Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T23:37:29.292Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Unionist Politics and Protestant Society in Edwardian Ireland*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Alvin Jackson
Alvin Jackson
Affiliation:
University College, Dublin
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Like the ‘Tory in clogs’ of Edwardian Britain, the Unionist working man has generally eluded the historian of modern Ireland. Indeed, to some extent, the image of Irish Unionism, whether popular or scholarly, has been supplied by the apologetic biographers of the ‘great men’ of loyalism, and by the rhetoric of political opponents like Michael Farrell: at any rate the historiography of the movement is peopled with irredentist squires and Anglo-Irish peers, bowler-hatted Orange artisans – Engel's ‘Protestant brag-garts’ – and cynical industrial barons. The existence of a more popular Unionism is acknowledged, though only in a context (the militancy of 1912, the bravura of 12 July marches) when it may not be ignored: even so, as with an older scholarly attitude towards popular British toryism, there has been a tendency among historians to treat mass Unionism as a freak of progress, demanding apologetic explanation rather than sustained illumination. With the institutions of popular Conservatism now, after thirty years of historical research, a firm feature of the British historical landscape, the need to reveal something of the electoral base of Ulster Unionism is all the more apparent. This is particularly true of the rural hinterland of the loyalist movement which, even more than Belfast, has been the victim of neglect.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 33 , Issue 4 , December 1990 , pp. 839 - 866
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See, for example, Farrell's, Michael important Northern Ireland: The Orange state (London, 1976)Google Scholar; Engels, to Bernstein, Eduard, 22 May 1886, in Dixon, R. (ed.), Marx, Engels: Ireland and the Irish question (London, 1978), p. 466Google Scholar.

2 Joyce, Patrick, Work, society and politics: The culture of the factory in later Victorian England, paperback edition (London, 1982), pp. xiii, 268Google Scholar.

3 Clarkson, L. A., ‘Population change and urbanisation, 1821–1911’, in Kennedy, Liam and Ollerenshaw, Philip (eds.), An economic history of Ulster, 1820–1940 (Manchester, 1985), p. 152Google Scholar. Henry Patterson, ‘Industrial labour and the labour movement, 1820–1914’, in ibid. p. 159. Evans, E. E. (ed.), Harvest home, the last sheaf: a selection from the writings of T. G. F. Paterson relating to county Armagh (Armagh, 1975), pp. 113–29Google Scholar.

4 Walker, B. M., ‘Pride, prejudice and politics: society and elections in Ulster, 1868–1886’ (unpublished draft), p. 114Google Scholar. Walker, , ‘Parliamentary representation in Ulster, 1868–86’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Trinity College, Dublin, 1976), pp. 390–1Google Scholar.

5 Walker, , ‘Parliamentary representation’, pp. 391–2Google Scholar.

6 Clarke, P. F., Lancashire and the new liberalism (Cambridge, 1971), p. 40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Stewart, A. T. Q., The narrow ground: aspects of Ulster, 1609–1969 (London, 1977), pp. 166–7Google Scholar. Buckland, P. J., Irish unionism II: Ulster unionism and the origins of Northern Ireland, 1886–1922 (Dublin, 1973)Google Scholar, passim.

8 Clarke, , Lancashire, p. 40Google Scholar.

9 Public Record Office of Northern Ireland, J. E. Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, Peel to T. L. O'Shaughnessy, 6 Apr. 1896 (copy).

10 Peel papers, D.889/4C/7E, J. L. White to Peel, 9 Dec. 1899; D.889/4C/2, 262, Peel to O'Shaughnessy, 30 Nov. 1899 (copy). Lowell, A. L., The government of England, 2 vols (New York, 1924), I, 496Google Scholar.

11 Peel papers, D.889/4C/4, Peel to Lonsdale, 24 July 1913 (copy).

12 For example, Birch, A. H., Small-town politics: a study of political life in Glossop (Oxford, 1959), pp. 45–53Google Scholar.

13 Armagh Guardian (hereafter AG), 2 Feb. 1900.

14 AG, 2 Jan. 1891, 26 June 1891.

15 Irvine, Alexander, The souls of poor folk (London, 1921), p. 40Google Scholar.

16 Peel papers, D.889/4C/2, Peel to Barton, 17 Feb. 1900 (copy).

17 Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, Peel to Corry, 28 Nov. 1887 (copy).

