Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T06:13:16.670Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Sexual Crisis and Popular Religion in London, 1770–1820

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 December 2008

Anna Clark
Anna Clark
Affiliation:
University of North Carolina at Charlotte
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Religion is becoming a crucial issue in women's history. Tired of portraying women as misguided victims, historians have begun to show how women have used religion, especially radical religion, to gain added status or at least impart meaning to their lives.l But in this new portrayal we must be careful to untangle the threads of female religious symbolism from the realities of women's lives, to examine the contrast between the opportunities for women in radical religion and the restrictions placed upon them by established churches and chapels. Furthermore, we must consider that religion is vital to the construction of masculinity in strengthening patriarchal power but also in revealing the needs of men, especially plebeian and working-class men, to cope with their lack of power.

Type
Religion and the Working Class
Information
International Labor and Working-Class History , Volume 34 , Fall 1988 , pp. 56 - 69
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

I would like to thank Judith Walkowitz, John Gillis, Ellen Ross, and Leonore Davidoff for their comments and support.

1. Malmgreen, Gail, ed., Religion in the Lives of English Women, 1760–1930 (Bloomington, Ind., 1986)Google Scholar; Obelkevich, Jim, Roper, Lyndal, and Samuel, Raphael, eds., Disciplines of Faith: Studies in Religion, Politics and Patriarchy (London, 1987)Google Scholar; Valenze, Deborah, Prophetic Sons and Daughters: Female Preaching and Popular Religion in Industrial England (Princeton, 1985).Google Scholar

2. Thompson, E. P, The Making of the English Working Class (New York, 1968), 38–51Google Scholar; Hobsbawm, E. J., Primitive Rebels (New York, 1965), chap. 8Google Scholar, and “Methodism and the Threat of Revolution,” in Labouring Men: Studies in the History of Labour (London, 1965), 23–33.Google Scholar

3. The term is borrowed from Taylor, Barbara, Eve and the New Jerusalem: Socialism and Feminism in the Nineteenth Century (New York, 1983), 268.Google Scholar She locates it in the 1830s and 1840s, but I would put in much earlier, evident by 1780 if not before. For a more complete exposition of the earlier sexual crisis, see Clark, Anna, “Womanhood and Manhood in the Transition from Plebeian to Working-Class Culture, London, 1780–1845” (Ph.D. diss., Rutgers University, 1987).Google Scholar

4. Clark, Anna, “Whores and Gossips: Sexual Reputation in London, 1770–1825,” Current Issues in Women's History (London, forthcoming).Google Scholar

5. Valenze, , Prophetic Sons and Daughters, 111.Google Scholar

6. Ibid.; Malmgreen, Gail, “Domestic Discords: Women and the Family in East Cheshire Methodism, 1750–1830,”Google Scholar and Abelove, Henry, “The Sexual Politics of Early Wesleyan Methodism,” in Obelkevich, Roper, and Samuel, eds., Disciplines of Faith, 55–70 and 86–98.Google Scholar

7. Semmel, Bernard, The Methodist Revolution (London, 1974), 20.Google Scholar

8. This also happened in the seventeenth century. See Thomas, Keith, “Women and the Civil War Sects,” Past and Present 13 (1958): 42–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Mack, Phyllis, “Women as Prophets during the English Civil War,” Feminist Studies 8 (Spring 1982): 23–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9. Bramwell, William, A Short Account of the Life and Death of Ann Cutler, with an Appendix by Zechariah Taft, containing an Account of Elizabeth Dickinson, 2d ed. (York, 1827), 34Google Scholar; Brown, Earl Kent, Women of Mr. Wesley's Methodism (New York, 1983), 10.Google Scholar

10. Currie, Robert, Methodism Divided (London, 1968), 17.Google Scholar

11. Methodist Magazine (1800), 299.Google Scholar

12. Valenze, , Prophetic Sons and Daughters, 140Google Scholar; Weekly Dispatch, 4 05 1828Google Scholar; Kendall, H. B., History of Primitive Methodism (London, 1919), 1:103.Google Scholar

