Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T07:20:49.386Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Race, Meritocracy, and the American Academy during the Immediate Post—World War II Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

James D. Anderson
James D. Anderson*
Affiliation:
Department of Educational Policy Studies, College of Education, at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This address concerns the initial integration of African American scholars into the American academy. It traces an interesting and unusual national campaign that first opened the doors of northern white universities to African American scholars. The primary focus is on what this campaign reveals about the interrelationship of race and meritocracy in mainstream American higher education during the immediate post-World War II period. It is also a story about a select pool of highly qualified African American scholars and their opportunities for employment at northern white universities. Finally, this is also a history of a particular process of institutional racism. One underlying purpose is to explore the usefulness of the social science concept of institutional racism for framing and explaining the formation and development of specific types of racial exclusion or discrimination in educational systems that operate with explicitly race-neutral or “color-blind” laws, procedures, and policies.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 33 , Issue 2 , Summer 1993 , pp. 151 - 175
Copyright
Copyright © 1993 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Feagin, Joe R. and Booher Feagin, Clairece, Discrimination American Style: Institutional Racism and Sexism (Malabar, Fla., 1978); Nathan Glazer, Affirmative Discrimination: Ethnic Inequality and Public Policy (New York, 1975), 69.Google Scholar

2 Glazer, Affirmative Discrimination, 69.Google Scholar

3 Guzman, Jessie P. “Persons Appointed to Positions in White Institutions of Higher Learning,“ Negro Year Book, ed. Guzman, (Tuskegee, Ala., 1947), 16–18; University of Chicago, Annual Register: 1917 (Chicago, 1917), 59; NAACP, “Negro Higher Education in 1921–22,” Crisis 24 (June 1922): 108.Google Scholar

4 Wale, Fred G. to Leon W. Scott, 14 Feb. 1946, and Wale to James H. M. Henderson, 24 Jan. 1946, folder 2, box 308, Julius Rosenwald Fund Papers, Special Collections, Fisk University Archives, Nashville, Tenn. (hereafter cited as JRF Papers).Google Scholar

5 Wale to Josephine Glasgow, 21 Nov. 1945, folder 2, box 308, JRF Papers; Fred G. Wale, “Chosen for Ability,” Atlantic Monthly 180 (July 1947): 81–84.Google Scholar

6 Wale, “Chosen for Ability,“ 81–84.Google Scholar

7 Ibid., 83; Wale to Ralph Cooper Hutchison, 17 Sep. 1945, and Wale to Nicholas Murray Butler, 11 June 1945, folder 2, box 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

8 Olson, Keith W. The G.I. Bill, the Veterans, and the Colleges (Lexington, Ky., 1974), 44; John Dale Russell, ed., Problems of Faculty Personnel, in Proceedings of the Institute for Administrative Officers of Higher Institutions (Chicago, 1946), 18: 6.Google Scholar

9 Harry Washington Greene, Holders of Doctorates among American Negroes: An Educational and Social Study of Negroes Who Have Earned Doctoral Degrees in Course, 1876–1943 (Boston, 1946).Google Scholar

10 Wale, “Chosen for Ability,“ 82; Wale to Butler, 11 June 1945, Wale to Hutchison, 17 Sep. 1945, Katherine McBride to Wale, 2 Jan. 1947, and R. D. Hetzel to Wale, 3 July 1945, folders 2, 4, boxes 308, 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

11 Deutsch, Monroe E. to Wale, 19 June 1945, and Edward J. Scanlon to Wale, 27 Sep. 1945, folders 2, 4, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

12 Scanlon to Wale, 27 Sep. 1945, L. M. Gould to Wale, 25 Dec. 1946, A. Chesley York to Wale, 20 June 1945, Hetzel to Wale, 3 July 1945, Alan Valentine to Wale, 21 June 1945, and George D. Stoddard to Wale, 20 Jan. 1947, folders 2, 8, 13, 15, 20, boxes 308, 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

13 For the selected list of African American scholars, see list in box 308 or 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

14 Thomas Sowell contends that historically most black academics preferred to remain in black colleges because of choice and because their career characteristics did not match the research publication requirements of major research universities. These factors, however valid, would not account for the African American scholars on Wale's list. Thomas Sowell, Education: Assumptions versus History (Stanford, Calif., 1986), 77–78.Google Scholar

15 Eurich, Alvin C. to Wale, 19 June 1945, Deutsch to Wale, 19 June 1945, Robert G. Sproul to Wale, 20 June 1945, and C. A. Dykstra to Wale, 20 June 1945, folder 4, box 308, JRF Papers; Los Angeles Times, 24 Aug. 1946.Google Scholar

16 Scanlon to Wale, 27 Sep. 1945, Gould to Wale, 25 Dec. 1946, York to Wale, 20 June 1945, Hetzel to Wale, 3 July 1945, and Valentine to Wale, 21 June 1945, folders 2, 13, 15, 20, boxes 308, 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

17 Wrightman, Clair S. to Wale, 24 Dec. 1946, and Wrightman to Wale, 21 June 1945, folder 19, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

18 Gildersleeve, Virginia E. to Wale, 28 June 1945, “Negroes on Northern College Faculties,” 16 Oct. 1946, record of interviews with President Horvde of the New School for Social Research, Professor Counts of Teachers College, and Dean Gildersleeve, folders 2, 20, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

19 West, John C. to Wale, 28 June 1945, A. L. Strand to Wale, 25 June 1945, Harvey L. Turner to Wale, 23 June 1945, Turner to Wale, 18 Sep. 1945, Turner to Wale, 28 Dec. 1946, Russell D. Cole to Wale, 14 June 1945, William A. Shimer to Wale, 5 Oct. 1945, and Benjamin F. Schwartz to Wale, 16 June 1946, folders 1, 10, 14, 17, 22, 23, boxes 308, 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

20 Espy, Herbert G. to Wale, 31 Dec. 1946, Wale to Espy, 17 Jan. 1947, and Espy to Wale, 24 Jan. 1947, folder 20, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

21 Gates, Thomas S. to Wale, 21 June 1945, and Clarence E. Josephson to Wale, 23 June 1945, folders 2, 23, boxes 308, 309, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

22 Henderson, A. D. to Wale, 25 June 1945, Henderson to Wale, 10 Dec. 1945, and James P. Baxter to Wale, 6 Feb. 1947, folders 13, 23, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

23 Very Rev. Msgr. Carl J. Ryan to Wale, 21 June 1945, and John C. Baker to Wale, 9 July 1945, folders 9, 23, boxes 294, 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

24 Cole, Russell D. to Wale, 14 June 1945, Wale to Cole, 17 Sep. 1945, Wale to Cole, 20 Sep. 1945, Turner to Wale, 23 June 1945, Turner to Wale, 18 Sep. 1945, and Turner to Wale, 28 Dec. 1946, folders 23, 14, boxes 294, 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

25 Giersbach, W. C. to Wale, 5 July 1945, folder 1, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar

26 Mekeel, Arthur J. to Wale, 14 June 1945, Cecil E. Henshaw to Wale, 4 Oct. 1945, Mearl P. Culver to Wale, 20 Dec. 1946, and Arthur W. Calhoun to Wale, 11 July 1947, folders 10, 11, box 308, JRF Papers.Google Scholar