Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T05:02:59.322Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Sociological Perspectives on the Origins of Child Abuse Legislation in Israel

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 July 2014

Mimi Ajzenstadt  and
Gabriel Cavaglion
Get access

Abstract

This paper examines the historical background and the social processes that have changed the perception of child abuse in Israel from almost complete lack of awareness to concern and formal societal reaction during the 1990s. The recent emergence of child abuse as a social problem and the consequent actions of scrutiny and surveillance through legislation, law enforcement, punishment and educational prevention is set within the cultural milieu of the past two decades. This sociological analysis shows that there was a gradual transition from a private condition to a public “social problem”. The social actors involved in this process primarily included social workers, professional educators, academics, the daily press, members of Israel's Parliament and law enforcement agents.

For various scholars and professionals, the incident that triggered awareness and concern about child abuse in general and child sexual abuse in particular was the tragic death of young Moran Denemias in 1989. However, in our paper we posit that this single tragic incident in itself did not prompt officials or the general public to view it as part of a larger problem. The general political tendency to overreact to the emerging issue of abuse, and the rapidity with which the Law for the Prevention of Abuse of Minors and Helpless Persons was passed at the end of the 1980s can be explained by a general moral sentiment that matured decades earlier.

Type
Articles
Information
Israel Law Review , Volume 37 , Issue 1 , Spring 2003 , pp. 169 - 196
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press and The Faculty of Law, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem 2004

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Goode, Erich, Deviant Behavior (New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1994) 12Google Scholar; Goode, Erich and Ben-Yehuda, Nachman, Moral Panic: The Social Construction of Deviance. (Cambridge, Blackwell, 1994) 87Google Scholar.

2 See, for example, Schneider, Joseph and Kitsuse, John, eds. Studies in the Sociology of Social Problems (New Jersey, Ablex, Norwood, 1987)Google ScholarPubMed.

3 Spector, Malcolm and Kitsuse, John, Constructing Social Problems. (California, Cumming, 1977) 75Google Scholar; Gusfield, Joseph, The Culture of Public Problems: Drinking, Driving and the Symbolic Order (Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, 1981)Google Scholar.

4 Pfohl, Stephen, “The Discovery of Child Abuse” (1977) 24 Social Problems 310–323CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Plummer, Kenneth, Sexual Stigma: An Interactionist Account (London, Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1975) 78Google Scholar; Travers, Olive, Behind the Silhouettes: Exploring the Myths of Child Sexual Abuse (Belfast, Blackstaff Press, 1999) 15Google Scholar.

5 Best, Joel, Images of Issues: Typifying Contemporary Social Problems (New York, Walter de Gruynter Corporation, 1989)Google Scholar.

6 Pfuhl, Erdwin, The Deviance Process (New York, Van Nostrand, 1980) 134Google Scholar.

7 Ibid., at 150.

8 Ibid., at 138.

9 Ibid., at 135.

10 Ibid., at 147.

11 For the case of child abuse see: Nelson, Barbara, Making an Issue of Child Abuse: Political Agenda Setting for Social Problems (Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, 1984) 5Google Scholar; Costin, Lela, Karger, Jacob and Stoesz, David, The Politics of Child Abuse in America (New York, Oxford University Press, 1996)Google Scholar.

12 Jenks, Chris, Childhood (London, Routledge, 1996) 98Google ScholarPubMed.

13 See, for example, Denzin, Norman K. and Yvonna, Lincoln S., eds. Handbook of Qualitative Research (Thousand Oaks, Sage, 2nd ed. 2000)Google Scholar.

14 See, for example, Riessman, Catherine Kohler, Narrative Analysis (Newbury Park CA, Sage, 1993)Google Scholar.

15 Cf. Goode and Ben-Yehuda, supra n. 1, at 92.

16 Finkelhor, David, Child Sexual Abuse: New Theory and Research (New York, The Free Press, 1984) 3Google Scholar.

17 Morag, Tamar, “Taking Stock of a Revolution: Child Abuse and the Law in Israel, 1989–1997” in Freeman, Michael, ed. Overcoming Child Abuse: A Window on a World Problem (Great Britain, Ashgate, 2000) 205Google Scholar.