13. Guildhall Library, Society of Geneologists, transcripts of Methodist Chapel Registers, 1835–37 for Clerkenwell; 1827, 1837 for Aldersgate; MacLeod, Hugh, Class and Religion in the Late Victorian City (London, 1976), 32.Google Scholar

14. In two poor Westminster parishes, Methodists represented only 242 out of a population of 5,366; “Report on the State of the Working Classes in the Parishes of St. Margaret and St. John, Westminster,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 3 (1840): 15.Google Scholar Nonetheless, Methodists were more successful than the Established Church. See laments of clergymen in the Lambeth Palace, Fulham Papers, London Visitations, 1790 and 1810.

15. Greater London Record Office (GLCRO), N/C/32/1/3, Minute Books. For more discussion on chapel discipline, see Clark, , “Womanhood and Manhood,” 126–36.Google Scholar

16. Reid, W. H., The Rise and Dissolution of the Infidel Societies of this Metropolis (London, 1800), 41.Google Scholar

17. Hopkins, James K., A Woman to Deliver Her People: Joanna Southcott and English Millenarianism in an Era of Revolution (Austin, Tex., 1982), chap. 3.Google Scholar

18. Thompson, , Making of the English Working Class, 387.Google Scholar

19. Harrison, J. E. C., The Second Coming: Popular Millenarianism, 1780–1850 (London, 1979), 87, 132.Google Scholar

20. Garrett, Clarke, Respectable Folly: Millenarianism and the French Revolution in France and England (Baltimore, 1975), 190–96.Google Scholar

21. Gott, Dorothy, The Midnight Cry (London, 1787), 2–7Google Scholar, and Gott, , Christ the Standard of Truth set by the Morning Star (London, 1798), 10.Google Scholar

22. Gott, , Midnight Cry, 59.Google Scholar

23. Copy of a letter to Mrs. Lewis, undated, Westminster Public Library, Marylebone branch.

24. Flaxmer, Sarah, Satan Revealed (London, 1795), 8.Google Scholar

25. Gott, Dorothy, The Morning Star, 53, 10.Google Scholar

26. Oracle, 22 01 1795; 2 04 1795.Google Scholar

27. Harrison, , Second Coming, 31, 66.Google Scholar

28. Taylor, , Eve and the New Jerusalem, 164Google Scholar; Harrison, , Second Coming, 108.Google Scholar

29. GLCRO Acc. 1040/223.

30. Gott, , Morning Star, 38.Google Scholar Santa Francesca Romana also used snakes as a phallic metaphor for masculine evil; Boanas, Guy and Roper, Lyndal, “Feminine Piety in Fifteenth-Century Rome: Santa Francesca Romana,” in Obelkevich, Roper, and Samuel, eds., Disciplines of Faith, 185.Google Scholar

31. Seymour, Alice, The Express, 2 vols. (London, 1909), 1:116.Google Scholar

32. Taylor, , Eve and the New Jerusalem, 163Google Scholar; Balleine, G. R., Past Finding Out: The Tragic Story of Joanna Southcott and Her Successors (London, 1956), 6Google Scholar; Seymour, , Express, 1:168.Google Scholar

33. Hopkins, , A Woman to Deliver Her People, 23.Google Scholar

34. Dreamers Vade-Mecum (London, 1807), 5.Google Scholar

35. “The Remarkable … Life and Dreadful Sufferings of the Poor, Unhappy Elizabeth Watson,” St. Bride's Library of Printing, Ballad Collection, London.

36. Hopkins, , A Woman to Deliver Her People, 85.Google Scholar

37. Ibid., 86.

38. Balleine, , Past Finding Out, 58.Google Scholar

39. Hopkins, , A Woman to Deliver Her People, 113.Google Scholar

40. The Young Woman's and Widow's Universal Dreambook (Liverpool, 1823), 12.Google Scholar

41. Gott, , Morning Star, 42.Google ScholarMack, Phyllis (“Woman as Prophets,” 27Google Scholar) cites a seventeenth-century Quaker mystic, Jane Lead, who dreamed that “Eve will now come forth as a mighty, strong, terrible eagle.”

