Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T05:28:44.714Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

POLITICS IN SCHOOLGIRL DEBATING CULTURES IN ENGLAND, 1886–1914

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 October 2019

HELEN SUNDERLAND Open the ORCID record for HELEN SUNDERLAND [Opens in a new window]
HELEN SUNDERLAND*
Affiliation:
University of Cambridge
*
Corpus Christi College, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, CB2 1RH [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Debating was an important part of schoolgirls’ political education in late Victorian and Edwardian England that has been overlooked in the scholarship on female education and civics instruction. Debates offered middle- and working-class schoolgirls an embodied and interactive education for citizenship. Considering both the content of discussions and the process of debating, this article argues that school debates provided a unique opportunity for girls to discuss political ideas and develop political skills. Debates became intertwined with girls’ peer cultures, challenging contemporary and historiographical assumptions of girlhood apoliticism. Positioning girls as political subjects sheds new light on political change in modern Britain. Schoolgirl debates show how gendered political boundaries were shifting in this period. Within the unique space of the school debating chamber, girls were free to appropriate and subvert ‘masculine’ political subjects and ways of speaking. In mock parliaments, schoolgirls re-created the archetypal male political space of the House of Commons, demonstrating their familiarity with parliamentary politics. Schoolgirl debates therefore foreshadowed initiatives that promoted women's citizenship after partial suffrage was achieved in 1918, and they help to explain how the first women voters were assimilated easily into existing party and constitutional politics.

Type
Article
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 63 , Issue 4 , September 2020 , pp. 935 - 957
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

I would like to thank Dr Ben Griffin for his helpful comments on an earlier version of this article. I am grateful to the archivists at North London Collegiate School, Manchester High School for Girls, Wimbledon High School, and Notting Hill and Ealing High School for their assistance.

References

1 Holton, Sandra Stanley, Feminism and democracy: women's suffrage and reform politics in Britain, 1900–1918 (Cambridge, 1986)Google Scholar; Purvis, June and Holton, Sandra Stanley, eds., Votes for women (London, 2000)Google Scholar; Pugh, Martin, The march of the women: a revisionist analysis of the campaign for women's suffrage, 1866–1914 (Oxford, 2000)Google Scholar; Law, Cheryl, Suffrage and power: the women's movement, 1918–1928 (London, 1997)Google Scholar; Gottlieb, Julie V. and Toye, Richard, eds., The aftermath of suffrage: women, gender, and politics in Britain, 1918–1945 (Basingstoke, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Walker, Linda, ‘Party political women: a comparative study of Liberal women and the Primrose League, 1890–1914’, in Rendall, Jane, ed., Equal or different: women's politics, 1800–1914 (Oxford, 1987), pp. 165–91Google ScholarPubMed; Collette, Christine, For Labour and for women: the Women's Labour League, 1906–1918 (Manchester, 1989)Google Scholar; Thackeray, David, ‘Home and politics: women and Conservative activism in early twentieth-century Britain’, Journal of British Studies, 49 (2010), pp. 826–48CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

3 Law, Suffrage and power, pp. 112–15; Pat Thane, ‘The impact of mass democracy on British political culture, 1918–1939’, in Gottlieb and Toye, eds., Aftermath of suffrage, pp. 54–69.

4 Childs, Michael, ‘Labour grows up: the electoral system, political generations, and British politics, 1890–1929’, Twentieth Century British History, 6 (1995), pp. 123–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Pugh, Martin, Women and the women's movement in Britain, 1914–1999 (2nd edn, Basingstoke, 2000), pp. 66–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jarvis, David, ‘Mrs Maggs and Betty: the Conservative appeal to women voters in the 1920s’, Twentieth Century British History, 5 (1994), pp. 129–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Purvis, June, ‘The Women's Party of Great Britain (1917–1919): a forgotten episode in British women's political history’, Women's History Review, 25 (2016), pp. 638–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Wallbank, M. V., ‘Eighteenth century public schools and the education of the governing elite’, History of Education, 8 (1979), pp. 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Holt, Jenny, Public school literature, civic education and the politics of male adolescence (Aldershot, 2008), p. 31Google Scholar.

