Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:58:00.408Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Rediscovering the Yellow River and the Yangtze River: the Circulation of Discourses on the North–South Dichotomy between Late Qing China and Meiji Japan

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 March 2019

Fei Chen
Fei Chen*
Affiliation:
Shanghai Normal University
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many novels, poems, and academic works produced in the last decades of Qing China were characterized by a structure of North–South dichotomy. While existing studies have investigated the root of this narrative structure in Chinese traditions, this article tries to uncover Japan's lesser-known role in the revitalization of traditional discourses. It first discusses how Japanese intellectuals, such as Shiga Shigetaka and Naitō Konan, reconfigured Chinese discourses on the North–South dichotomy as theories to assert Japan's superiority over China. It goes on to examine how Liang Qichao appropriated Japanese theories to mobilize southern Chinese to participate in state politics. It then explores how Chinese revolutionary students in Japan exploited Japanese intellectuals’ and Liang's discourses to promote a cross-provincial consciousness by representing China as a river-based region writ large. Lastly, it reveals how the restructured discourses on the North–South dichotomy were manipulated by revolutionaries after they flowed back to China.

Keywords

North–South dichotomylocal consciousnessnational consciousnessthe Yellow Riverthe Yangtze River
Type
Research Article
Information
International Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 16 , Issue 1 , January 2019 , pp. 33 - 51
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Beigu, 悲谷 (1907). “Ershi shiji Huanghe” 二十世紀黃河 (“The Yellow River in the Twentieth Century”). Henan 河南 1, pp. 63–74.Google Scholar
Burns, Susan L. (2003). Before the Nation: Kokugaku and the Imagination of Community in Early Modern Japan. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Ching May, Bo 程美寶 (2006). Diyu wenhua yu guojia rentong: wanqing yilai “Guangdong wenhua” guan de xingcheng 地域文化與國家認同：晚清以來“廣東文化”觀的形成 (“Local Culture and National Identity: the Formation of the idea of ‘Cantonese Culture' since the Late Qing”). Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Ding, Wenjiang 丁文江 and Fengtian, Zhao 趙豐田 (1983). Liang Qichao nianpu 梁啟超年譜 (“An Annalistic Biography of Liang Qichao”). Shanghai: Shanghai Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Dong, Qichang 董其昌 (1968). Hua zhi 畫旨 (“The Principle of Painting”). In Rongtai ji (si) 容台集(四), pp. 2089–2200. Taipei: Guoli Zhongyang Tushuguan.Google Scholar
Fogel, Joshua A. (1996). The Literature of Travel in the Japanese Rediscovery of China, 1862–1945. Stanford, CA: Stanford University.Google Scholar
Fogel, Joshua A. (1984). Politics and Sinology: The Case of Naitō Konan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.Google Scholar
Foucault, Michel (1980). “Truth and Power.” In Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writing, 1972–1977, ed. Gordon, Colin, trans. Gordon, Colin et al. , pp. 109–33. New York, NY: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
