Published online by Cambridge University Press: 18 December 2008
The conference held at Bradford in 1893 to form an Independent Labour Party was accompanied by a Labour Church service which some 5,000 people attended. It was organised by John Trevor, who in 1891 had left his Unitarian pulpit in Manchester and founded the first Labour Church. “God in the Labour Movement”, he explained “– working through it, as once he worked through Christianity, for the further salvation of the world – that was the simple conception that I had been seeking, and which at last came to me…” The fullest account of this movement created by Trevor has been given in H. M. Pelling's The Origins of the Labour Party, where it is sensibly cited as a stage in the “transfer of social energy from religion to politics.” The purpose of the present article is to dissent from certain judgments made by Mr. Pelling and to suggest, in some particulars, a different interpretation.
page 445 note 1 Prophet, Labour, 02 1893, 16.Google Scholar
page 445 note 2 Trevor, J., My quest for God (1897), 241.Google Scholar
page 445 note 3 Pelling, H. M., The Origins of the Labour Party, 1880–1900 (1954), 139.Google Scholar
page 445 note 4 Ibid., 151–2.
page 446 note 1 Prophet, Labour, 05 1892, 38.Google Scholar
page 446 note 2 World, Christian, 4 08 1892, 635.Google Scholar
page 446 note 3 Quoted in: Brockway, F., Socialism over sixty years (1946), 41.Google Scholar
page 446 note 4 Annual, Labour, 1898, 193.Google Scholar
page 446 note 5 Prophet, Labour, 06 1896, 97.Google Scholar
page 446 note 6 Clayton, J., The rise and decline of socialism in Great Britain, 1884–1924 (1926), 98.Google Scholar
page 446 note 7 Labour Church Record, 10 1899, 5.Google Scholar
page 447 note 1 Prophet, Labour, 08 1896, 129.Google Scholar
page 447 note 2 Ibid., Nov. 1892, 85–6.
page 447 note 3 Trevor, J., An Independent Labour Party, 1892, 11.Google Scholar
page 447 note 4 Prophet, Labour09 1894, 120.Google Scholar
page 447 note 5 Ibid., Oct. 1894,136–7.
page 448 note 1 Quoted in: Thompson, A. M., Here I lie(1937), 54.Google Scholar
page 448 note 2 Leader, Labour, 10 11 1894, 2.Google Scholar
page 448 note 3 Pelling, H. M., op. cit., 146.Google Scholar
page 449 note 1 Birmingham Labour Church, minutes of executive committee meeting, 7 06 1895.Google Scholar
page 449 note 2 In Labour Church publications there are references to some 50 churches in England (slightly more than half of them in Lancashire and the West Riding of Yorkshire), 1 in Wales and 4 in Scotland. At least 37 of the churches were established by 1896, and in no subsequent year do more than 2 appear to have been formed. In 1898 The Labour Prophet (monthly) had to be abandoned for lack of support, and was replaced by a smaller quarterly, The Labour Church Record, which in turn disappeared in 1902, after the secretary of a Labour Church had written in one of the last issues (April 1901, 4): “I find Labour Churches generally weak, unbusiness-like, and quarrelsome”.
page 449 note 3 Postgate, R., The life of George Lansbury (1951), 54–5.Google Scholar
page 450 note 1 British Weekly, 5 11 1891, 21.Google Scholar
page 450 note 2 Labour Prophet, 06 1895, 89.Google Scholar
page 450 note 3 A Labour Church Hymn Book was printed in 1892 and another in 1906. The Birmingham Labour Church printed its own in 1894, and a number of Churches printed sheets of hymns from time to time.
page 450 note 4 Labour Prophet, 06 1895, 89.Google Scholar
page 451 note 1 Ibid.
page 451 note 2 Ibid., May 1893, 39.
page 451 note 3 Ibid., June 1895, 89.
page 451 note 4 Ibid.
page 451 note 5 Ibid., May 1893, 39; March 1898,166.
page 451 note 6 Hobson, S., Pilgrim to the left(1938), 41.Google Scholar
page 451 note 7 Guardian, Manchester, quoted in Labour Prophet, 02 1892, 10.Google Scholar
page 451 note 8 Prophet, Labour, 08 1893, 80.Google Scholar
page 451 note 9 Ibid., June 1893, 50.
page 452 note 1 Ibid., Feb. 1894, 32.
page 452 note 2 Birmingham Labour Church, minutes of members' meeting, 25 01 1895Google Scholar; ibid., minutes of executive committee meeting, 1 Feb. 1895.
