This rapid review clarified the evidence supporting avoidance of venipuncture on the ipsilateral arm in breast cancer patients who have had sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) or axillary lymph node clearance (ALNC), as a preventive measure against lymphoedema.

A systematic search was carried out for systematic reviews with the following elements:

• • Population – breast cancer patients who had SLNB or ALNC

• • Intervention – avoidance of venipuncture in the ipsilateral arm

• • Comparator –use of either arm for venipuncture

• • Outcomes – risk of lymphoedema in the ipsilateral arm

Databases searched included PubMed (MEDLINE), Epistemonikos and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Included reviews were critically appraised with the AMSTAR2 instrument and the primary studies were extracted and tabulated in a narrative synthesis.

Six reviews were included; none of the reviews self-identified as systematic reviews in their titles/abstracts. Four reviews did report methods, including systematic search strategies and describing studies in adequate detail. However, all reviews did not meet most criteria on the AMSTAR2 checklist. The reviews concluded that the evidence base for avoiding venipuncture was inconsistent. An evidence table was consequently drawn up of the primary studies included in the reviews as a narrative synthesis of the primary evidence base.

The primary evidence base comprised 12 observational studies – six prospective cohort or descriptive studies and 6 retrospective studies. These studies were inconsistent and inconclusive; studies that found an association or reported cases following ipsilateral venipuncture were subject to recall bias or other potential confounders. Guidelines or patient information recommending avoidance of ipsilateral venipuncture do so based on expert opinion rather than consistent findings from empirical studies.

All reviews concluded that the evidence base for avoiding venipuncture was inconsistent. Review authors consistently recognized there was no strong basis for the prevalent recommendations to avoid ipsilateral venipuncture to prevent lymphoedema. Such recommendations lead to unnecessary measures that may be detrimental to patients. Stakeholders should reconsider advice to patients in the light of existing evidence and weigh up the uncertain benefits against potential harm to patients.