18 Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, Peel to Barton, 28 Dec. 1891 (copy).

19 Peel papers, D.889/4C/5B, Peel to Stronge, 11 Dec. 1891 (copy).

20 Peel papers, D.889/4C/2, Peel to Barton, 11 Jan. 1898 (copy).

21 Jackson, Alvin, ‘Irish unionism and the Russellite threat, 1894–1906’, in Irish Historical Studies, xxv, 100 (11 1987), 376–404CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, Peel to Barton, 29 Dec. 1894. AG, 3 May 1895.

23 Hansard, 4th series, 1895, XXXII, 1597. Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, Peel to Barton, 15 July 1895.

24 AG, 2 Feb. 1900, 16 Feb. 1900. For the context see McMinn, J. R. B., ‘Presbyterianism and politics in Ulster, 1871–1906’, in Studia Hibernica, XXI (1981), 127–46Google Scholar; and McMinn, , ‘Revd J. B. Armour and Liberal politics in North Antrim, 1869–1914’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Queen's University, Belfast, 1979), pp. 139–42Google Scholar.

25 AG, 17 May 1895, the farmers reported as watching Barton ‘narrowly’.

26 Peel papers, D.889/4C/2, Peel to Lonsdale, 16 Feb. 1901, 18 Feb. 1901, 19 Feb. 1901, 21 Feb. 1901, 22 Feb. 1901 (copies). Bew, Paul, Conflict and conciliation, 1890–1910: Parnellites and agrarian radicals (Oxford, 1987), pp. 88–9Google Scholar.

27 Peel papers, D.889/4C/3, Peel to Lonsdale, 3 May 1906, 9 Apr. 1908, 7 Jan. 1910. For a characteristic tory response see British Library, Arthur Balfour papers, Add. MS 49765, fo. 148: J. S. Sanders to W. Short, 5 May 1908.

28 Clarke, , Lancashire, p. 40Google Scholar. Joyce, , Work, society and politics, p. 268Google Scholar.

29 Thompson, F. M. L. and Tierney, D. (eds.), General report on the Gosford estates in county Armagh, 1821, by William Grieg (Belfast, 1975), p. 9Google Scholar.

30 AG, 23 June 1893.

31 Peel papers, D.889/4C/6, Peel to Edwin Best, 11 Feb. 1900.

32 Hansard, 4th series, 1892, 1, 501.

33 Walker, , ‘Pride, prejudice and politics’, p. 82Google Scholar.

34 Anon, , Armagh County Council, 1899–1973 (np, nd), p. 2Google Scholar. Harbinson, John, The Ulster Unionist Party, 1882–1973: Its development and organisation (Belfast, 1973), p. 235Google Scholar, n. 5 (d).

35 Harbinson, , Ulster Unionist Party, pp. 110, 126Google Scholar.

36 Peel papers, D.889/4C/1, 929, Peel to Lonsdale, 9 Apr. 1908.

37 Peel papers, D.889/4C/2, 301, Peel to O'Shaughnessy, 26 Jan. 1900.

38 Peel papers, D.889/4C/7E, McCrum to Peel, 27 Sept. 1900.

39 Peel papers, D.889/4C/3, 929, Peel to Lonsdale, 18 Oct. 1908.

40 Joyce, , Work, society and politics, pp. 232–4Google Scholar. Biographies of these men may be found in Young, R. M. (ed.), Belfast and the province of Ulster in the twentieth century (Brighton, 1909), pp. 417, 451Google Scholar.

41 Armagh County Council, pp. 1–2.

42 For example: Hansard, 3rd series, 1886, CCCVIII, 995; Hansard, 3rd series, 1887, CCCX, 1522; Hansard, 3rd series, 1887, CCCXXI, 269; Hansard, CCCXIV, 1228.

43 Jackson, Alvin, Edward Saunderson and the evolution of Ulster unionism (Belfast, forthcoming)Google Scholar.

44 Clarke, , Lancashire, pp. 45, 51–2Google Scholar.

45 Kinghan, Nancy, United we stand: the story of the Ulster women's unionist council, 1911–1974 (Belfast, 1974), pp. 7–8Google Scholar.

