Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T04:34:08.722Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Quality of Liquor in Nigeria During the Colonial Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 June 2011

Simon Heap
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Nigerian liquor trade provoked fierce debate: was it advancing development or fashioning an economy based on the unproductive consumption of alcohol? The liquor trade was caught between two prevailing colonial perspectives on African economic development: the Darwinian-based principle that Western civilisation had a duty to protect Africans from all bad external influences, and the civilise-through-trade concept seeking to modernise Africans by exploiting colonies to their fullest potential. Humanitarian concerns and economic interests were entangled. Positive views of the liquor trade claimed its necessity in developing the Nigerian economy. Some admitted that the trade formed a necessary evil, but did not fail to emphasise its role as a transitional currency, promoter of cash-crops-forexport, and a desirable commodity among those with money to spend. Merchants saw commerce as a great civilising agent, with the liquor trade as its most important constituent. On the other hand, liquor trade critics used the temperance equation to further their cause: drinking alcohol was bad, abstinence was good. Arguing that the imposition of ‘a Rum and Gin Civilization’ would be ‘a hydra that devours the natives’, halting useful commerce and hindering economic development, they agitated for Prohibition and a complete restructuring of the colonial economy along alcoholfree lines.

Type
Articles
Information
Itinerario , Volume 23 , Issue 2 , July 1999 , pp. 29 - 47
Copyright
Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Heap, S., ‘Alcohol in Africa: A Supplementary List of Post-1875 Literature’, A Current Bibliography on African Affairs 26/1 (1994-1995) 1–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Olukoju, A., ‘Rotgut and Revenue: Fiscal Aspects of the Liquor Trade in Southern Nigeria, 1890-1919’, Itinerario 21/2 (1997) 66–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar The revenue question is examined in Heap, ‘Living on the Proceeds of a Grog Shop: Liquor Revenue in Colonial Nigeria’ in: Bryceson, D. and Tellegen, N. eds, Alcohol in Africa: Mixing Business, Pleasure and Politics with Culture (Leiden 1999, in press)Google Scholar.

3 , Heap, ‘The Liquor Trade and the Nigerian Economy, 1880-1939’ (PhD-thesis, University of lbadan 1995).Google Scholar

4 Heap, , ‘The Impact of the Transport Revolution on the Market Economy of the Liquor Trade in Nigeria during the Colonial Era’, Journal of Transport History 20/1 (1999, in press).Google Scholar

5 ‘The Report of the Liquor Traffic Commission’, Lagos Weekly Record, 18 December 1909, 2-3. Also, Ambler, C.H., ‘Alcohol and Disorder in Pre-Colonial Africa’, Boston University African Studies Center Working Paper 126 (1987) 14Google Scholar.

6 ‘The Importation of Ardent Spirits into the Colony’, Lagos Times and Gold Coast Advertiser, 13 April 1881, 2.

7 ‘The Quality of the West African Trade Spirits’, Lagos Weekly Record, 13 August 1910, 2.

8 Aborigines' Protection Society, ‘Poison for Africans’, Poisoning of Africa 1 (1895) 1.Google Scholar

9 Native Races and Liquor Traffic United Committee (NRLTUC), Speech of the Right Reverend Bishop Tugwell at the Annual Meeting of the NRLTUC, 7 May 1908 (London 1908) 6.Google Scholar

10 Public Record Office, London (PRO), Colonial Office London (CO) 147/144, Sir W. MacGregor, Governor, Lagos, to J. Chamberlain, Secretary of State for the Colonies, Britain, 15 September 1899; ‘Message of the Governor to the Legislative Council’, Lagos Standard, 19 March 1902, 2.

11 Gloye, F., Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Liquor Trade in Southern Nigeria, Part II: Minutes of Evidence, Command Paper 4, 907, 1909, questions 5,051-5,057, 129Google Scholar; Heap, , ‘Before “Star”: The Import Substitution of Western-style Liquor in Nigeria, 1870-1970’, African Economic History 24 (1996) 73–77.Google Scholar

12 Lagos Blue Books of Statistics, 1901-1903.

13 Lagos Annual Report (1903) 38.

14 Welsh, T., ‘Contrasts in African legislation’, Journal of the Royal African Society 2 (1903) 199Google Scholar; ‘Message of the Governor to the Legislative Council’, 2; Olukoju, ‘Rotgut’, 67.

15 Strachan, H., Minutes, question 776, 22;Google ScholarProctor, C., Minutes, questions 16, 087-16,088, 398.Google Scholar

16 Lagos Annual Report (1903) 38.

17 Ibid..

18 Lagos Ordinance no. 3 of 1903 to Provide for the Sale of Food in a Pure State and for the Prevention of the Adulteration Thereof, clause 4(b).

19 Morel, E.D., The Attack upon the Commission of Inquiry into the Spirit Trade in Southern Nigeria (Liverpool 1910) 84Google Scholar; PRO, CO 520/110, Reply of the NRLTUC to Criticisms of the Colonial Office, 5 December 1911, 14-15.

20 Proctor, Minutes, questions 16,141, 16,158, 399-400.

21 PRO, CO 520/55, Lord Elgin, Secretary of State for the Colonies, Britain, to L.H. Nott, Secretary, NRLTUC, 15 April 1908; Olukoju does not mention alcohol as the reason for the introduction of differential rates. Olukoju, ‘Rotgut’, 70-71.

22 PRO, CO 520/101, Memorandum by T.F. Burrowes, Controller of Customs, Southern Nigeria, 1, in Sir W. Egerton, Governor, Southern Nigeria, to L.V. Harcourt, Secretary of State for the Colonies, Britain, 21 February 1911.

23 Kingsley, M.H., ‘Liquor Traffic with West Africa’, Fortnightly Review (March 1896) 541.Google Scholar

24 Kingsley, ‘Liquor’, 549.

25 Ibid., 550.

26 ‘The West African Liquor Trade’, Lagos Weekly Record, 16 April 1898, 2.

27 Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Liquor Trade in Southern Nigeria, Part I: Report, Command Paper 4,906 (1909) 15.

28 Waller, H., Trafficking in Liquor with the Natives of Africa (London 1887) 8.Google Scholar

29 Ajasa, K., Minutes, question 2,985, 78.Google Scholar

30 C. Punch, Minutes, appendix A, 413-414.

31 F. Hives, Minutes, appendix A, 421.

32 Nigerian National Archives, Ibadan (NAI), Chief Secretary's Office, Lagos (CSO) 1/1/20, Sir H.E. McCallum, Governor, Lagos, to Chamberlain, 6 October 1897.

33 ‘Governor Carter and Bishop Tugwell on the Drink Traffic’, Lagos Standard, 3 July 1895, 2.

34 PRO, CO 147/147, John Holt and Company to Chamberlain, 20 July 1899.

35 Rhodes House Library, Oxford, John Holt Papers, MSS.Afr.s.1525, Box 9, file 1, Holt to Chamberlain, 13 May 1899.

36 NAI, CSO 1/1/18, G.C. Denton, Governor, Lagos, to Chamberlain, 10 April 1897.

37 ‘The Deputation on the Liquor Traffic to His Excellency the Governor’, Lagos Standard, 14June 1899, 3.

38 PRO, CO 147/138, Sir R.D.R. Moor, Commissioner and Consul-General, Niger Coast Protectorate, to Sir G.T. Carter, Governor, Lagos, 9 November 1897.

39 PRO, CO 147/125, Moor to Carter, 8 September 1897; PRO, CO 444/3, Moor to Chamberlain, 3 November 1899.

40 Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Liquor Trade, 7.

41 Brown, Minutes, questions 2,116-2,117, 57.

42 Chief C. Gam, Minutes, questions 12,524-12,525, 311.

43 Simpson-Gray, E.A., Minutes, appendix A, 410Google Scholar; Gloye, , Minutes, question 5,021, 129Google Scholar.

44 Humfrey, L.E.H., Minutes, appendix A, 417.Google Scholar

45 Baillie, J.A., Minutes, appendix A, 425.Google Scholar

46 PRO, CO 446/76, Sir E.P.C. Girouard, Governor, Northern Nigeria, to Earl of Crewe, Secretary of State for the Colonies, Britain, 17 November 1908; Morel, , Nigeria: Its Peoples and Its Problems (London 1911) 246.Google Scholar Olukoju makes no mention of local liquor.

47 Nigerian National Archives, Enugu (NAE), Calabar Provincial Office (CALPROF) 14/4/240, H.S. Burrough, Acting District Commissioner, Okigwi, to W.E.B. Copland-Crawford, Acting Provincial Secretary, Eastern Province, Southern Nigeria, 5 May 1909; Rev H. Atundaola, Minutes, questions 14,337-14,338, 353; I.T. Palmer, Minutes, questions 14,406-14,410, 354; Hartley, C.W.S., The Oil Palm (London 1967) 547Google Scholar.

48 ‘The Uses of the Oil Palm’, West Africa, 14 May 1904, 485; Green, M.M., Igbo Village Affairs (London 1947) 35, 175.Google Scholar In one area the average consumption of palm wine among 200 people surveyed was 167 grams per head per day; some men drank a dozen pints a week: Dalziel, J.M., The Useful Plants of West Tropical Africa (London 1937) 506Google Scholar.