18 Kadman, Yizhak, “The Law for Preventing Abuse of Minors and Helpless Persons: A Turning Point of the Social Attitude in Israel to Child Abuse” (1992) 38 Social Security 135, at 136Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

19 Eden, Levy, Distressed Childhood: Sex, Violence and Children (Haifa, Tamar, 1996)Google Scholar. [in Hebrew]; Reifen, David, “Reflections on Child Welfare Laws in Israel” in Jarus, Arie, Marcus, Joseph, Oren, Joseph and Rapaport, Chanan, eds. Children and Families in Israel: Some Mental Health Perspectives (New York, Gordon and Breach, 1970) 183–208Google Scholar.

20 Cited in Morag, supra n. 17, at 205.

21 Ibid.

22 Ibid., at 207.

23 See Reifen, supra n. 19, at 204.

24 Melamed, Aharon, “Introduction” in Me'ir, Hovav, ed. Sexual Abuse of Children: The Law, Investigator and the Court (Tel Aviv, Cherikover, 1993) 9Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

25 Goldstein, Stephen, The Rights of the Child in Israel (Jerusalem, The Hebrew University, 1981) 80Google Scholar [in Hebrew]; Sachs, Shimon, Neglected Children and Youth Prevention and Education (Tel Aviv, Ramot, 1982)Google Scholar [in Hebrew]; Reifen, supra n. 19.

26 Goldstein, supra n. 25, at 80–81.

27 See Reifen, supra n. 19, at 204.

28 Report of the Commission of Investigation of Delinquency (The Agranat Commission) (Jerusalem, Ministry of Justice, 1956) 44 [in Hebrew].

29 Kadman, supra n. 18.

30 Portugese, Jacqueline, Fertility Policy in Israel: The Politics of Religion, Gender and Nation (Westport, CT.: Praeger, 1998) 56Google Scholar.

31 Jaffe, Eliezer, Child Welfare in Israel (New York, Praeger, 1982) 5Google Scholar.

32 See Portugese, supra n. 30, at 20.

33 Ajzenstadt, Mimi and Cavaglion, Gabriel, “The Sexual Body of the Young Jew as an Arena of Ideological Struggle, 1821–1948” (2002) 25 Symbolic Interaction 93, at 112CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Biale, David, Eros and the Jews: From Biblical Israel to Contemporary America (New York, Harper Collins, 1992) ch. 8Google Scholar.

34 Cited in Jaffe, supra n. 31, at 11.

35 Ministry of Welfare, Israel, Annual Report (Jerusalem, Ministry of Welfare, 1949) 1Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

36 Ajzenstadt, Mimi, “Crime, Social Control and the Process of Social Classification: Juvenile Delinquency/Justice Discourse in Israel 1948–1970” (2002) 49 Social Problems 585–604CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jaffe, supra n. 31, at 24; Melamed, Aharon, Juvenile Delinquency and its Prevention (Jerusalem, Ministry of Welfare, 1964)Google Scholar; Smilansky, Moshe, Weintraub, Shoshana and Hanegbi, Yehuda, eds. Child and Youth Welfare in Israel (Jerusalem, The Szold Institute, 1960) 245–258Google Scholar.

37 See Jaffe, supra n. 31, at 27; Marcus, Joseph and Russell, Alexander, “The Vulnerable and the Handicapped”, in Jarus, Arie, Marcus, Joseph, Oren, Joseph and Rapaport, Chanan, eds. Children and Families in Israel: Some Mental Health Perspectives (New York, Gordon and Breach, 1970) 385Google Scholar; Smilansky et al., supra n. 36, at 223–229.

38 See Smilansky et al., supra n. 36, at 230–244.

39 Menachem Amir and Me'ir Hovav, “Juvenile Delinquency in Israel”, in Arie Jarus et al., eds. supra n. 37, at 465.

40 See Melamed, supra n. 36.

41 See E. Jaffe, supra n. 31, at 28; see also Jarus et al., eds. supra n. 37.

42 Agranat Commission, supra n. 28.

43 Schiff, Gary, “The Politics of Population Policy in Israel” (1978) Winter Forum on the Jewish People, Zionism and Israel 173–192Google Scholar; Schiff, Gary, “The Politics of Fertility Policy in Israel” in Ritterband, Paul, ed., Modern Jewish Fertility (Leiden, The Netherlands, Brill, 1981)Google Scholar.

44 See Portugese, supra n. 30, at 76–79.

45 Prime Minister's Report for Children and Youth in Distress (Jerusalem, State of Israel, 1974)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

46 Cavaglion, Gabriel, “The Institutionalization of Knowledge in Israeli Sex Education Programs: A Historical Review, 1948–1987” (2000) 25 Journal of Sex Education and Therapy 286, at 288–289Google Scholar.

