Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 January 2017
The National Defense Education Act (NDEA) of 1958 was the first federal investment in low-interest student loans and became a precedent for expansion of student loans in the Higher Education Act of 1965. In its controversial loyalty provisions, the NDEA required loan recipients to affirm loyalty to the U.S. government. Between 1958 and 1962, thirty-two colleges and universities refused to participate or withdrew from the NDEA loan program, arguing that the loyalty provisions unfairly targeted students and violated principles of free inquiry. This essay argues that debate over the loyalty provisions fractured a partnership between progressives who favored general aid to education and conservatives who supported short-term investment for defense purposes. Although debates over the NDEA loyalty requirements seem specific to the Cold War, a close examination of the arguments illuminates their alignment with long-standing ideological conflicts over legitimacy of federal aid to higher education.
1 Suspitsyna, Tatiana, “Higher Education for Economic Advancement and Engaged Citizenship: An Analysis of the U.S. Department of Education Discourse,” Journal of Higher Education 83, no. 1 (2012), 49–72; and Shear, Michael D., “Colleges Rattled as Obama Seeks Rating System,” New York Times, 26 May 2014, A1.Google Scholar
2 Urban, Wayne J., More than Science and Sputnik: The National Defense Education Act of 1958 (Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 2010), 1–9.Google Scholar
3 Ibid., 184.Google Scholar
4 Botti, John McDonough, “The NDEA, Loyalty, and Community: Resistance at Two Liberal Arts Colleges” (PhD dissertation, University of Maryland, 2014); and Clowse, Barbara Barksdale, Brainpower for the Cold War: The Sputnik Crisis and National Defense Education Act of 1958 (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1981).Google Scholar
5 Loss, Christopher P., Between Citizens and the State: The Politics of American Higher Education in the 20th Century, Politics and Society in Twentieth-Century America (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012), 1–16, 156–61; and Schwegler, John Stephan, “Academic Freedom and the Disclaimer Affidavit of the National Defense Education Act: The Response of Higher Education” (EdD dissertation, Teachers College Columbia University, 1982), 128–38.Google Scholar
6 Higher Education for American Democracy: A Report of the President's Commission on Higher Education (Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office, 1948); Loss, Between Citizens and the State, 118; and Hutcheson, Philo A., “The 1947 President's Commission on Higher Education and the National Rhetoric on Higher Education Policy,” History of Higher Education Annual 22, no. 1 (2002), 91–102.Google Scholar
7 Simpson, Alfred D., “Financing Higher Education,” Journal of Higher Education 19, no. 4 (April 1948), 202.Google Scholar
8 Freeland, Richard M., Academia's Golden Age: Universities in Massachusetts, 1945–1970 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), 84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
9 Hutcheson, “The 1947 President's Commission,” 97.Google Scholar
10 Ibid.; and Reuben, Julie A and Perkins, Linda, “Introduction: Commemorating the Sixtieth Anniversary of the President's Commission Report, ‘Higher Education for Democracy,”’ History of Education Quarterly 47, no. 3 (August 2007), 265–76.Google Scholar
11 Urban, More than Science and Sputnik, 48–65.Google Scholar
12 Ibid.Google Scholar
13 Ibid.Google Scholar
14 Ibid., 65.Google Scholar
15 Clowse, Brainpower for the Cold War, 125–27.Google Scholar