46 AG, 24 Mar. 1893.

47 AG, 2 June 1893.

48 Ibid.

49 Ibid.

50 Gibbon, Peter, ‘The origins of the Orange Order and the united Irishmen: a study in the sociology of revolution and counter-revolution’, Economy and Society, I (1972), 135–62Google Scholar. Hoppen, K. T., Elections, politics and society in Ireland, 1832–1885 (Oxford, 1984), p. 405Google Scholar. Inglis, H. D., Ireland in 1834: a journey throughout Ireland in the spring, summer and autumn of 1834, 2 vols (London, 1835), II, 276–7Google Scholar. For a corrective see Clarkson, L. A., ‘Armagh 1770: portrait of an urban community’, in Harkness, David and O'Dowd, Mary (eds.), The town in Ireland: historical studies XIII (Belfast, 1981), pp. 86–9Google Scholar.

51 AG, 23 Feb. 1894. Hansard, 4th series, 1894, XXI, 1040.

52 For example: AG, 20 May 1910.

53 Hansard, 4th series, 1896, XXXIX, 943.

54 AG, 22 July 1910, 26 Aug. 1910, 18 Nov. 1910, 30 Jan. 1911. Peel papers, D.889/4C/4, 77, Peel to Lonsdale, 25 Oct. 1909; D.889/4C/7H, Barr to Peel, 4 July 1906.

55 AG, 13 Jan. 1911. Compare the bitterness felt by the Revd. William Corkey fifty years after the promulgation of the decree: Corkey, , Glad did I live: memories of a long life (Belfast, 1962), pp. 151–68Google Scholar.

56 Armagh Public Library, Armagh Clerical Union Minutes: 28 Dec. 1909.

57 AG, 16 Feb. 1912, 13 Jan. 1905.

58 Walker, , ‘Parliamentary representation’, pp. 391–2Google Scholar. Healy, T. M., Letters and leaders of my day, 2 vols. (London, 1928), I, 231–2Google Scholar.

59 Patterson, Henry, Class conflict and sectarianism: the protestant working class and the Belfast labour movement, 1868–1920 (Belfast, 1980), pp. 28–9Google Scholar. Gibbon, Peter, The origins of Ulster unionism: the formation of popular protestant politics and ideology in nineteenth-century Ireland (Manchester, 1975), pp. 83–6Google Scholar. Hepburn, A. C. and Collins, B., ‘Industrial society: the structure of Belfast, 1901’, in Roebuck, P. (ed.), Plantation to partition: essays in Ulster history in honour of J. L. McCracken (Belfast, 1981), pp. 210–28Google Scholar.

60 Strauss, E., Irish nationalism and British democracy (London, 1951), p. 234Google Scholar. Crossick, G., An artisan elite in Victorian society: Kentish London, 1840–1880, p. 20Google Scholar.

61 Data compiled from House of Commons accounts and papers, 1902, CXXVI, 252, 296–303 (Census of Ireland for 1901). Ollerenshaw, P., ‘Industry, 1820–1914’, in Kennedy, and Ollerenshaw, , Economic history, pp. 82–3Google Scholar.

62 Hansard, 4th series, 1893, XII. 538

63 Pelling, Henry, ‘The concept of the labour aristocracy’, in his Popular politics and society in late Victorian Britain, 2nd edn (London, 1979), p. 57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64 Lucas, R., Colonel Edward Saunderson MP: a memoir (London, 1908), pp. 301–4Google Scholar.

65 AG, 30 Aug. 1900.

66 AG, 27 July 1894.

67 Compare Crossick, , Artisan elite, pp. 251 ffGoogle Scholar.

68 Vincent, John, The formation of the Liberal party (London, 1966), p. 79Google Scholar.

69 Patterson, R. J., Catch-my-pal: a story of good samaritanship (London, 1912), p. 23Google Scholar.

70 For British parallels see: Harrison, Brian, Peaceable kingdom: stability and change in Modern Britain (Oxford, 1982), p. 152Google Scholar.

