1 See for example: Howe, Stephen, Ireland and empire: colonial legacies in Irish history and culture (Oxford, 2000)Google Scholar; McDonough, Terrence (ed.), Was Ireland a colony? Economics, politics and change in nineteenth-century Ireland (Dublin, 2005)Google Scholar; Kenny, Kevin (ed.), Ireland and the British Empire (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar; Cleary, Joe, ‘Amongst empires: a short history of Ireland and empire studies in international context’ in Éire-Ireland, xxxii, 1–2 (2007), pp 11–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Mansergh, Nicholas, Survey of British Commonwealth affairs: problems of wartime co-operation and post-war change, 1939–1952 (Oxford, 1958), p. 59.Google Scholar

3 Idem, The unresolved question: the Anglo-Irish question and its undoing, 1912–72 (New Haven, 1991), p. 321.

4 Ibid., pp 34, 82, 103; Ward, Alan J., The Irish constitutional tradition: responsible government in modern Ireland, 1782–1992 (Dublin, 1994), pp 81–4Google Scholar; Peatling, G. K., British opinion and Irish self-government, 1865–1925 (Dublin, 2001), pp 46-7, 61–70, 113–17, 153–4Google Scholar; Knirck, Jason, ‘The dominion of Ireland: the Anglo-Irish Treaty in an imperial context’ in Éire-Ireland, xxxii, 1–2 (2007), pp 229-55CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Finnan, Joseph P., John Redmond and Irish unity, 1912–1918 (Syracuse, 2004), pp 87-8.Google Scholar

5 Gwynn, Denis, The life of John Redmond (London, 1932), pp 384, 532Google Scholar; Kendle, John, Walter Long, Ireland and the Union, 1908–20 (Dún Laoghaire, 1992), pp 50, 140Google Scholar; McDowell, R. B., The Irish Convention, 1917–18 (London, 1970), p. 50Google Scholar; Lowry, Donal, ‘Irish-South African relations and the British Commonwealth, c. 1902–1961’ in McCracken, Donal (ed.), Ireland and South Africa in modern times (Durban, 1996), pp 90-1Google Scholar; Horace Plunkett to John X. Merriman, 22 Oct. 1917 (South African Library, Cape Town, Merriman papers); Merriman to Plunkett, 28 July 1917, 12 Dec. 1917, 19 Feb. 1925, 2 Apr. 1925 (Plunkett Foundation, University of Oxford, Plunkett papers); Southborough to Plunkett, 31 July 1918, Plunkett to Merriman, 22 Oct. 1917 (ibid.).

6 Digby, Margaret, Horace Plunkett: an Anglo-American Irishman (Oxford, 1949), pp 217, 239–40.Google Scholar

7 Mansergh, The unresolved question, pp 32, 82, 103.

8 Millin, Sarah Gertude, General Smuts (London, 1936), p. 292Google Scholar; Forester, Margery, Michael Collins (Dublin, 1989), p. 112Google Scholar; Art O’Brien to Eamon de Valera, 4 June 1921 (N.A.I., DE2/ 526).

9 Plunkett to Jan Christiaan Smuts, 8 June 1921 (State Archives Pretoria (S.A.P.), Smuts papers).

10 StErvine, John, Craigavon: Ulsterman (London, 1949), pp 421, 439Google Scholar; Lowry, Donal, ‘Ulster resistance and loyalist rebellion in the Empire’ in Jeffery, Keith (ed.), ‘An Irish empire’? Aspects of Ireland and the British Empire (Manchester, 1996), p. 96.Google Scholar

11 Geyser, O., ‘Irish independence: Jan Smuts and Eamon de Valera’ in Round Table, no. 348 (1998), pp 473-84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Costello, Frank, ‘King George V’s speech: prelude to the Anglo-Irish truce’ in Éire-Ireland, xx (1987), pp 43–87Google Scholar; correspondence between Smuts and inter alia Stamfordham, Lord, George, David Lloyd and George, V in der Poel, Jean van (ed.), Selections from the Smuts papers (Cambridge, 1973), v, 87–105Google Scholar; Earl of Longford and O’Neill, Thomas P., Eamon de Valera (London, 1970), p. 130.Google Scholar

