Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rcrh6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T18:23:00.202Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Bishop Francis Hutchinson (1660–1739): a case study in the eighteenth-century culture of improvement

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Andrew Sneddon*
Affiliation:
School of History and Anthropology, Queen’s University of Belfast

Extract

In recent years our understanding of the attempts of the Irish Protestant élite to convert and ‘civilise’ Ireland in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries has increased substantially. Some historians have examined the various campaigns to convert the largely Irish-speaking Catholic native population to Protestantism, through schools, the employment of Irish-speaking clergy and the publication of key religious texts in Irish. Others have explored Protestant efforts to civilise Ireland by bringing its governmental and legal infrastructure into line with those of England and through the spread of English dress, language, industries and agriculture.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Milne, Kenneth, ‘Irish charter schools’ in Irish Journal of Education, viii (1974), pp 329 Google Scholar; Leerssen, Joep, ‘Archbishop Ussher and Gaelic culture’ in Studia Hib., xxii-xxiii (1982-3), pp 5058 Google Scholar; Barnard, T.C., ‘Protestants and the Irish language, c. 1675–1725’ in Jn. Ecc. Hist., xliv (1993), pp 243-72CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Williams, N.J.A., I bprionta i leabhar: na Protastúin agus prós na Goeilge, 1567–1724 (Dublin, 1986)Google Scholar; Hayton, David, ‘Did Protestantism fail in early eighteenth-century Ireland? Charity schools and the enterprise of religious and social reformation, c. 1690–1730’ in Ford, Alan, McGuire, James and Milne, Kenneth (eds), As by law established: the Church of Ireland since the Reformation (Dublin, 1995), pp 166-86Google Scholar; Sneddon, Andrew, ‘“Darkness must be expell’d by letting in the light”: Bishop Francis Hutchinson and the conversion of Irish Catholics by means of the Irish language’ in Eighteenth-Century Ireland, xix (2004), pp 3755 Google Scholar; Fitzsimon, Betsey Taylor, ‘Conversion, the Bible, and the Irish language: the correspondence of Lady Ranelagh and Bishop Dopping’ in Brown, Michael, McGrath, Charles Ivar and Power, T.P. (eds), Converts and conversion in Ireland, 1650–1850 (Dublin, 2005), pp 157-82Google Scholar.

2 Barnard, T.C., ‘The Hartlib circle and the cult and culture of improvement in Ireland’ in Greengrass, Mark, Leslie, Michael and Raylor, Timothy (eds), Samuel Hartlib and universal reformation: studies in intellectual communication (Cambridge, 1994), pp 281-97Google Scholar; idem, Gardening, diet and “improvement” in later seventeenth-century Ireland’ in Journal of Garden History, x (1990), pp 7185 Google Scholar; Coughlan, Patricia, ‘Natural history and historical nature: the project for a natural history of Ireland’ in Greengrass, et al. (eds), op.cit.,pp 298317 Google Scholar.

3 Proudfoot, Lindsay, ‘Land ownership and improvement, c. 1700 to 1845’ in idem and Nolan, William (eds), Down history and society: interdisciplinary essays on the history of an Irish county (Dublin, 1997), pp 212-19, 221–2, 226Google Scholar; Borsay, Peter and Proudfoot, Lindsay, ‘The English and Irish urban experience, 1500–1800: change, convergence, and divergence’ in iidem (eds), Provincial towns in early modern England and Ireland: change, convergence, and divergence (Oxford, 2002), pp 2, 24Google Scholar; W. H. Crawford, ‘ The creation and evolution of small towns in Ulster in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries’, ibid., pp 102–3; idem, Economy and society in eighteenth-century Ulster’ (Ph.D. thesis, Queen’s University Belfast, 1983), p. 19 Google Scholar; idem, The influence of the landlord in eighteenth-century Ulster’ in Cullen, L.M. and Smout, T.C. (eds), Comparative aspects of Scottish and Irish economic history, 1600–1900 (Edinburgh, 1977), pp 199200 Google Scholar; Barnard, T.C., The kingdom of Ireland, 1641–1760 (Basingstoke, 2004), pp 8089 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, The cultures of eighteenth-century Irish towns’ in Borsay, & Proudfoot, (eds), op. cit., pp 195-6Google Scholar.

