Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T16:00:21.423Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Grave and Sudden Provocation: Revisiting R. v. Ahluwalia – Implementing a New Exception Under Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code and the Defence of the Battered Woman Syndrome

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 August 2022

Dhruv Mehta*
Affiliation:
Jindal Global Law School, Sonipat, India
*
*Corresponding Author: Dhruv Mehta, Jindal Global Law School, O.P. Jindal Global University, Sonipat Narela Road, Sonipat, Haryana 131001, India. E-mail: [email protected]

Abstract

Lenore Walker introduced the concept of battered woman syndrome in the 1970s, which helps explain the psychological state of battered women and why such women face a slow-burn reaction. This article helps explain why battered woman syndrome must be included under the Indian Penal Code, 1860. It is further proposed that the present exception of a grave and sudden provocation be retained, and a new exception of sustained provocation be created under the Indian Penal Code. The inclusion of sustained provocation would help the cause of battered women. The article concludes with a proposal for creating a new exception under §300 of the Indian Penal Code.

Abstracto

Abstracto

Lenore Walker introdujo el concepto del síndrome de la mujer maltratada en la década de 1970, que ayuda a explicar el estado psicológico de las mujeres maltratadas y por qué enfrentan una reacción de combustión lenta. Este artículo ayuda a explicar por qué el síndrome de la mujer maltratada debe incluirse en el Código Penal de la India de 1860. Se propone además que se mantenga la actual excepción de una provocación grave y repentina, y se cree una nueva excepción de provocación sostenida en el Código Penal de la India. La inclusión de la provocación sostenida ayudaría a la causa de las mujeres maltratadas. El artículo concluye con una propuesta para crear una nueva excepción bajo §300 del Código Penal de la India.

Abstrait

Abstrait

Lenore Walker a introduit le concept de syndrome de la femme battue dans les années 1970, ce qui aide à expliquer l’état psychologique des femmes battues et pourquoi ces femmes font face à une réaction de brûlure lente. Cet article aide à expliquer pourquoi le syndrome de la femme battue doit être inclus dans le Code pénal indien de 1860. Il est en outre proposé que l’exception actuelle de provocation grave et soudaine soit conservée et qu’une nouvelle exception de provocation soutenue soit créée dans le Code pénal indien. L’inclusion de la provocation soutenue aiderait la cause des femmes battues. L’article se termine par une proposition de création d’une nouvelle exception en vertu de l’article 300 du Code pénal indien.

抽象的

抽象的

Lenore Walker 在 1970 年代引入了受虐女性综合症 的概念,这有助于解释受虐女性的心理状态以及为什么这些女性会面临缓慢的烧伤反应。 本文有助于解释为什么受虐妇女综合症必须纳入 1860 年印度刑法典。进一步建议保留目前的严重和突然挑衅的例外情况,并根据印度刑法典创建持续挑衅的新例外情况. 包括持续挑衅将有助于受虐妇女的事业。 文章最后提出了一项根据印度刑法典第 300 条创建新例外的提议。

الملخص

الملخص

قدمت لينور ووكر مفهوم متلازمة المرأة المعنفة في السبعينيات ، مما يساعد في تفسير الحالة النفسية للنساء المعنفات ولماذا تواجه هؤلاء النساء رد فعل بطيء للحرق. تساعد هذه المقالة في توضيح سبب وجوب إدراج متلازمة المرأة المعنفة في قانون العقوبات الهندي لعام 1860. ومن المقترح أيضًا الإبقاء على الاستثناء الحالي للاستفزاز الخطير والمفاجئ ، وإنشاء استثناء جديد للاستفزاز المستمر بموجب قانون العقوبات الهندي. إن إدراج الاستفزاز المستمر من شأنه أن يساعد قضية النساء المعنفات. تختتم المقالة باقتراح لإنشاء استثناء جديد بموجب المادة 300 من قانون العقوبات الهندي.

Type
Article
Copyright
© International Society of Criminology, 2022

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Deb, Aishwarya. 2018. “Battered Woman Syndrome: Prospect of Situating it Within Criminal Law in India.” SSRN. Retrieved 9 August 2022 (https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3458792).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jaising, Indira. 2002. “Domestic Violence and the Law.” Journal of the National Human Rights Commission 1:72–8. Retrieved 9 August 2022 (https://nhrc.nic.in/sites/default/files/I-%20BOOK.pdf).Google Scholar
Kumari, Ved. 1999. “Gender Analysis of the Indian Penal Code.” Pp. 139–60 in Engendering Law: Essays in Honour of Lotika Sakar, edited by Dhanda, Amita and Parashar, Archana. Lucknow: Eastern Book Company. Retrieved 9 August 2022 (http://www.womenstudies.in/elib/crime_ag_women/ca_gender_analysis.pdf).Google Scholar
Law Commission of the United Kingdom. 2005. “A New Homicide Act for England and Wales?, Report No. 177.” Retrieved 9 August 2022 (https://www.lawcom.gov.uk/app/uploads/2015/03/cp177_Murder_Manslaughter_and_Infanticide_consultation_overview_.pdf).Google Scholar
Nigam, Shalu. 2016. “Battered Women Syndrome: Applying this Legal Doctrine in the Indian Context.” SSRN. Retrieved 9 August 2022 (https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2819322).Google Scholar
O’Donovan, Katherine. 1991. “Defences for Battered Women Who Kill.” Journal of Law and Society 18(2):219–40.Google Scholar
Schneider, Elizabeth M. 1980. “Equal Rights to Trial for Battered Women: Sex Bias in the Law of Self Defense.” Harvard Civil Rights–Civil Liberties Law Review 15(3):623–48.Google Scholar
Smith, Joan. 1993. “Doubting Thomas.” Pp. 56 in Misogynies, 7th ed., edited by Smith, Joan. London: Faber and Faber.Google Scholar
Vibhute, K. I. 2012. PSA Pillai’s Criminal Law, 11th ed. New York: LexisNexis.Google Scholar
Walker, Lenore E.A. 2016. The Battered Woman Syndrome, 4th ed. New York: Springer Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Williamson, Adrian. 2020. “Gender and the Law of Provocation in the Long Twentieth Century.” Women’s History Review 29(3), 495519.Google Scholar
Young, Alison. 1993. “Conjugal Homicide and Legal Violence: A Comparative Analysis.” Osgoode Hall Law Journal 31(4):761808.Google Scholar