Ishikawa, Yoshihiro (2004). “Liang Qichao, the Field of Geography in Meiji Japan and Geographical Determinism.” In The Role of Japan in Liang Qichao's Introduction of Modern Western Civilization to China, ed. Fogel, Joshua A., pp. 156–76. Berkeley, CA: Institute of East Asian Studies, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Jin, Chongji 金沖及 (1991). “Wuchang qiyi hou gesheng duli zhi niaokan” 武昌起義后各省獨立之鳥瞰 (“An Overview of the Provincial Independence after the Wuchang Uprising”). Jindaishi yanjiu 近代史研究 6, pp. 15–33.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Philip A. (1980). Rebellion and Its Enemies in Late Imperial China: Militarization and Social Structure, 1796–1864. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Lacouperie, Terrien de (1894). Western Origin of the Early Chinese Civilization, from 2300 B.C. to 200 A.D. London: Asher & Co.Google Scholar
Li, Buqing 李步青 (1903). “Huanghe” 黃河 (“The Yellow River”). Hubei xueshengjie 湖北學生界 2, pp. 72–78.Google Scholar
Liang, Qichao 梁啟超 (1999). “Zhongguo dili dashi lun” 中國地理大勢輪 (“An Overview of Chinese Geography”). In Liang Qichao quanji disijuan 梁啟超全集第4卷 (“Collected Works of Liang Qichao vol. 4”), ed. Pinxing, Zhang 張品興, pp. 929–46. Beijing: Beijing Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Liang, Qichao (1999). “Zhongguoshi xulun” 中國史敘論 (“An Introduction to Chinese History”). In Liang Qichao quanji dierjuan 梁啟超全集第2卷 (“Collected Works of Liang Qichao vol. 2”), ed. Pinxing, Zhang 張品興, pp. 448–54. Beijing: Beijing Chubanshe.Google Scholar
“Lilou, Xia” 離婁下 (2012). In Mengzi 孟子, trans. Lihua, Wan 萬麗華, Xu, Lan 藍旭, pp. 169–93. Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
Shaoyang, Lin 林少陽 (2014). “Shō Heirin to shinmatsu ni okeru ‘nan’ gensetsu” 章炳麟と清末における『南』言説” (“Zhang Binglin and the Discourse on ‘South’ in Late Qing China”). Kanan kenkyū 華南研究 1, pp. 47–72.Google Scholar
Lin, Shiming 林世明 (1980). Yihetuan shibian qijian dongnan hubao yundong zhi yanjiu 義和團世變期間東南互保運動之研究 (“A Study of the Southeast Autonomous Plan in the Boxer Rebellion”). Taiping: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Liu, Shipei 劉師培 (1997). “Nanbei xuepai butong lun” 南北學派不同論 (“An Argument on the Academic Difference between North and South”). In Liu Shenshu yishu 劉申叔遺書 (“Collected Works of Liu Shipei”) vol. 1, pp. 548–62. Nanjing: Jiangsu Guji Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Liu, Yazi 柳亞子 (1983). Nanshe jilüe 南社紀略 (“A Record of the Southern Society”). Shanghai: Shanghai Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Liu, Yiqing 劉義慶 (1996). Shishuo xinyu 世說新語 (“A New Account of the Tales of the World”). Guilin: Guangxi Minzu Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Lü, Shunchang 吕顺长 (2010). “Nihonjin kara mita Chūgokujin no kokuminsei – Meiji kōhanki no Chūgoku ryokōki o chūshin ni” 日本人から見た中国人の国民性—明治後半期の中国旅行記を中心に (“National Character of the Chinese from a Japanese Perspective – a Case Study of the Travel Logs in the Late Meiji Era”). Shitennōji Daigaku kiyō 四天王寺大学紀要 49, pp. 67–84.Google Scholar