4 Barnard, T.C., ‘Reforming Irish manners: the religious societies in Dublin during the 1690s’ in Hist. Jn., xxxv, (1992), pp 805-38CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, Improving clergymen, 1660–1760’ in Ford, , McGuire, & Milne, (eds), As by law established, pp 137, 146Google Scholar.

5 Magennis, Eoin, ‘Coal, corn and canals: parliament and the dispersal of public moneys, 1695–1772’ in Hayton, D.W. (ed.), The Irish parliament in the eighteenth century: the long apprenticeship (Edinburgh, 2001), pp 7186 Google Scholar; Broderick, David, The first toll-roads: Ireland’s turnpike roads, 1729–1858 (Cork, 2002), pp 2783 Google Scholar.

6 Hoppen, K.T., The common scientist in the seventeenth century: a study of the Dublin Philosophical Society, 1683–1708 (London, 1970)Google Scholar; Gribbon, H.D., ‘The Irish Linen Board, 1711–1828’ in Cullen, & Smout, (eds), Comparative aspects, pp 7787 Google Scholar; Livesey, James, ‘The Dublin Society in eighteenth-century Irish political thought’ in Hist. Jn., xlvii (2004), pp 615-40CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Magennis, Eoin, ‘A land of milk and honey: the Physico Historical Society and the surveys of mid-eighteenth-century Ireland’ in R.I.A. Proc., cii (2002), sect. C, pp 199217 Google Scholar.

7 Proudfoot, Lindsay, Property ownership and urban village improvement in provincial Ireland (Edinburgh, 1997), p. 212 Google Scholar.

8 McNally, Patrick, Parties, patriots and undertakers: parliamentary politics in early Hanoverian Ireland (Dublin, 1997), p. 75 Google Scholar; Barnard, T.C., Irish Protestant ascents and descents, 1641–1740 (Dublin, 2004), pp 7880 Google Scholar.

9 Reilly, Susan, ‘William King and the idea of improvement’ in Fauske, C.J. (ed.), Archbishop William King and the Anglican Irish context, 1688–1729 (Dublin, 2003), pp 148-59Google Scholar; Clarke, Desmond, Arthur Dobbs ... surveyor-general of Ireland, prospector and governor of North Carolina (London, 1958)Google Scholar; idem, Prior, Thomas, 1681-1751 : founder of the Royal Dublin Society (Dublin, 1951)Google Scholar; Caffentzis, C.G., ‘Why did Berkeley’s bank fail? Money and libertinism in eighteenth-century Ireland’ in Eighteenth-Century Ireland, xii (1997), pp 100-15Google Scholar; James Kelly, ‘Jonathan Swift and the Irish economy in the 1720s’, ibid., vi (1991), pp 7–36; Mahony, Robert, ‘Protestant dependence and consumption in Swift’s Irish writings’ in Connolly, S.J. (ed.), Political ideas in eighteenth-century Ireland (Dublin, 2000), pp 84104 Google Scholar.

10 See Livesey, ‘Dublin Society’.

11 Hutchinson, Francis, A sermon preached at St Edmund’s Bury, on the first of May, 1707, being the day of thanksgiving for the union of Scotland and England (London, 1707)Google Scholar.

12 Sneddon, Andrew, ‘The life and thought of Bishop Francis Hutchinson, 1660–1739’ (Ph.D. thesis, Lancaster University, 2003), pp 110-78Google Scholar.

13 Hutchinson, , A sermon preached in Christ’s Church, Dublin, on the first of August, 1721 (Dublin, 1721) pp 35 Google Scholar; idem, A sermon preached in Christ’s Church, Dublin, on Friday, November 5th, 1731 (Dublin, 1731), pp 24, 26Google Scholar; idem, The certainty of Protestants a safer foundation than the infallibility of papists (Dublin, 1738), pp 78 Google Scholar.

