Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T06:04:56.161Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Sunni Radicalism in the Middle East and the Iranian Revolution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 January 2009

Emmanuel Sivan
Emmanuel Sivan
Affiliation:
Department of History Herew University, Jerusalem
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Sunni radicalism surfaced before the Iranian Revolution of 1978. It arose out of conditions specific to Arab countries and the manner in which those faithful to the Suuna reacted to these conditions. In the quater century between the appeareance of the ideas of Sayyis Qutb, the father of Sunni radicalism, and the end of the 1970s, not only were the Sunni radical movements devoid of Iranian-Shi⊂i influence, but almost no reference was made in these movements to the fact that Iranian Islam was simultaneously undergoing a process of radicalization. A mixture of ignorance and apathy predominanted. The most one can find are several references to the organizational lessons of the Fidaciyan al-Islam, an Iranian phenomenon of the early 1950s; it seems that whatever inspiration the radical Sunni movements in Arab lands sought from the outside came from Sunni circles in India andPakistan.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Middle East Studies , Volume 21 , Issue 1 , February 1989 , pp. 1 - 30
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

Author's note: This article was written while I was a fellow at the Center for International Studies, Princeton University, 1987–1988.

1 See al-Madani, M. M., ed., Da'wat al-taqrib min khilal risalat al-Islam (Cairo, 1966);Google ScholarZu'bi, M. A., al-Sunna wa-l-Shi'a (Beirut, 1961);Google Scholaral-Shak'a, M., Islam bila madhahib (Beirut, 1981);Google Scholaral-Qummi, M. T., Qissat al-taqrib (Cairo, 1960);Google Scholaral-Wafi, A. A., Bayna-l-Shi'a wa-ahl al-Sunna (Cairo, 1984).Google Scholar

2 al-'Aziz, F. 'Abd [Shqaqi], Khomeini. al-hall wa-l-badil (Cairo/Gaza, 1979), pp. 140 ff.Google Scholar

3 Cf. Maghniya, M. J., al-Fiqh 'ala-l-madhahib al-khamsa (Beirut, 1960);Google Scholaral-Ghita⊃, M. H. Al-Kashif, Asl-al-Shi'a wa-usuliha, 10th ed. (Cairo, 1958).Google Scholar

4 al-Afghani, M., Sirab fi Iran (Beirut, 1982), pp. 35–36.Google Scholar

5 Khomeini on the Imams: al-Hukumar al-islamiyya, pp. 20, 22. Khomeini, on Islamic fraternity: in his appeal to Mecca pilgrims, al-Shahid (Tehran), 08 22, 1984.Google Scholar

6 al-Turkmani, M. A., al-Ta'rif bi-madhhab al-Shi'at al-imamiyya (Amman, 1983), pp. 110–25. Cf. Islamic Association of Gaza, Jawla fi-l-fikr al-shi'i (n.d.), pp. 23–28.Google Scholar

7 Canetti, E., Crowds and Power (New York, 1973), pp. 168, 171.Google Scholar Cf. Tudor, H., Political Myth (London, 1972), pp. 137 ff.;CrossRefGoogle ScholarThompson, L., The Political Mythology of Apartheid (New Haven, 1985), Ch. 1.Google Scholar

8 Zu'bi, al-Sunna wa-l-Shi'a, pp. 42–43; al-Hayat, May 11, 1965. Cf. Maatouk, L., La représentation de la mort de I'Imam Hussein èa Nabatiyeh (Beirut, 1974).Google Scholar

9 Al-hukuma al-islamiyya, pp. 70–76, 91. Cf. Murtada, J., “Wilayat al-Faqih,” al-Tawhid (Tehran, 1983), pp. 9–10.Google Scholar

10 Cf. 'Ulwan, A. N., Warathat al-anbiya', 6th ed. (Beirut and Aleppo, 1983).Google Scholar

11 Haqa'iq hawla harakat al-ittijah al-islami (Tunis 1983), pp. 8, 9, 43, 46. Of the 601 Muslim Brethren arrested in Egypt in 1954, only three were ulama. Of the 303 members of the Jihad group in Egypt (1981), only six were ulama (five of them students of theology). Of the 296 members of the Syrian Islamic underground arrested or killed during 1979–1981, only 18 were ulama (all of the lower ranks).