7 Vincent, David, Literacy and popular culture: England, 1750–1914 (Cambridge, 1989), pp. 259–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rose, Jonathan, The intellectual life of the British working classes (London and New Haven, CT, 2001), pp. 58–91Google Scholar.

8 Wiggins, Sarah, ‘Gendered spaces and political identity: debating societies in English women's colleges, 1890–1914’, Women's History Review, 18 (2009), pp. 737–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Formative works in the field include Fletcher, Sheila, Feminists and bureaucrats: a study in the development of girls’ education in the nineteenth century (Cambridge, 1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hunt, Felicity, ed., Lessons for life: the schooling of girls and women, 1850–1950 (Oxford, 1987)Google Scholar; Purvis, June, Hard lessons: the lives and education of working-class women in nineteenth-century England (Cambridge, 1989)Google Scholar; Gomersall, Meg, Working-class girls in nineteenth-century England: life, work and schooling (Basingstoke, 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For isolated references to schoolgirl debates, see Avery, Gillian, The best type of girl: a history of girls’ independent schools (London, 1991), pp. 259–60Google Scholar; Kean, Hilda, Deeds not words: the lives of suffragette teachers (London, 1990), p. 7Google Scholar.

10 Heathorn, Stephen J., For home, country, and race: constructing gender, class, and Englishness in the elementary school, 1880–1914 (Toronto and London, 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Keating, Jenny, ‘Approaches to citizenship teaching in the first half of the twentieth century: the experience of the London County Council’, History of Education, 40 (2011), pp. 761–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Yeandle, Peter, Citizenship, nation, empire: the politics of history teaching in England, 1870–1930 (Manchester, 2015)Google Scholar.

11 Wright, Susannah, ‘Creating liberal-internationalist world citizens: League of Nations Union junior branches in English secondary schools, 1919–1939’, Paedagogica Historica (2018), pp. 1–20Google Scholar.

12 Dyhouse, Carol, Girls growing up in late Victorian and Edwardian England (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

13 Gomersall, Working-class girls, pp. 78–122.

14 Dyhouse, Girls growing up, pp. 41–2.

15 Sutherland, Gillian, ‘Education’, in Thompson, F. M. L., ed., The Cambridge social history of Britain, 1750–1950 (3 vols., Cambridge, 1990), iii, pp. 119–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at pp. 141–52.

16 Catherine Sloan, ‘The school magazine in Victorian England’ (D.Phil. thesis, Oxford, 2019).

17 Magazines and records from the schools cited in this article are held at the North London Collegiate School (NLCS) Archive, Notting Hill and Ealing High School Archives, Wimbledon High School Archives, and Central Foundation Girls’ School Archive. The records of the City of London School for Girls are held at the London Metropolitan Archives (CLA/054/B/02/001–005). For references to an earlier, short-lived debating society at NLCS, see K. G. B., ‘The conversation class’, Our Magazine (OM), no. 5 (Apr. 1877), pp. 112–13; ‘Editorial’, OM, 3 (July 1878), p. 47.

18 Magazines from Manchester High School for Girls cited in this article are held at the Manchester High School for Girls Archive.

19 ‘Schools’, Journal of Education, 296 (Mar. 1894), p. 230; ‘Schools’, Journal of Education, 322 (May 1896), p. 311; Major, Edith Helen, ‘History’, in Burstall, Sara A. and Douglas, M. A., eds., Public schools for girls: a series of papers on their history, aims, and schemes of study (London, 1911), pp. 85–96Google Scholar, at p. 95; Sondheimer, Janet and Bodington, P. R., eds., The Girls’ Public Day School Trust, 1872–1972: a centenary review (London, 1972), p. 84Google Scholar.

20 Shuttleworth, Sally, The mind of the child: child development in literature, science, and medicine, 1840–1900 (Oxford, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Reporter, M.H.S.D.S., ‘M. H. S. debating society’, Manchester High School Magazine (MHSM), 2 (Dec. 1886), p. 122.

22 E. Read, ‘The N. L. C. S. G. debating society’, OM, 13 (Mar. 1888), p. 29; Ally Tchaykovsky, ‘Debating society’, OM, 19 (Nov. 1894), pp. 144–5; Margaret Morgan-Jones, ‘Debating society’, OM, 33 (June 1908), p. 67.

