Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:18:33.710Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

THE PROTESTANT MINORITY IN SOUTHERN IRELAND

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 November 2012

EUGENIO F. BIAGINI
EUGENIO F. BIAGINI*
Affiliation:
Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. Please use the Get access link above for information on how to access this content.
Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Review Article
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 55 , Issue 4 , December 2012 , pp. 1161 - 1184
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hubert Butler to Carol Janeway, rough notes for a letter, Apr–July 1980, in Butler papers, Trinity College Dublin, 10304/639/3.

2 For a few examples see Hiden, J. and Smith, D., ‘Looking beyond the nation state: a Baltic vision for national minorities between the wars’, Journal of Contemporary History, 41 (2006), pp. 387–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and the essays in Smith, D., Swain, G., and Galbreath, D., eds., From recognition to restoration: Latvia's history as a nation-state. Series: on the boundary of two worlds: identity, freedom and moral imagination in the Baltics (Amsterdam and New York, NY, 2010)Google Scholar.

3 P. Berger, ‘Introduction: the cultural dynamics of globalization’, in P. Berger and S. P. Huntington, Many globalizations: cultural diversity in the contemporary world (Oxford, 2002), pp. 12–16.

4 A. Choinowski, ‘Polish national character, the Sanacja Camp, and the national democracy’, in I. Banac and K. Verdery, eds., National Character and National Ideology (New Haven, CT, 1995), p. 33.

5 Bahm, K. F., ‘The inconveniences of nationality: German bohemians, the disintegration of the Habsburg monarchy, and the attempt to create a “Sudeten German” identity’, Nationalities Papers, 27 (1999), pp. 375–405CrossRefGoogle Scholar; C. J. Paces, ‘“The Czech nation must be Catholic!”: an alternative version of Czech nationalism during the first republic’, ibid., pp. 407–28; Belzyt, L., ‘Zur Frage der nationalen Bewußtseins der Masuren im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert’, Zeitschrift für Ostmitteleuropaforschung, 45 (1996), pp. 35–70Google Scholar; Die Volksdeutschen in Polen, Frankreich, Ungarn und der Tschechoslowakei, herausgegeben von J. Kochanowski and M. Sach (Göttingen, 2006).

6 Wilson, T. K., Frontiers of violence: conflict and identity in Ulster and Upper Silesia, 1918–1922 (Oxford, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Brown, S. J., ‘“Outside the Covenant”: the Scottish Presbyterian churches and Irish immigration, 1922–1938’, Innes Review, 1 (1991), pp. 19–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hughes, T. O., ‘Anti-Catholicism in Wales, 1900–1960’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 53 (2002), pp. 312–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Green, S. J. D., The passing of Protestant England, 1920–1990 (Cambridge, 2011)Google Scholar.

8 Butler, D. and Ruane’, J., ‘Identity, difference and community in Southern Irish Protestantism: the Protestants of West Cork’, National Identities, 11 (2009), p. 76CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 See Marianne Elliott's monumental The Catholics of Ulster: a history (London, 2000); see also Harris, M., The Catholic Church and the foundation of the Northern Irish state (Cork, 1993)Google Scholar; Phoenix, E., Northern nationalism: nationalist politics, partition and the Catholic minority in Northern Ireland (Belfast, 1994)Google Scholar; and Hebburn, A. C., Catholic Belfast and Nationalist Ireland in the age of Joe Devlin, 1871–1934 (Oxford, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. By contrast, so far little attention has been paid to Loyalist Catholics, especially in the South.

10 A few examples are: McDowell, R. B., Crisis and decline: the fate of Southern Unionism (Dublin, 1997)Google Scholar; T. A. M. Dooley, ‘Monaghan Protestants in a time of crisis, 1919–1922’, in R. Comerford et al., Religion, conflict and coexistence in Ireland (Dublin, 1990); I. d'Alton, ‘Keeping faith: an evocation of the Cork Protestant character, 1820–1920’, in P. O'Flanagan and C. Buttimer, eds., Cork history and society (Dublin, 1997), and his ‘“A vestigial population”? Perspectives on Southern Irish Protestants in the twentieth century’, Eire-Ireland, 44 (Winter 2009–10); Hart, P., The IRA & its enemies, 1916–1923 (Oxford, 1998)Google Scholar, and The IRA at war, 1916–1923 (Oxford, 2003); Bowen, Kurt, Protestants in a Catholic state: Ireland's privileged minority (Dublin, 1983)Google Scholar, and Magahey, Alan, The Irish Protestant churches in the twentieth century (London, 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 For a few examples see Genet, Jacqueline, ed., The Big House in Ireland: reality and representation (Savage, Md., 1991)Google Scholar; Rauchbauer, Otto, ed., Ancestral voices: the Big House in Anglo-Irish literature: a collection of interpretations (Dublin, 1992)Google Scholar; Kreilkamp, Vera, The Anglo-Irish novel and the Big House (Syracuse, NY, 1998)Google Scholar; Valerie Pakenham, The Big House in Ireland, with special photography by Thomas Pakenham (London, 2000).