14 Hutchinson to Abp William Wake, June 1721 (Christ Church, Oxford, Wake MSS, xiii, no. 251)Google Scholar; Hutchinson, Sermon ...November 5th, 1731, p. 30.

15 Hutchinson, Francis, A defence of the ancient historians (Dublin, 1734), p. 128 Google Scholar.

16 Victory, Isolde, ‘The making of the Declaratory Act of 1720’ in O’Brien, Gerald (ed.), Parliament, politics and people: essays in eighteenth-century Irish history (Dublin, 1989), pp 824 Google Scholar.

17 McNally, Patrick, ‘Wood’s Halfpence, Carteret, and the government of Ireland, 1723–6’ in I.H.S., xxx, no. 119 (May 1997), pp 354-76Google Scholar.

18 For a detailed account of Hutchinson’s conversion projects see Sneddon, ‘ “Darkness must be expell’d” ‘, pp 37–55.

19 Hutchinson, , A sermon preached in Christ-Church, Dublin, on Thursday the 30th day of January, 1723 (Dublin, 1723), p. 7 Google Scholar.

20 Dobbs wrote An essay on the trade and improvement of Ireland (2 vols, Dublin, 1728-30)Google Scholar, built the Newry Canal, and was a founding and active member of the Dublin Society.

21 In the post-Revolution church, latitudinarian Anglicans were a relatively small group of influential clergymen closely associated with the promotion of the new science, as well as the Whig interest and rational religion.

22 Stewart, Larry, The rise of public science: rhetoric, technology and natural philosophy in Newtonian Britain, 1660–1750 (Cambridge, 1992), pp 119, 154, 146Google Scholar; Shapin, Steven, The scientific revolution (Chicago, 1996), pp 115, 117–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gascoigne, John, ‘Politics, patronage and Newtonianism: the Cambridge example’ in Hist. Jn., xxvii (1984), pp 124 Google Scholar.

23 Jacob, M.C., The Newtonians and the English revolution, 1689–1720 (Hassocks, 1976), pp 18, 20, 163–200, 271Google Scholar; Gascoigne, John, Cambridge in the age of the Enlightenment — science, religion and politics from the Restoration to the French Revolution (Cambridge, 1989), pp 46 Google Scholar.

24 Harrison, Peter, The Bible, Protestantism, and the rise of natural science (Cambridge, 1998), pp 193204 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Walsh, John and Taylor, Stephen, ‘Introduction’ in John Walsh, Colin Haydon and Stephen Taylor (eds), The Church of England, c. 1689–1844: from toleration to Tractarianism (Cambridge, 1993), pp 3640 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Martin Fitzpatrick, ‘Latitudinarianism at the parting of the ways: a suggestion’, ibid., pp 209–13; Gascoigne, John, ‘Anglican latitudinarianism and political radicalism in the late eighteenth century’ in History, lxxi (1986), pp 22-4CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Porter, Roy, Enlightenment, Britain and the creation of the modern world (London, 2000), pp 99128 Google Scholar.

26 Peltonen, Markku, ‘Politeness and Whiggism, 1688–1732’ in Hist. Jn., xlviii (2005), pp 391413 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Borsay, Peter, ‘The culture of improvement’ in Langford, Paul (ed.), The eighteenth century (Oxford, 2002), pp 183-4, 189Google Scholar.

28 Stewart, Public science, p. 16.

29 Sneddon, ‘Hutchinson’, pp 37–42.

30 Hutchinson, Certainty of Protestants, p. 17.

31 Idem, A short view of the pretended spirit of prophecy, taken from its first rise in the year 1688, to its present state among us (Edinburgh, 1709), pp 13–43,49, 54–70, 173—4; idem, A compassionate address to those papists, who will be prevail’d with to examine the cause for which they suffer (London, 1716), p. 20.

