Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T03:55:23.403Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Advent of the Second (Oba) Dynasty: Another Assessment of a Benin History Key Point*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 May 2014

Dmitri M. Bondarenko
Dmitri M. Bondarenko*
Affiliation:
Russian Academy of Sciences
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

There is no other theme in precolonial Benin Kingdom studies around which so many lances have been broken as that of consolidation of the present-day Second (Oba) dynasty and the person of its founder Oranmiyan (Oranyan in Yoruba). The main reason for this is the existence of considerable disagreements between numerous Bini and Yoruba versions of the oral historical tradition. Besides this, the story of Oranmiyan is one of the Bini and Yoruba oral history pages most tightly connected with mythology. This fact becomes especially important if one takes into account that the oral tradition is no doubt the main (though not the only) source on the consolidation of the Oba Dynasty in Benin. The key point on which different Bini and Yoruba traditions openly contradict each other, and which scholars debate, is the origin of the Dynasty. Who initiated its founding: Bini or Yoruba? Was it a request or a conquest? Are the characters of the oral tradition relations historical figures? Finally, what were historical, sociocultural, and political circumstances of the Oba accession?

If one disengages from details, three groups of traditional versions that describe the origin and life of Oranmiyan (including its period connected with Benin) can be distinguished. These groups may be designated as the Yoruba one, the Benin “official” (i.e., traditionally recognized by Oba themselves and most widely spread among common Bini) and Benin “apocryphal” traditions. In the meantime it should be borne in mind that Bini and Yoruba native gatherers and publishers of the oral historical tradition could influence each other. For example, the Yoruba Johnson could influence the Bini Egharevba, while the latter in his turn could influence another Yoruba, Fabunmi, and so on.

Type
Research Article
Information
History in Africa , Volume 30 , 2003 , pp. 63 - 85
Copyright
Copyright © African Studies Association 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

This study was supported by Russian Foundation for Humanitarian Studies (project # 01-03-00332a).