12 E.g. Foster, R. F., W. B. Yeats: a life (2 vols., Oxford, 1997–2003)Google Scholar; Kennedy, Séan, ed., Beckett and Ireland (Cambridge, 2010)Google Scholar; F. O'Toole, ‘Bringing Synge back in from a curious cold’, Irish Times, 12 June 2010, p. 8. For Yeats's attitude see also Moynahan, Julian, Anglo-Irish: the literary imagination in a hyphenated culture (Princeton, NJ, 1994), pp. 199–200Google Scholar.

13 Morris, Catherine, Alice Milligan and the Irish cultural revival (Dublin, 2012)Google Scholar; and Cliff, B. and Grene, N., Synge and Edwardian Ireland (Oxford, 2012)Google Scholar; and the two important books by Fitzpatrick, David, ‘Solitary and wild’: Frederick MacNeice and the salvation of Ireland (Dublin, 2011)Google Scholar, and The Orange: Protestant brotherhood in Ireland since 1795 (Cambridge, forthcoming). See also Gemma Clark's unpublished work, ‘Fire, boycott, threat and harm: social and political violence within the local community: a study of three Munster counties during the Irish Civil War, 1922–1923’ (D.Phil. thesis, Oxford, 2011).

14 Daly, Mary, ‘Irish nationality and citizenship since 1922’, Irish Historical Studies, 32 (2001), pp. 337–407CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Bew, Paul, Ireland: the politics of enmity, 1789–2006 (Oxford, 2007)Google Scholar.

16 Gibney, John, The shadow of a year: the 1641 Rebellion in Irish history and memory (Madison, WI, forthcoming)Google Scholar. See also McBride, I., The siege of Derry in Ulster Protestant mythology (Dublin, 1997)Google Scholar, and Claydon, Tony and McBride, Ian, eds., Protestantism and national identity: Britain and Ireland, c. 1650 – c. 1850 (Cambridge, 1998)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 On these episodes see Lewis, Gwynne, Second Vendée: the continuity of Counter-Revolution in the department of the Gard, 1789–1815 (Oxford, 1978)Google Scholar; Fitzpatrick, David, Catholic royalism in the Gard, 1814–1852 (Cambridge, 2003)Google Scholar; and the comparative Joseph Ruane, ‘After conflict: Protestant identity in the Gard today’, in Philip Benedict, Hugues Daussy, and Pierre-Olivier Léchot, eds., Histoire, mémoire et identités en mutation: les Huguenots en France et en diaspora (XVIe–XXe siècles) (Paris, 2010).

18 Jenkins, B., Irish nationalism and the British state: from Repeal to revolutionary nationalism (Montreal and London, 2006), p. 135Google Scholar; see also Kerby A. Miller, ‘The lost world of Andrew Johnston: sectarianism, social contact, and cultural change in Southern Ireland during the pre-Famine era’, in James S. Donnelly and Kerby A. Miller (eds.), Irish popular culture, 1650–1850 (Dublin and Portland, OR, 1998), pp. 222–41; Bartlett, Thomas, The fall and rise of the Irish nation: the Catholic question, 1690–1830 (Dublin, 1992)Google Scholar; and McConnel, J.. ‘Remembering the 1605 Gunpowder Plot in Ireland, 1606–1920’, Journal of British Studies, 50 (2011), pp. 863–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Hoppen, K. T., Elections, politics and society in Ireland, 1832–1885 (Oxford, 1984)Google Scholar, and Ireland since 1800: conflict and conformity (London, 1989).

