Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T23:01:51.506Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

In the Name of Socialism: Zionism and European Social Democracy in the Inter-War Years

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 February 2009

Paul Kelemen
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Summary

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Since 1917, the European social democratic movement has given fulsome support to Zionism. The article examines the ideological basis on which Zionism and, in particular, Labour Zionism gained, from 1917, the backing of social democratic parties and prominent socialists. It argues that Labour Zionism's appeal to socialists derived from the notion of “positive colonialism”. In the 1930s, as the number of Jewish refugees from Nazi persecution increased considerably, social democratic pro-Zionism also came to be sustained by the fear that the resettlement of Jews in Europe would strengthen anti-Semitism and the extreme right.

Type
Research Article
Information
International Review of Social History , Volume 41 , Issue 3 , December 1996 , pp. 331 - 350
Copyright
Copyright © Internationaal Instituut voor Sociale Geschiedenis 1996

References

1. Jacobs, J., On Socialists and “the Jewish Question” after Marx (New York, 1992)Google Scholar; Silberner, E., Sozialisten zur Judenfrage (Berlin, 1962)Google Scholar; Traverso, E., The Marxists and the “Jewish Question” (New Jersey, 1990)Google Scholar; Wistrich, R., Socialism and the Jews (London, 1982)Google Scholar.

2. Ibid., p. 150;Fletcher, R., Revisionism and Empire (London, 1984), pp. 57–59Google Scholar.

3. Labour party and Trades Union Congress, Memorandum on War Aims (London, 1917)Google Scholar; the Inter-Allied Labour and Socialist Conference's version is contained inMcCurdy, C., A Clean Peace (London, 1918)Google Scholar.

4. Quoted inJarblum, M., The Socialist International and Zionism (New York, 1933), p. 17Google Scholar.

5. Sonderbeilage zu No. 52 der “Mitteilungen des Kopenhagener Bureaus der zionistischen Organisation”, A137/76, Central Zionist Archives (Jerusalem).

6. Jarblum, The Socialist International and Zionism, p. 17.

7. Silberner, Sozialisten zur Judenfrage, p. 280.

8. Wistrich, Socialism and the Jews, pp. 242–261.

9. Jarblum, The Socialist International and Zionism, p. 9.

10. Forward, 1 March 1919.

11. Van der Slice, A., International Labour, Diplomacy and Peace 1914–1919 (Philadelphia, 1941), p. 318CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12. Kautsky, K., Are the Jews A Race? (London, 1926), p. 207Google Scholar; Jacobs, J., “Marxism and Anti-Semitism: Kautsky's Perspective”, International Review of Social History, 30, 3 (12 1985), p. 426CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13. Locker, B., “Karl Kautsky und der Zionismus”, Der Neue Weg, 12 1924Google Scholar.

14. Wistrich, Socialism and the Jews, p. 167.

15. Quoted in Vorwärts, 29 September 1929.

16. Ibid.

17. La Vie Socialiste, December 1929.

18. Bauer, Otto, “What is Austro-Marxism?”, in Bottomore, T. (ed.), Austro-Marxism (Oxford, 1979), p. 46Google Scholar.

19. Glasneck, J., “Die Internationale Sozialdemokratie und die Zionistische Palästina-Kolonisation in den Jahren 1929/30”, Wissenschaftliche Zeitschrift der Martin Luther Universität, G.H., 26, 4 (1977), p. 48Google Scholar.

20. Poale Zion reported to the Socialist International, in 1925, a membership of 13,500 of which 3,350 were in Palestine, 3,000 in the US and the rest spread over a half dozen countries. In 1934, its membership outside Palestine was 39,000 spread over a dozen countries. In Belgium and Britain, from where some of the strongest socialist support came, it had between 500–600 members for most of the inter-war period. Archivs der Sozialistischen Arbeiter Internationale (hereafter SAI), 2511/28, 134/22 and 3153, Institute of Social History, Amsterdam (hereafter ISH).

21. Comité Socialiste pour la Palestine Ouvrière (hereafter Comité; Socialiste), Bulletin no. 1, November 1929.

22. MacDonald, J.R., A Socialist in Palestine (London, 1922), p. 23Google Scholar; Wedgwood, J., The Seventh Dominion (London, 1928), p. 114Google Scholar; Adler, quoted in Braunthal to Erlich, December 1935, Braunthal Papers, Letters, no. 48 (ISH); Lóbe, quoted in Glasneck, “Die Internationale Sozialdemokratie und die Zionistische Palástina-Kolonisation in den Jahren 1929/30”, p. 42.

23. Quoted in Reberioux, M. and Haupt, G., “L'attitude de l'lnternationale”, Le Mouvement Sociale, 45 (10 1963), p. 18 n. 43Google Scholar.

24. Ibid, p. 19.

25. Sozialistische Monatshefte, vol. 11 (1907), pt. 2, p. 989.

26. MacDonald, J.R., “Labour and International Relations”, Address delivered on 24 November 1917 at the Annual Conference of the Derby and District ILP Federation (Derby and District ILP Federation, 1917)Google Scholar.

27. Quoted in Samidei, M., “Les Socialistes francais et le probleme colonial entre Ies deux guerres, 1919–1939”, Revue francaise du science politique, 18, 6 (1968), p. 1139Google Scholar.

28. Bulletin of the Labour and Socialist International, series 2, no. 3 (September 1928), p. 11.

29. Lorwin, L., Labour and Internationalism (London, 1929), p. 441Google Scholar.

30. Kaplansky, S., The Jews and the War (Hague, 1916), pp. 32–33Google Scholar.

31. “Declaration to the Hollando-Scandinavian Committee”, in Borochov, B., Class Struggle in the Jewish Nation (New Brunswick and London, 1984), p. 210Google Scholar.