12 Ma'alim fi-l-tariq, pp. 152, 160.

13 Asl al-Shi'a wa-usuliha, p. 128. Critique in Afghani, Sirab fi Iran p. 35.

14 E.g., al-Hukummat al-islamiyya, pp. 20, 23, 25, 39, 82. Cf. Fadlallah, M. H., al-Islam wa-mantiq al-quwwa (Beirut, 1979), pp. 236–37.Google Scholar

15 Hasan, Ma'tuq, al-Marja'iyya al-diniyya al'ulya 'inda l-Shi'at al-imamiyya (Beirut, 1970);Google Scholaral-Sadr, M. Bakir, Lumha tamhidiyya 'an mashru' dustur al-jumhuriyyat al-islamiyya (Najaf, 1979).Google ScholarCf. Fadlallah, M. H., Ma huwa Hizb Allah (Beirut, 1984).Google Scholar

16 Mutahhari, M., Nahdat al-Mahdi, Arabic trans. (Beirut, n.d.), p. 3.Google Scholar

17 Cf. 'Abbud, S., “Wilayat al-Faqih”, at- Wahda (Beirut), 2 (1983), 104–12;Google ScholarFadlallah, M. H. in al-Muntalaq (Beirut), 31 (10, 1986), 12.Google Scholar

18 Cf. Al-'Ahd (Hezbollah, Beirut), May 3, 1986.

19 Shqaqi, Khomeini, pp. 39–40, 59–60. Critique by Maghniya, A., al-Khumayni fi aqwalihi waaf'alihi (Beirut, 1979), p. 167;Google Scholaral-Khalidi, M., Naqd kitab al-hukumat al-islamiyya (Amman, 1983), pp. 4–6, 9.Google Scholar

20 Hanafi, in introduction to his edition of al-Hukumat al-islamiyya Cairo, 1979), pp. 15, 17, 24, 26–27.Google Scholar

21 Interview with al- Watan al-'arabi, April 19–25, 1982.

22 Interview with al-Shira', November 21, 1983.

23 al-Ghanushi, R., “al-Thawrat al-iraniyya,” al-Ma'rifa (Tunis), 02 12, 1979;Google Scholarcf. al-Ghanushi, R., Maqatat (Paris, 1984), pp. 77–79, 87, 101 ff.Google Scholar

24 al-Siba'i, M., al-Sunna wa-makanatuha fi-l-tashri' al-istami (Beirut, 1976), Introduction.Google Scholar

25 Ghanushi, Maqalat, passim.

26 Muhammad, Abu Mu'awiya, Hukm sabb al-sahaba (Cairo, 1978);Google ScholarZahir, I. I., al-Shi'a wa-l-Sunna (Cairo, 1979).Google Scholar

27 Matariq al-nur, ed. Malallah, M..Google Scholar

28 Nasih, S. M., Mawqif al-Khumayni mina-l-Shi'a wa-l-tashayyu' (Cairo, 1981).Google Scholar

29 Al-Ahram, August 14, 1980; al-Turkmani, al-Ta'rjf Text of the speech in al-Mujtama' (Kuwait), August 7, 1980.

30 Haqa'iq hawla harakat al-ittijah at-islami, pp. 21, 18.

31 Jawla fi-l-fikr al-shi'i, pp. 29, 30.

32 Ahmad, A. S., Introduction to Matariq at-nur, p. 4.Google Scholar

33 'UIwan, A., al-Uhuwwat al-islamiyya (Amman, 1981). The author is a Syrian.Google Scholar

34 See 'al-Sharqawi, A., at-Husayn tha'iran (Cairo, 1969);Google Scholaral-Kharbutli, A. H., 'Asharat thawrat fi-l-Islam (Beirut, 1970), pp. 170 ff.Google Scholar

35 The best ecumenist book is Maghniya, M. J., Ma'a batalat Karbala (Beirut, 1960). On ecumenical notables' assemblies on 'Ashura, see al-Hayat, April 9, 1968; March 29, 1969; al-Nahar, February 14, 1973; November 20, 1981; al-Anwar January 23, 1975; December 22, 1977.Google Scholar

36 Maatouk, La représentation, pp. 21–26, 37, 43–44; Chrara, W., Transformation d'une manifestalion religieuse dans un village un Liban du sud (Beirut, 1968), pp. 33–37.Google Scholar

37 Text of Shams al-Din's lecture on Husayn in al-Hayat April 15, 1969; id., Thawrat al-Husayn (Beirut, 1969). Expanded versions of the book were published in 1974 and 1979.

38 Chrara, Transformation, pp. 94–100.

39 Text of his speeches in al-Nahar, February 3, 1974; January 23, 1975.

40 Cf. al-Anwar, December 22, 1977; al-Amal (organ of the movement), October 29, 1983; al-Nahar and al-Anwar, October 5, 1984; Libération (Paris), September 26, 1985.

41 Al-Nahar, August 26, 1974.

42 Al-Nahar, December 11, 1978; November 30, 1979.

43 Al-Hakim's speech was published in Tehran in a booklet form, Thawrat at-Husayn (1982). Cf. Iraq, Munazamat al-Amal al-Islami fi, Iraq al-yawm wa-l-bahth 'ani-l-Husayn (Tehran, 1982).Google Scholar

44 Leaflet of the movement, January 12, 1984 (private collection).

45 Liwa' al-Sadr, (June 16, 1982), 5. Cf. the editorial, “'Ashura, al-Hikma (Beirut), 8 (1981), 3.

46 See al-Hakim, , al-Kifah al-musallah (Tehran, 1981); speech of the qadi of Sidon quoted in Risalat al-Thawrag al-Islamiyya (Tehran), (April 15, 1983), 15; interview of the Iraqi radical leader,Google Scholaral-Husayni, , in al-Shahid (Tehran), (06 3, 1981), 21.Google Scholar

