Hostname: page-component-6d856f89d9-5pczc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-16T08:10:19.042Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Undouted Realities’: Clarendon on Sacrilege*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Martin Dzelzainis
Martin Dzelzainis
Affiliation:
Royal Holloway and Bedford New College, London
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The phrase in the title is Charles I's. Writing from Newcastle to Henry Jermyn, John Culpepper and John Ashburnham in September 1646, he voiced his ‘unexpressable greefe andastonishment’ at the advice on the church which he had received from them during the course of his negotiations with the parliamentary commissioners. For they had assured Charles that, if he was no doubt‘ obliged’ by his conscience ‘to doe all’ that was in his ‘power to support and maintain that function of Bishops’, then he had already discharged that obligation to the full, as ‘all the world can witness’. Conscience, in this sense, had no further claims on him, nor could it be more strictly interpreted:

if by conscience is intended to assert that Episcopacy is jure divino exclusive, wherby no Protestant (or rather Christian) Church can be acknowledged for such without a Bishop, we must therin crave leave wholly to differ. And if we be in an errour, we are in good company; ther not being (as we have cause to believe) 6 persons of the Protestant Religion of the other opinion. Thus much we can add, that at the treaty of Uxbridge none of your Divines then present (though much provoked thereunto) would maintain that (we might say uncharitable) opinion, no not privatly amongst your commissioners. Nether doeth it follow that in this, or any the most riged, sence you are obliged to perish in company with Bishops meerly out of pitty (and certainly you have nothing els left to assist them with) or that monarchy ought to fall, because Episcopacy cannot stand.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 33 , Issue 3 , September 1990 , pp. 515 - 540
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Charles, I to Jermyn, , Culpepper, and Ashburnham, , 21 Sept.1646, in State papers collected by Edward, earl of Clarendon (3 vols., Oxford, 1767–86), II, 264Google Scholar. Hereafter cited as S.P.C.

2 Jermyn, and Culpepper, to Charles, I, 18/28 09 1646, S.P.C., II, 263Google Scholar.

3 Charles, I to Jermyn, , Culpepper, and Ashburnham, , 21 09. 1646, S.P.C., II, 265Google Scholar.

4 Charles, I to Jermyn, , Culpepper, and Ashburnham, , 21 and 7 09. and 19 08, 1646, S.P.C., II, 264–5, 260, 248Google Scholar.

5 Charles, I to Murray, , 15 10 1646, S.P.C., II, 276Google Scholar.

6 For Steward, see Pocock, N., Life of Richard Steward (London, 1908), and the article in the D.N.B.Google Scholar

7 Charles I to the prince of Wales, 26 Aug., and to Jermyn, , Culpepper, and Ashburnham, , 21 09 1646, S.P.C., II, 253–4, 265Google Scholar.

8 Hyde, Edward, earl of Clarendon, The Life of Edward, earl of Clarendon (Oxford, 1759), pp. 89, 103–4Google Scholar.

9 Hyde, to Steward, , 8 01 1647, S.P.C., II, 328Google Scholar.

10 Hyde, to Nicholas, , 15 11 1646, S.P.C., II, 286Google Scholar.

11 Hyde, to Dalkeith, , 20 10 1646, S.P.C., II, 284Google Scholar.

12 Hyde, to Digby, , 30 11 1648, S.P.C., II, 459Google Scholar.

13 Hyde, to Nicholas, , 24 02 1647, S.P.C., II, 341Google Scholar.

14 Wormald, B. H. G., Clarendon: politics, history and religion 1640–1660 (reissue, Cambridge, 1989), pp. 214, 276, 281Google Scholar.

15 Wormald, , Clarendon, p. 240Google Scholar.

16 Gardiner, S. R., ‘A scheme of toleration propounded at Uxbridge in 1645’, English Historical Review, II (1887), 341Google Scholar.

17 Wormald, , Clarendon, pp. 281, 297, 303Google Scholar. On Great Tew, see now also Hayward, J. C., ’New directions in studies of the Falkland circle’, The Seventeenth Century, II, 1 (1987), 19–48Google Scholar, and Trevor-Roper, H. R., Catholics, Anglicans and Puritans (London, 1987), pp. 166–230Google Scholar.

18 Hyde's will is dated Elizabeth, Castle, Jersey, , 3 04 1647, S.P.C., II, 359Google Scholar. Wormald quotes the same passage (but not what follows) as an example of ‘Chillingworthian liberalism’, Clarendon, p. 310.

19 Wormald, , Clarendon, pp. 162ndash;3, 225, 307, 312Google Scholar.

20 The essay can be found in The miscellaneous works of the right honourable Edward, earl of Clarendon (London, 1751), pp. 211ndash;17Google Scholar. Hyde's preoccupation with the bishops' lands and sacrilege at around this time is clear from his letters to Nicholas of 15 Nov. 1646 (‘I concur fully with you in your zeal and conclusion in the case of alienating the Church Lands; but why have you contracted your consideration of the Church to that point only? Is your opinion altered in the point of discipline and government?’) and 12 Dec. 1646 (‘In your opinion of the undoubted sacrilege, of alienating the Church Lands; I agree with you fully; but I know not how to say, that the abolishing the function of Bishops is the lesser sin; saving that it would be easier to restore their order than their lands’), S.P.C., II, 286, 308. In the 1751 edition the essay is wrongly dated 1641: for the proposed date of 1648 see note 39 below.