References

Adediran, ‘B.Pleasant Imperialism: Conjectures on Benin Hegemony in Eastern Yorubaland, African Notes 15(1991), 83–95.Google Scholar
Afigbo, A.E.Prolegomena to the Study of the Culture History of the Igbo-Speaking Peoples of Nigeria. In Swartz, B.K. Jr. and Dumett, R.E., eds., West African Culture Dynamics: Archaeological and Historical Perspectives. The Hague, 1980, 305–27.Google Scholar
Afolayan, S.F.Pre-Colonial Concept of History in Nigeria. Africana Marburgensia. Sonderkeft 11(1986), 31–47.Google Scholar
Aisien, E.Benin City: The Edo State Capital. Benin City, 1995.Google Scholar
Ajisafe, A. K.Laws and Customs of the Benin People. Lagos, 1945.Google Scholar
Akinjogbin, I.A.Ife: The Home of a New University, Nigeria Magazine 92(1967), 40–46.Google Scholar
Akinola, G.A.The Origin of the Eweka Dynasty of Benin: A Study of the Use and Abuse of Oral Traditions, Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 8(1976), 21–36.Google Scholar
Akpata, A.Benin: Notes on Altars and Bronze Heads, Ethnologia Cranmorensis 1(1937), 5–10.Google Scholar
Alderson, A.D.The Structure of the Ottoman Dynasty. Oxford, 1956.Google Scholar
Babayemi, S.O.The Oyo, Ife, Benin Relationship Reconsidered, African Notes 8(1979), 15–26.Google Scholar
Bascom, W.The Early Historical Evidence of Yoruba Urbanisin. In Damachi, U.G. and Seibel, H.D., eds. Social Change and Economic Development in Nigeria. New York, 1971, 11–39.Google Scholar
Belkov, P.L.“Epos migratsij” v sisteme atributov traditsionnoj vlasti. In Popov, V.A., ed. Simvoly i atributy vlasti: genezis, semantika, funktsii. St. Petersburg, 1996, 63–71.Google Scholar
Bezrogov, V.G.Mifologicheskie predstavlenija o korole na nachal' nykh etapakh stanovlenija korolevskoj vlasti v Irlandii in Koshman, L.V., ed. Kul'tura srednikh vekov i novogo vremeni. Moscow, 1987, 42–50.Google Scholar
Bezrogov, V.G.Rannesrednevekovye genealogii znatnykh rodov v sis-teme etnieheskogo samosoznanija, in Svanidze, A.A., ed. Elita i etnos srednevekovja. Moscow, 1995, 28–38.Google Scholar
Biobaku, S.O.An Historical Sketch of the Peoples of Western Nigeria, Odù 6(1958), 60–68.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M.Benin nakanune pervykh kontaktov s evrope-jtsami: chelovek, obshchestvo, vlast'. Moscow, 1995.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M.Doimperskij Benin: formirovanie i evoljutsija sistemy sotsial'no-politicheskikh institutov. Moscow, 2001.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M. and Korotayev, A.V.. Family Size and Community Organization: A Cross-Cultural Comparison”, Cross-Cultural Research 34(2000), 152–89.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M. and Roese, P.M.. The Efa: Mysterious Aborigines of Edoland. In Bondarenko, D.M. and Sledzevski, I. V., eds. Afrika: obshchestva, kul'tury, jazyki (Vzaimodejstvie kul'tur v protsesse sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoj i politicheskoj transformatsii mestnykh obshchestv. Istorija i sovremennost’). Moscow, 1998a, 18–26.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M. and Roese, P.M.. Pre-Dynastic Edo: The Independent Local Community Government System and Socio-Political Evolution, Ethnographisch-Archäologische Zeitschrift 39(1998b), 367–72.Google Scholar
Bondarenko, D.M. and Roese, P.M.. Ancient Benin: Where did the First Monarchs Come from?, Asian and African Studies 10(2001), 185–98.Google Scholar
Bradbury, R. E.The Benin Kingdom and the Edo-Speaking Peoples of South-Western Nigeria. London, 1957.Google Scholar
Bradbury, R. E.The Historical Uses of Comparative Ethnography with Special Reference to Benin and the Yoruba, in Vansina, J., Mauny, R. and Thomas, L. V., eds. The Historian in Tropical Africa. London, 1964, 145–64.Google Scholar