32. van Kol, H. H., La Démocratie Socialiste Internationale et le Sionisme (Lausanne, 1919), p. 33Google Scholar.

33. MacDonald, A Socialist in Palestine, p. 19.

34. Ibid, p. 20.

35. Braunthal, J., “Arabs and Jews in Palestine”, Contemporary Review, 149 (04 1946), pp. 472–473Google Scholar.

36. La Vie Socialiste, December 1929.

37. Snell, H., Man, Movement and Myself (London, 1936), p. 240Google Scholar. Snell's derogatory remark appears to be a reference to the use of the nail plough by Arab peasants. Since he had been a farm labourer in his youth, he presumably felt qualified to make such a judgement but, in 1930, the director of the Jewish Agency's agricultural research institute in Palestine, who had knowledge of the local conditions and cannot be suspected of undue sympathy for Arab fanning methods, gave a significantly different assessment: ”When rain comes down for a long time continuously or with brief intervals, the Arab plough is the only one with which work can be done. In such conditions the European plough [with its broad iron share] does not cut the ground, but packs the dust together, makes bricks, rolls the earth into clods, and damages the ground for years. Hence in rainy years the Arab plough prolongs the working season.” Quoted in Kamen, C.S., Little Common Ground (Pittsburgh, 1991), p. 301 n. 15Google Scholar.

38. Comité Socialiste, Bulletin no. 1, November 1928.

39. Vandervelde, E., Le pays d'Israel (Paris, 1929). p. 211Google Scholar.

40. MacDonald, A Socialist in Palestine, p. 19.

41. Shalev, M., Labour and the Political Economy in Israel (New York, 1992), p. 41CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42. Vandervelde, Le pays d'Israel, p. 72; Wedgwood, The Seventh Dominion, p. 86.

43. Vandervelde, Le pays d'Israel, p. 126.

44. Comité Socialiste, Bulletin no. 4, November 1929.

45. Ibid.

46. Comité Sodaliste, Bulletin no. 6, February 1931.

47. Flapan, S., Zionism and the Palestinians (London, 1979), p. 206Google Scholar.

48. Comité Socialiste, Bulletin no. 8, February 1934; MacDonald, Ramsay, when retracting the Passfield White Paper, accepted the Zionist aim to exclude Arab labour from the Jewish sector: “The principle of preferential and, indeed, exclusive employment of Jewish labour by Jewish organizations, is a principle which the Jewish agency are entitled to affirm.” Hansard, Commons, 13 02 1931, vol. 248, col. 757Google Scholar.

49. Hansard, Commons, vol. 326, cols 2337, 2344, 21 July 1937; also seeKelemen, P., “Zionism and the British Labour Party: 1917–1939”, Social History, 21, 1 (01 1996), pp. 71–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50. Quoted in Bober, A. (ed.), The Other Israel (New York, 1972), p. 12Google Scholar.

51. Report of the Commission of Inquiry on Disturbances in May 1921, Cmd. 1540 (London, 1921), p. 45.

52. Report of the Commission on the Palestine Disturbance of August 1929, Cmd. 3538 (London, 1930), pp. 129–130.

53. Braunthal, “Arabs and Jews in Palestine”, p. 474; a few Labour Zionist leaders also recognized, in private, the reality of Arab nationalist opposition to Zionism. Shertok, Moshe, who was to become Israel's first foreign minister, wrote to Ben-Gurion in 1921: “For the sake of self-delusion we have made it all sound easy and simple – a handful of effendis against the masses of workers.” Quoted in Gorny, Y., Zionism and the Arabs, 1882–1948 (Oxford, 1987), p. 135Google Scholar.

54. Comité Sodaliste, Bulletin no. 11, January 1938.

55. La Vie Socialists December 1929.

56. Schreiber, J. P., “L'attitude des Juifs en Belgique face au Nazisme: le boycottage Iconomique, 1933–1939”, in Van Doorslaer, R. et al. , Les Juifs en Belgique (Brussels, 1994), p. 80Google Scholar.

57. Le Populate, 23 May 1933.

58. Nicosia, F.R., The Third Reich and the Palestine Question (London, 1986), p. 47Google Scholar.

59. Adler to Jarblum, 4 May 1936, SAI 2523/85–187.

60. “Jewish Emigration from Germany and German Exports”, International Department, Labour Party, SAI 2523/9.

61. Adler to Jarblum, 4 May 1936, SAI 2523/85–87.

62. Adler to Jarblum, SAI 2523/12.

63. Nicosia, The Third Reich and the Palestine Question, p. 157.

64. Communications on the Conditions of Political Prisoners, 18 August 1939.

65. Ibid, 6 July 1938.

66. International Information, 17 November 1938; Circular no. 35, 6 December 1935, Labour Party Archives, WG/REF/6 (Manchester Labour History Museum).

67. Noiriel, G., Workers in French Society in the 19th and 20th Centuries (Oxford, 1990), p. 162Google Scholar; Pollard, S., The Development of the British Economy (London, 1983), p. 155Google Scholar; Maddison, A., “Economic Policy and Performance in Europe, 1913–1970”, in Cipolla, C.M. (ed.), The Fontana Economic History of Europe. The Twentieth Century (Glasgow, 1976), p. 465Google Scholar.

68. Schor, R., L'opinion française et les étrangères en France, 1919–1939 (Nancy, 1985), p. 564Google Scholar; Report of the Proceedings at the 70th Annual Trade Union Congress (London, 1938), p. 208.

69. Communications on the Conditions of Political Prisoners, 18 October 1933; Hansard, Commons, vol. 304, col. 2101, 25 July 1935.

70. Comité Sodaliste, Bulletin no. 8, February 1934.