32 Idem, An historical essay concerning witchcraft (London, 1718), pp 12, 50, 132–4, 150–60; Bostridge, Ian, Witchcraft and its transformations, c. 1650–1750 (Oxford, 1997), pp 144-51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 Hutchinson, Francis, A sermon preached at the publick commencement at Cambridge, 3 July 1698 (Cambridge, 1698), pp 1112 Google Scholar.

34 Idem,Historical essay, p. 258; idem, Sermon ...November 5th, 1731, p. 22.

35 Idem, Historical essay, p. 257.

36 Ibid., p. 232.

37 Ibid., p. 134.

38 Hutchinson to Cox Macro, 12 Nov. 1722 (B.L., Add. MS 32556, f. 151).

39 Hutchinson to Sir Hans Sloane, 12 Oct. 1723 (ibid., Sloane MS 4047, ff 67–8).

40 Sneddon, ‘Hutchinson’, pp 22–9; Falvey, Jeremiah, ‘The Church of Ireland episcopate in the eighteenth century: an overview’ in Eighteenth-Century Ireland, viii (1993), pp 106, 113Google Scholar.

41 Hayton, D.W., ‘From barbarian to burlesque: English images of the Irish, c. 1660–1750’ in Ir. Econ. & Soc. Hist., xv (1988), pp 89 Google Scholar.

42 Hutchinson, Francis, A letter to a member of parliament, concerning the imploying and providing for the poor (Dublin, 1723), p. 10 Google Scholar.

43 Ibid., p. 11.

44 Kelly,’Swift’, p. 7.

45 Connolly, S.J., Religion, law, and power: the making of Protestant Ireland, 1660–1760 (Oxford, 1992), p. 41 Google Scholar.

46 Kelly, James, ‘Harvests and hardship: famine and scarcity in Ireland in the late 1720s’ in Studia Hib., xxvi (1991-2), p. 65 Google Scholar; Cullen, L.M., An economic history of Ireland since 1660 (2nd ed., London, 1972), pp 43-9Google Scholar.

47 Cullen, Econ. hist. Ire., p. 49; Kelly, ‘Harvests & hardship’, pp 78–9, 82, 86–7, 90; Kelly, ‘Swift’, p. 28; printed transcript of a subscription list drawn up by Abp Boulter, to relieve the poor of Ireland, c. 1729 (P.R.O.N.I., T/656/1, p. 187).

48 Kelly, ‘Harvests & hardship’, pp 89–103; idem, ‘Swift’, p. 28.

49 Lords jn. Ire., ii, 712.

50 Commons jn. Ire. (4th ed., Dublin, 1796–1802), xiii, 267–8.

51 Lords jn. Ire., ii, 684; Ryder, Michael, ‘The bank of Ireland, 1721: land, credit and dependency’ in Hist. Jn., xxv (1982), pp 559-69Google Scholar.

52 Ryder, ‘Bank of Ireland’, pp 564, 577, 570–81; Moore, Seán, ‘Satiric norms, Swift’s financial satires and the bank of Ireland controversy of 1720–1’ in Eighteenth-Century Ireland, liv (2002), pp 26, 29–31, 38–11Google Scholar.

53 Hall, F.G., History of the Bank of Ireland (Dublin, 1949), pp 1824 Google Scholar.

54 Hutchinson, Francis, A letter to the gentlemen of the landed interest in Ireland, relating to a bank (Dublin, 1721), p. 4 Google Scholar.

55 Ibid., p. 10.

56 Ibid.

57 Ibid., p. 11.

58 Ibid., p. 23.

59 Ibid., pp 23–4.

60 Ibid., p. 20.

61 Ibid., p. 23.

62 Bishop Francis Hutchinson commonplace book, 1721–30, pp 11–13, 37, 39, 56–7 (2nd pagination) (P.R.O.N.I., Down diocesan papers, DIO/1/22/1. This commonplace book is split into three sections and has a peculiar pattern of pagination: the first section has its own pagination; the middle section has no pagination; while the final section also has its own pagination. Thus, in order to avoid confusion, the first section is referred to as 1st pagination and the third section as 2nd pagination.