12 Art O’Brien to Michael Collins, 28 Dec. 1920 (U.C.D.A., De Valera papers, P150/1900); Collins, Michael, ‘Ireland as the pivot of a League of Nations’ in Manchester Guardian, 7 Dec. 1921Google Scholar; idem, The path to freedom (Dublin, 1922), pp 29, 39,43, 89–92; Rosenthal, Eric, General de Wet (Cape Town, 1968), p. 281Google Scholar; O’Rahilly, Alfred, The case for the Treaty (n.d.); Duncan Hall, H., The British Commonwealth of Nations (London, 1920)Google Scholar; Harkness, David, ‘Britain and the independence of the dominions: the 1921 crossroads’ in Moody, T. W. (ed.), Nationality and the pursuit of national independence (Belfast, 1978), p. 158.Google Scholar

13 Massey, Vincent, What’s past is prologue (London, 1963), p. 247.Google Scholar

14 Martin, Ged, ‘The Irish Free State and the evolution of the Commonwealth’ in Hyam, R. and Martin, G. (eds), Reappraisals in British imperial history (London, 1975), pp 201, 206–7Google Scholar; Swinfen, D. B., Imperial appeal: the debate on appeal to the Privy Council, 1833–1986 (Manchester, 1987), pp 88–93.Google Scholar

15 Documents on Irish foreign policy (5 vols, Dublin, 1998–2006), and see in particular Kennedy, Michael, Ireland and the League of Nations, 1919–1946 (Dublin 1996)Google Scholar and Skelly, J. M., Irish diplomacy at the United Nations, 1945–1965 (Dublin, 1996).Google Scholar

16 Deirdre McMahon, Republicans and imperialists (New Haven, 1984); idem, ‘A larger and noisier Southern Ireland: Ireland and the evolution of dominion status in India, Burma and the Commonwealth, 1942–9’ in Kennedy, Michael and Morrison Skelly, Joseph (eds), Irish foreign policy (Dublin, 2000), pp 155-91Google Scholar; idem, ‘Ireland and the Empire-Commonwealth’ in Judith M. Brown and Wm. Roger Louis (eds), The Oxford history of the British Empire: vol iv: the twentieth century (Oxford, 1999), pp 138–62; idem, ‘Ireland, the Empire, and the Commonwealth’ in Kenny (ed.), Ireland & the British Empire, pp 182–219; Canning, Paul, British policy towards Ireland (Oxford, 1985).Google Scholar

17 ‘Notes on conversations’ in Mansergh, Nicholas, Nationalism and independence (Cork, 1997), p. 191.Google Scholar

18 Fanning, Ronan, ‘Anglo-Irish relations’ in Irish Studies in International Affairs, iv (1985), p. 15.Google Scholar

19 Idem, Independent Ireland (Dublin, 1983), p. 83 (Lowry’s italics).

20 Coogan, T. P., De Valera: long fellow, long shadow (London, 1995), p. 422.Google Scholar

21 Kennedy, Ireland & the League, p. 74.

22 Keown, Gerard, ‘Creating an Irish foreign policy in the 1920s’ in Kennedy, & Skelly, (eds), Irish foreign policy, 1919–66, p. 28Google Scholar; O’Malley, Kate, Ireland, India and empire (Manchester, 2008), p. 53.Google Scholar

23 Kennedy, Ireland & the League, p. 21; Collins, The path to freedom, p. 43.

24 Canning, British policy, p. 82.

25 Mansergh, Nicholas, The Irish Free State: its government and politics (London, 1934), p. 271.Google Scholar

26 Martin, ‘The Irish Free State’, pp 206, 217.

27 Kennedy, Ireland & the League, p. 50.

28 See Stewart, R. B., Treaty relations of the British Commonwealth of Nations (New York, 1939), pp 338-42Google Scholar; Kennedy, Ireland & the League, ch. 1 and p. 258; Harvey, H. J., Consultation and co-operation in the Commonwealth (London, 1952), pp 282-3Google Scholar; Keith, A. B., The governments of the British Empire (London, 1936), pp 95-6.Google Scholar

