Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T00:42:17.821Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Causes of the Constitutional Revolution in Iran

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 January 2009

Ervand Abrahamian
Ervand Abrahamian
Affiliation:
Baruch College, City University of New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Marx, the prophet of revolution, may no longer haunt conservative politicians, but Marx, the theorist of revolution, continues to both attract and arouse social scientists. In the words of one student of politics, the social sciences, especially political sociology, can be described as a ‘century-long dialogue with Karl Marx.’ And as one prominent historian of ideas has aptly stated, Marx can properly be called the midwife of twentieth-century social thought, ‘for in the process of discarding what they had found invalid in Marxism and explaining what aspects of it had proved helpful, the innovators of the late nineteenth century took their first steps towards constructing a more general theory of social reality.’ For example, Emile Durkheim developed the paradigm of ‘mechanical and organic solidarity’ to counter the theory of class struggle. Vilfred Pareto and Gaetano Mosca stressed the dichotomy between ruling elites and ruled masses to supplant the concept of socioeconomic classes. Robert Michels formulated the ‘iron law of oligarchy’ to warn that popular organizations, such as the Social Democratic Parties, would bring in not the era of democratic socialism but the autocracy of bureaucratic socialists.’ And Max Weber, of course, devoted much of his career to showing that the dynamics of class conflict should be studied concomitantly with the heavy weights of conservative ideologies, traditional religions, ethnic castes, and bureaucratic institutions.

Type
Research Article
Information
International Journal of Middle East Studies , Volume 10 , Issue 3 , August 1979 , pp. 381 - 414
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Nordlinger, E., ed. Politics and Society: Comparative Political Sociology (Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1970), p. 8.Google Scholar

2 Hughes, S., Consciousness and Society (New York, 1958), p. 74.Google Scholar

3 Durkheim, E., The Division of Labor (New York, 1964).Google Scholar

4 Pareto, V., The Ming of Society (London, 1935);Google ScholarMosca, G., The Ruling Class (New York, 1939).Google Scholar

5 Michels, R., Political Parties (New York, 1949).Google Scholar

6 Gerth, H. and Mills, C. W., eds, From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology (New York, 1969).Google Scholar

7 For recent works on theories of revolution see: Stone, L., ‘Theories of Revolution,’ World Politics, 18, 2 (01 1966), 159–176:CrossRefGoogle ScholarZagorin, P., ‘Theories of Revolution in Contemporary Historiography,’ Political Science Quarterly, 88, 1 (03 1973), 3–26;CrossRefGoogle ScholarKaplan, L., ed. Revolution: A Comparative Study (New York, 1973);Google ScholarWelch, C. and Taintor, M., ed. Revolution and Political Change (Los Angeles, 1972);Google ScholarJohnson, C., Revolutionary Change (Berkeley, 1968)Google Scholar; special issue ‘Revolution and Social Change,’ Comparative Politics, 5, 3 (04 1973)Google Scholar; special issue ‘Theories of Revolution,’ Comparative Studies in Society and History, 18, 2 (04 1976).Google Scholar

8 Engels, F., ‘Speech at the Graveside of Karl Marx,’ Selected Works (Moscow, 1958), II, 167.Google Scholar

9 Padover, S., ed., Karl Marx on Revolution (New York, 1971), pp. 55, 422–424, 456–462.Google Scholar

10 Engels to Bloch, Selected Works, II, 488.

11 Hill, C.: Puritanism and Revolution (New York, 1964)Google Scholar; Century of Revolution (Edinburgh, 1961)Google Scholar; God's Englishman (London, 1970).Google Scholar

12 Thompson, E. P., The Making of the English Working Class (London, 1963).Google Scholar

13 Rudé, G.: The Crowd in History (New York, 1964)Google Scholar; The Crowd in the French Revolution (New York, 1967)Google Scholar; co-authored with Hobsbawrn, E., Captain Swing (New York, 1968).Google Scholar

14 Hobsbawm, E.: Labouring Men (London, 1964)Google Scholar; Primitive Rebels (New York, 1959)Google Scholar; Bandits (New York, 1971)Google Scholar; Revolutionaries (New York, 1973).Google Scholar

15 Hobsbawm, E., ‘Karl Marx's Contribution to Historiography,’ in Blackburn, R., ed., Ideology in Social Sciences, (London, 1972), pp. 265–288.Google Scholar

16 Richter, M., ‘Tocqueville's Contribution to the Theory of Revolutions,’ in Friedrich, C., ed., Revolutions (New York, 1969).Google Scholar