20 Mitchel, John, The last conquest of Ireland, (perhaps) (Glasgow, 1860)Google Scholar, and The history of Ireland: from the Treaty of Limerick to the present time (Dublin, 1869). For modern interpretations, see A. J. P. Taylor, ‘Genocide: a review of The great hunger by Cecil Woodham-Smith (1962)’, in idem, Essays in English history (London, 1976), pp. 73–9; and Nally, D. P., Human encumbrances: political violence and the Great Irish Famine (Notre Dame, IN, 2011)Google Scholar. For two examples of landlords (one Protestant, the other Catholic) committed to Famine relief, see Brian Casey, ‘Land, politics and religion on the Clancarthy estate, East Galway, 1851–1914’ (Ph.D. thesis, NUI Maynooth, 2012), and Aidan Enright, ‘The political life of Charles Owen O'Conor, 1860–1906’ (Ph.D. thesis, Queen's University Belfast, 2012).

21 Kissane, B., New beginnings:constitutionalism & democracy in modern Ireland (Dublin, 2011)Google Scholar, pp. 21–2.

22 Hart, , The IRA & its enemiesGoogle Scholar, and The IRA at war. For some controversies at the level of popular and public history, see the media coverage generated by Murphy, Gerard, The year of disappearances: political killings in Cork, 1921–1922 (Dublin, 2010)Google Scholar, for example Eoghan Harris, Irish Examiner, 5 Nov. 2010, and Caoimhe Nic Dháibháid, Irish Times, 11 Dec. 2010, and the correspondence on the burning of the Ballyconree Protestant Orphanage in West Cork in 1922, particularly Niall Meehan in Irish Times, 20 Jan. 2012, p. 12. For the latest academic development in this diatribe, see Fitzpatrick, D. (ed.) Terror in Ireland, 1916–1923 (Dublin, 2012)Google Scholar; Regan, John, ‘The Bandon valley massacre as a historical problem’, History, 97 (2012), pp. 70–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar : idem, ‘Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde: “the two histories”’, History Ireland, 20 (2012), pp. 10–15.

23 See leading articles, ‘Criminal madness’, Irish Independent, issues of 26 Apr. – 4 May 1916, p. 2, and ‘The clemency plea’, Irish Independent, 10 May 1916, p. 2.

24 McDowell, R. B., The Irish Convention, 1917–1918 (Dublin, 1970)Google Scholar, and The Church of Ireland 1869–1969 (Dublin, 1975).

25 Cit. in ‘Parliament and the church’, Irish Times, 16 Mar. 1923, p. 9.

26 Kreilcamp, V., The Anglo-Irish novel and the Big House (Syracuse, NY, 1998)Google Scholar; Corcoran, N., Elizabeth Bowen: the enforced return (Oxford, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Foster, John Wilson, Irish novels, 1890–1940: new bearings in culture and fiction (Oxford, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Ian d'Alton, ‘The last Big House: perspectives from Lennox Robinson and Elizabeth Bowen’, unpublished paper read to the Royal Irish Academy's Committee for Irish Literatures in English Conference ‘The Big House in twentieth-century Irish writing’, 14–15 Oct. 2008. For a survey, see Genet, , The Big House in IrelandGoogle Scholar.

27 Dooley, T., The decline of the Big House in Ireland: a study of Irish landed families, 1860–1960 (Dublin, 2000)Google Scholar.

28 Dooley, T., ‘The land for the people’: the land question in independent Ireland (Dublin, 2004), pp. 18–19, 57–9Google Scholar. Even after the Hogan Act, the landed minority retained a comparatively strong position: the census of 1926 indicated that ‘Protestants who made up only 8.4 per cent of the population of the Free State, owned 28 per cent of the farms over 200 acres in size’ (ibid., p. 45).

29 Craig is a little-studied figure who deserves a fresh reappraisal. The two existing biographies – Ervine, St John Greer, Craigavon, Ulsterman (London, 1949)Google Scholar, and Buckland, P., James Craig: Lord Craigavon (Dublin, 1980)Google Scholar – are not only limited in scope, but also clearly dated. The most important work on his tenure in office is Buckland, P., The factory of grievances: devolved government in Northern Ireland, 1921–1939 (Dublin, 1979)Google Scholar.

30 E.g. Fitzpatrick, D., Politics and Irish life, 1913–1921: provincial experience of war and revolution (Dublin, 1977)Google Scholar; P. Bew, ‘Sinn Fein, agrarian radicalism and the war of independence, 1919–1921’, in D. G. Boyce, ed., The revolution in Ireland, 1879–1923 (London, 1988), and ‘The national question, land and “revisionism”: some reflections’, in D. G. Boyce and A. O'Day, eds., The making of modern Irish history: revisionism and the revisionist controversy (London, 1996); Hart, , The I.R. A. and its enemiesCrossRefGoogle Scholar; Campbell, F., Land and revolution: nationalist politics in the west of Ireland, 1891–1921 (Oxford, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Jackson, A., Ireland, 1798–1998: politics and war (Oxford, 1999), p. 213Google Scholar.

