Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T17:15:27.487Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Defending democracy? The legislative response to political extremism in the Irish Free State, 1922–l39

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Bill Kissane
Bill Kissane*
Affiliation:
Department of Government, London School of Economics
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Irish Free State was both victim and survivor of the general crisis of European democracy in the inter-war era. Born into civil war in 1922, it saw repeated bouts of instability and political violence, the emergence of radicalised movements on the left and right in the 1930s, and the subsidence of political unrest late in that decade. In this period the state’s reliance on emergency legislation to deal with subversion was obviously an indication of the persistence of unrest, and such laws have usually been seen as an inescapable part of the state’s pursuit of authority and legitimacy. On the other hand, the Irish case is also an example of how a state’s political development can be affected by civil war, since the continuities in the state’s legislative response to political extremism, from 1922 onwards, are too strong to ignore. Of course, the Free State was also one of the few new democracies to survive the period with its democratic institutions intact, but from the outset this achievement was accomplished through the paradox of withholding the conventions of democracy until the period of crisis would pass. One view is that this was the price to be paid for countering the threat to democratic government posed by subversive organisations, while such organisations themselves argue that they remained subject not to a ‘government of laws’ but to ‘a government of men’. As in other situations, the legitimacy of such legislation was inextricably linked to the case governments made for there being a state of emergency, but such arguments were always deeply contested. Either way, the whole issue of emergency legislation reveals both a confused understanding of the requisites of constitutional government in Ireland, and the need to appreciate the complex nature of the decisions states make in an era of violent conflict.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 34 , Issue 134 , November 2004 , pp. 156 - 174
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2004

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See Report of the committee to review the Offences Against the State Act 1939-1998 and related matters (Dublin, 2002), pp 9–59 Google Scholar.

2 O’Connor, Emmet, Syndicalism in Ireland, 1917-1923 (Cork, 1988), p. 163 Google Scholar.

3 See Féin, Sinn, Lost liberties: the Offences Against the State Act (Dublin, 1972), p. 11 Google Scholar.

4 See Clifford, Brendan, The Irish Civil War: the conflict that formed the state (Cork, 1993)Google Scholar.

5 O’Halpin, Eunan, Defending Ireland: the Irish state and its enemies since 1922 (Oxford, 1999), p. 1 Google Scholar.

6 Freeman’s Journal, 6 July 1922.

7 Prager, Jeffrey, Building democracy in Ireland: political order and cultural integration in a newly independent nation (Cambridge, 1986), pp 38, 76CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 ‘Army emergency powers, 1922’, 7 Dec. 1922 (N.A.I., DT S1746).

9 Judge advocate general to commander-in-chief, 23 Apr. 1923 (ibid., DT S2091).

10 ‘Civil War amnesty resolution’, 4 Nov. 1924 (ibid., DT S4120).

11 ‘Department of Justice report on the present position (August 1931) as regards the activities of unlawful and dangerous associations in the Saorstát with a summary of similar activities in recent years’, Anti-State Activities: Joint Pastoral (ibid., DT S5864B).

12 Ibid.

13 McGarry, Fearghal, Frank Ryan (Dundalk, 2002), p. 20 Google Scholar.

14 Ibid.

15 ‘Memo by General O’Duffy on proposal for Article 2A of the constitution’, 7 Oct. 1931 (N.A.I., DJ JUS 8/306).

16 ‘Memo — Implementing the proposed Treasonable Offences Act’, 7 Oct. 1931 (ibid., DJ B22/35).

17 An Phoblacht, 21 Feb. 1931.

18 McGarry, Frank Ryan, p. 24.

19 ‘Copy of confidential report by Commissioner Garda Síochána for period 11 Jan. 1931 - 31 May 1931’, 27 July 1931 (U.C.D.A., FitzGerald papers, P80/856 (1)).

20 ‘Department of Justice report on the present position (August 1931) ...’ (N.A.I., DT S5864B).

21 O’Duffy to cabinet, 2 Nov. 1931 (U.C.D.A., FitzGerald papers, P80/857).

22 Department of Justice memo, 5 Apr. 1930 (N.A.I., DT S5864A).

23 ‘Department of Justice Report on the present position (August 1931) ...’ (ibid., DT S5864B).