“Lun lieguo zujiedi zhanshi zhi guanxi ji yangzijiang bugerang xieyue zhi piping” (1903). 論列國租借地戰時之關係及揚子江不割讓協約之批評 (“On Concessions during the Wartime and the Criticism of Non-Concession Treaty Related to the Yangtze River”). Jiangsu 江蘇 9–10, pp. 11–28.Google Scholar
Masubuchi, Tatsuo 増淵 達夫 (1983). Rekishika no dōjidaishiteki kōsatsu ni tsuite 歴史家の同時代史的考察について (“On the Contemporary Views of Historians”). Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.Google Scholar
Murata, Yūjiro 村田 雄二郎 (2015). “Gangcang Tianxin de Zhongguo nanbei yitong lun” 岡倉天心的中國南北異同論 (“Okakura Tenshin's Theory of the Differences and Similarities between Northern China and Southern China”). Huadong Shifan Daxue xuebao (zhexue shehui kexue ban) 華東師範大學學報 (哲學社會科學版), 47:4, pp. 11–18.Google Scholar
Naitō, Konan 内藤 湖南 (1970a). “Chisei okusetsu” 地勢臆説 (“A Hypothesis of Earthly Ether”), appendix of Kinsei bungaku shiron 近世文学史論 (“A Treatise on the Modern Literary History”). In Naitō Konan zenshū dai 1-kan 内藤湖南全集第1巻 (“Collected Works of Naitō Konan vol. 1”), eds. Kiichirō, Kanda 神田 喜一郎 and Kenkichi, Naitō 内藤 乾吉, pp. 117–25. Tokyo: Chikuma Shobō.Google Scholar
Naitō, Konan 内藤 湖南 (1970b). “Nihon no tenshoku to gakusha” 日本の天職と学者 (“The Duty of Japan and Scholars”). In Naitō Konan zenshū dai 1-kan 内藤湖南全集第1巻 (“Collected Works of Naitō Konan vol. 1”), eds. Kiichirō, Kanda 神田 喜一郎 and Kenkichi, Naitō 内藤 乾吉, pp. 126–33. Tokyo: Chikuma Shobō.Google Scholar
Okakura, Tenshin 岡倉 天心 (1993a). “Shina nanboku no kubetsu” 支那南北の区別 (“The Difference between North and South in China”). In Okakura Tenshin zenshū dai 3-kan 岡倉天心全集第3巻 (Collected Works of Okakura Tenshin vol. 3), ed. Kenjirō, Kumamoto 隈本 謙次郎, pp. 97–101. Tokyo: Heibonsha.Google Scholar
Okakura, Tenshin 岡倉 天心 (1993b). “Shina bijutsu ni tsuite” 支那美術ニ就テ (“On Chinese Art”). In Okakura Tenshin zenshū dai 5-kan 岡倉天心全集第5巻 (“Collected Works of Okakura Tenshin vol. 5”), ed. Kenjirō, Kumamoto 隈本 謙次郎, pp. 146–52. Tokyo: Heibonsha.Google Scholar
Qiao, Yigang 喬以鋼 and Lin, Chen 林晨 (2006). “Qingmo xiaoshuo zhong de nanbei zhibian he nanbei zhi lü – yi dui ‘gengzi zhi luan’ de xuxie wei zhongxin” 清末小說中的南北之辯和南北之旅 – 以對‘庚子之亂‘的敘寫為中心 (“The Contention and Journey between the North and the South in the Novels of the Late Qing Dynasty – Focus on the Narration about the Chaos of Gengzi”). Qinghua Daxue xuebao (zhexue shehui kexue ban) 清華大學學報 21:2, pp. 81–88.Google Scholar
Qingguo Liuxuesheng Huiguan 清國留學生會館 (1903). “Fenxiao fensheng renshu tongji biao” 分校分省人數統計表 (“A Survey of Chinese Students Based on Schools and Provinces”). In Qingguo liuxuesheng huiguan di'erci baogao 清國留學生會館第二次報告 (“The Second Report by the Association of Chinese Students in Japan”). Tokyo: Qingguo Liuxuesehng Huiguan.Google Scholar
Ruan, Yuan 阮元 (1993). “Nanbei shupai lun” 南北書派論 (“The Discourse on the Calligraphy Schools in the South and the North”). In Yanjingshi ji di 3-juan 研經室集第3卷 (“A Collection of Works from the Chamber of Studying the Classics vol. 3”), pp. 553–57. Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
Shiga, Shigetaka 志賀 重昂 (1897). Chirigaku; Tokyo Senmon Gakkō bungakuka daigokai daiichibu kōgiroku 地理学: 東京專門學校文學科第五回第一部講義録 (“Geography: Record of Lectures for Department of Literature, Tokyo Senmon Gakkō”). Tokyo: Tokyo Senmon Gakkō.Google Scholar