49 ‘The Liquor Traffic’, Lagos Standard, 14 October 1908, 2; ‘Liquor Traffic, by Herbert Macaulay’, Nigeria Chronicle, 2 April 1909, supplement; S.H. Pearce, Minutes, question 4,785, 123.

50 NAE, Chief Secretary, Enugu (CSE) 12/1/317, A.B. Hobson, Government Analyst, to D.Alexander, Director of Medical and Sanitary Services, 29 July 1926.

51 NAE, CALPROF 14/4/240, Burrough to Copland-Crawford, 5 May 1909; NAI, CSO 26/06066/vol I, I.B. Gascoyne, Agent, Niger Company, Onitsha, to R.A. Roberts, Senior Resident, Onitsha Province, 8 October 1925.

52 Hives, , Minutes, appendix A, 421.Google Scholar

53 Oluwole, Bishop I., Minutes, questions 1,471-1,472, 41.Google Scholar

54 M.L. Tew, Minutes, appendix A, 421; NAI, CSO 20/4/NC. 169/16, H.S. Goldsmith, Lieutenant-Governor, Northern Provinces, to D.C. Cameron, Central Secretary, 3 February 1918; Washburne, C., Primitive Drinking (New York 1961) 68–69Google Scholar.

55 Rev E. George, Minutes, question 6,668, 167; Baillie, Minutes, appendix A, 425.

56 Dr E.H. Tipper, Minutes, questions 5,570-5,574, 140; Lugard, , The Dual Mandate, 603Google Scholar.

57 NAI, CSO 23/18/190/1917, E.C. Duff, Resident, Kontagora Province, to G.R. Matthews, Secretary, Northern Provinces, 9 January 1918; Fadahunsi, A., Ngur-adi, N. and Ambi, Y.A. eds, The Socio-Economy of Grain-based Drink Beverages in Kaduna State (Zaria 1989)Google Scholar.

58 ‘The Drink Traffic in Yoruba’, Niger and Yoruba Notes 4/43 (January 1898) 59.

59 ‘Is Fermented Palm Wine Alcoholic?’, Nigerian Chronicle, 5 March 1909,2; A. Pratt, Minutes, questions 570-573, 15.

60 Smith, Furness, ‘Restrictions of Liquor Traffic in Southern Nigeria’, Church Missionary Review 61 (1910) 149.Google Scholar

61 Dr H. Strachan, Minutes, question 759, 21; Welsh, ‘Contrast in African Legislation’, 200-201.

62 NAE, CALPROF 14/4/140, Copland-Crawford to District Commissioners, Calabar, Ikom, Oban and Obubra, 22 April 1909; Sir T.E. Thorpe, Minutes, appendix B, 440; NRLTUC, The Liquor Traffic in Southern Nigeria (London 1910) 19.Google Scholar

63 Oluwole, Minutes, questions 1,662-1,663, 46; E. Obafemi, Minutes, question 3,525, 89; Hartley, , The Oil Palm, 545–546Google Scholar.

64 ‘Editorial’, Lagos Echo, 6 July 1895, 2.

65 Tugwell, Minutes, question 976, 27.

66 Tipper, Minutes, questions 5,583-5,586, 140.

67 ‘The Gin Traffic Controversy from an African Point of View, by Abdul Mortaleb’, Lagos Weekly Record, 27 July 1895, 2; Hartley, , The Oil Palm, 547Google Scholar.

68 W.T.G. Lawson, Minutes, question 4,481, 116.

69 Chief Henshaw, D.J., Minutes, questions 11,297-11,299, 277.Google Scholar

70 Ross, W.A., Minutes, question 5,205, 133.Google Scholar

71 Nigerian National Archives, Abeokuta, Egba Council Records 1/1/45/vol 3, ‘Native Beverages, Preparation of’, Egba Council, 6 August 1931.

72 ‘Palm Wine Sellers’, Lagos Daily News, 12 March 1930, 1.

73 ‘Palm Wine Centres!’, West African Pilot, 28 April 1939, 4.

74 NAI, Commissioner ofthe Colony's Office (COMCOL) l/1520/S.l, A.B.Hobson, Government Analyst, 15 August 1933, in R.E. Foulger, Commissioner of Police, Colony, to G.M. Falk, Commissioner of the Colony, 17 August 1933.