32 Kerby A. Miller, ‘The lost world of Andrew Johnston’, in J. S. Donnelly and K. A. Miller, eds., Popular culture in Ireland, 1650–1850 (Dublin, 1998).

33 For Miller's views, see his classic ‘Presbyterianism and “modernization” in Ulster’, Past & Present, 80 (1978), pp. 66–90, and his more recent ‘Did Ulster have a devotional revolution?’, in J. H. Murhpy, ed., Evangelicals and Catholics in nineteenth-century Ireland (Dublin, 2005), pp. 38–54.

34 d'Alton, I., Protestant society and politics in Cork, 1812–1844 (Cork, 1980)Google Scholar.

35 Farry, M., The aftermath of Revolution: Sligo, 1921–1923 (Dublin, 2000)Google Scholar.

36 M. Moffitt, ‘Protestant tenant farmers and the land league’, in Carla King and Conor McNamara, eds., The west of Ireland: new perspectives on the nineteenth century (Dublin, 2011).

37 Niamh Gallagher, ‘“Greater Ireland” and the making and unmaking of an inclusive Irish national identity 1914–1919’ (Cambridge Ph.D. thesis, to be submitted in 2013).

38 Peter Martin, ‘Unionism: the irish nobility and revolution, 1919–1923’, in J. Augusteijn, ed., The Irish Revolution, 1913–1923 (Basingstoke and New York, NY, 2002), p. 162.

39 d'Alton, Ian, ‘Southern Irish Unionism: a study of Cork Unionists: the Alexander Prize Essay’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th ser., 23 (1973), pp. 71–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘Cork Unionism: its role in parliamentary and local elections, 1885–1914’', Studia Hibernica, 15 (1975), pp. 143–61; Ruane, Joseph and Butler, David, ‘Identity, difference and community in Southern Irish Protestantism: The Protestants of West Cork’, National Identities, 11 (2009), p. 74Google Scholar.

40 Fitzpatrick, Politics, p. 48; Campbell, F., The Irish establishment, 1879–1914 (Oxford, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 Nord, P., The Republican moment: the struggle for democracy in nineteenth-century France (Cambridge, MA, 1995)Google Scholar; Chatterjee, N., The making of Indian secularism: empire, law and Christianity (New York, NY, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On these themes, see Kuru, A. T., Secularism and state policies toward religion: the United States, France, and Turkey (Cambridge, 2009), pp. 136–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Martin, P., Censorship in the two Irelands 1922–1939 (Dublin, 2006), p. 213Google Scholar.

43 Walsh, Pat, The curious case of the Mayo librarian (Cork, 2009), p. 66Google Scholar.

44 Memoirs of Senator James G. Douglas: concerned citizen, ed. J. Anthony Gaughan (Dublin, 1998).

45 See for example Fitzpatrick, D., ed., The Feds: an account of the Federated Dublin Voluntary Hospitals, 1961–2005 (Dublin, 2006)Google Scholar; and Whiteside, L. with Whiteside, A., Where Swift and Berkeley learnt: a history of Kilkenny College (Dublin, 2009)Google Scholar.

46 See the collection of testimonies in Murphy, C. and Adair, L., eds., Untold stories: Protestants in the Republic of Ireland (Dublin, 2002)Google Scholar.

47 T. Dooley, ‘Monaghan Protestants in a time of crisis, 1919–1922’, in R.Comerford et al., Religion, conflict and coexistence in Ireland (Dublin, 1990), and idem, The plight of Monaghan Protestants, 1912–1926 (Dublin, 2000).

48 Deák, István, Beyond nationalism: a social and political history of the Habsburg officer corps, 1848–1918 (Oxford and New York, NY, 1990)Google Scholar.

49 O'Byrne, R., The biography of an Irish gentleman (Dublin, 2010)Google Scholar.

50 Tobin, Robert, The minority voice: Hubert Butler and Southern Irish Protestantism, 1900–1991 (Oxford, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

51 Alfred Webb in a private letter, 22 June 1886, quoted in Regan-Lefebrvre, J., Cosmopolitan nationalism in the Victorian empire: Ireland, India and the politics of Alfred Webb (London, 2009), pp. 92–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.