21 Hyde, to Sheldon, , 29 08 1647, S.P.C., II, 375Google Scholar.

22 For accounts of Hyde' commonplace books see the following: Raab, F., The English face of Machiavelli (London, 1964), pp. 146–7Google Scholar; Trevor-Roper, H. R., Edward Hyde, earl of Clarendon (Oxford, 1975), p. 13Google Scholar; Dzelzainis, M., ‘Edward Hyde and Thomas Hobbes's Elements of law, natural and politic’, Historical Journal, XXXII, 2 (1989), pp. 303–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 See Watson, G., ‘The reader in Clarendon's History of the rebellion’, Review of English Studies, XXV (1974), 396–409CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Trevor-Roper, Clarendon, p. 21.

24 Hooker, Richard, Of the lawes of ecclesiasticall politie (London, [1593]–1597), pp. 9–10 (second pagination, as in all following references)Google Scholar.

25 Hooker, , Ecclesiastical politie, pp. 20, 21, 244 (misnumbered, should be 246)Google Scholar.

26 Hooker, , Ecclesiasticall politie, pp. 249, 250Google Scholar.

27 Hooker, , Ecclesiasticall politie, pp. 242, 245Google Scholar.

28 Hooker, , Ecclesiasticall politie, pp. 245, 249Google Scholar.

29 Welsby, Paul A., Lancelot Andrewes (London, 1958), pp. 70–1, 130–2Google Scholar; Hooker, , Ecclesiasticall politie, p. 21Google Scholar.

30 Welsby, , Andrewes, pp. 33–4, 38Google Scholar; Isaacson, Henry, ‘Life and death of…Lancelot Andrewes’, in Lancelot Andrewes, Two answers to Cardinal Perron and other miscellaneous works (Oxford, 1854), p. xxviiGoogle Scholar.

31 Andrewes, Lancelot, Sacrilege a snare (London, 1646), p. 14Google Scholar.

32 Andrewes, , Sacrilege, p. 22Google Scholar.

33 Andrewes, , Sacrilege, pp. 19, 21, 22Google Scholar.

34 Buckeridge, John, A sermon preached at the funeral of…Lancelot late lord bishop of Winchester (London, 1629), p. 21Google Scholar. This is appended to Andrewes, Lancelot, XCVI sermons (London, 1629)Google Scholar.

35 Mede, to Twisse, , 15 July 1635, in The works of the pious and profoundly-learned Joseph Mede, ed. Worthington, John (3rd edn, London, 1672), p. 829Google Scholar. For Mede, or Mead, see the article in the D.N.B. and the introductory material in the Works. The ‘Preface’ by Twisse, to Mede's, The apostasy of the latter times (London, 1642)Google Scholar is also valuable.

36 Twisse to Mede, 3 Aug. 1635, and Mede to Twisse, Apr. 1637, in Mede, , Works, pp. 832, 850Google Scholar.

37 See ‘An appendix to the foregoing history of the author's life’, in Mede, , Works, p. xliGoogle Scholar.

38 ‘Discourse XXX’ of Mede's, Diatribae, in Works, p. 141Google Scholar.

39 For the dating of Mede's Diatribae, see the ‘General preface’ by John Worthington in Mede, Works, unpaginated. ‘Discourse XXVII’ was first printed in Diatribae (London, 1648), pp. 379–403Google Scholar. Hyde left Jersey on 26 June 1648.

40 Mede, , Works, pp. 119, 120Google Scholar.

41 Mede, , Works, pp. 116, 118, 121Google Scholar.

42 Mede, , Works, p. 122Google Scholar.

43 ‘Preface’ to Spelman, Henry, The history and fate of sacrilege (London, 1698), sig. A2Google Scholar; Spelman, Clement, ‘To the Reader’, in Spelman, HenryDe non temerandis ecclesiis, churches not to be violated(Oxford, 1946), sig. B4Google Scholar.

44 For the articles of the treaty of Edinburgh, , see The journals of the house of Lords, VI, 364– 5Google Scholar. Details of the sale of the bishops' lands with a full list of ordinances can be found in Shaw, W. A., A history of the English Church during the Civil Wars and under the Protectorate (2 vols., London, 1900), II, 204–13Google Scholar; the ordinances themselves are in Acts and ordinances of the Interregnum, collected and ed. by Firth, C. H. and Rait, R. S. (3 vols., London, 1911), I, 967 ffGoogle Scholar.

45 Constitutional documents of the Puritan revolution 1625–1660, selected and ed. by Gardiner, S. R. (3rd edn, Oxford, 1906), p. 329Google Scholar.