23 Biagini, Eugenio F., British democracy and Irish nationalism, 1876–1906 (Cambridge, 2007), p. 89CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Reporter, M.H.S.D.S., ‘M. H. S. debating society’, p. 122.

25 Morgan, Simon, A Victorian woman's place: public culture in the nineteenth century (London, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gleadle, Kathryn, Borderline citizens: women, gender and political culture in Britain, 1815–1867 (Oxford, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Richardson, Sarah, The political worlds of women: gender and politics in nineteenth century Britain (New York, NY, and London, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Rogers, Rebecca, ‘Porous walls and prying eyes: control, discipline, and morality in boarding schools for girls in mid-nineteenth-century France’, in Maynes, Mary Jo, Søland, Birgitte, and Benninghaus, Christina, eds., Secret gardens, satanic mills: placing girls in European history, 1750–1960 (Bloomington, IN, 2005), pp. 115–30Google Scholar, at pp. 123–7.

27 Livingstone, David N., ‘Keeping knowledge in site’, History of Education, 39 (2010), pp. 779–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 784.

28 Brown, Heloise, ‘The truest form of patriotism’: pacifist feminism in Britain, 1870–1902 (Manchester, 2003), p. 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29 ‘Debating society’, MHSM, 2 (Nov. 1888), p. 269; NLCS debating society minutes book, 1887–1890 (spring term 1890); M. H. Jemmett, ‘The debate club’, Wimbledon High School Magazine (WHSM), 10 (Mar. 1899), p. 39; NLCS debating society minutes book, 1891–1899 (Christmas term 1899); Doris M. Levy, ‘Form notes: form Lower IV’, Central Foundation Girls’ School Magazine (CFGSM), 1 (Mar. 1904), p. 78; Gladys Miall Smith, ‘Debating society’, OM, 32 (Oct. 1907), p. 103; ‘The debating society’, Magazine of the City of London School for Girls (MCLSG), 12 (Dec. 1908), pp. 37–8; M. E. Lewis, ‘The debate club’, WHSM, 20 (Apr. 1909), p. 29.

30 Florence Anders, ‘Debating society’, OM, 24 (Mar. 1899), pp. 39–41; Margaret Morgan-Jones, ‘Debating society’, OM, 33 (Feb. 1908), pp. 26–8.

31 Pleasance E. Johnson, ‘The debating society’, Notting Hill High School Magazine (NHHSM), 20 (Mar. 1904), p. 37; ‘The debating society’, MCLSG, 8 (Dec. 1904), p. 47; Noel Hearn, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 24 (Mar. 1908), p. 31; M. Maizels, ‘Form notes: form IVB’, CFGSM, 1 (July 1909), p. 443; M. E. Lewis, ‘The debate club’, WHSM, 21 (Apr. 1910), p. 28; Hilda Bodley, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 27 (Mar. 1911), p. 37; Olive Eglington, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 28 (Mar. 1912), p. 30; ‘The debating society’, MCLSG, 16 (Apr. 1912), pp. 2–10.

32 Catherine Hall and Sonya O. Rose, eds., At home with the empire: metropolitan culture and the imperial world (Cambridge, 2006).

33 Mangan, J. A., ed., ‘Benefits bestowed’? Education and British imperialism (Manchester, 1988)Google Scholar; English, Jim, ‘Empire Day in Britain, 1904–1958’, Historical Journal, 49 (2006), pp. 247–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 H. Lee, ‘Debating society’, OM, 21 (Nov. 1896), pp. 117–19; Nona Byrne, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 25 (Mar. 1909), pp. 33–4; Levy, ‘Form notes: form Lower IV’, p. 78.

35 See for example, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 10 (Mar. 1894), p. 40; Gladys Miall Smith, ‘Debating society’, OM, 32 (Oct. 1907), pp. 104–5.

36 Read, ‘N. L. C. S. G. debating society’, pp. 29–30; Monica Curtis, ‘Debating society’, OM, 35 (Mar. 1910), p. 29; ‘The debating society’, MCLSG, 14 (Mar. 1910), pp. 7–9; Fanny Levine, ‘Form notes: form IVB’, CFGSM, 21 (Apr. 1910), p. 492.