47 See Ajzenstadt and Cavaglion, supra n. 33.

48 Cavaglion, Gabriel, The Professional Discourse of Sex Education in Israel. (Ph.D. dissertation. Jerusalem, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 1997)Google Scholar [in Hebrew]; Cavaglion, supra n. 46; for a general survey of these programs and their use in the classroom see: Ben-Shalom, A., The State of Family Education and Sex Education in Israeli Secular Schools: A Survey (Jerusalem, Ministry of Education, 1977)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

49 Kal, Esther, Which Sex are We? (Tel Aviv, Levin-Epstein-Modan, 1974)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

50 See Cavaglion, supra n. 48.

51 See Cavaglion, supra n. 46; Portugese, supra n. 30, at 130.

52 David, Hava and Spitz, Yehudit, “Children Victims of Sexual Crimes”, paper presented at the Symposium on Child Protection in Israel, organized by Social Workers Association in Israel, (Jerusalem, Avnet, 1979) 223–235Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

53 Ibid., at 231.

54 Ibid.

55 Ibid.

56 Ibid., at 234.

57 Zimrin, Hanita, Battered Child: The Phenomenon and Ways of Intervention. Paper presented at the Symposium on Child Protection in Israel, organized by Social Workers Association in Israel (Jerusalem, Avnet, 1979) 132–137Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

58 Zimrin, Hanita, Child Abused by Disabled and not Disabled Mothers. M.A. dissertation the School of Social Work (Jerusalem, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 1973)Google Scholar. [in Hebrew]

59 Zimrin, Hanita, Battered Children: A Multi-Dimensional Problem (Tel Aviv, Social Work School Council, 1985)Google Scholar. [in Hebrew]

60 See Morag, supra n. 17, at 207.

61 Dan Margalit, , “Reports from the Parliament” Haaretz, November 16th 1984, p. 3Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

62 Report of the Committee on Sexual Crimes against Minors (Jerusalem, Ministry of Justice, 1987) 2Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

63 Ibid.

64 Ibid., at 12.

65 Ibid., at 18.

66 Ibid., at 19.

67 Ibid., at 23–29.

68 Ibid., at 34.

69 Ibid.

70 Ibid., at 35.

71 President's Conference for the Well Being of the Child. A Presentation of Data on Children and Youth in the 0–19 Age Group Describing their Social Situation (Jerusalem, The Office of President of Israel, 1981)Google Scholar.

72 See Kadman, supra n. 18, at 142; see also the discussion in Sznaider, Natan and Talmud, Ilan, “Moral Sentiments and the Social Organization of Public Compassion: The Case of Child Abuse in Israel” (1998) 35 International Journal of Contemporary Sociology 14–27Google Scholar.

73 Kadman, supra n. 18, at 137; Morag, supra n. 17, at 208; Eden, supra n. 19, at 40, 127.

74 Goren, Yehuda, “Four-year-old Girl, Victim of Abuse, Died”, Ma'ariv, February 12th 1989, p. 1Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

75 Goren, Yehuda, “One Phone Call to the Police Could Have Saved my Daughter”, Ma'ariv, February 13th 1989, p. 1Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

76 Ibid.

77 Ibid.

78 Goren, Yehuda, “Abuse”, Ma'ariv, February 14th 1989, p. 1e [in Hebrew].Google Scholar

79 Goren, Yehuda, “Yossi Hazan Held in Solitary Confinement, to Be Protected from Inmates' Revenge”, Ma'ariv, February 15th 1989, p. 12Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

80 Ibid.

81 Cf. Cohen, Stanley, States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering (Cambridge, Polity Press, 2001)Google Scholar; see also Downs, Anthony, “Up and Down with Ecology: ‘The Issue-Attention Cycle’” (1972) 32 Public Interest 38–52Google Scholar.

82 Morag, supra n. 17, at 208.

83 Report of the Committee on Sexual Crimes against Minors (Jerusalem, Ministry of Justice, 1987)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

84 See Nelson, supra n. 11, at 5.

85 “Bill of the Council for Child Protection: To Punish Child Abusers More Severely”, Ma'ariv, February 6th 1989, p. 12Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

86 See the discussion in Sznaider and Talmud, supra n. 72.

87 Ibid.

88 Christie, Nils, “The Ideal Victim”, in Ezzat, Fattah, ed. From Crime Policy to Victim Policy: Reorienting the Justice System (New York, St. Martin Press, 1986) 17–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Krane, Julia, “Patriarchal Biases in the Conceptualization of Child Sexual Abuse: A Review and Critique of Literature from a Radical Feminist Perspective” (1990) 7 Canadian Social Work Review 183–191Google Scholar; Madriz, Esther, Nothing Bad Happens to Good Girls: Fear of Crime in Women's Lives (Berkeley, University of California Press, 1997) 77Google Scholar.