63 Hutchinson, Letter ... relating to a bank, p. 31.

64 Ibid.

65 Kelly,‘Swift’,p. 13.

66 Kelly, Patrick, ‘The politics of political economy in mid-eighteenth-century Ireland’ in Connolly, (ed.), Political ideas, p. 113 Google Scholar.

67 Hutchinson, Letter to a member of parliament, p. 12.

68 Ibid.

69 Ibid., p. 14.

70 Ibid., pp 2–9,15.

71 Ibid., p. 5.

72 Ibid.

73 Ibid., pp 6–9.

74 Ibid., pp 2–3, 5–9.

75 Ibid., p. 9.

76 Ibid., pp 3–4, 6.

77 Molesworth, Robert, Some considerations for the promoting of agriculture, and employing the poor (Dublin, 1723), p. 41 Google Scholar.

78 SirFownes, William, Methods proposed for regulating the poor, supporting some and employing others, according to their several capacities (Dublin, 1725), pp 614 Google Scholar.

79 Kelly,‘Swift’, pp 13–15.

80 Molesworth, Some considerations, pp i-ii, 5–7, 18, 21, 23–7, 42.

81 Ibid., p. ii.

82 Ibid., p. 39.

83 Ibid., pp 39–40.

84 Ibid., pp 23, 24.

85 Ibid., p. 30.

86 Ibid.

87 Ibid.

88 Ibid., p. 31.

89 Ibid.

90 Barnard, Kingdom of Ireland, p. 80; Berman, David, ‘The culmination and causation of Irish philosophy’ in Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie, liv (1982), pp 257-79Google Scholar; Stewart, M.A., ‘John Smith and the Molesworth circle’ in Eighteenth-Century Ireland, ii (1987), pp 89102 Google Scholar.

91 Considerations upon ‘Considerations for promoting of agriculture, and providing for the poor’ (2nd ed., Dublin, 1724), pp 17,44-71Google Scholar.

92 Kelly,‘Swift’, pp 23, 31.

93 Kelly, ‘Politics of political economy’, p. 107.

94 Ibid., p. 113.

95 Ibid., pp 112, 108.

96 Hutchinson, Francis, A second letter to a member of parliament, recommending the improvement of the Irish fishery (Dublin, 1729), p. 27 Google Scholar.

97 Ibid., pp 29–30.

98 Harris, Bob, ‘Scotland’s herring fisheries and the prosperity of the nation, c. 1660–1760’ in Scot. Hist. Rev., lxxix (2000), pp 3943, 60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

99 Hutchinson, Second letter, p. 17.

100 Ibid., p. 27.

101 Barnard, T.C., ‘Fishing in seventeenth-century Kerry: the experience of Sir William Petty’ in Kerry Arch. & Hist. Soc. Jn., xvi (1989), p. 14 Google Scholar; Kelly, James, ‘William Burton Conyngham and the north-west fishery of the eighteenth century’ in R.S.A.I. Jn., cxv (1985), p. 65 Google Scholar.

102 Hutchinson, Second letter, pp 3–4; Commons jn. Ire., iii, 570.

103 Kelly, ‘Harvests & hardship’, p. 79.

104 Hutchinson, Second letter, p. 22.

105 Ibid., pp 13–15.

106 Bishop Francis Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, p. 131 (Down, Connor and Dromore Diocesan Registry, Belfast)Google Scholar.

107 Hutchinson, Second letter, pp 12–13.

108 Ibid., pp 15–16.

109 Ibid., pp 20–21.

110 Kelly, ‘Harvests & hardship’, pp 95–100.

111 Magennis, ‘Coal, corn & canals’, pp 71–86.

112 Privy council registers, 1 June 1729 - 16 June 1732 (The National Archives [UK], P.R.O., PC 2/91); Lords jn. Ire., iii, 86–147; Commons jn. Ire., iii, 575–652.