Bradbury, R.E.The Kingdom of Benin, in Forde, D. and Kaberry, P. M., eds. West African Kingdoms in the Nineteenth Century. London, 1967, 1–35.Google Scholar
Bradbury, R.E.Chronological Problems in the Study of Benin History, in Bradbury, R.E., Benin Studies. London, 1973[1959], 17–43Google Scholar
Burdo, A.Niger et Bénué. Voyage dans l'Afrique centrale. Paris, 1880.Google Scholar
Clark, J.D.Doistoricheskaja Afrika. Moscow, 1977.Google Scholar
Courlander, H.Tales of Yoruba Gods and Heroes. New York, 1973.Google Scholar
Crowder, M.The Story of Nigeria. London, 1978.Google Scholar
Curnow, K.Art of Fasting: Benin's Ague Ceremony, African Arts 30/4(1997), 46-53, 93–94.Google Scholar
Darling, P.J.Archaeology and History in Southern Nigeria. The Ancient Linear Earthworks of Benin and Ishan, 2 vols.: Oxford, 1984.Google Scholar
De Barros, J.Asia de João de Barros: Dos Feitos que os Portugueses fizeram no descobrimento e conquista dos mares e terras de Oriente. Dec.I. Coimbra, 1988[1552].Google Scholar
Dennett, R.E.At the Back of the Black Man's Mind, or Notes on the Kingly Office in West Africa. London, 1906.Google Scholar
Dike, K.O.Benin—srednevekovoe gosudarstvo Nigerii”, Kur'er JuNESKO 10(1959), 13–14.Google Scholar
Ebohon, O.Cultural Heritage of Benin. Benin City, 1972.Google Scholar
Egharevba, J. U.Benin Law and Custom. Port Harcourt, 1949.Google Scholar
Egharevba, J. U.A Short History of Benin. Ibadan, 1960.Google Scholar
Egharevba, J. U.Chronicle of Events in Benin. Benin City, 1965.Google Scholar
Egharevba, J. U.A Brief Life History of Evian. Benin City, 1970.Google Scholar
Emovon, A.Preservation and Development of Traditional Oral Poetry: The Edo (Bini) Example, in Abimola, W., ed. Oral Poetry in Nigeria. Lagos, 1981, 265–82.Google Scholar
Eweka, E.B.The Benin Monarchy (Origin and Development). Benin City, 1989.Google Scholar
Eweka, E.B.Evolution of Benin Chieftaincy Titles. Benin City, 1992.Google Scholar
Fabumni, M.A.An Anthology of Historical Notes on Ife City. Ikeja, 1985.Google Scholar
Freyer, B.Royal Benin Art in the Collection of the National Museum of African Art. Washington, 1987.Google Scholar
Hook, S.H.Mifologija Blizhnego Vostoka. Moscow, 1991.Google Scholar
Igbafe, P.A.Benin in the Pre-Colonial Era, Tarikh 5(1974), 1–16.Google Scholar
Isichei, E.A History of Nigeria. London, 1983.Google Scholar
Johnson, S.The History of the Yorubas. Lagos, 1921.Google Scholar
Jungwirth, M.Gedanken zu einer Ethnohistorie des Benin Reiches, Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien 98(1968), 67–74.Google Scholar
Kochakova, N. B.Rozhdenie afrikanskoj tsivilizatsii (Ife, Ojo, Benin, Dagomeja), Moscow, 1986.Google Scholar
Kochakova, N.B.Ile-Ife: integratsionnye funktsii sakral'no-kul'tovogo tsentra v proshlom i nastojashchem, in Sledzevski, I.V. and Bondarenko, D.M., eds. Afrika: obshchestva, kul'tury, jazyki (Vzaimodejstvie kul'tur v protsesse sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoj i politi-cheskoj transformatsii mestnykh obshchestv. Istorija i sovremen-nost'). Moscow, 1998, 27–38.Google Scholar
Kubbel', L.E.Ocherki potestarno-politicheskoj etnografii. Moscow, 1988.Google Scholar
Law, R.Contemporary Written Sources, in Biobaku, S.O., ed. Sources of Yoruba History. Oxford, 1973, 9–24.Google Scholar
Lloyd, P.C.The Political Development of West African Kingdoms, Journal of African History 9(1968), 319–29.Google Scholar
Manning, P.Hegelian Dialectics in Benin Kingdom Historiography, Canadian Journal of African Studies 20(1986), 431–35.Google Scholar
Marquart, J.Die Benin-Sammlung des Reichsmuseums für Völkerkunde in Leiden. Leiden, 1913.Google Scholar
