Children and youth in out-of-home care face many challenges regarding their development and general well-being. It is necessary to put in place best practices to support them where they are most vulnerable. Providing recommendations to health and social services for best practices regarding social and academic success interventions, this study puts forward a synthesis method that combines empirical data and the expertise of key practitioners in the context of Quebec social services.

A systematic review was first undertaken to identify the most effective interventions. Included studies (n = 31) were analyzed according to their methodological quality, collaboration processes, and type of care (foster home vs. residential care). To ensure the applicability of the recommendations made in the context of Quebec social services, contextual data, and clinical expertise were collected. Contextual data was gathered through local research reports, administrative data, and government documents. The expertise of multiple stakeholders was obtained in follow-up committees and semi-structured interviews (n = 4). In addition, to ensure their relevance and scope, recommended guidelines were debated in a deliberation committee.

The analysis between expert, contextual and empirical data led to several recommended evidence-based practices. In accordance with expert opinions, experimental and quasi-experimental studies show that various types of collaboration are beneficial for children and youth in out-of-home care. Notably, intersectoral collaborations were warranted in more complex situations (i.e., youth in residential centers), while partnership agreement was sufficient in less complex situations (i.e., children in foster homes). However, even if effective, some interventions are difficult to apply in real life and certain considerations must be taken into account (e.g. confidentiality issues, availability of resources).

Utilizing three sets of data, guidelines have been proposed to help health and social services to identify best practices and promote the academic development of out-of-home care children and youth.