17 Parsons, T., The Social System (New York, 1964), pp. 521–523.Google Scholar

18 Gurr, T., Why Men Rebel (Princeton, 1969).Google Scholar

19 Kasravi, A., Tarikh-i Mashrūteh-i Iran (The History of the Iranian Constitution) (Tehran, 1961);Google ScholarMalekzadeh, M., Tarikh-i Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The History of the Constitutional Revolution in Iran), Vol. I (Tehran, 1949)Google Scholar; Dawlatabadi, Y., Hayat-i Yahyai (The Life of Yahyai), Vol. I (Tehran, 1957);Google ScholarKermani, Nizam al-Islam, Tarikh-i Bidari-yi Iranian (The History of the Iranian Awakening), Vol. I (Tehran, 1967).Google Scholar

20 Adamiyat, F., Fekr-i Azadi va Moqadimeh-yi Nahzat-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The Concept of Liberty and the Beginnings of the Constitutional Movement in Iran) (Tehran, 1961)Google Scholar; Adamiyat, , Andisheh-ha-yi Mirza Aqa Khan Kermani (The Ideas of Mirza Aqa Khan Kermani) (Tehran, 1967);Google ScholarAdamiyat, , Fekr-i Demokrasi-yi Ijtima‘yi va Nahzat-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The Concept of Social Democracy and the Constitutional Movement in Iran) (Tehran, 1975)Google Scholar; ‘Shamim, A., Iran dar Dawreh-i Saltanat-i Qajar (Iran during the Qajar Dynasty) (Tehran, 1963);Google ScholarSafa'i, I., Rahbaran-i Mashruteh (The Leaders of the Constitution) (Tehran, 1963);Google ScholarFarmayan, H. Farman, ‘The Forces of Modernization in Nineteenth Century Iran,’ in Polk, W. and Chambers, R., eds., Beginnings of Modernization in the Middle East (Chicago, 1966), pp. 119–151.Google Scholar

21 Razavani, M., Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The Constitutional Revolution in Iran) (Tehran, 1965), pp. 10–11.Google Scholar

22 For rare works that stress the economic causes of the revolution see Keddie, N.: ‘Iranian Politics, 1900–1905: Background to Revolution,’ Middle Eastern Studies, 5, 1 (01 1969), 2–35;Google Scholar‘The Origins of the Religious-Radical Alliance in Iran,’ Past and Present, 34 (07 1966), 70–80;CrossRefGoogle ScholarBill, J., The Politics of Iran; Groups, Classes, and Modernization (Columbus, 1972)Google Scholar; Pavlovich, M. and Iranski, J., Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The Constitutional Revolution of Iran), translated from Russian by Hushiyar, (Tehran, 1962);Google ScholarMomeni, B., Iran dar Astaneh-yi Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat (Iran on the Eve of the Constitutional Revolution) (Tebran, 1966).Google Scholar

23 Browne, E., The Persian Revolution of 1905–1909 (London, 1920).Google Scholar

24 Sykes, P., A History of Persia (London), 1963, II, 395–397.Google Scholar

25 Wilber, D., Iran: Past and Present (Princeton, 1955), p. 81.Google Scholar

26 Avery, P., Modern Iran (London, 1965), pp. 106–139.Google Scholar

27 Binder, L., Iran: Political Development in a Changing Society (Berkeley, 1963).Google Scholar

28 Lambton, A., ‘The Persian Constitutional Revolution of 1905–6,’ in Vatikiotis, P., ed., Revolutions in the Middle East (London, 1972), pp. 173–182.Google Scholar

29 For an elaboration of this definition see Kamenka, E., ‘The Concept of Political Revolution,’ in Friedrich, , ed., Revolutions, pp. 122–135.Google Scholar

30 Marx, K., ‘The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte,’ Selected Works (Moscow, 1958), I, 247.Google Scholar

31 Marx, K., The Poverty of Philosophy (Chicago, 1920), pp. 188–189.Google Scholar

32 Ossowski, S., Class Structure in Social Consciousness (London, 1963), pp. 69–87;Google ScholarCenters, R., The Psychology of Social Class (Princeton, 1949), pp. 21–27.Google Scholar

33 For a description of the class structure in nineteenth-century Iran see Abrahamian, E., ‘European Feudalism and Middle Eastern Despotisms,’ Science and Society, 39, 2 (Summer 1975), 129–156.Google Scholar

34 Khamsi, F., ‘The Development of Capitalism in Rural Iran,’ unpublished M.A. thesis, Columbia University, 1968.Google Scholar

35 Busse, H., History of Persia under Qajar Rule (New York, 1972).Google Scholar

36 Abrahamian, E., ‘The Crowd in the Persian Revolution,’ Iranian Studies, 2, 4 (Autumn 1969), 128–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

37 Kinneir, J., A Geographical Memoir of the Persian Empire (London, 1813), p. 45.Google Scholar

38 Lambton, A., ‘Persian Society under the Qajars,’ Journal of the Royal Central Asian Society, 48, 4 (07–10 1961), 130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

39 Malcolm, J., History of Persia (London, 1829), II, 429.Google Scholar

40 Marx, K., Pre-Capitalist Economic Formations, ed. Hobsbawm, E. (London, 1964), p. 70.Google Scholar

41 Issawi, C., The Economic History of Iran, 1800–1914 (Chicago, 1971), p. 132.Google Scholar

42 The term ‘European world-system’ is borrowed from Wallerstein, I., The Modern World-System (New York, 1974).Google Scholar

43 Marx, K., ‘The Communist Manifesto,’ Selected Works, I, 38.Google Scholar

44 Many nineteenth-century observers claimed that the inflation was caused by Qajar debasernents of the silver coinage. But the debasements corresponded with the inflation in neither time nor degree. The coinage dilution of 50 percent hardly paced the price inflation of nearly 600 percent. And the debasements occurred mostly in the first half of the century, although food prices rose sharply in the second half of the century. For the statistics see Issawi, Economic History of Iran, pp. 339–390.

45 For the early attempts at modfnization see Adamiyat, F., Amir Kabir va Iran (Amir Kabir and Iran) (Tehran, 1969)Google Scholar; Lorentz, J., ‘Modernization and Political Change in Nineteenth-Century Iran,’ unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Princeton University, 1974.Google Scholar

46 Mirza Hussein Khan Tahvildar-i Isfahan, Jukhrafiha-yi Isfahan (The Geography of Isfahan) (Tehran, 1963), pp. 100–101.

47 Lieutenant-Colonel Picot, ‘Persia: Biographical Notices,’ F.O. 881/Persia 1897/ 7028.

48 Mirza Taqi Khan Hakimbashi, ‘Reports on Bushire,’ Esnad-i Nowuafteh (Recently Found Documents), ed. I. Safa'i (Tehran, 1970), pp. 104–115.

49 Frye, R., ‘The Charisma of Kingship in Ancient Iran,’ Iranica Antiqua, 4 (1964), 36–54.Google Scholar

50 Lambton, A., ‘Justice in the Medieval Persian Theory of Kingship,’ Studia Islamica, 17 (1957), 91–119.Google Scholar

51 Algar, H., Religion and State in Iran, 1785–1906 (Berkeley, 1969), p. 57.Google Scholar

52 For detailed biographies see Adamiyat, , Fekr-i Azadi, pp. 100–120;Google ScholarAlgar, H., Mirza Malkum Khan (Berkeley, 1973).Google Scholar

53 Ra'in, I., Faramushkhaneh va Frernasunri dar Iran (The House of Oblivion and Freemasonry in Iran) (Tehran 1968) I, 525. The religious authorities also spread rumors that the Fāramūshkhāneh was organizing sex orgies for the ‘beardless youth of the Dar al-Funun.’Google Scholar

54 Khan, Malcom, ‘Persian Civilization,’ Contemporary Review, 54 (02 1891), 238–244.Google Scholar

55 Khan, Malkum, ‘God has Blessed Iran,’ Qānūn, 1 (02 1890).Google Scholar

56 Khan, Malkum, ‘A Letter from Qazvin,’ Qānūn, 6 (07 1890).Google Scholar

57 Quoted by Keddie, N., Religion and Rebellion in Iran: The Tobacco Protest of 1891–1892 (London, 1966), p. 49.Google Scholar

58 Malekzadeh, , Tarikh-i Inqilab, I, 174–177.Google Scholar

59 Mujtahedi, M., Tarikh-i Zindigani-ui Taqizadeh (The History of Taqizadeh's Life) (Tehran, 1942);Google ScholarTaqizadah, H., ‘My Life,’ Rahenma-yi Ketab, 13, 7 (05–06 1970), 243–266.Google Scholar

60 Quoted by Malekzadeh, , Tarikh-i Inqilab, I, 153–154.Google Scholar

61 Kermani, Nizam al-Islam, Tarikh-i Bidari, vol. I.Google Scholar

62 Javid, S., Fedakaran-i Faramush-shudeh (Forgotten Heroes) (Tehran, 1966);Google ScholarIqbal, A., ‘Sharifzadeh,’ Yadgar, 3, 10 (05–06 1947), 58–73;Google ScholarTaherzadeh-Behzad, K., Qiyam-i Azerbayjan dar Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The Revolt of Azerbayjan in the Constitutional Revolution) (Tehran, 1953).Google Scholar

63 Javid, S., Nahzat-i Mashrutiyat-I Iran (The Constitutional Movement in Iran) (Tehran, 1968), pp. 60–70.Google Scholar

64 Document, ‘Concerning the Iranian Social Democratic Party,’ Donya, 5, 2 (Summer 1966), 99–103;Google Scholar document, ‘The Regulations of the Iranian Social Democratic Party,’ Donya, 3, 4 (Winter 1962), 76–80.Google Scholar

