Behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) are common in Alzheimer's disease (AD) and can potentially contribute to disease burden among caregivers. In this letter, an attempt is reported to establish if disease burden was higher among those with BPSD compared to those without it.
In 1996, the International Psychogeriatric Association Consensus Group defined BPSD as “symptoms of disturbed perception, thought content, mood or behaviour that frequently occur in patients with dementia.” BPSD are common in AD (Coen et al., Reference Coen1997). These are among the most important factors when considering whether a dementia patient should be institutionalized or not.
Western data suggest that BPSD occur in about 50–90% of patients with dementia (Coen et al., Reference Coen1997), while little is known about the prevalence of or associations with BPSD in developing countries (10/66 Dementia Research Group, 2004). Aggregate data of BPSD per se is not available in an Indian context. However, incidence of individual symptoms of BPSD is available e.g. between 10% and 73% of patients with AD experience delusions, with paranoid delusions being the most common. Similarly, hallucinations occur in 12–53% of patients with AD. Visual hallucinations are most common followed by auditory hallucinations. Aggressive symptoms such as verbal outbursts, physical threats, or violence and agitation were observed in 75% of the patients (Shaji et al., Reference Shaji, Bose and Kuriakose2009). There is a paucity of cross-cultural studies of BPSD.
Prevalence of AD in India appears to be low. Indians generally have joint family norms since ancient times as opposed to nuclear family norms in Western countries, which perhaps contribute to psychological as well as social support for the elderly. Culture can also influence BPSD and caregivers’ response to such symptoms (Shaji et al., Reference Shaji, Bose and Kuriakose2009). We therefore wanted to know if BPSD contribute to caregiver's burden in the Indian context, and, if so, to what extent.
The study was conducted in an outpatient department of a neurology unit of a tertiary care hospital from November 2006 to March 2007, in New Delhi, India. Patients were recruited randomly and followed up prospectively. AD patients fulfilling National Institute of Neurological and Communicative Diseases and Stroke/Alzheimer's Disease and Related Disorders (NINCDS-ARDA) criteria (Ihl et al., Reference Ihl2011) were included in the study. Cooperative patients and their relatives willing to be interviewed for study were recruited.
Secondary causes of dementia were excluded by appropriate investigations, e.g. T3, T4, and TSH estimation, VDRL, FTS-Ab. The BEHAVE-AD scale (Schreinzer et al., Reference Schreinzer2005) was used to assess BPSD. The Pai and Kapur Disease Burden Scale (Pai and Kapur, Reference Pai and Kapur1981) was used to assess caregiver burden.
A total of 38 patients were studied (M:F = 33:5; age range = 55–85 years). Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) scores were calculated for each patient and they were divided into three dementia severity categories depending upon their score (mild- I = 18; moderate- II = 12; severe- III = 8).
BPSD were found in 20 (53%) out of 38 patients. Nine out of 20 (45%) patients had psychotic symptoms (visual hallucinations = 4; auditory hallucinations = 2; delusions = 3). Anxiety and phobias were seen in five patients. Anger outbursts were seen in three and two patients had violent behaviors. One patient had affective disturbance involving frequent crying and emotional outbursts. Fifteen out of the 20 were receiving treatment for BPSD while the rest did not receive any special treatment. Olanazpine and quetiapine were the two most commonly used drugs.
The Pai and Kapur Disease Burden Scale (Pai and Kapur, Reference Pai and Kapur1981) score was higher in those with BPSD compared to those without (p < 0.05). The MMSE score was lower in those with BPSD compared to those without (p < 0.05).
BPSD represent a growing burden to caregivers and healthcare institutions and contribute to the financial burden as well. There is increased frequency of depression and emotional problems in caregivers of AD patients (Schreinzer et al., Reference Schreinzer2005). The occurrence of BPSD is often the triggering event for recognition and referral of people with dementia to specialist services. These symptoms often present relatively late in the course of the illness. The development of BPSD is a major risk factor for caregiver burden (Coen et al., Reference Coen1997) and institutionalization, and is more important in this regard than the enduring cognitive deficits of the disease process. All aspects of BPSD can be associated with caregiver burden, but paranoia, aggression, and sleep–wake cycle disturbance appear to be particularly important. The burden associated with BPSD is different for each symptom and does not always depend on frequency and severity of BPSD. It has been reported that some symptoms, such as agitation/aggression and irritability/lability, may affect the caregivers significantly, although their frequency and severity are low (Suh and Kim, Reference Suh and Kim2004). Health policies to meet the unmet needs of elderly people are urgently needed, especially for AD patients at home without treatment (Matsumoto et al., Reference Matsumoto2007). The present study shows that the disease burden among those with BPSD is higher compared to those without it (p < 0.05). Early recognition and prompt treatment of BPSD with antipsychotics can potentially decrease the caregiver burden and delay institutionalization of patients with AD.
Conflict of interest
None.