Sun, Jiang 孫江 (2014). Chūgoku no “kindai” o tou – rekishi, kioku, aidentiti 中国の『近代』を問う——歴史・記憶・アイデンティティ(“Exploring China's ‘Modernity’ – History, Memory and Identity”). Tokyo: Kyūko Shoin.Google Scholar
Sun, Zhimei 孫之梅 (2000). “Nanshe ji Nanshe yanjiu” 南社及南社研究 (“Nanshe and the Study of Nanshe”). Shandong Daxue xuebao (zhexue shehui kexue ban) 山東大學學報 (哲學社會科學版) 6, pp. 10–15.Google Scholar
Sun, Zhimei 孙之梅 (2003). Nanshe yanjiu 南社研究 (“A Study of the Southern Society”). Beijing: Renmin Wenxue Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Tanaka, Stefan (1996). Japan's Orient: Rendering Pasts in History. Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Wakeman, Frederic Jr. (1966). Social Disorder in South China, 1839–1861. Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Wang, Shizhen 王世貞 (1959). “Qu zao” 曲藻 (“Splendid Songs”). In Zhongguo gudian xiqu lunzhu jicheng 中國古典戲曲論著集成 (“A Collection of Chinese Texts on the Classical Dramas”), ed. Zhongguo Xiqu Yanjiuyuan 中國戲曲研究院, pp. 17–42. Beijing: Zhongguo Xiju Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Wengui, 文詭 (1903). “Fei shengjie” 非省界 (“Refuting Provincial Distinction”). Zhejiang chao 浙江潮 3, pp. 13–32.Google Scholar
Wu, Jian 吳鍵 (2015). “‘Wenzhi’ yu ‘nanbei’: Liu Shipei Nanbei wenxue butong lun tanxi” “文質”與“南北”：劉師培《南北文學不同論》探析 (“‘Wenzhi’ yu ‘nanbei’: an Exploration of a Treatise on the Literary Differences between Southern China and Northern China), Wenyi lilun yanjiu 文藝理論研究 35:6, pp. 102–9.Google Scholar
V.G.T. Sheng, V.G.T. 生 (1903). “Yingde yu yangzijiang zhi jingzheng” 英德于扬子江之竞争 (“The Competition between UK and Germany over the Yangtze River”). Jiangsu 江苏 (Jiangsu) 8, pp. 81–87.Google Scholar
Xu, Kangzong 許亢宗 (2004). “Xu Kangzong xingchenglu shuzheng gao” 許亢宗行程錄疏證稿 (“Xu Kangzong's Travel Logs”). In Wudai Song Jin Yuan ren bianjiang xingji shisan zhong shuzhenggao 五代宋金元人邊疆行記十三種疏證稿 (“Thirteen records of the Journeys to Frontiers by People in the Five Dynasties, Song, Jin and Yuan Dynasties”), ed. Jingyan, Jia. 賈敬顏, pp. 215–55. Shanghai: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
Yan, Zhitui 顏之推 (2014). Yanshi jiaxun 顏氏家訓 (“Family Instructions of Master Yan”). Beijing: Zhongguo Huaqiao Chubanshe.Google Scholar
Yang, Nianquan 楊念群 (2010). Hechu shi Jiangnan: qingchao zhengtongguan de queli he shilin jingshen de bianyi 何處是江南：清朝正統觀的確立和士林精神的變異(“Where Is Jiangnan? The Establishment of the Orthodoxy and the Change in the Literati's Ideas in the Qing Dynasty”). Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Yan, Ying 晏婴 (1985). Yanzi chunqiu 晏子春秋 (“Annals of Master Yan”). Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
“Yangzijiang, ” 揚子江 (“The Yangtze River”) (1903). Hubei xueshengjie 湖北學生界 5, pp. 66–72.Google Scholar
“Yu, Gong” 禹貢 (2012). In Shang shu 尚書 (“Book of Documents”), trans. Ping, Mu 慕平, pp. 51–77. Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
Zhang, Chuntian 張春田 (2015). Geming yu shuqing: Nanshe de wenhua zhengzhi yu Zhongguo xiandaixing (1903–1923) 革命與抒情：南社的文化政治與中國現代性 (1903–1923) (“Revolution and the Lyrical: the Politics of Culture in the Southern Society and Chinese Modernity [1903–1923]”). Shanghai: Shanghai Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar