Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-cphqk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-11T08:41:35.239Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Taken lives matter: open justice and recognition in inquests into deaths at the hands of the state

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 June 2016

Sam McIntosh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Lord Neuberger describes open justice as a procedural principle requiring that ‘what goes on in court and what a court decides is open to scrutiny’ (Neuberger, 2011). The prime rationale given for this principle is that it is a safety check on procedural fairness. Such a conception of open justice applies on only a superficial level in inquests into use-of-force deaths at the hands of the state. This paper examines the practice of, and rationales behind, opening up use-of-force deaths at the hands of the state to scrutiny through inquests. They suggest a primarily intrinsic rather than instrumental link between openness and inquests’ purposes, which requires a reframing of traditional conceptions of open justice in this context. It is further argued that recognition theory can provide the normative link between openness and justice in these circumstances – a link that is implicit in the term ‘open justice’ but rarely explored in inquests.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Law in Context , Volume 12 , Issue 2: Frontiers in Coronial Justice – ushering in a new era of coronial research , June 2016 , pp. 141 - 161
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Allen, Jonathan (1999) ‘Balancing Justice and Social Unity: Political Theory and the Idea of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission’, University of Toronto Law Journal 49: 315–353.Google Scholar
Allen, Jonathan (2001) ‘The Place of Negative Morality in Political Theory’, Political Theory 29(3): 337–363.Google Scholar
BBC (2010) ‘Relatives' Reactions to Bloody Sunday Report’, 15 June 2010. Online <http://www.bbc.com/news/10323362> (last accessed 13 May 2016). (last accessed 13 May 2016).' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=BBC+(2010)+‘Relatives'+Reactions+to+Bloody+Sunday+Report’,+15+June+2010.+Online++(last+accessed+13+May+2016).>Google Scholar
Bell, Christine and Keenan, Johanna (2005) ‘Lost on the Way Home – The Right to Life in Northern Ireland’, Journal of Law and Society 32: 68–89.Google Scholar
Bingham, Tom (2011) The Rule of Law. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Brennan, John M. (ed.) (2014) The A–Z of Death and Dying: Social, Medical, and Cultural Aspects. Oxford: ABC-CLIO.Google Scholar
Brink, Bert van den and Owen, David (eds) (2007) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Brodrick, (1971) Report of the Committee on Death Certification and Coroners. Cmd 4810. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Burney, Ian A. (2000) Bodies of Evidence: Medicine and the Politics of the English Inquest, 1830–1926. Baltimore: JHU Press.Google Scholar
Casale, Silvia (2013) Report of the Independent External Review of the IPCC Investigation into the Death of Sean Rigg. London: IPCC.Google Scholar
Cohen, Stanley (1993) ‘Human Rights and Crimes of the State: The Culture of Denial’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 26(2): 97–115.Google Scholar
De Toit, André (2000) ‘The Moral Foundations of the South African TRC: Truth as Acknowledgment and Justice as Recognition’, in Robert, I. Rotberg and Thompson, Dennis (eds), Truth v. Justice: The Morality of Truth Commissions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 122–141.Google Scholar
Dorries, Christopher (2014) Coroners’ Courts: A Guide to Law and Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Foucault, Michael (1977) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Fraser, Nancy (1995) ‘From Redistribution to Recognition? Dilemmas of Justice in a “Post-Socialist” Age’, New Left Review 212: 68–93.Google Scholar
Gibson, Owen and CONN, David (2012) ‘Hillsborough: The Truth about the Causes of the Disaster’, The Guardian, 12 September 2012. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/zuk5cjr> (last accessed 13 May 2016).Google Scholar
Haldemann, Frank (2008) ‘Another Kind of Justice: Transitional Justice as Recognition’, Cornell International Law Journal 41(3): 675–737.Google Scholar
Hattenstone, Simon (2005) ‘We Cannot Take Them at Their Word’, The Guardian, 18 August. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/nogwx2w> (last accessed 26 June 2014).Google Scholar
Hinsliff, Gabby (2008) ‘Families Fight Plan for Secret Inquests in Friendly-fire Deaths’, The Guardian, 6 April 2008. Online: <http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/apr/06/military.iraq> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Hirschfield, Paul J. and Simon, Daniella (2010) ‘Legitimating Police Violence: Newspaper Narratives of Deadly Force’, Theoretical Criminology 14(2): 155–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Honneth, Axel (1996) The Struggle for Recognition: The Moral Grammar of Social Conflicts, translated from the original German and with an introduction by Anderson, Joel. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Honneth, Axel (2004) ‘Recognition and Justice: Outline of a Plural Theory of Justice’, Acta Sociologica 47(4): 351–364.