Mauny, R.Tableau géographique de l'Ouest Africain au moyen âge, d'après les sources écrites, la tradition et l'archéologie. Dakar, 1961.Google Scholar
Mel'nikova, E.A.Proiskhozhdenie pravjashchej dinastii v rannes-rednevekovoj istoriogrnfii. Legitimizatsija inoetnichnoj znati, in Svanidze, A.A., ed. Elita i etnos srednevekovja. Moscow, 1995, 39–44.Google Scholar
Mowat, L.Symbols of Kings. Benin Art at the Pitt-Rivers Museum. Oxford, 1991.Google Scholar
Nevadomsky, J.Kingship Succession Rituals in Benin, part 3: The Coronation of the Oba, African Arts 17/3(1984), 48–56.Google Scholar
Obayemi, A.The Yoruba and Edo-spcaking Peoples and Their Neighbours Before 1600, in Ajayi, J.F.A. and Crowder, M., eds. History of West Africa, I. London, 1976, 196–263.Google Scholar
Obayemi, A.M.Between Nok, Ile-Ife, and Benin. Progress Report and Prospects, Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 10(1980), 31–43.Google Scholar
Omoregie, O. S. B.The Trials of Ogiso Owodo. Benin City, 1990.Google Scholar
Onokerhoraye, A.G.Urbanism as an Organ of Traditional African Civilization: The Example of Benin, Nigeria, Civilisations 25(1975), 294–305.Google Scholar
Otite, O.Historical Aspects of the Sociology of the Bendel State of Nigeria, Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 9(1977), 41–64.Google Scholar
Pacheco Pereira, D.Esmeraldo de Situ Orbis. Bissau, 1956 [1505/08].Google Scholar
Page, P.R.Benin Arts and Crafts, Farm and Forest 5(1944), 166–69.Google Scholar
Palau Marti, M.Essai sur la notion de roi. Chez les yoruba et les ajafon (Nigeria et Dahomey). Paris, 1960.Google Scholar
Palmer, H.R.Sudanese Memoirs: Being Mainly Translations of a Number of Arabic Manuscripts Relating to the Central and Western Sudan, 3. London, 1928.Google Scholar
Roese, P.M.Das Königreich Benin: von den Anfängen bis 1485, Anthropos 79(1984), 191–222.Google Scholar
Roese, P.M.Die Hierarchie des ehemaligen Königreiches Benin aus der Sicht zeitgenössischer europäischer Beobachter, Ethnograph-isch-Archäologische Zeitschrift 29(1988), 47–73.Google Scholar
Roth, H.L.Great Benin. Its Customs, Art and Horrors. Halifax, 1903.Google Scholar
Ryder, A.F.C.A Reconsideration of the Ife-Benin Relationship, Journal of African History 6(1965), 25–37.Google Scholar
Sagalaev, A.M. and Oktjabr'skaja, I.V., Traditsionnoe mirovozzrenie tjurkov Juzhnoj Sibiri. Znak i ritual. Novosibirsk, 1990.Google Scholar
Sargent, R.A.From a Redistribution to an Imperial Social Formation: Benin c.1293-1536, Canadian Journal of African Studies 20(1986), 402–27.Google Scholar
Schurhammer, G.Das Rätsel der Benin Altertümer, Katholischen Missionen 56(1928), 28–30.Google Scholar
Shaw, T.Radiocarbon Dating in Nigeria. Ibadan, 1968.Google Scholar
Smith, R.S.Kingdoms of the Yoruba. 2d ed.: London, 1988.Google Scholar
Sölken, H.Innerafrikanische Wege nach Benin, Anthropos 49(1954), 809–933.Google Scholar
Stoll, O.Zur Frage der Benin-Altertümer, Internationales Archiv für Ethnographie 15(1902), 161–66.Google Scholar
Stride, G.T. and Ifeka, C.. Peoples and Empires of West Africa: West Africa in History, 1000-1800. London, 1971.Google Scholar
Talbot, P.A.The Peoples of Southern Nigeria. A Sketch of Their History, Ethnology and Languages. 4 vols.: London, 1926.Google Scholar
Thornton, J.K.Traditions, Documents and the Ife-Benin Relationship, History in Africa 15(1988), 351–62.Google Scholar
Ugowe, C.O.O.Benin in World History. Lagos, 1997.Google Scholar
Vansina, J.Oral Tradition. London, 1965.Google Scholar
Willett, F.Ife in the History of West African Sculpture. London, 1967.Google Scholar
Willett, F.Archaeology, in Biobaku, S.O., ed. Sources of Yoruba History. Oxford, 1973, 111–39.Google Scholar
Willett, F. Nigerija, in Shinnie, P.L., ed. Zheleznyj vek Afriki. Moscow, 1982, 5–29.Google Scholar