Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T08:34:14.777Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Functioning of Indigenous Cultural Protocols in Australia’s Contemporary Art World

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 October 2016

Marianne Riphagen  and
Gretchen M. Stolte
Marianne Riphagen
Affiliation:
Cultural Anthropology and Development Studies, Radboud University Nijmegen, the Netherlands; Email: [email protected]
Gretchen M. Stolte
Affiliation:
Centre for Digital Humanities Research, Research School of Humanities and the Arts, College of Arts and Social Sciences, Australian National University; Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

In recent decades, cultural protocols have emerged as a non-judicial alternative to the inadequate legal protection of Indigenous cultural heritage. They are meant to protect Indigenous peoples from the misappropriation of their heritage by outsiders and enhance Indigenous peoples’ control over their own domain. This article examines the functioning of Indigenous cultural protocols within Australia’s contemporary art world. As we will demonstrate, cultural protocols have clear practical utility. They can raise awareness, instigate changes in behaviour, and operate as a conduit for correcting the unauthorized use of Indigenous cultural materials. Yet, a disjunction exists between codified ideals and a messy reality. Our analysis of two protocol transgressions shows that protocols do not automatically protect Indigenous individuals equally. Furthermore, although discussions about compliance are infused with rhetoric about the authority of “the Indigenous community,” Indigenous people with cultural connections to contested heritage objects do not always have a clear voice in decisions made about their use.

Type
Research Article
Information
International Journal of Cultural Property , Volume 23 , Issue 3 , August 2016 , pp. 295 - 320
Copyright
Copyright © International Cultural Property Society 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Allen, Lindy. 2008. “Tons and Tons of Valuable Material: The Donald Thomson Collection.” In The Makers and Making of Indigenous Australian Collections, edited by Peterson, Nicolas, Allen, Lindy, and Hamby, Louise, 387–418. Carlton, Australia: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
Anderson, Jane. 2005. “Access and Control of Indigenous Knowledge in Libraries and Archives: Ownership and Future Use.” Paper presented at Correcting Course: Rebalancing Copyright for Libraries in the National and International Arena, New York, 5–7 May.Google Scholar
Anderson, Jane, and Younging, Gregory. 2010. “Discussion Paper on Protocols.” Paper presented at the Canadian Public Art Funders Professional Development Meeting on Aboriginal Arts, Canada, 9–10 March.Google Scholar
Australia Council for the Arts. 2007a. Protocols for Producing Indigenous Australian Visual Arts. Surry Hills: Australia Council for the Arts.Google Scholar
Australia Council for the Arts. 2007b. Protocols for Producing Indigenous Australian Media Arts. Surry Hills: Australia Council for the Arts.Google Scholar
Bell, Richard. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was the Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 20.Google Scholar
Bernard, H. Russell. 2002. Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Methods. Walnut Creek: AltaMira Press.Google Scholar
Boles, Frank, George-Shongo, David, and Weideman, Christine. 2008. Report: Task Force to Review Protocols for Native American Archival Materials. Washington, DC: Society of American Archivists.Google Scholar
Bowrey, Kathy. 2006. “Alternative Intellectual Property? Indigenous Protocols, Copyleft and New Juridifications of Customary Practices.” Macquarie Law Journal 6: 65–96.Google Scholar
Brown, Michael. 1998. “Can Culture be Copyrighted?” Current Anthropology 39, no. 2: 193–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clemens, Justin. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was the Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 20.Google Scholar
Clemens, Justin. 2007. “A Law That Cannot Be Enforced: The Politics of Art in Australia.” The Monthly 21: 62–64.Google Scholar
Clifford, James. 2001. “Indigenous Articulations.” The Contemporary Pacific 13, no. 2: 468–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Croft, Brenda L. 1992. “A Very Brief Bit of an Overview of the Aboriginal Arts/Cultural Industry by a Sort of Renegade, or the Cultural Correctness of Certain Issues.” Art Monthly Australia 56: 20–22.Google Scholar
Davis, Michael, and Holcombe, Sarah. 2010. “‘Whose Ethics?’ Codifying and Enacting Ethics in Research Settings.” Australian Aboriginal Studies, no. 2: 1–9.Google Scholar
