Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T06:11:27.877Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Archaeology and Acrimony: Gertrude Bell, Ernst Herzfeld and the Study of Pre-Modern Mesopotamia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 April 2014

Lisa Cooper
Lisa Cooper*
Affiliation:
Associate Professor, Near Eastern Archaeology, Deptartment of Classical, Near Eastern, and Religious Studies, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada, [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Letters sent from the German scholar Ernst Herzfeld to Gertrude Bell between 1909 and 1912 provide valuable information about the scholarship of these remarkable characters as they explored issues pertaining to the development of early Islamic art and architecture in Mesopotamia. Through a spirited and often fractious exchange of ideas about a range of artistic and architectural topics that included vaulting techniques, the design of early mosques and palace forms, one can track the impact each had upon the other's scholarship, and the degree to which their respective views shaped one another's conclusions about important Islamic period sites such as Samarra and Ukhaidir.

Type
Research Article
Information
IRAQ , Volume 75 , 2013 , pp. 143 - 169
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute for the Study of Iraq 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Asher-Greve, J. M. 2006. Bell, Gertrude L., 1868–1926, in Cohen, G. M. and Joukowsky, M. S. (eds.) Breaking Ground: Pioneering Women Archaeologists (Ann Arbor), pp. 142–97.Google Scholar
Bell, G. L. 1905. Review of Schulz and Strzygowski 1904. Mschatta. Bericht über die Aufnahme der Ruine von Bruno Schulz und kunstwissenschatliche Untersuchung von Josef Strzygowski, Jahrbuch der Königlichen Preuszischen Kunstsammlungen 25: 205–373. Revue archéologique 5: 431–32.Google Scholar
Bell, G. L. 1907. The Desert and the Sown (London).Google Scholar
Bell, G. L. 1910. The Vaulting System of Ukhaidir, Journal of Hellenic Studies 30: 69–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bell, G. L. 1911. Amurath to Amurath: A Journey along the Banks of the Euphrates (London).Google Scholar
Bell, G. L. 1914. Palace and Mosque at Ukhaidir: A Study in Early Mohammadan Architecture (Oxford). Bloom, J. 2002. Introduction, in J. Bloom (ed.) Early Islamic Art and Architecture (Aldershot, UK).Google Scholar
Carswell, J. 1981. Introduction, in Bosch, G., Carswell, J. and Petherbridge, G. (eds) Islamic Bindings and Bookmaking. A Catalogue of an Exhibition in the Oriental Institute Museum, University of Chicago, May 18–August 18, 1981 (Chicago), pp. ix–xi.Google Scholar
de Beylié, L. 1907a. Pronte et Samarra (Paris).Google Scholar
de Beylié, L. 1907b. L'architecture des Abbassides au IXe siècle. Voyage archéologique à Samarra dans le basin du Tigre, Revue Archéologique 4me sér. 10: 1–18Google Scholar
Gunter, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. 2005. Ernst Herzfeld and Near Eastern Studies, 1900–1950, in Gunther, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. (eds.) Ernst Herzfeld and the Development of Near Eastern Studies, 1900–1950 (Leiden), pp. 3–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hauser, S. R. 2003. Ernst Herzfeld, Life and Work, Encyclopaedia Iranica 12 Fase. 3: 290–93.Google Scholar
Hauser, S. R. 2005. History, Races and Orientalism: Eduard Meyer, the Organization of Oriental Research, and Ernst Herzfeld's Intellectual Heritage, in Gunther, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. (eds.) Ernst Herzfeld and the Development of Near Eastern Studies, 1900–1950 (Leiden), pp. 505–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1907. Samarra. Aufnahmen und Untersuchungen zur islamischen Archaeologie (Berlin).Google Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1909. Über die historische Geographie von Mesopotamien, Petermanns Mitteilungen 55, 345–49.Google Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1910. Die Genesis der islamischen Kunst und das Mshatta-Problem, Der Islam 1, 27–63, 105–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1911a. Zu Strzygowski's Aufsätzen in Band II, 79ff u. OLZ Nr 4, Der Islam 2: 411–13.Google Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1911b. Review of van Berchem and Strzygowski 1910, Amida. Matériaux pour l'épigraphie et l'histoire musulmanes du Diyar-Bekr par Max van Berchem. Beiträge zur Kunstgeschichte des Mittelalters von Nordmesopotamien, Hellas und dem Abendlande von Josef Strzygowski. Orientalische Literaturzeitung 14: 397–436.Google Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1912. Erster vorläufiger Bericht über die Ausgrabungen von Samarra (Berlin).Google Scholar