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Honneth, Axel (2007) Disrespect: The Normative Foundations of Critical Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Iser, Mattias (2013) ‘Recognition’, in Zalta, Edward N. (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/ofrqfye> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Kiss, Elizabeth (2000) ‘Moral Ambition Within and Beyond Political Constraints: Reflections on Restorative Justice’, in Thompson, Dennis and Rothberg, Robert I. (eds), Truth v. Justice: The Morality of Truth Commissions. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 68–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lakhani, Nina (2012) Why Did Police Shoot Dead Unarmed Man Azelle Rodney Seven Years Ago?’ The Independent, 29 August 2012. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/ckdo2zx> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Lawrence, Regina G. (2000) The Politics of Force: Media and the Construction of Police Brutality. Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Martin, Greg and Scott Bray, Rebecca (2013) ‘Discolouring Democracy? Policing, Sensitive Evidence, and Contentious Deaths in the United Kingdom’, Journal of Law and Society 40(4): 624–656.Google Scholar
Neuberger, Lord (Master of the Rolls) (2011) Open Justice Unbound? Judicial Studies Board Annual Lecture. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/guwlwma> (last accessed 13 May 2016).Google Scholar
Ní Aoláin, Fionnuala (2002) ‘Truth Telling, Accountability, and the Right to Life in Northern Ireland’, European Human Rights Law Review 5: 572–590.Google Scholar
O'neill, Shane and Smith, Nicholas H. (2012) Recognition Theory as Social Research: Investigating the Dynamics of Social Conflict. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Owen, David (2007) ‘Self-Government and “Democracy as Reflexive Co-operation”: Reflections on Honneth's Social and Political Ideal.’ In Brink, Bert van den and Owen, David (eds), Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 290–323.Google Scholar
Pemberton, Simon (2008) ‘Demystifying Deaths in Police Custody: Challenging State Talk’, Social & Legal Studies 17(2): 237–262.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Petoukhov, Konstantin (2012) ‘Locating a Theoretical Framework for the Canadian Truth and Reconciliation Commission: Charles Taylor or Nancy Fraser’, International Indigenous Policy Journal 3(2): 1–17.Google Scholar
Poor Law Commission (1841) Accounts and Papers of the Poor Law Commission, Session 26 January – 22 June 1841.Google Scholar
Rawls, John (2001) Justice as Fairness: A Restatement. London: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodrick, Sharon (2006) ‘Open Justice, the Media and Avenues of Access to Documents on the Court Record’, University of South Wales Law Journal 29: 90–138.Google Scholar
Scott Bray, Rebecca (2013) ‘Paradoxical Justice: The Case of Ian Tomlinson’, Journal of Law and Medicine 21(2): 447–472.Google Scholar
Scott Bray, Rebecca and Martin, Greg (2012) ‘FOI: Closing Down Open Justice in the United Kingdom’, Alternative Law Journal 37: 126–127.Google Scholar
Scraton, Phil and Chadwick, Kathryn (1986) ‘Speaking Ill of the Dead: Institutionalised Responses to Deaths in Custody’, Journal of Law and Society 13(1): 93–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scraton, Phil and Chadwick, Kathryn (1987) In the Arms of the Law: Coroner's Inquests and Deaths in Custody. London: Pluto.Google Scholar
Shklar, Judith N. (1990) The Faces of Injustice. London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Sim, Joe and Ward, Tony (1994) ‘The Magistrates of the Poor? Coroners and Deaths in Custody in Nineteenth-century England.’ In Clark, Michael and Crawford, Catherine (eds), Legal Medicine in History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 245–268.Google Scholar
Stanley, Elizabeth (2009) Torture, Truth and Justice: The Case of Timor-Leste. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Stubbs, Celia (2010) ‘For Blair Peach, a Little Justice’, The Guardian, 1 May 2012. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/pqynyht> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Taylor, Charles (1994) ‘The Politics of Recognition’, in Gutmann, Amy (ed.), Multiculturalism: Examining the Politics of Recognition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 25–73.Google Scholar
Taylor, Matthew (2014) ‘Jimmy Mubenga's Widow: I Can't Watch This Happen to Another Family’, The Guardian, 16 December 2014. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/qburjtj> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Taylor, Matthew and Lewis, Paul (2013) ‘G4S Faces Damages Claim over Killing of Jimmy Mubenga’, The Guardian, 10 July 2013. Online: <http://business-humanrights.org/en/g4s-faces-damages-claim-over-killing-of-jimmy-mubenga-uk>.Google Scholar
Thomas, Leslie Adam Straw, Machover, Daniel and Friedman, Danny (2014) Inquests: A Practitioner's Guide, 3rd rev. edn.London: Legal Action Group.Google Scholar
Wainwright, Martin (2011) ‘Unlawful Restraint “Contributed to Death of Boy in Custody”’, The Guardian, 27 January 2011. Online: <http://tinyurl.com/oydry5q> (last accessed 6 July 2015).Google Scholar
Walker, Andrew (2007) ‘Coroner's Pre-Inquest Ruling Touching Upon the Death of Azelle Rodney.’ Online: <http://tinyurl.com/osylp3k> (last accessed 6 July 2015). (last accessed 6 July 2015).' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Walker,+Andrew+(2007)+‘Coroner's+Pre-Inquest+Ruling+Touching+Upon+the+Death+of+Azelle+Rodney.’+Online:++(last+accessed+6+July+2015).>Google Scholar