16 85 Cong. Rec. 19,086 (1958).Google Scholar
17 Clowse, Brainpower for the Cold War, 137.Google Scholar
18 85 Cong. Rec. 19,596 (1958).Google Scholar
19 Clowse, Brainpower for the Cold War, 138.Google Scholar
20 Divine, Robert A., The Sputnik Challenge (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993), 165.Google Scholar
21 Henry, David D., “The Role of the Federal Government in Higher Education,” Educational Record 40, no. 3 (July 1959), 197.Google Scholar
22 U.S. Senate Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, The National Defense Education Act of 1958: A Summary and Analysis of the Act (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1958), 1–2; Urban, More than Science and Sputnik, 2–4.Google Scholar
23 National Defense Education Act of 1958: Hearing before Subcommittees of the Committee on Education and Labor of the House of Representatives, Eighty-sixth Congress, First Session. (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1959), 3.Google Scholar
24 U.S. Senate Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, The National Defense Education Act, Sec. 202.Google Scholar
25 Clowse, Brainpower for the Cold War, 131–32; Urban, More than Science and Sputnik, 184–85.Google Scholar
26 Kirshen, H. B., “The Internal Security Act of 1950,” Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors 37, no. 2 (July 1951), 260–75.Google Scholar
27 U.S. Senate Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, The National Defense Education Act, Sec. 1001(f), 45.Google Scholar
28 Schwegler, “Academic Freedom” 99–100.Google Scholar
29 85 Cong. Rec., 2nd Sess., 17,320 (1958).Google Scholar
30 Schwegler, “Academic Freedom”; and “Colleges Oppose U.S. Non-Red Oath: 6 Schools Denounce Pledge as Condition for Student Loan Under’ 58 Act,” New York Times, 22 January 1959, 12.Google Scholar
31 “College to Return Aid: Bennington Says It Opposes Oaths Required by U.S.,” New York Times, 7 May 1959, 66; “A College Rejects Student-Loan Aid,” New York Times, 10 October 1959, 12; and “Oberlin Fights Oath: Quits Student Loan Plan and Returns $68,146 to U.S.,” New York Times 17 November 1959, 28.Google Scholar
32 “Government Security Checks: Statement of the Haverford College Faculty,” AAUP Bulletin 44, no. 2 (June 1958), 401–2.Google Scholar
33 Glass, Bentley and Fidler, William P., “Disclaimer Affidavit Requirement: Association Officers Express Disapproval of Title X, Section 1001 (F) (1) of the National Defense Education Act of 1958,” AAUP Bulletin 44, no. 4 (December 1958), 771.Google Scholar
34 Griswold, A. Whitney, “Loyalty: An Issue of Academic Freedom,” New York Times Magazine, 20 December 1959, SM42.Google Scholar
35 Ibid., 47.Google Scholar
36 Loss, Between Citizens and the State, 159; Urban, More than Science and Sputnik, 183–84.Google Scholar
37 86 Cong. Rec., 1st Sess. 14,096, (1959).Google Scholar
38 Eckelberry, R. H., “Editorial: The Disclaimer Affidavit,” Journal of Higher Education 31, no. 3 (March 1960), 159–60.Google Scholar
39 86 Cong. Rec., 1st Sess., 14,096 (1959).Google Scholar
40 Andrew, John A., The Other Side of the Sixties: Young Americans for Freedom and the Rise of Conservative Politics (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1997), 53–74.Google Scholar
41 “Second Session at Half Way Point,” Congressional Digest 39, no. 4 (April 1960), 126.Google Scholar
42 Ibid., 108.Google Scholar
43 Ibid., 126.Google Scholar
44 86 Cong. Rec., 1st Sess., 14,075 (1959).Google Scholar
45 Costanzo, Joseph F., “Loyalty Oath Affidavit,” University of Detroit Law Journal 37, no. 5 (June 1960), 721.Google Scholar
46 “Disclaimer Affidavit: Non-Participating and Disapproving Colleges and Universities,” AAUP Bulletin 48, no. 4 (December 1962), 331.Google Scholar