Herzfeld, E. 1924 Paikuli. Monument and Inscription of the Early History of the Sasanian Empire (Berlin), 2 vols.Google Scholar
Hillenbrand, R. 1991. Creswell and Contemporary Central European Scholarship, Muqarnas 8: 23–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hillenbrand, R. 1994. Islamic Architecture. Form, Function and Meaning (New York).Google Scholar
Howell, G. 2006. Gertrude Bell. Daughter of the Desert, Shaper of Nations (London).Google Scholar
Kröger, J. 2005. Ernst Herzfeld and Friedrich Sarre, in Gunther, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. (eds.) Ernst Herzfeld and the Development of Near Eastern Studies, 1900-1950 (Leiden), pp. 45–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leisten, T. 2003. Excavation of Samarra. Volume I: Architecture. Final Report of the First Campaign 1910–1912 (Mainz am Rhein).Google Scholar
Leisten, T. 2005. Concerning the Development of the Hira-style Revisited, in Gunther, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. (eds.) Ernst Herzfeld and the Development of Near Eastern Studies, 1900–1950 (Brill), 371–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lukitz, L. 2006. A Question in the Middle East. Gertrude Bell and the Making of Modern Iraq (London).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marchand, S. L. 1994. The Rhetoric of Artifacts and the Decline of Classical Humanism: The Case of Josef Strzygowski, History and Theory 33: 106–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marchand, S. L. 2009. German Orientalism in the Age of Empire. Religion, Race and Scholarship (Cambridge).Google Scholar
Northedge, A. 2007. The Historical Topography of Samarra (London).Google Scholar
Ousterhout, R. G. and Jackson, M. P. C. 2008. Editors' Foreword, in new edition of W.M. Ramsay and G. L. BellThe Thousand and One Churches (Philadelphia), pp. ix–xxxiv.Google Scholar
Ramsay, W. M. and Bell, G. L. 1909. The Thousand and One Churches (London).Google Scholar
Renger, , 2005. Ernst Herzfeld in Context: Gleanings from His Personnel File and Other Sources, in Gunther, A. C. and Hauser, S. R. (eds.) Ernst Herzfeld and the Development of Near Eastern Studies, 1900–1950 (Brill), 561–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reuther, O. 1912. Ocheïdir. Nach Aufnahmen von Mitgliedern der Babylon Expedition der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft (Leipzig).Google Scholar
Sarre, F. and Herzfeld, E., 1910. Iranische Felsreliefs (Berlin).Google Scholar
Sarre, F. and Herzfeld, E. 1911. Archäologische Reise im Euphrat- und Tigris-Gebiet vols. I and III (Berlin).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schulz, B. and Strzygowski, J. 1904. Mschatta. Bericht über die Aufnahme der Ruine von Bruno Schulz und kunstwissenschatliche Untersuchung von Josef Strzygowski, Jahrbuch der Königlichen Preuszischen Kunstsammlungen 25: 205–373.Google Scholar
Strzygowski, J. 1908. Review of E. Herzfeld 1907, Samarra. Aufnahmen und Untersuchungen zur islamischen Archaeologie. Deutsche Literaturzeitung 2: 107.Google Scholar
Strzygowski, J. 1911. Review of E. Herzfeld 1910 Die Genesis der islamischen Kunst und das Mshatta-Problem. Orientalische Literaturzeitung 14: 179–83.Google Scholar
Van Berchem, M. 1894–1920, Matériaux pour un Corpus Inscriptionum Arabicarum. 3 volumes (Cairo).Google Scholar
van Berchem, M. and Stryzgowski, J. 1910, Amida. Matériaux pour l'épigraphie et l'histoire musulmanes du DiyarBekrpar Max van Berchem. Beiträge zur Kunstgeschichte des Mittelalters von Nordmesopotamien, Hellas und dem Abendlande von Josef Strzygowski (Heidelberg).Google Scholar
Wallach, J. 1996. Desert Queen (New York).Google Scholar
Welch, K. 2006. Esther, B.Deman, Van, 1862–1937, in Cohen, G. M. and Joukowsky, M. S. (eds.) Breaking Ground: Pioneering Women Archaeologists (Ann Arbor), pp. 68–108.Google Scholar
Winstone, H. V. F. 1978. Gertrude Bell (London).Google Scholar