24 Department of Justice memo, 19 Mar. 1930 (ibid., DT S5074A).

25 McGarry, Frank Ryan, p. 5.

26 Cosgrave to Abp MacRory, 10 Sept. 1931 (N.A.I., DT S5864B).

27 O’Duffy to Executive Council, 21 Oct. 1931 (U.C.D.A., FitzGerald papers, P80/480).

28 Seanad Eireann deb., xiv, 25 (16 Oct. 1931).

29 ‘Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, publications contrary to’, n.d. (N.A.I., DTS228/31).

30 Organisations inimical to the state’, 16 Oct. 1931 (ibid., DT S2439).

31 ‘Copy of confidential report by Commissioner Garda Síochána for period 11 January 1931 -31 May 1931’, 27 July 1931 (U.C.D.A., FitzGerald papers, P80/856 (1)).

32 ‘Interview given by Mr de Valera to representatives of the United Press’, 29 Oct. 1931 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2168).

33 Cosgrave to Abp MacRory, 10 Sept. 1931 (N.A.I., DT S5864B).

34 An Phoblacht, 23 Aug. 1930.

35 Roche to McDunphy, 2 Sept. 1930 (N.A.I., DT S1899).

36 ‘Interview given by Mr de Valera to Mr Henri de Kerillis’, 4 July 1931 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2166).

37 ‘Notes on use of Article 2A by present government’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S2454).

38 See Cronin, Mike, The Blueshirts and Irish politics (Dublin, 1997), pp 135-67Google Scholar.

39 ‘Abnormal duties in 1934’, ‘Return of political outrages’, n.d. (N.A.I., DJ JUS 8/355).

40 Kissane, Bill, Explaining Irish democracy (Dublin, 2002), p. 186 Google Scholar.

41 O’Farrell to de Valera, 5 Mar. 1934 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2290).

42 Dáil Éireann deb., li, 2237 (28 Mar. 1934).

43 De Valera, speech in Tralee, 17 Dec. 1933 (N.A.I., de Valera papers, P150/2279).

44 ‘Outrages in Kerry, 15 August to 5 December 1933’, n.d. (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2279).

45 O’Farrell to de Valera, 5 Mar. 1934 (ibid., P150/2290).

46 Irish Times, 11 Feb. 2003.

47 ‘Notes on the use of Article 2A by present government’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S2454).

48 De Valera, speech in Tralee, 17 Dec. 1933 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2279).

49 See Regan, John M., The Irish counter-revolution, 1921-1936: treatyite politics and settlement in independent Ireland (Dublin, 1999), pp 324-73Google Scholar.

50 MacDermot, Frank, Dáil Éireann deb., li, 2366 (1 Mar. 1934)Google Scholar.

51 ‘Table showing convictions by military tribunal, 1933-1936’, n.d. (N.A.I., DJ JUS 8/396).

52 ‘Persons charged before constitution tribunal’, n.d. (ibid.).

53 Ó Seannacháin to Comhairle Dáil Ceanntair, 30 Dec. 1933 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2279).

54 Kissane, Bill, ‘Democratic consolidation and government changeover in the Irish Free State’ in Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, xxxix (2001), p. 15 Google Scholar.

55 ‘Abnormal duties in 1934’, n.d. (N.A.I., DJ D28/34).

56 Gearty, Conor, ‘Terrorism, morality and human rights’ (public lecture given at the London School of Economics, 20 Jan. 2003)Google Scholar.

57 Irish Press, 30 Mar. 1935.

58 McGarry, Frank Ryan, p. 28.

59 Fanning, Ronan, ‘The rule of order: Eamon de Valera and the I.R.A., 1923-40’ in O’Carroll, J.P. and Murphy, J.A. (eds.) De Valera and his times (Cork, 1983), p. 163 Google Scholar.

60 ‘Resolution no. 25 carried at General Army Convention, 17 March 1933’ (U.C.D.A., Moss Twomey papers, P69/186 (1)).

61 McGarry, Frank Ryan, p. 36.

62 De Valera, speech in Tralee, 17 Dec. 1933 (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2279).

63 ‘Resolution of Kerry Dáil Ceanntair of Fianna Fáil’, 28 Nov. 1933 (ibid.).

64 Hanley, Brian, The I.R.A., 1926-1936 (Dublin, 2002), p. 139 Google Scholar.

65 Ibid., p. 137.

66 Ibid., pp 138-9.

67 Dáil Eireann deb., li, 2505 (1 Mar.1934).

68 ‘Notes on use of Article 2A by present government’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S2454).

69 Irish Times, 17 Aug. 1936.

70 ‘Notes on use of Article 2A by present government’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S2454).

71 ‘Military tribunal statistics’, n.d. (ibid., DJ D29/36).