37 Trentmann, Frank, Free trade nation: commerce, consumption, and civil society in modern Britain (Oxford, 2008), p. 2Google Scholar; Thackeray, David, ‘Rethinking the Edwardian crisis of conservatism’, Historical Journal, 54 (2011), pp. 191–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at pp. 194–9.

38 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1900–1909 (midsummer term 1900); H. Macdonald, ‘Report of debating society’, WHSM, 16 (Apr. 1905), p. 25; Marjorie Bailhache, ‘Debating society’, OM, 31 (Feb. 1906), pp. 30–1; D. Chick, ‘The debating society’, NHHSM, 22 (Mar. 1906), p. 33; E. J. G. Kirkwood, ‘The literary and debating society’, MCLSG, 11 (Mar. 1907), pp. 4–5; W. Todd, ‘Form notes: form IVB’, CFGSM, 1 (Apr. 1907), p. 277; Hearn, ‘Debating society’, p. 31; M. E. Lewis, ‘The debate club’, WHSM, 19 (Apr. 1908), p. 41; Clara Birnberg, ‘Form notes: form VB’, CFGSM, 1 (July 1908), pp. 373–4; May Parsley, ‘Debating society’, OM, 34 (Nov. 1909), pp. 120–2.

39 Kean, Deeds not words; Oram, Alison, Women teachers and feminist politics, 1900–1939 (Manchester, 1996)Google Scholar.

40 Ruby C. Allen, ‘Form notices: VB’, MCLSG, 15 (Mar. 1911), p. 6.

41 H. Macdonald, ‘Debating society’, WHSM, 13 (Mar. 1902), pp. 31–2.

42 ‘N. L. C. S. G. debating society’, OM, 14 (Mar. 1889), pp. 38–9; X. Y. Z., ‘Our parliamentary debate’, OM, 18 (Mar. 1893), pp. 29–31.

43 Gladys Miall Smith, ‘Debating society’, OM, 32 (Oct. 1907), p. 104.

44 Eglington, ‘Debating society’, p. 30.

45 ‘Fifth and Fourth Form discussion society’, City of London School Magazine, 4 (June 1880), London Metropolitan Archives, CLA/053/03/01/004, p. 117.

46 ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 30 (Mar. 1914), p. 29.

47 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1887–1890 (spring term 1887).

48 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1900–1909 (Christmas term 1907).

49 For example, see ‘School debates’, Schoolmistress, 65 (6 Nov. 1913), p. 108.

50 ‘On being up-to-date’, Teachers’ Aid (TA), 26 (11 June 1898), pp. 259–60.

51 J. B. T., ‘A scholars’ literary and debating society’, TA, 47 (30 Jan. 1909), p. 432; ‘The day's difficulties: oral composition wrinkles’, Woman Teacher's World (WTW), 8 (15 Nov. 1911), p. 294.

52 ‘The day's difficulties: subjects for debate’, WTW, 8 (31 Jan. 1912), p. 622.

53 ‘School debates’, p. 108.

54 ‘School entertainments’, TA, 22 (19 Sept. 1896), pp. 593–4. This article summarizes the preceding entertainment debates. One further debate was published that year: E. Wilkes Smith, ‘Debate for children's entertainment’, TA, 23 (26 Dec. 1896), pp. 296–8.

55 ‘The day's difficulties: school debates’, WTW, 8 (15 Nov. 1911), p. 295.

56 Reporter, M.H.S.D.S., ‘M. H. S. debating society’, p. 121.

57 Griffin, Emma, ‘The making of the Chartists: popular politics and working-class autobiography in early Victorian Britain’, English Historical Review, 129 (2014), pp. 578–605CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

58 Meisel, Joseph S., Public speech and the culture of public life in the age of Gladstone (New York, NY, 2002), pp. 11–49Google Scholar; Hoegaerts, Josephine, ‘Speaking like intelligent men: vocal articulations of authority and identity in the House of Commons in the nineteenth century’, Radical History Review, 121 (2015), pp. 123–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at pp. 125–6.

59 Goldman, Lawrence, Science, reform, and politics in Victorian Britain: the Social Science Association, 1857–1886 (Cambridge, 2002), pp. 115–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 Balfour, Lady Frances, Ne obliviscaris: dinna forget (2 vols., London, 1930), ii, p. 138Google Scholar.