65 Adamiyat, , Fekr-i Azadi, pp. 206–217.Google Scholar

66 Malekzadeh, , Tarikh-i Inqilab, II, 5–18.Google Scholar

67 Malekzadeh, M., Zindigani-yi Malek al-Motakallemin (The Life of Malek al-Motakallemin) (Tehran, 1946), p. 148.Google Scholar

68 The biographical information has been obtained from interviews, miscellaneous newspapers, and Bamdad, M., Tarikh-i Rajal-i Iran (The History of Iranian Statesmen) Vols. I–IV (Tehran, 1968).Google Scholar

69 Habl al-Matin, 2–23 March 1905.Google Scholar

70 The Shah rejected a Russian offer of £350,000 which stipulated that a Russian officer should be placed in charge of all military contingents besides the Cossack brigade (British Minister to the Foreign Office, ‘Annual Report for 1905.’ F.O. 371/Persia 1906/106).

71 Habl al-Matin, 19 June 1905.Google Scholar

72 British Minister to the Foreign Office, ‘Annual Report for 0905,’ F.O. 370/Persia 1906/106.

73 Qudsi, H., Kitab-i Khatirat-i Man ya Tarikh-i Sad Saleh (The Book of My Life or the History of One Hundred Years) (Tehran, 1963), 1, 99–100.Google Scholar

74 Malekzadeh, , Tarikh-i Inqilab, II, 10.Google Scholar

75 Kermani, Nizam al-Islam, Tarikh-i Bidari, I, 124.Google Scholar

76 Habl al-Matin, 28 September 1906.Google Scholar

77 Britain, Great, Correspondence Respecting the Affairs of Persia (London, 1909), I, pp. 3–4.Google Scholar

78 Kasravi, , Tarikh-i Mashruteh, p. 110.Google Scholar

79 Britain, Great, Correspondence Respecting the Affairs of Persia, I, 4.Google Scholar

80 Kermani, Nizam al-Islam, Tarikh-i Bidari, I, 274.Google Scholar

81 Husseini, Hajji Ahmad Tarresh, Ruznameh-i Akhbar-i Mashrutiyat (A Diary of the Constitution) (Tehran, 1972), p. 40.Google Scholar

82 Heravi-Khurasani, M., Tarikh-i Paydayish-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The History of the Genesis of the Iranian Constitution) (Tehran, 1953), p. 50.Google Scholar

83 Recounted by Yousef, Shaykh, Muzakerat-i Majlis-i Shawra-yi Melli (The Proceedings of the National Assembly), First Majlis, p. 351.Google Scholar

84 Some members of the opposition feared that the court would bar them from such an ‘Islamic Assembly’ by denouncing them as ‘heretics’ (al-Islam, Nizam, Tarikh-i Bidari, I, 329).Google Scholar

85 Quoted by ibid., p. 359.

86 Britain, Great, Correspondence Respecting the Affairs the Affairs of Persia, I, p. 4.Google Scholar

87 Arsanjani, H., ‘Anarchism in Iran,’ Darya, 17 07 1944.Google Scholar

88 Malekyadeh, , Tarikh- Inqilab, II, 180.Google Scholar

89 Translations of the constitutional laws have been reprinted in Browne, , The Persian Revolution, pp. 354–400.Google Scholar

90 The 1,000 tomans included much of the medium-incomed landowners, but not the self-employed farmers.

91 Shaji'i, Z., Nemayandegan-i Majlis-i Shawra-yi Melli dar Bistuyek Dawreh-i Qanunguzari (The Members of the National Assembly during Twenty-One Legislative Sessions) (Tehran, 1965), p. 176.Google Scholar

92 Taqizadeh, H., ‘My Life,’ Rahenma-yi Ketab, 13, 7 (05–06 1970), 243–266.Google Scholar

93 Taqizadeh, H., ‘List of Members of the First Majlis,’ Kaveh, 07 1918.Google Scholar

94 For a discussion of these terms see Taqizadeh, H., ‘The First National Assembly,’ Ittila'at-i Mahaneh, 5, 5 (07–08 1954), 3–6.Google Scholar

95 Britain, Great, Correspondence Respecting the Affairs of Persia, I, 27.Google Scholar

96 Kasravi, , Tarikh-i Mashruteh, p. 519.Google Scholar

97 See Keddie, N., ‘The Assassination of Amin as-Sultan,’ in Bosworth, C. E., ed., Iran and Islam (Edinburgh, 1971), pp. 336–339.Google Scholar

98 Quoted by Browne, , The Persian Revolution, p. 337.Google Scholar

99 Kasravi, A., Inqilabi Christ? (What Is a Revolution?) (Tehran, 1945).Google Scholar

100 Kermani, A. Majd al-Islam, Tarikh-i Inqilab-i Mashrutiyat-i Iran (The History of the Constitutional Revolution in Iran) (Isfahan, 1972), III, 21.Google Scholar