89 Cf. Gusfield, supra n. 3.

90 See the discussion in Jenkins, Philip, Moral Panic: Changing Concepts of Child Molesters in Modern America (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1998) 119–120Google Scholar; see also Nelson, supra n. 11, at 1–2.

91 Morag supra n. 17, at 217.

92 Ben-Arie, Asher and Zionit, Yaffa, eds. Children in Israel: Statistical Yearbook. (Jerusalem, The National Council for the Child, 2001) 315–316Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

93 Israel National Police, Annual Report, Planning Dept. and Training Division (Jerusalem, 1986 and 1996) [in Hebrew].

94 David, Merav and Harpaz, Shirit, “Number of Children Victims of Abuse Doubled”, Ma'ariv, January 29th 2004, p. 20Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

95 Israel Prison Service,Annual Report (Jerusalem, Israel Prison Service, 1999) 17Google ScholarPubMed [in Hebrew].

96 Israel Prison Service, Annual Report (Jerusalem, Israel Prison Service, 1989) 51Google ScholarPubMed [in Hebrew].

97 See Sznaider and Talmud, supra n. 72.

98 Cohen, Tamar, Living in the Shadow of the Secret (Tel Aviv, Modan, 1991)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

99 See the discussion in O. Travers, supra n. 4, at 15.

100 See, for example, Orbach, Israel, Endless Pain (Jerusalem, Schocken, 2000)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

101 See, for example, Ried, Maya, Prisoner: an Autobiography of Professional Incest (Tel Aviv, Tamuz, 2002)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

102 Ayalon, Ofra, Child Abuse in the Family (Jerusalem, The Szold Institute, 1999)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

103 For a general overview see Bar-Guy, Elah and Margalit, Carmi, Sources for Family Life Education and Sexual Instruction: a Bibliography (Jerusalem, Ministry of Education, 1994)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

104 Sne-Or, Zahava, I Have the Right to Say No! (Jerusalem, Ministry of Education, 1989)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

105 Caplan, Gerald, Principles of Preventive Psychiatry (New York, Basic Books, 1964)Google Scholar.

106 Best, Joel, Threatened Children: Rhetoric and Concern about Child-Victims (Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, 1990) 40Google Scholar; see some similarities with women's prevention programs in Stanko, Elizabeth, “Safety Talk: Conceptualizing Women's Risk Assessment as a ‘Technology of the Soul’” (1997) 14 Theoretical Criminology 479–499CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

107 See the discussion in Sol Gordon, and Gilgun, Jane, “Sex Education and the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse” (1985) 11 Journal of Sex Education and Therapy 46–52Google Scholar; Kerns, Sherryll Kreizer, “Rethinking Prevention” (1986) 10 Child Abuse & Neglect 259–261Google Scholar; Kitzinger, Jenny, “Who Are You Kidding? Children, Power and the Struggle against Sexual Abuse”, in Allison, James and Allan, Prout, eds. Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood: Contemporary Issues in the Sociological Study of Childhood (London, Routledge Farmer, 1997), 165, 178Google Scholar; Stone, Mary Ellen, “New Myths about Child Sexual Abuse”, in Nelson, Mary and Clark, Kay, eds. Preventing Child Sexual Abuse (Santa Cruz, California: Network, 1986) 130–132Google Scholar.

108 Mimi Aj zenstadt and Gabriel Cavaglion, “Telling Stories about Child Abuse: The Case of Preventive Manuals in Israel” (unpublished).

109 For a general discussion see Strauss, Murray, Gelles, Richard and Steinmetz, Suzanne, Beyond Closed Doors: Violence in the American Family (Garden City, N.J., Anchor, 1980)Google Scholar.

110 Annual Report on Children's Investigations, Victims and Suspected Witnesses (Jerusalem, Ministry of Labour and Welfare, 1992) [in Hebrew].