Deger, Jennifer. 2008. “Imprinting on the Heart: Photography and Contemporary Yolngu Mournings.” Visual Anthropology 21, no. 4: 292–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deger, Jennifer. 2016. “Thick Photography.” Journal of Material Culture 21, no. 1: 111–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Everett, Kristina. 2009. “Welcome to Country … Not.” Oceania 79, no. 1: 53–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foley, Fiona. 2011. “When the Circus Came to Town.” Art Monthly Australia 245: 5–7.Google Scholar
Follent, Sarah. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was The Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 17.Google Scholar
Gilchrist, Stephen. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was The Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 21.Google Scholar
Gray, Stephen. 2004. “Imagination, Fraud and the Cultural Protocols Debate: A Question of Free Speech or Pornography?” Media and Arts Law Review 9, no. 3: 23–37.Google Scholar
Greer, Olivia J. 2013. “Using Intellectual Property Laws to Protect Indigenous Cultural Property.” Bright Ideas 22, no. 3: 27–33.Google Scholar
Hamby, Louise. 2008. “The Reluctant Collector: Lloyd Warner.” In The Makers and Making of Indigenous Australian Collections, edited by Peterson, Nicolas, Allen, Lindy, and Hamby, Louise, 355–86. Carlton, Australia: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
Harrison, Rodney. 2013. “Reassembling Ethnographic Museum Collections.” In Reassembling the Collection: Ethnographic Museums and Indigenous Agency, edited by Harrison, Rodney, Byrne, Sarah, and Clarke, Anne, 3–38. Santa Fe: SAR Press.Google Scholar
Herbert, Tracey, and Wherry, Cathi Charles, eds. 2014a. Proceedings of the Cultural Protocols and the Arts Forum. Brentwood Bay, Australia: First Peoples’ Cultural Council.Google Scholar
Herbert, Tracey, and Wherry, Cathi Charles. 2014b. “Executive Summary.” In Proceedings of the Cultural Protocols and the Arts Forum, edited by Herbert, Tracey and Wherry, Cathi Charles, 7–10. Brentwood Bay, Australia: First Peoples’ Cultural Council.Google Scholar
Janke, Terri. 1998. Our Culture: Our Future: Report on Australian Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property Rights. Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission.Google Scholar
Janke, Terri. 2001. “Berne, Baby, Berne: The Berne Convention, Moral Rights and Indigenous Peoples’ Cultural Rights.” Indigenous Law Bulletin 5, no. 6: 14–18.Google Scholar
Janke, Terri, and Dawson, Peter. 2012. New Tracks: Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Expression and the Australian Intellectual Property System. Sydney: Terri Janke and Company.Google Scholar
Johnson, Helen. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was the Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 18.Google Scholar
Kaus, David. 2008. “Professional and Amateurs: Different Histories of Collecting in the National Ethnographic Collection.” In The Makers and Making of Indigenous Australian Collections, edited by Peterson, Nicolas, Allen, Lindy, and Hamby, Louise, 281–314. Carlton, Australia: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
Lydon, Jane. 2010. “Return: The Photographic Archive and Technologies of Indigenous Memory.” Photographies 3, no. 2: 173–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacInnes, Colin. 1964. Australia and New Zealand. New York: Time Life Books.Google Scholar
Mackinolty, Chips, and Duffy, Michael. 1987. Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner in Arnhem Land? Darwin, Australia: Northern Land Council.Google Scholar
McGrath, Pamela Faye, and Brooks, David. 2010. “Their Darkest Hour: The Films and Photographs of William Grayden and the History of the ‘Warburton Range Controversy’ of 1957.” Aboriginal History 34: 115–41.Google Scholar
Mellor, Doreen, and Janke, Terri. 2001. Valuing Art, Respecting Culture: Protocols for Working with the Australian Indigenous Visual Arts and Craft Sector. Potts Point, Australia: National Association for the Visual Arts.Google Scholar
Merlan, Francesca. 2005. “Explorations towards Intercultural Accounts of Socio-Cultural Reproduction and Change.” Oceania 75, no. 3: 167–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merlan, Francesca. 2014. “Recent Rituals of Indigenous Recognition in Australia: Welcome to Country.” American Anthropologist 116, no. 2: 296–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michaels, Eric. 1991. “A Primer of Restrictions on Picture-Taking in Traditional Areas of Aboriginal Australia.” Visual Anthropology 4, no. 3–4: 259–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morphy, Howard. 1991. Ancestral Connections: Art and an Aboriginal System of Knowledge. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Morphy, Howard. 1998. Aboriginal Art. London: Phaidon Press.Google Scholar
Morphy, Howard. 2015. “Open Access versus the Culture of Protocols.” In Museums as Process: Translating Local and Global Knowledges, edited by Silverman, Raymond, 90–104. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Mundine, Djon. 2010. “Nowhere Boy.” Artlink 30, no. 1: 91–93.Google Scholar