72 Fanning, ‘Rule of order’, p. 165.

73 McGarry, Fearghal, Irish politics and the Spanish Civil War (Cork, 1999), p. 155 Google Scholar.

74 MacBride to Ó Ceallaigh, 2 May 1936 (N.A.I., DT S1899).

75 Secret Department of Justice memo, 25 Nov. 1935 (ibid., DT S2454).

76 Secret Garda document, 23 Oct.1935 (ibid., DT S2454).

77 Hanley, I.R.A., p. 141.

78 Secret Garda document, 23 Oct. 1935 (N.A.I., DT S2454).

79 Hanley, I.R.A., p. 144.

80 O’Halpin, Defending Ireland, p. 108.

81 Dáil Éireann deb., lxxiv, 1310 (8 Feb. 1939).

82 Ibid., col. 1384 (2 Mar. 1939).

83 ‘General Eoin O’Duffy: Proposed trial by constitution’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S6786).

84 Report of committee to review Offences Against the State Act, p. 52.

85 ‘Constitution Committee, 1934: Report on Part 1 of terms of reference’ (U.C.D.A., de Valera papers, P150/2365).

86 Clarke, D.M., ‘Emergency legislation, fundamental rights, and Article 28.3.3° of the Irish constitution’ in Ir. Jurist, xii (1977), p. 283 Google Scholar.

87 Minister for Justice to each member of Executive Council, 25 Oct. 1934 (N.A.I., DT S1045 A).

88 ‘Legislation to replace Article 2A of former constitution’, 5 Apr. 1938 (ibid.).

89 Office of Minister for Justice to Taoiseach’s Office, 30 Dec. 1938 (ibid.).

90 Report of committee to review Offences Against the State Act, pp 53-4.

91 ‘Police observation on the Offences Against the State Bill’, 7 Feb. 1939 (N.A.I., DT S10454B).

92 Dáil Éireann deb., lxxiv, 1283 (8 Feb. 1939).

93 Ibid., col. 1441 (2 Mar. 1939).

94 Daly, Mary E., Industrial development and Irish national identity, 1922-1939 (Dublin, 1992), p. 171 Google Scholar.

95 Kelly, J.M., Fundamental rights in the Irish law and constitution (Dublin, 1961), p. 253 Google Scholar.

96 Report of committee to review Offences Against the State Act, p. 54.

97 O’Hanlon, R.J., ‘Special courts and military tribunals under the constitution of Ireland: powers of the President in relation to emergency legislation’ in Ir. Jurist, xxxi (1965), p. 3 Google Scholar.

98 Clifford, Angela, The constitutional history of Éire/Ireland (Cork, 1987), p. 317 Google Scholar.

99 MacBride, Seán, Civil liberty: towards a new Ireland (Dublin, 1949), p. 12 Google Scholar.

100 ‘Memorandum summarising provisions of the bill’, n.d. (N.A.I., DT S10454C).

101 ÓGadhra, Nollaig, Civil war in Connacht, 1922-23 (Cork, 1999), p. 9 Google Scholar.

102 Campbell, Colm, Emergency law in Ireland, 1918-1925 (Oxford, 1994), pp 5–6 Google Scholar.

103 Popper, Karl, Philosophy, politics, and scientific method (Cambridge, 1998), p. 65 Google Scholar.

104 Kelly, Fundamental rights, p. 44.

105 See Casey, J.P., Constitutional law in Ireland (2nd ed., London, 1992), p. 50 Google Scholar.

106 See Clarke, ‘Emergency legislation’, pp 217-32.

107 Doolan, Brian, Constitutional law and constitutional rights in Ireland (3rd ed., Dublin, 1994), p. 150 Google Scholar.

108 Lloyd, David, Anomalous states: Irish history and the post-colonial moment (Dublin, 1993), p. 3 Google Scholar.

109 O’Halpin, Defending Ireland, p. 203.

110 Elias, Norbert, The Germans (Cambridge, 1996), pp 171–299 Google Scholar.

111 Capoccia, Giovanni, ‘Defending democracy: reactions to political extremism in interwar Europe’ in European Journal of Political Research, xxxix (2001), p. 432 Google Scholar.

112 Rich, P.B. and Stubbs, Richard (eds), The counter-insurgent state: guerrilla warfare and state building in the twentieth century (Basingstoke & New York, 1997), p. 8 Google Scholar.

113 O’Halpin, Defending Ireland, p. 351.