47 Chayes, Abram J., “Abram J. Chayes Oral History Interview—JFK #1,” in John F. Kennedy Oral History Collection (John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, 1964), 53–58, http://www.jfklibrary.org/Asset-Viewer/Archives/JFKOH-ABJC-01.aspx Google Scholar
48 Burns, James MacGregor, John Kennedy: A Political Profile (New York: Harcourt, Brace and World, 1961), 268.Google Scholar
49 Kennedy, John Fitzgerald, “Loyalty Oath: An Obstacle to Better Education,” AAUP Bulletin 45, no. 1 (March 1959), 25.Google Scholar
50 Ibid.Google Scholar
51 “Education: Loyalty Oath and Disclaimer Affidavit,” Papers of John F. Kennedy. Pre-Presidential Papers. Presidential Campaign Files, 1960 (John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Undated), 2.Google Scholar
52 Kennedy, “Loyalty Oath,” 26.Google Scholar
53 Joughin, Louis, “Disclaimer Affidavit,” AAUP Bulletin 45, no. 3 (September 1959), 339–41.Google Scholar
54 Griswold, “Loyalty,” 18.Google Scholar
55 Kenworthy, E. W., “Senate Votes End of Student Oath: Acts to Bar Non-communist Pledge Opposed by Many Leading Universities,” New York Times, 16 June 1960, 1; and Schwegler, “Academic Freedom,” 116–17.Google Scholar
56 “Second Session at Half Way Point,” 113.Google Scholar
57 Ibid., 119.Google Scholar
58 86 Cong. Rec., 1st Sess., 14,074 (1959).Google Scholar
59 Ibid., 14,068.Google Scholar
60 Ibid., 14,071.Google Scholar
61 86 Cong. Rec., 2nd Sess., 12,663 (1960).Google Scholar
62 Ibid., 12,666–67.Google Scholar
63 Ibid., 12,667.Google Scholar
64 86 Cong. Rec. 1st Sess, 14,098 (1959)Google Scholar
65 86 Cong. Rec., 2nd Sess., 12,664 (1960).Google Scholar
66 “Second Session at Half Way Point,” 118.Google Scholar
67 86 Cong. Rec., 2nd Sess., 12666 (1960).Google Scholar
68 Ibid., 12667.Google Scholar
69 Ibid.Google Scholar
70 Ibid.Google Scholar
71 Ibid.Google Scholar
72 Ibid.Google Scholar
73 Schweder, “Academic Freedom,” 123; Orentlicher, Herman I., “Disclaimer Affidavit: A Valediction,” AAUP Bulletin 48, no. 4 (Dec. 1962): 324–30; and “Exit: College Affidavit,” New York Times, 18 October 1962, 38.Google Scholar
74 Orentlicher, “Disclaimer Affidavit,” 327.Google Scholar
75 Ibid.Google Scholar
76 “Letters to the Times,” New York Times, 30 October 1962, 34.Google Scholar
77 Ibid.Google Scholar
78 Graham, Hugh Davis, The Uncertain Triumph: Federal Education Policy in the Kennedy and Johnson Years (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1984), 28–29.Google Scholar
79 Ibid., 28–32.Google Scholar
80 Ibid., 35.Google Scholar
81 Ibid., 50–52; and The Higher Education Facilities Act of 1963: H.R. 6143, Introduced by Representative Edith Green (Oregon), Research American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy ed. (Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, 1963), 1–16.Google Scholar
82 Green, Edith, Education and the Public Good: The Federal Role in Education, The Burton Lecture (Cambridge, MA: Distributed for the Graduate School of Education of Harvard University by Harvard University Press, 1964), 13.Google Scholar
83 Graham, The Uncertain Triumph, 53–83.Google Scholar
84 Hunter, Majorie, “College Aid Bill Passed by the House, 367 to 22,” New York Times, 27 August 1965, 1.Google Scholar
85 Morris, John D., “Senate Votes, 79–3, for College Aid Bill: Senate Approves College Aid Bill,” New York Times 3 September 1965, 1.Google Scholar
86 “Lyndon B. Johnson, Remarks at Southwest Texas State College Upon Signing the Higher Education Act of 1965,” 8 November 1965, The American Presidency Project, http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=27356&st=johnson&st1=higher+education.Google Scholar