111 See Ben Arie and Zionit, supra n. 92, at 328.

112 See Morag, supra n. 17, at 218.

113 Efrat-Got, Galia and Ben-Arieh, Asher, “The Epidemiology of Child Abuse in Children as Victims of Abuse in the Family” in Zionit, Yaffa and Kadman, Yizhak, eds. Report of the Council for Child Protection (Jerusalem, Council for Child Protection, 2001) 30Google Scholar. [in Hebrew]

114 See, for example, McDonald, Gayle M., ed. Social Context and Social Location in the Sociology of Law (Toronto, Broadview Press, 2002)Google Scholar.

115 Beckett, Chris, Child Protection: An Introduction (London, Sage, 2003)Google Scholar.

116 Cited in, United Nations, Press Release: Israel Presents Second Periodic Report to the Committee on Rights of Child on its Compliance with the Convention, October 2, 2002.

117 See, the discussion regarding this process in the USA in Best, supra n. 106 and Jenkins, supra n. 90.

118 See Jenkins, supra n. 90, at 232.

119 Weissman, Edna, Child Abuse Prevention (Jerusalem, Ministry of Education, 1988)Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

120 Edleson, Jeffrey and Eisikovits, Zvi, “Visions of Continued Change”, in Edleson, Jeffrey and Eisikovits, Zvi, eds. Future Interventions with Battered Women and their Families (Thousand Oaks, California, Sage, 1996) 2Google Scholar.

121 Heise, Lori, “Violence against Women: Global Organization for Change”, in Edleson, Jeffrey and Eisikovits, Zvi, eds. Future Interventions with Battered Women and their Families (Thousand Oaks, California, Sage, 1996) 9Google Scholar.

122 For a general discussion see, for example, Pinsof, William, “The Death of ‘Till Death Us Do Part’: The Transformation of Pair-Bonding in the 20th Century” (2002) 41 Family Process 135–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

123 See Jenks, supra n. 12, at 89–90.

124 Amir, Delila and Binyamin, Orly, “Abortion Approval as a Ritual of Symbolic Control”, in Feinman, Clarice, ed. The Criminalization of a Woman's Body (New York, Haworth, 1992) 5Google Scholar.

125 Naveh, Gedalia, The Absorption of Single-Parent Immigrant Families from the Former Soviet Union (Jerusalem, JDC – Brookdale Institute, 1994)Google Scholar.

126 Leshem, Eliezer, “The Population of Israel and its Attitude to the 90's New Immigrants,” (1993) 40 Social Security 54–73Google Scholar [in Hebrew].

127 See the discussion in Smith-Rosenberg, Carroll, “Sex as Symbol in Victorian Purity: An Ethno-historical Analysis of Jacksonian America”, in Demos, John and Boocock, S., eds. Turning Points: Historical and Sociological Essays on the Family (Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1978) 212Google Scholar.

128 See Jenks, supra n. 12, at 90.

129 Evans, David, Sexual Citizenship: The Material Construction of Sexualities (London, Routledge, 1993)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kitzinger, supra n. 107, at 165.

130 See Best, supra n. 106, at 127; see also Kilbourne, Jean, “The Child as Sex Object: Images of Children in the Media”, in Nelson, Mary and Clark, Kay, eds. Preventing Child Sexual Abuse (Santa Cruz, California, Network, 1986)Google Scholar; and see Kincaid, James, Erotic Innocence: The Culture of Child Molesting (Durham and London, Duke University Press, 1998) 17–18Google Scholar.

131 Jenks, supra n. 12.

132 For Great Britain, see for example Richardson, James, Best, Joel and Bromley, David “Satanism as a Social Problem” in Richardson, James, Best, Joel and Bromley, David, eds. The Satanism Scare (New York, Aldine de Gruyter, 1991) 3–12Google Scholar; La Fontaine, JeanSpeak of the Devil: Tales of Satanic Abuse in Contemporary England (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1998)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

133 James, Allison, Jenks, Chris and Prout, Alan, Theorizing Childhood (Cambridge, Polity Press, 1998) 152Google Scholar.

134 See Kitzinger, supra n. 107, at 176.

135 See Goode and Ben-Yehuda, supra n. 1, at 87.

136 Report of the Committee on Sexual Crimes against Minors (Jerusalem: Ministry of Justice, 1987) 6Google Scholar [in Hebrew]; see also Sne-Or, supra n. 104, at 1.

137 See discussion in Goode, supra n. 1, at 94.

138 Ibid., at 135.

139 Scull, Andrew, “Deviance and Social Control”, in Smelser, Neil, ed. Handbook of Sociology (Beverly Hills, California, Sage, 1988) 686Google Scholar.