29 Keith, A. B., The constitutional law of the dominions (London, 1933), p. 80.Google Scholar

30 Kennedy, Ireland & the League, pp 184–5.

31 Kennedy, M., ‘The Irish Free State and the League of Nations’ in Irish Studies in International Affairs, iii (1992), pp 18–19.Google Scholar

32 Keogh, Dermot, Ireland and Europe, 1919–1948 (Dublin, 1988), p. 30.Google Scholar

33 Carroll, Joseph T., Ireland in the war years (New York, 1975), p. 37.Google Scholar

34 Memorandum from Seán T. O’Ceallaigh to Pope Benedict XV, 18 May 1920, Paris 1920 (N.A.I., D.F.A., E.S.).

35 Keogh, Dermot, Ireland and the Vatican: the politics and diplomacy of Church-state relations, 1922–1960 (Cork, 1995), p. 40Google Scholar; Joseph Walshe to Sean Murphy, 2 May 1929 (N.A.I., D.F.A., secretary’s files, S28A).

36 Keogh, Ireland & the Vatican, pp 79–80; idem, The Vatican, the bishops and Irish politics, 1919–1939 (Cambridge, 1986), pp 39, 261; Holmes, Michael, ‘The Irish and India: imperialism, nationalism and internationalism’ in Bielenberg, Andy (ed.), The Irish diaspora (London, 2000).Google Scholar

37 Memorandum on the attitude of France towards Ireland, 10 Oct. 1920 (N.A.I., Gavan Duffy papers, 1125/10).

38 Keogh, Ireland & the Vatican, p. 118.

39 Memorandum on the Taoiseach’s right to advise a dissolution, 11 May 1944 (T.C.D., Frederick H. Boland papers, MS 10470/9).

40 Harkness, David, The restless dominion (London, 1969), pp 56–79.Google Scholar

41 See Martin, ‘The Irish Free State’, p. 217.

42 Canning, British policy, p. 75; Lavin, Deborah, From Empire to international Commonwealth: a biography of Lionel Curtis (Oxford, 1995), p. 212CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Callanan, Frank, T. M. Healy (Cork, 1996), pp 595-8.Google Scholar

43 Roskill, S., Hankey: man of secrets: vol. 2,1919-1931 (London, 1972), p. 480.Google Scholar

44 Stewart, R. B., Treaty relations of the British Commonwealth of Nations (New York, 1939). pp 338–42.Google Scholar

45 Whelan, Bernadette, United States foreign policy and Ireland from empire to independence, 1913–29 (Dublin, 2006).Google Scholar

46 Hartley, S., The Irish question as a problem in British foreign policy, 1914–18 (London, 1987), p. 198CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Carroll, F. M., American opinion and the Irish question, 1910–23 (Dublin, 1978), ch. 5–6Google Scholar; O’Day, Alan, ‘Irish nationalism and Anglo-American relations in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries’ in Leventhal, Fred M. and Quinault, Roland (eds), Anglo-American attitudes from revolution to partnership (London, 2000), pp 168-94.Google Scholar

47 Coogan, De Valera, pp 141–5.

48 Hopkinson, M., Green against green: the Irish Civil War (Dublin, 1988), p. 47Google Scholar. See also memorandum from Harry Boland to Eamon de Valera, 4 Aug. 1921 (U.C.D., D.F.A., E.S., box 27, file 150); Nolan, Aengus, Joseph Walshe: Irish foreign policy, 1922–1946 (Cork, 2008), p. 115.Google Scholar

49 Coogan, De Valera, p. 422.

50 T. M. Healy to J. H. Thomas, 8 July 1924 (N.A.I., D.T., S1983); Harkness, Restless dominion, pp 63–4.

51 Timothy Smiddy to Desmond FitzGerald, 5 Apr. 1927 (N.A.I., D.F.A., EA231/1/1929).

52 Keogh, ‘Profile of Joseph Walshe’, p. 71.

53 Dwyer, De Valera, p. 180.

54 O’Brien, John, ‘Australia, Britain, Ireland and the Ottawa conference’ in MacDonagh, Oliver and Mandle, W. F. (eds), Ireland and Australia (Canberra, 1989)Google Scholar, passim; McMahon, Republicans, pp 48–55, 68–87, 251–3.

55 McMahon, Republicans, p. 194.

56 Preston, Richard, The defence of the undefended border: planning for war in North America, 1867–1939 (Montreal, 1977), p. 277.Google Scholar

57 MacDonald, C. A., The United States, Britain and appeasement, 1937–1939 (London, 1981).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

58 Dwyer, T. Ryle , De Valera (Dublin, 1991), p. 215.Google Scholar

59 Canning, British policy, p. 286.

60 Carroll, J., ‘U.S.-Irish relations’ in Irish Sword, xix (1993-95), pp 99–100.Google Scholar

61 Rosenberg, J. L., ‘The 1941 mission of Frank Aiken to the United States’ in I.H.S., xx, no. 86 (1980), pp 163–74Google Scholar; Keogh, Dermot, Twentieth-century Ireland (New York, 1995), p. 119.Google Scholar

62 Fanning, Ronan, ‘The Anglo-American alliance and the Irish application for membership of the United Nations’ in Irish Studies in International Affairs, ii (1986), p. 45.Google Scholar

63 See Skelly, Irish diplomacy, p. 93.

64 Harkness, Restless dominion, p. 32.

65 William T. Cosgrave to James Barry Munnik Hertzog, 6 Nov. 1926; Hertzog to Cosgrave 16 Nov. 1926; Col. Maurice Moore to Hertzog, 11 Oct. 1930 (S.A.P., Prime Minister’s office, Hertzog papers (MEM), vol. 1/77); ‘Arrival of General Hertzog’ in Irish Times, 1 Nov. 1930; ‘Ireland and South Africa’, and ‘Free State and South Africa’ in ibid., 2 Nov. 1930; ‘General Hertzog in Ireland - free partners in Commonwealth’ in Daily Telegraph, 3 Nov. 1930; ‘Ireland proud of General Hertzog’ in Rand Daily Mail, 3 Nov. 1930.

66 Cook, Ramsay, ‘A Canadian account of the 1926 Imperial Conference’ in Journal of Commonwealth Political Studies, iii (1965), pp 57-8.Google ScholarX

67 See O’Malley, Ireland, India & empire, ch. 2–3.

68 Mansergh, Survey, p. 359; Cabinet printed note CP 237 (37) (copy), 14 Oct. 1937 (University of Durham, Malcolm MacDonald papers, 10/4/22-4).

69 Keith, A. B., The dominions as sovereign states: their constitutions and governments (London, 1938), pp xiii–xiv.Google Scholar

70 Mansergh, Nationalism & independence, p. 191.

71 Fisk, Robert, In time of war: Ireland, Ulster and the price of neutrality, 1939–45 (Dublin, 1983), p. 30.Google Scholar

72 Charles te Water to Hertzog, 18 May 1932 (S.A.P., Department of External Affairs, BTS1/31/1); de Valera to Hertzog, 31 May 1935 (N.A.I., D.F.A., 5/211); Hertzog to de Valera, 4 June 1935 (S.A.P., Te Water papers, AE2/15/xix). See also ‘Mr. de Valera and Gen. Hertzog - reply to appeal on the oath’ in Manchester Guardian, 9 Apr. 1932; ‘South Africa and Free State - General Hertzog’s message’, and ‘Interest in Capetown - General Hertzog and the republicans’ in The Times, 9 Apr. 1932; ‘Die kabelgramme aan De Valera’ in Die Burger [Cape Town], 11 Apr. 1932; ‘General Smuts and the Irish “family trouble”’ in Cape Argus, 18 Apr. 1932; ‘Anglo-Irish dispute - General Hertzog as arbitrator’ in Pretoria News, 2 July 1932.

73 McMahon, Republicans, p. 74; Smuts to A. and M. Gillett, 13 July 1932 (University of Cambridge, Smuts papers [microfilm]).

74 Mansergh, Nationalism & independence, p. 285; Stewart, Andrew, ‘The British government and the South African neutrality crisis, 1938–39’ in English Historical Review, cxxiii (2008), pp 947-72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

75 Department of External Affairs, vol. 2: Imperial Conference minutes, 14 June 1937 (S.A.P., BTS1/31/1); Mansergh, Nicholas, Survey of British Commonwealth affairs: problems of external policy, 1931–1939 (Oxford, 1952), pp 270–333Google Scholar; Holland, Robert, Britain and the Commonwealth alliance>, 1918–1939 (London, 1981), ch. 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tamchina, R., ‘In search of common causes: the Imperial Conference of 1937’ in Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, i (1972-73), pp 81-2.Google Scholar

76 McMahon, Republicans, pp 209, 213; memorandum by Malcolm MacDonald, 4 June 1937 (T.N.A., D035/891/XI/72).

77 See Hancock, W. K., Survey of British Commonwealth affairs, 1918–1939 (London, 1942), ch. 3Google Scholar; Darwin, John, ‘Imperialism in decline? Tendencies in British imperial policy between the wars’ in Historical Journal, xxiii (1980), pp 661–4.Google Scholar

78 Memorandum on passports from Joseph P. Walshe to Eamon de Valera, 12 Dec. 1938 (U.C.D.A., De Valera papers, PI50/2550).

79 Wyk, A. van, Vyfdae: oorlogskrisis van 1939 (Cape Town, 1985)Google Scholar; Louw, Eric H., L.V., lerland toon die weg aan (Beaufort West, 1939).Google Scholar

80 Mansergh, , Survey (1958), p. 155.Google Scholar

81 J. P. Walshe to assistant secretary concerning visit of Colonel Reitz, 28 Nov. 1939 (N.A.I., DFA235/108); Reitz, Deneys, No outspan (London, 1943), pp 256-60Google Scholar; Martin, A., ‘An Australian Prime Minister in Ireland: R. G. Menzies 1941’in Smith, F. B. (ed.), Ireland, England and Australia (Canberra, 1990), pp 195–200Google Scholar; Menzies, R., Afternoon light: some memories of men and events (London, 1967), pp 36–43.Google Scholar

82 Mansergh, , Survey (1958), pp 77,155, 187Google Scholar; Carroll, Ireland in the war years, pp 145–6, 153–4; Cunningham, Emma, ‘Ireland, Canada and the American note’ in Keogh, Dermot and O’Driscoll, Mervyn (eds), Ireland and World War II: diplomacy and survival (Cork, 2006), pp 144-58.Google Scholar

83 O’Farrell, Patrick, ‘Irish-Australian diplomatic relations’ in Quadrant, xxxiv (1980), p. 12 [Lowry’s italics].Google Scholar

84 Mansergh, The unresolved question, p. 321.

85 Skelly, Irish diplomacy, p. 36; Daly, M. E., ‘The Irish Free State/Éire/Republic of Ireland/Ireland: “A country by any other name?”’ in Journal of British Studies, xliv (Jan. 2007), pp 72–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

86 Sexton, Brendan, Ireland and the Crown, 1922–1936 (Dublin, 1989), p. 112.Google Scholar

87 Te Water diary, 11 July 1933 (S.A.P., Te Water papers, AE2/37).

88 McMahon, Republicans, p. 24.

89 Massey, What’s past is prologue, p. 298; Te Water diary, 11 July 1933 (S.A.P., Te Water papers, AE2/37).

90 Chisolm, A. and Davie, M., Beaverbrook (London, 1992), p. 181.Google Scholar

91 Harkness, ‘Patrick McGilligan’, p. 118.

92 Keogh, Ireland & the Vatican, p. 118.

93 Ibid., p. 81.

94 Memorandum to Dr Bodenstein, Ottawa, 23 July 1932 (S.A.P., Department of External Affairs, BTS1/31/1).

95 Note on Mr Patrick Harnnon’s public services, n.d. (House of Lords, Sir Patrick Hannon papers, H57/1); Lysaght, Charles, Brendan Bracken (London, 1979).Google Scholar

96 Fedorowich, Kent, ‘The problems of disbandment: the R.I.C. and imperial migration, 1919–1929’ in I.H.S., xxx, no. 117 (May 1996), p. 99.Google Scholar

97 Keogh, Ireland & the Vatican, pp 133–4; Darwin, ‘Imperialism in decline?’, pp 661–4.

98 Mansergh, Nationalism and independence, p. 93.

99 P. Kennedy, ‘Why did the British Empire last so long?’ in idem, Strategy and diplomacy (London, 1989, p. 209.

100 Mansergh, Nationalism & independence, p. 189.

101 Memorandum by Malcolm MacDonald, July 1936 (T.N.A., ISC(32)108), quoted in McMahon, Republicans, p. 182.

102 Ibid.; Geyer, A. L., Vierjaar in ‘Highveld’ (Cape Town, 1969), pp 50, 70–1Google Scholar; secretary of external affairs to secretary of An Rialtas, 4 Oct. 1951 (N.A.I., D.T., S15153); Broodryk, M. and van der Westhuizen, J., Die Nasionale Party, 1940–1948 (Bloemfontein, 1994), p. 701.Google Scholar

103 Keogh, Ireland & Europe, p. 207.

104 Mansergh, Nicholas, The Commonwealth experience: vol. II: from British to multiracial Commonwealth (Toronto, 1982), p. 140Google Scholar; idem, The unresolved question, p. 315.

105 McCabe, I., ‘John Costello announces’ the repeal of the External Relations Act’ in Irish Studies in International Affairs, iii (1992), pp 67–77.Google Scholar

106 Worrall, A. and Lorimer, W., ‘Highveld’: the story of a house. The residence of the South African ambassador to the United Kingdom (Johannesburg, 1986), pp 37-8.Google Scholar

107 John A. Costello to N. C. Havenga, 23 Dec. 1949 (S.A.P., Havenga papers, A38/19/8/2); Te Water papers (S. A.P., AE 2/26); ‘Relations between Union and Eire’ in State information newsletter, no. 469, 27 Nov. 1948 (Institute of Contemporary History, Bloemfontein, Eric Louw papers, file 85); Louw to D. F. Malan, 4 Oct. 1948 (ibid.).

108 Harkness, ‘Patrick McGilligan’, p. 129.

109 Smuts to Churchill, 21 May 1949 in Poel, van der (ed.), Selections from the Smuts papers, vii, 296-7.Google Scholar

110 Horgan, J., Sean Lemass: the enigmatic patriot (Dublin, 1997), p. 252.Google Scholar

111 Mansergh, Nationalism & independence, p. 208. See also Fanning, Ronan, ‘The response of the London and Belfast governments to the declaration of the Republic of Ireland, 1948–49’ in International Affairs, lviii (1981-82), pp 95–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McEvoy, F., ‘Canada, Ireland and the Commonwealth: the declaration of a republic’ in I.H.S., xxiv, no. 96 (1983), pp 506-27Google Scholar; O’Farrell, P., ‘Irish-Australian diplomatic relations’ in Quadrant, xxxiv (1980), pp 11–19Google Scholar; Quirke, N., ‘Australia’s role in Ireland’s declaration of a republic and withdrawal from the Commonwealth’ in MacDonagh, Oliver (ed.), Irish-Australian Historical Studies (Canberra, 1989)Google Scholar; O’Brien, John, ‘Ireland’s departure from the British Commonwealth’ in Round Table, no. 308 (1988), pp 179-94CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Dean, D. W., ‘Final exit? Britain, Eire, the Commonwealth and the repeal of the External Relations Act’ in Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, xx ( 1993), pp 391–418.Google Scholar

112 Memorandum of 6 Dec. 1948 (T.C.D., Frederick H. Boland papers, 10470/21 ).

113 Ovendale, R., The English-speaking alliance, 1945–51 (London, 1985), p. 75.Google Scholar

114 Collins, The path to freedom, pp 88–9; see also Costello, F., Michael Collins (Dublin, 1997), pp 72-5Google Scholar; Mansergh, Nationalism & independence, p. 98.

115 Darwin, ‘Imperialism in decline?’, passim.

116 Costello, John A., Dáil Éireann speech, 24 Nov. 1948 in Mansergh, Nicholas (ed.), Documents and speeches on British Commonwealth affairs, 1931–1952 (2 vols. London, 1953) ii, 805-6.Google Scholar