page 452 note 3 Prophet, Labour, 12 1897, 140.Google Scholar
page 452 note 4 Ibid., July 1898,195.
page 452 note 5 Ibid., May 1895,79.
page 452 note 6 Ibid., Dec. 1897,140.
page 452 note 7 Ibid.
page 453 note 1 Ibid., Sep. 1894,128.
page 453 note 2 Ibid.
page 453 note 3 Ibid., June 1896, 90.
page 453 note 4 Ibid., March 1898,162.
page 453 note 5 Ibid., Aug. 1893, 74.
page 454 note 1 Ibid, Dec. 1894,171.
page 454 note 2 Hobson, , op. cit., 40–1. Hobson does not say what they quarrelled about, but this is plain from reports of meetings.Google Scholar
page 454 note 3 See, for example, Prophet, Labour, 05 1894, 52.Google Scholar
page 454 note 4 Ibid., Oct. 1893, 100.
page 454 note 5 Ibid., May 1892, 40; Dec. 1894,165.
page 454 note 6 Cinderella Clubs were invented by Blatchford when he was on the Sunday Chronicle in 1889. (L. Thompson, Portrait of an Englishman: Robert Blatchford [1951], 62). They were taken up in several Labour Churches, and The Labour Prophet began in May 1893 to include a Cinderella Supplement for children.
page 454 note 7 Prophet, Labour, 07 1896, 106.Google Scholar
page 454 note 8 Ibid., May 1898,182.
page 454 note 9 Ibid., March–April 1894,41.
page 454 note 10 Ibid., Oct. 1893,100.
page 455 note 1 Birmingham Labour Church, minutes of executive committee meeting, 21 08 1896.Google Scholar
page 455 note 2 Quoted in Thompson, A. M., op. cit., 101.Google Scholar
page 455 note 3 Snowden, Philip Viscount, An autobiography (1934), I, 71.Google Scholar
page 456 note 1 Labour Church Record, 07 1899, 2.Google Scholar
page 456 note 2 Labour Leader, 29 12 1894, 4.Google Scholar
page 456 note 3 Labour Prophet, 10 1893, 100.Google Scholar
page 456 note 4 Ibid., Oct. 1894,136.
page 456 note 5 Letter from the committee of the Labour Church Union to members of Labour Churches, 1895, stuck into the minutes of the Birmingham Labour Church.
page 456 note 6 Prophet, Labour, 09 1898, 216.Google Scholar
page 456 note 7 Ibid., July 1895, 105.
page 457 note 1 Ibid., June 1898, 188.
page 457 note 2 Ibid., March 1896, 46.
page 457 note 3 Blatchford, R., My eighty years (1931)Google Scholar; Carpenter, E., My days and dreams (1916)Google Scholar; Clynes, J. R., Memoirs, 2 vols. (1937)Google Scholar; Lansbury, G., My Life (1928)Google Scholar; Mann's, Tom memoirs (1923)Google Scholar; Sexton, J., Sir James Sexton, agitator: the life of the dockers' M.P.: an autobiography (1936)Google Scholar; Snowden, , op. cit.;Google ScholarThompson, A. M., op. cit.;Google ScholarTillett, B., Memories and Reflections (1931).Google Scholar
page 457 note 4 See Clynes, , op. cit., I, 85.Google Scholar
page 458 note 1 Labour Annual, 1898, 195.Google Scholar
page 458 note 2 Labour Church Record, 07 1899, 7.Google Scholar
page 458 note 3 Labour Prophet, 07 1895, 105.Google Scholar
page 458 note 4 Ibid., Aug. 1896, 129; June 1897, 90.
page 458 note 5 Ibid., July 1896, 119. There were also a number of “Socialist Sunday Schools” run on similar lines, but apparently in association with I.L.P. branches rather than Labour Churches.
page 458 note 6 Ibid., July 1898, 197.
page 458 note 7 Ibid., May 1894, 56.
page 458 note 8 Great Thoughts, 7 11 1896, 90.Google Scholar
page 458 note 9 Labour Prophet, 01 1894, 9.Google Scholar
page 459 note 1 Ibid., May 1893, 41.
page 459 note 2 Labour Church Record, 07 1899, 6.Google Scholar
page 459 note 3 Ibid., April 1899, 1.
page 459 note 4 Foster, D.B., Socialism and the Christ (1921), 33, 50.Google Scholar
page 459 note 5 Birmingham Labour Church, annual report of executive committee, 1909.