46 SirWalker, Edward, Perfect copies of all the votes, letters, proposals and answers…in the treaty held at Newport (London, 1705), p. 85Google Scholar. This is appended to Walker, , Historical discourses (London, 1705)Google Scholar.

47 Walker, , Perfect copies, pp. 86, 98Google Scholar.

48 Wormald, , Clarendon, p. 281Google Scholar.

49 Gardiner, , ‘Scheme of toleration’, 341Google Scholar; Hyde, Edward, earl of Clarendon, The history of the rebellion, ed. Macray, W. D. (6 vols., Oxford, 1888), III, 479, 483Google Scholar. See also Trevor-Roper, , Clarendon, pp. 22–3Google Scholar.

50 Wormald, , Clarendon, p. 276Google Scholar.

51 King, P., ‘The episcopate during the Civil Wars, 1642–1649’, English Historical Review, LXXXIII (1968), 533–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

52 Clarendon, , History, IV, 430–55Google Scholar.

53 Sermon, VII in Chillingworth, William, Works (3 vols., Oxford, 1838), II, 202, 203–4Google Scholar.

54 S.P.C., II, 359.

55 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 217Google Scholar.

56 Annotations upon all the books of the Old and New Testament (London, 1645)Google Scholar, unpaginated. However, the second, enlarged edition of theAnnotations, published in London in 1651 (also unpaginated), commented on the same text that ‘if he that taketh from the Church but a little of that which was his own, be sacrilegious, and st[r]ooken dead for the same; what punishment will the same Divine Justice lay on him who by fraud or violence taketh away the possessions wherewith other men endowed the Church?’

57 See, for example, Charles, I to the prince of Wales, 6 11 1648, S.P.C., II, 435Google Scholar; Walker, Perfect copies, passim; and the transcripts from the diaries of Nicholas Oudart in Liber X of Francis Peck, Desiderata curiosa (London, 1732), esp. pp.3, 12, 22Google Scholar.

58 Steward, Richard, An answer to a letter written at Oxford, and superscribed to Dr. Samuel Turner, concerning the church, and the revenues thereof (n.p., 1647), sig. A2, A3Google Scholar.

59 Steward, Answer, sig. A4.

60 Ibid.

61 Ibid. sig. A4v.

62 From Selden's Table talk in Selden, John, Opera omnia, ed. Wilkins, David (3 vols., London, 1726), III, col. 2023Google Scholar.

63 Ibid.

64 Selden, , Opera, III, col. 2015Google Scholar.

65 Selden, , Opera, III, col. 2073Google Scholar.

66 Steward, , Answer, pp. 35–6, 37, 38, 49Google Scholar.

67 Steward, , Answer, p. 42Google Scholar.

68 Steward, , Answer, pp. 27–8Google Scholar.

69 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 213–14, 217Google Scholar.

70 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 212Google Scholar.

71 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 212Google Scholar.

72 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 214Google Scholar.

73 For Hyde's friendship with Selden see Clarendon, , Life, p. 16Google Scholar. Selden's association with Great Tew and the significance of this is discussed in Tuck, Richard, Natural rights theories (Cambridge, 1979), pp. 101–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 214Google Scholar.

75 Seneca, , De beneficiis, in Moral essays, trans. by Basore, J. W., Loeb Classical Library (3 vols., Cambridge Mass., 1925), III, 465, 473Google Scholar.

76 Selden, , Opera, III, col. 2072Google Scholar.

77 Seneca, , Moral essays, III, 473, 475Google Scholar.

78 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 214Google Scholar.

79 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 215Google Scholar.

80 Mede, , Churches, that is, appropriate places for Christian worship (London, 1638), pp. 1–2Google Scholar.

81 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 215, 489Google Scholar. See also pp. 438, 490 and (on Psalm LXXIV) 560–63.

82 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, p. 215Google Scholar; A brief view and survey of the dangerous and pernicious errors to church and state, in Mr Hobbes's book, entitled Leviathan (London, 1676), p. 68Google Scholar. Lots three and four at the sale of Clarendon's MSS in April 1764 were advertised as consisting of (in each case) 24 pages in his own hand of ‘Extracts from Mr. Mede's Observations on the Scriptures, Lord Clar. Montpelier. 2d April 1670’ and ‘Collections out of Mr. Mede's Works and Mr. Stillingfleet's, Lord Clar. Montpelier, 20 April 1670’, A catalogue of a collection of manuscripts of the great earl of Clarendon ([London], 1764), p. IGoogle Scholar.

83 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 211–12Google Scholar.

84 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 211, 212Google Scholar.

85 Wormald, , Clarendon, p. 169Google Scholar.

86 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 215, 216Google Scholar.

87 Spelman, De non temerandis ecclesiis, sig. D4v.

88 See Hill, Christopher, Economic problems of the church (Oxford, 1956), pp. 153, 342Google Scholar.

89 Clarendon, , Miscellaneous works, pp. 216, 217Google Scholar.