61 C. Birnberg, ‘Form notes: form IVB’, CFGSM, 1 (July 1906), p. 229.

62 A girl in form Lower V, ‘Debating’, WHSM, 12 (Apr. 1901), p. 25.

63 Wiggins, ‘Gendered spaces’, pp. 740, 745.

64 W. R. Richmond, ‘A teachers’ parliamentary debating society’, TA, 8 (13 Apr. 1889), pp. 33–5.

65 M. A. Turner, ‘Debating society’, OM, 20 (July 1895), p. 64.

66 Mumford, Edith E. Read, Through rose-coloured spectacles: the story of a life (Leicester, 1952), p. 26Google Scholar.

67 Light, Alison, Forever England: femininity, literature and conservatism between the wars (London, 1991), pp. 210–12Google Scholar.

68 Gladys Miall Smith, ‘Debating society’, OM, 32 (June 1907), p. 66.

69 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1900–1909 (spring term 1905); NLCS debating society minutes book, 1891–1899 (Christmas term 1895).

70 ‘Notting Hill High School debating society’, NHHSM, 9 (Mar. 1893), pp. 39–40.

71 ‘The day's difficulties: school debates’, WTW, 8 (15 May 1912), p. 1100.

72 M. H. Jemmett, ‘Debate club’, WHSM, 1 (Dec. 1889), p. 15.

73 Winifred Taylor, ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 15 (Mar. 1899), p. 38.

74 ‘Debating society’, NHHSM, 30 (Mar. 1914), p. 29.

75 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1887–1890 (spring term 1887).

76 Hanham, H. J., Elections and party management: politics in the time of Disraeli and Gladstone (London, 1959), p. 105Google Scholar; Davis, John W., ‘Working-class make-believe: the South Lambeth Parliament (1887–1890)’, Parliamentary History, 12 (1993), pp. 249–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

77 Matthew, H. C. G., ‘Rhetoric and politics in Great Britain, 1860–1950’, in Waller, P. J., ed., Politics and social change in modern Britain: essays presented to A. F. Thompson (Brighton, 1987), pp. 34–58Google Scholar.

78 Wiggins, ‘Gendered spaces’, p. 748.

79 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1887–1890 (midsummer term 1888).

80 ‘The debating society’, OM, 13 (Nov. 1888), pp. 113–14.

81 Ibid., p. 113; ‘N. L. C. S. G. debating society’, p. 39.

82 Margaret A. Turner, ‘The debating society’, OM, 20 (Nov. 1895), pp. 105–8.

83 Lois Biddle, ‘Form notes: form IVA’, CFGSM, 1 (Dec. 1909), p. 469.

84 Red Tape, ‘Quintessence of parliament’, MCLSG, 20 (July 1916), pp. 36–9.

85 Wilford F. Field, ‘A school parliament’, TA, 16 (20 May 1893), pp. 186–7. For further instalments, see TA, 16 (27 May 1893), pp. 202–3; TA, 16 (3 June 1893), pp. 218–19.

86 ‘Parliament in school’, TA, 31 (9 Mar. 1901), p. 547; TA, 32 (8 June 1901), p. 227.

87 ‘Interesting lessons: the children's parliament’, WTW, 8 (14 Feb. 1912), p. 700.

88 NLCS debating society minutes book, 1887–1890 (midsummer term 1888).

89 Thompson, James, ‘“Pictorial lies”? Posters and politics in Britain, c.1880–1914’, Past & Present, 197 (2007), pp. 177–210CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 194.

90 This is evident from the first parliamentary debate, ‘The debating society’, OM, 13 (Nov. 1888), pp. 113–14.

91 Read Mumford, Through rose-coloured spectacles, p. 22.

92 X. Y. Z., ‘Our parliamentary debate’, p. 31.

93 Rogers, ‘Porous walls and prying eyes’, p. 126.

94 Hon. Secretary, ‘The Sodalitas debating society’, CFGSM, 1 (Dec. 1907), p. 318.

95 Janet Evans, ‘Oddments’, CFGSM, 1 (Apr. 1910), pp. 488–9.

96 Philo, Chris, ‘“The corner-stones of my world”: editorial introduction to special issue on spaces of childhood’, Childhood, 7 (2000), pp. 243–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.