42. Taylor, , Eve and the New Jerusalem, 167.Google Scholar

43. Seymour, , Express, 1:168, 185.Google Scholar

44. Oracle, 22 01 1795, 2 04 1795.Google Scholar

45. Seymour, , Express, 1:52.Google Scholar

46. For middle-class religious manliness, see Davidoff, Leonore and Hall, Catherine, Family Fortunes: Men and Women of the English Working Class, 1780–1850 (London, 1987), 110.Google Scholar

47. Hudson, Pat and Hunter, Lynette, “Autobiography of William Hart, Cooper, 1776–1857, Part 2,” London Journal 8 (1982): 71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

48. Bryan, William, A Testimony of the Spirit of Truth Concerning Richard Brothers (London, 1795), 3.Google Scholar

49. GLCRO N/C/69/13/1, 28 01 1742.Google Scholar

50. Swan, William, The Journal of Two Poor Dissenters (London, 1970), 45–52.Google Scholar

51. Hinde Street Minutes, 23 12 1817.Google Scholar

52. Times, 25 07 1810.Google Scholar

53. Old Bailey Sessions Papers, 09 1798, 559.Google Scholar

54. Huehns, Gertrude, Antinomians in English History, with Special Reference to the Period 1640–1660 (London, 1951), 67, 84.Google Scholar

55. Harrison, , Second Coming, 30.Google Scholar

56. For Huntington and Relly, see The Dictionary of National Biography (DNB); for Church, , The Infamous Life of John Church, the St. George's Field Preacher (London, 1817)Google Scholar; for Ward, C. B. H., Memoir of John Ward, named Zion by the Call of God (Birmingham, 1882).Google Scholar

57. Reid, , Rise and Dissolution, 41Google Scholar; there was also an antinomian congregation in Bartholomew by the Exchange; Lambeth Palace, Fulham Papers, London Visitation, 81a and b, 1790.

58. Ibid., London Visitation, St. Andrew Holborn, 1790.

59. Clark, , “Womanhood and Manhood,” 228.Google Scholar

60. Hooper, Ebenezer, The Celebrated Coalheaver, or Reminiscences of the Rev. William Huntington, S. S. (London, 1871), 19Google Scholar; Onesimus, , Memoirs of the Life and Ministry of the late William Huntington, S. S. (London, 1813), 32Google Scholar; DNB; Benbow, William, The Crimes of the Clergy Laid Open (London, 1823), 200.Google Scholar

61. Religion and Morality Vindicated (London, 1813).Google Scholar

62. Benbow, , Crimes of the Clergy, 19.Google Scholar

63. Hooper, , Celebrated Coalheaver, 34.Google Scholar

64. Church, John, The Nature of a Gospel Church (London, 1814), 23.Google Scholar

65. Church, John, The Foundling: or, the Child of Providence (London, 1823), 159.Google Scholar

66. Clark, , “Womanhood and Manhood,” chap. 6.Google Scholar

67. Onesimus, , Memoirs, 32.Google Scholar

68. Benbow, , Crimes of the Clergy, 200Google Scholar; Fleury, Maria de, A Serious Address to the Rev. William Huntington (London, 1788), 6.Google Scholar

69. Church, John, The Living Letter with the Pen of Truth (London, 1814), 15.Google Scholar

70. C. B. H., Ward; Taylor, Eve and the New Jerusalem, 106Google Scholar; Thompson, E. P., Making of the English Working Class, 799.Google Scholar

71. Isis, 17 (11 1832)Google Scholar; Taylor, , Eve and the New Jerusalem, 170–72.Google Scholar

72. Clark, , “Womanhood and Manhood,” chap. 8.Google Scholar

73. Valenze, Deborah, “Cottage Religion and the Politics of Survival,” in Equal or Different: Women's Politics, 1800–1914, ed. Rendall, Jane (Oxford, 1987), 33.Google Scholar

74. Mack, , “Women as Prophets,” 35.Google Scholar