uninfluenced by Edwards's: Edwards, W., ‘The Wanoe: a short historical sketch’, NADA, 4 (1926), 13–28.Google Scholar

57 Cf.Chibambo, Yesaya M., My Ngoni of Nyasaland, trans. Stuart, C. (London, 1942), 15.Google Scholar

58 Liesegang, , Gaza Nguni, 171.Google Scholar

59 Edwards, , ‘Wanoe’, 16.Google Scholar

60 Holleman, J. F., ‘Some “Shona” tribes of Southern Rhodesia’, in Colson, E. and Gluckman, M. (eds.), Seven Tribes of British Central Africa (Manchester, 1951), 382–3, n. 2.Google Scholar

61 Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 35–6.Google Scholar

62 Holleman, , ‘Shona’, 380–1.Google Scholar

63 Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 35–6; cf. the previously cited tie-ups in Mangwende tradition.Google Scholar

64 Chidziwa, J., ‘History of the Vashawasha’, NADA, 9, I (1964), 26;Google ScholarSeed, J. H., ‘A glimpse of native history: the Vashawasha”, NADA, 14 (1936–1937), 5–16.Google Scholar

65 Edwards, ‘Wanoe’, 16, indicates a short reign for this chief, c. 1878–9.

66 Chidziwa, , ‘Vashawasha’, 31.Google Scholar

67 Posselt, , Fact and Fiction, 22–3;Google ScholarTizerai, P., ‘The story of the Chilimanzi people’, NADA, 26 (1949), 36–8;Google ScholarMary, Aquina, ‘The tribes in Chilimanzi Reserve and their relation to the Rozvi’, NADA, 9, 2 (1965), 40–51.Google Scholar

68 Tizerai, , ‘Chilimanzi’, 38.Google Scholar Smith, ‘Monomotapas’, notes an early eighteenth-century (no. 3) and an early nineteenth-century (no. 13) Dhlembewu, niether of whom is succeeded by a Chikore; but Robinson, K. R., ‘A history of the Bikita district’, NADA, 34 (1957), 81, includes a Dhlembewu Chikore among the Rozwi chiefs of Bikita District.Google Scholar

69 Aquina, , ‘Tibes’, 42.Google ScholarSmith, , ‘Monomotapas’, includes a Baswi Gumboremvura (no. 10) and two Mutinhimas (nos. 11, 15) in his haphazard list.Google Scholar

70 Franklin, H., ‘“Nyaningwe”: notes on the Chibi family’, NADA, 6 (1928), 80–7;Google ScholarSeymour, L. F., ‘The tradition of the Va Mare of Chibi’, NADA, 17 (1950),73–6.Google Scholar See also Tagwireyi, J. H., ‘Origin of the Vamari clan’, NADA, 2 (1950), 63-6.Google Scholar

71 Franklin, , ‘Nyaningwe’, 82.Google Scholar

72 François, Coillard, On the Threshold of Central Africa, trans. Mackintosh, C. W. (London, 1897), 32. Franklin, ‘Nyaningwe’, 83, identifies this Chibi as Matsero.Google Scholar

73 Fagan, , ‘The Greefswald sequence: Bambandyanalo and Mapungubwe’, J. Afr. Hist. V, no. 3 (1964), 358.Google Scholar

74 Stayt, H. A., The Bavenda (London, 1931);Google Scholarvan Warmelo, N. J. (ed.), Contributions towards Venda History, Religion and Tribal Ritual (Pretoria, 1950);Google Scholar G. P. Lestrade, ‘Some notes on the ethnic history of the Uhavenda and their Rhodesian affinities’, in ibid. See also van Warmelo (ed.), The Copper Miners of Musina and the Early History of the Zoutpansberg (Pretoria, 1940).

75 Lestrade, , ‘Some notes on the political organization of the Venda-Speaking tribes’,Google Scholar in van, Warmelo, Contributions; Stayt, Bavenda, 195–96, 208–9;Google ScholarWarmelo, van, Contributions, 6–7;Google ScholarWessman, R., The Bawenda of tile Spelonken, trs. Weinthal, L. (London, 1908), 13.Google Scholar

76 Van, Warmelo, Contributions, 6–7,Google Scholar II; Monica, Wilson and Leonard, Thompson (eds.), The Oxford History of South Africa, I (New York, 1969), 440–2.Google Scholar

77 E. J., and Krige, J. D., The Realm of a Rain-Queen (London, 1943), 8–10, 308.Google Scholar

77 Ibid. 5–6; cf. above, note 5. The tradition of stealing the rain-charm from the great mambo recurs in at least one other regional charter myth. See Meredith, L. C., ‘The rain spirit of Mabota Murangadzwa, Melsetter district”, NADA, 3 77–81;Google ScholarPosselt, , ‘The story of the Princess Mepo’, NADA, 7 (1929), 115–17.Google Scholar

79 Jan, Vansina, Oral Tradition—A Study in Historical Methodology (London, 1965), 153.Google Scholar