113 Kelly, ‘Conyngham’, pp 64–5.

114 Harris, ‘Scotland’s herring fisheries’, pp 47–52.

115 Dickson, David, New foundations: Ireland 1660–1800 (2nd ed., Dublin, 2000), pp 115-16Google Scholar; Griffin, Patrick, The people with no name: Ireland’s Ulster Scots, America’s Scots Irish, and the creation of a British Atlantic world, 1689–1767 (Princeton, 2002), p. 97 Google Scholar.

116 A list of the members of the Dublin Society (Dublin, 1734), pp 39 Google Scholar; Connolly, Religion, law, & power, p. 57.

117 Dublin Society (R.D.S.) minute book, 1733–41, pp 1–87; 1731–3, pp 1–80.

118 Ibid., 1733–41, pp 33, 62, 65; ibid., 1731–3, pp 31–3, 45-6, 60, 22, 36.

119 Clarke, Prior.pp 34–7.

120 Dublin Society min. bk., 1731–3, pp 23, 24; ibid., 1733–41, pp 1, 40, 60, 73, 91, 98.

121 Clarke, Dobbs, pp 28–9.

122 Dublin Society min. bk., 1731–3, pp 45–7.

123 Ibid., 1733–41, p. 33.

124 Hutchinson, Francis, The state of the case of Loughneagh and the Bann (Dublin, 1738), p. 9 Google Scholar.

125 Ibid., pp 3–12.

126 Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, p. 159 (Diocesan Registry, Belfast).

127 Roebuck, Peter, ‘Landlord indebtedness in Ulster in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries’ in Goldstrom, J.M. and Clarkson, L.A. (eds), Irish population, economy and society: essays in honour of K. H. Connell (Oxford, 1981), p. 150 Google Scholar.

128 Notes in Hutchinson’s hand, c. 1726 (R.I.A., Irish manuscript collection, Antrim, Box 14: Lisburn, pp 116–18)Google Scholar.

129 Barnard, ‘Hartlib circle’, pp 296–7.

130 Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, pp 136–7, 401, 403 (Diocesan Registry, Belfast); Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1721–30, pp 57, 216 (2nd pagination) (P.R.O.N.I., MSDIO/1/22/1Google Scholar.

131 Dublin Society min. bk., 1731–3, p. 79.

132 Ibid., 1733–41, p. 65.

133 Hutchinson, State of the case, pp 16–19, 23.

134 Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1721–30, p. 57 (2nd pagination) (P.R.O.N.I., MS DIO/1/22/1)Google Scholar.

135 Ibid., p. 15 (1st pagination).

136 Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, pp 13, 96 (Diocesan Registry, Belfast).

137 A catalogue of books; being in the library of the Right Rev. Dr Francis Hutchinson, late bishop of Down and Connor (Dublin, 1756)Google Scholar; Wheeler, Gordon, ‘Bishop Francis Hutchinson: his Irish publications and his library’ in Gray, John and McCann, Wesley (eds), An uncommon bookman (Belfast, 1996), p. 147 Google Scholar.

138 Clarkson, L.A., ‘Hospitality, housekeeping and high living in eighteenth-century Ireland’ in Hill, Jacqueline and Lennon, Colm (eds), Luxury and austerity: Historical Studies XXI (Dublin, 1999), p. 88 Google Scholar; Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, pp 403, 418-19 (Diocesan Registry, Belfast).

139 Hutchinson commonplace bk., 1731–9, pp 401, 403 (Diocesan Registry, Belfast).

140 Ibid., p. 13.

141 Ibid., pp 129,424.

142 Incorporated Society cash book no. 1, 1733–78, (T.C.D., Incorporated Society records, MS 5419)Google Scholar.

143 Hayton, ‘Did Protestantism fail?’, p. 181.

144 Sibbet, R.M., On the shining Bann: records of an Ulster manor, for all touring in Northern Ireland (Belfast, 1928), pp 171-4Google Scholar.

145 I wish to thank Dr Robert Poole and Dr Toby Barnard for reading and commenting upon earlier drafts of this article.