71 For the role of Orangeism in the electoral history of North Armagh see: Thompson, Frank, ‘The Armagh elections of 1885–6’, Seanchas Ardmhacha: Journal of the Armagh Dioscesan Historical Society, VIII (1977), 364–8Google Scholar. PRONI, R. H. Wallace papers, D. 1889/6/6: Craig to Wallace, 5 Dec. 1906.

72 Bew, P., Gibbon, P., Patterson, H., The state in Northern Ireland, 1921–72: political forces and social dasses (Manchester, 1979), p. 46Google Scholar.

73 Pugh, M., The tories and the people, 1880–1935 (Oxford, 1985), pp. 41–2Google Scholar.

74 AG, 30 June 1911.

75 AG, 2 Aug. 1894. Foy, Michael, ‘The Ulster volunteer force: its domestic development and political importance in the period 1913–1920’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Queen's University, Belfast, 1986), p. 39Google Scholar.

76 A view quoted and slightly modified by Warren, Allen, ‘Citizens of the empire: Baden-Powell, scouts and guides, and an imperial ideal, 1900–1940’, in Mackenzie, J. M. (ed.), Imperialism and popular culture (Manchester, 1986), p. 235Google Scholar.

77 AG, 23 May 1913.

78 AG, 4 Oct. 1912.

79 Armagh Public Library, Minutes of the Church of Ireland Mutual Improvement Society (hereafter CIMIS): 20 Oct. 1905. Armagh Museum, Minutes of the Armagh United Protestant Young Men's Mutual Improvement Society (hereafter AUPYMMIS): 13 Nov. 1896.

80 For example: AG, 29 May 1914.

81 Harrison, B. H., ‘For church, queen and family: the Girls' Friendly Society, 1874–1920’, Past and Present, LXI (1973), 107–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

82 AG, 12 Jan. 1894.

83 Yeo, S., Religion and voluntary organisations in crisis (London, 1976), p. 296Google Scholar.

84 AG, 13 Oct. 1893.

85 AUPYMMIS Minutes, 14 Mar. 1890.

86 AUPYMMIS Minutes, 9 Nov. 1883.

87 AG, 28 Apr. 1893.

88 CIMIS Minutes: 9 Jan. 1907.

89 AUPYMMIS Minutes, 20 Feb. 1896, 15 Oct. 1897, 10 Dec. 1897.

90 AUPYMMIS Minutes, 19 Feb. 1886, 21 Nov. 1884.

91 AUPYMMIS Minutes, 10 Mar. 1893.

92 McMinn, J. R. B., Against the Tide: J. B. Armour, presbyterian minister and home ruler (Belfast, 1985), p. xliiGoogle Scholar. McDowell, R. B., The Church of Ireland, 1869–1969 (London, 1975), pp. 98–9Google Scholar.

93 McMinn, , Against the tide, p. xliiGoogle Scholar.

94 Hoppen, , Elections, politics and society, p. 267Google Scholar.

95 Peel papers, D.889/4C/6: Peel to Millar, 9 Jan. 1906.

96 For J. P. Corry's standing within his church see Johnston, Robert, The story of the Presbyterian Central Association, Belfast, 1882–1932 (Belfast, 1932), p. 13Google Scholar.

97 AG, 3 Apr. 1914. McDowell, , Church of Ireland, pp. 103–5Google Scholar.

98 Clarke, , Lancashire, p. 60Google Scholar. By Dec. 1916 the formerly apolitical Clerical Union was resolving congratulations to A. W. Samuel, Unionist M.P. for the University of Dublin, and ending their proceedings with ‘God save the King’.

99 AG, 18 Sept. 1914. In deploying the same theatrical image, Bowen, Elizabeth suggests the rather greater immediate impact of war on southern society: Bowen's court, 2nd edn (London, 1942), p. 316Google Scholar.

100 AG, 20 Nov. 1914.

101 This argument is pursued in Jackson, Alvin, The Ulster party: Irish unionists in the house of commons, 1884–1911 (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar, ch. 7.

102 Fitzpatrick, David, Politics and rural life, 1913–21: provincial experience of war and revolution (Dublin, 1977), p. 142Google Scholar.