The generation of organic matter from CO2 and H2O is a highly endothermic reaction. Energy for biological carbon fixation can be derived from chemical potential gradients in the environment by chemoautotrophic organisms or it can be harvested from photon energy by photosynthesis. On Earth, the plate tectonically driven carbon flux through the surface environment is of such a magnitude that the chemical free energy production within the Earth is insufficient to support conversion of any significant fraction of the carbon to organic matter through chemoautotrophy. Therefore, the chemical and isotopic fingerprints we observe in the Earth's surface environments are based on the invention of photosynthesis by life. We cannot a priori assume that life on any planet will invent photosynthesis and remote life detection should thus not be based exclusively on the expectations from our own ecosystem.