47 al-Sadr, M. B., al-Tashayyu' (Cairo, 1977); id., Khilafat al-insan wa-shahadat al-anbiya (Beirut, 1979). These contain a selection from his writings in the 1960s and early 1970s.Google Scholar

48 al-'Amili, J. M., “'Ismat al-anbiya wa-l-a'ima,” al-Hikma, 5 (1980), 34–36.Google Scholar Cf. the interview of Hammud, M. in al-Liwa' (Beirut), 03 16, 1984.Google Scholar

49 E.g., Mutahhari in Risalat al-thawrat al-islamiyya, April 15, 1983, 44–45; Qasim, A., ed., al-Hajj:bay'a wa-jihad (Beirut, 1983);Google ScholarHusayni, 'A. in al-Fajr (Qom), 2(1983), 9–10, 21–22, 37–38.Google Scholar

50 Risalat al-Thawrat al-Islamiyya, (March 16, 1983), 11; al-Shahid, (August 22, 1984), 24; al Tawhid, 1(1982), 38–40.

51 Al-Shahid, April 15, 1983, 45; al-Tawhid, 1(1982), 82–97.

52 Quoted by Hanafi, H. in al- Watan (Kuwait), 11 29, 1982.Google Scholar

53 Risalat al-Thawrat al-Islamiyya, (April 15, 1983), 13.

54 A. S. Ali, al-Ijtihad fi-l-Islam, ibid., 38–39; Hezbollah' s program, al-Risalat al-Maftuha … ila-l-mustad'ifin (Beirut, 1985).

55 Al-Shahid (April 9, 1980), 54.

56 Publisher's introduction to Nahdar al-Mahdi, p. 3.

57 Siddiqi, K., al-Harakat al-islamiyya: qadaya wa-ahdaf (London, 1981).Google Scholar

58 Al-Nadhir (Syrian underground), August 11, 1980.

59 Proceeclings of the trial in al-Safir, May 28, 1982.

60 Interview of Babti, A. with al-Shira' (Beirut), 12 5, 1983.Google Scholar

61 Sa'd al-Din interview of al-Watan al-'Arabi, April 16, 1982. Al-Nadhir, May 2, 1981; July 17, 1981; March 27, 1982; May 8, 1982; al-I'tisam (February, 1980), 6–7; al-Shira', November 21, 1983.

62 Quoted by Hanafi, H. in al- Watan (Kuwait), 11 29, 1982.Google Scholar

63 Interview with the movement's leaders in al-Usbu' al-'arabi, January 14, 1985; al-Liwa' (Beirut), March 16, 1984; al-Bilad (Beirut), September 23; al-'Alim (London), January 26, 1985; and their publication al-'Hajj:bay'a wa-jihad (Beirut, 1983). On ulama and revolution, see Siddiqi's, K. two articles in al-'lrfan, (September, 1984; October, 1984).Google Scholar

64 Al- Wahdat al-islamiyya, 1 (1983), 32–34; 5 (1984) (Qutb), 16–22; (Mutahhari), 3(1983), 31–34; article on Sadr by Fadlallah, 4(1983), 16–18 (synthesis by Dr. Nafisi, a Kuwaiti Sunni).

65 E.g., cf. Hammud, M., “al-Wahdat al-islamiyya,” at-Muntalaq, 21 (05 1983), 16–27. Note the overlapping of participants in the two organs (notably Hammud and Fadlallah).Google Scholar

66 E.g., Fadlallah, M. H., al-Muntalaq, 23 (1984), 4–7;Google Scholar J. Khalisi, ibid., 26 (1984), 9–22.

67 A. Dan, ibid., 23 (1984), 30–34. Cf. Fadlallah in al-'Ahd (Beirut), (June 26, 1985), 5–7.

68 Libération (Paris), September 26, 1985. Cf. Fadlallah's, interview with al-Hawadith (Beirut), 05 24, 1985.Google Scholar

69 Al-Sharq al-Awsat (London), September 10, 1984; Sha'ban's interview in al-Mukhrar al-Islami (Cairo), 1986.

70 Yasin, 'A., “Da'wa wa-dawla,” al-Jama'a (Marrakesh), 1/3 (1982); al-Dustur (London), November 14, 1985; interview with 'Umar 'Abd al-Rahman in al-Sha'b, (Cairo), November 5, 1985; al-Thawrai al-Islamiyya (Saudi radicals), May 1985, June 1987; anon., Jawla fi-l-fikr al-shi'i (Gaza, 1985); al-Bayan (Gaza), February 1986; Sa'id Sha'bans interview in al-Mukhtar al-Istami (Cairo), November–December 1985.Google Scholar

71 For a forceful argument to that effect see the recent book of the Syrian radical leader Sa'd Hawwa, al-Kumayniyya (Cairo, 1987). Hawwa at first admired the Revolution, but later became disenchanted.