75 NAI, COMCOL 1/947, W.K. Duncombe, Comptroller of Customs, to G. Hemmant, Chief Secretary to the Government, 17 June 1930. The same phenomenon had occurred on a smaller scale with the drinking of perfume in Lagos in the 1890s: NAI, CSO 1/1/28, MacGregor to Chamberlain, 27 December 1899. Meanwhile, ‘lavender water with its 47 per cent alcoholic content was said to be the most popular’ substitute alcoholic beverage in German Kamerun: Rudin, H., Germans in the Cameroons, 1884-1914 (New Haven 1938) 388Google Scholar.

76 NAI, COMCOL 1/947, Duncombe to Hemmant, 17 june 1930.

77 NAI, COMCOL 1/947, J.T. Spender, Commissioner of Police, to C.T. Lawrence, Administrator ofthe Colony, 12 July 1930.

78 NAI, Liquor Traffic by Alexander, 17 December 1925, 1. A generation earlier, Constance Larymore had expressed a similar worry: ‘The servants will be found absolutely omnivorous over kerosene oil; they spill it, they light the kitchen fire with it, and I have heard a despairing bachelor housekeeper declare that they drinkit, so rapidly does it disappear!’, Larymore, , A Resident's Wife (London 1908) 199 (emphasis in the original)Google Scholar.

79 NAI, CSO 1/32/92, Thomson to Amery, 4 August 1928; Hemmant, Officer Administering the Government, ‘Address to Legislative Council, 28 January 1931’, Sessional Paper no. 1 of 1931, 28.

80 Analyst Department Annual Report (1928) 5.

81 ‘A Lesson in Temperance Reform’, Nigerian Daily Mail, 10 February 1930, 3.

82 ‘Amendments to the Customs Tariff’, Lagos Daily News, 29 September 1930, 1.

83 Order-in-Council no. 51 of 1930 Made under the Customs Tariff Ordinance, clause 1(13).

84 ‘Amendments to the Customs Tariff’, 1.

85 NAI, CSO 1/32/108, Hemmant, Deputy Governor, Nigeria, to Lord Passfield, Secretary of State for the Colonies, Britain, 8 August 1931.

86 NAE, Owerri and Rivers Provincial Office (RTVTROF) 2/1/15, Report on Illicit Distillation in Degema Division, September 1932 to February 1933 by C.W. Clark, Assistant Commissioner of Police, Owerri Province, 1 March 1933, 4.

87 ‘On Prohibition, by Agboke’, Nigerian Echo, 21 September 1933, 3.

88 NAI, Ministry of Home Affairs, Ibadan (IBMINHOME) 1/26, P.R. Foulkes, District Officer, Ondo, in G.G. Harris, Acting Resident, Ondo Province, to Kelly, 15 July 1937.

89 NAE, RTVTROF 2/1/16, T.H. Wilson, Senior Commissioner of Police, Owerri Province, to H.C. Stevenson, Resident, Owerri Province, 23 July 1936.

90 NAE, RTVPROF 2/1/16, Wilson to Stevenson, 23 July 1936.

91 NAI, Okitipupa Divisional Office (OKITIDIV) 1/2/OWC.3, R.A. Vosper, District Officer, Okitipupa, to F.B. Carr, Acting Resident, Ondo Province, 26 February 1935; NAI, IBMINHOME 1/26, J. Wann, Resident, Ijebu Province, to EJ.G. Kelly, Secretary, Southern Provinces, 19 August 1936.

92 NAE, RTVTROF 2/1/17, P.B. Hebbert, District Officer, Degema, to Carr, Resident, Owerri Province, 30 December 1938.

93 Analyst Department Annual Reports, 1932-1935.

94 NAE, Aba District Office (ABADIST) 14/1/169, S.T. Madu, Aba, to CJ. Pleass, District Officer, Aba, 8 December 1932.

95 NAE, Brass District Office (BRASSDIST) 10/1/80, E.N.C. Dickinson, Assistant District Officer, Brass, to Native Court, Sabagreia, 16 February 1932.

96 NAI, ASADIV 1/AD. 199, I.N. Hill, District Officer, Asaba, to J.M. Simpson, Assistant District Officer, Agbor, 22 September 1932.

97 NAI, IBMINHOME 1/21, W.E. Hunt, Secretary, Southern Provinces, to Nigeria Residents, 9 December 1931.

98 NAE, RTVTROF 2/1/17, A.T.E. Marsh, Resident, Rivers Province, to Carr, Secretary, Eastern Provinces, 23 December 1947.

99 Miers, S., ‘The Brussels Conference of 1889-90’ in: Gifford, P. and Louis, W.R. eds, Britain and Germany in Africa (New Haven 1967) 83–118;Google ScholarMiers, , Britain and the Ending of the Slave Trade (London 1975) 272–284Google Scholar.