Museums Australia. 2005. Continuous Cultures, Ongoing Responsibilities: Principles and Guidelines for Australian Museums Working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Cultural Heritage. Canberra: Museums Australia.Google Scholar
Myers, Fred. 1986. Pintupi Country, Pintupi Self: Sentiment, Place, and Politics among Western Desert Aborigines. Washington, DC, and Canberra: Smithsonian Institution Press and Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies.Google Scholar
Myers, Fred. 1994. “Culture-Making: Performing Aboriginality at the Asia Society Gallery.” American Ethnologist 21, no. 4: 679–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Myers, Fred. 2002. Painting Culture: The Making of an Aboriginal High Art. Durham: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Myers, Fred. 2005. “Some Properties of Culture and Persons.” In Collaboration, Ownership and the Digital Economy, edited by Aiyer Ghosh, Rishab, 45–60. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
O’Neal, Jennifer. 2015. “‘The Right to Know’: Decolonizing Native American Archives.” Journal of Western Archives 6, no. 1: 1–17.Google Scholar
Peterson, Nicolas. 2003. “The Changing Photographic Contract: Aborigines and Image Ethics.” In Photography’s Other Histories, edited by Pinney, Christopher and Peterson, Nicolas, 119–45. Durham: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peterson, Nicolas, Allen, Lindy, and Hamby, Louise, eds. 2008. The Makers and Making of Indigenous Australian Collections. Carlton, Australia: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
Pickering, Michael, and Gordon, Phil. 2011. “Repatriation: The End of the Beginning.” In Australian Museums and Museology, edited by Griffin, Des and Paroissien, Leon. Canberra: National Museum of Australia, http://nma.gov.au/research/understanding-museums/MPickering_PGordon_2011.html (accessed 9 September 2016).Google Scholar
Raven, Margaret. 2010. “Protocols: Devices for Translating Moralities, Controlling Knowledge and Defining Actors in Indigenous Research, and Critical Ethical Reflection.” Australian Aboriginal Studies, no. 2: 33–47.Google Scholar
Riphagen, Marianne. 2008. “Black on White: Or Varying Shades of Grey? Indigenous Australian Photo-Media Artists and the ‘Making of’ Aboriginality.” Australian Aboriginal Studies, no. 1: 78–89.Google Scholar
Riphagen, Marianne. 2013. “Contested Categories: Brook Andrew, Christian Thompson and the Framing of Contemporary Australian Art.” Australian Humanities Review 55: 93–118.Google Scholar
Rowley, Susan. 2013. “The Reciprocal Research Network: The Development Process.” Museums Anthropology Review 7, no. 1–2: 22–43.Google Scholar
Roy, Alpana. 2008. “Copyright: A Colonial Doctrine in a Postcolonial Age.” Copyright Reporter 26, no. 4: 112–34.Google Scholar
Schüssel, Stuart. 2012. “Copyright Protection’s Challenges and Alaska Natives’ Cultural Property.” Alaska Law Review 29, no. 2: 313–40.Google Scholar
Stanhope, Zara. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was The Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 21.Google Scholar
Stolte, Gretchen. 2014. “Aboriginal Exhibitions and Aboriginal Communities: Contemporary Curation in Australia.” International Journal of Cultural and Creative Industries 1, no. 3: 52–63.Google Scholar
Stolte, Gretchen, Flinders, Lynelle, Creed, Cheryl, and Pau, Robert Tommy. 2015. “An Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Approach to Intellectual Property: Industry Insight into the Development of Indigenous Cultural Protocols.” International Journal of Cultural and Creative Industries 2, no. 3: 64–75.Google Scholar
Sunder, Madhavi. 2011. “New Working Group on ‘Cultural Protocols’ Convenes at New York University, 19 August 2011.” International Journal of Cultural Property 18, no. 4: 459–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Underhill, Karen J. 2006. “Protocols for Native American Archival Materials.” RBM: A Journal of Rare Books, Manuscripts, and Cultural Heritage 7, no. 2: 134–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ussher, Michelle. 2006. “What Should White Australians Do with ‘Bad’ Images?” Eyeline 61: 18.Google Scholar
Van Meijl, Toon. 2009. “Māori Intellectual Property Rights and the Formation of Ethnic Boundaries.” International Journal of Cultural Property 16, no. 3: 341–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
West, L. 2006. “Response to ABC Archival Footage.” In Yours, Mine and Ours: 50 Years of ABC TV. Sydney: Penrith Regional Gallery.Google Scholar
Winikoff, Tamara. 2006. “Gertrude Forum: The Only Thing You Taught Me Was The Only Thing You Know.” Eyeline 61: 19.Google Scholar
Younging, Gregory. 2014. “Workshop 1: Traditional Knowledge, Intellectual Property Rights and Existing Copyright.” In Proceedings of the Cultural Protocols and the Arts Forum, edited by Herbert, Tracey and Wherry, Cathi Charles, 51–52. Brentwood Bay, Australia: First Peoples’ Cultural Council.Google Scholar