Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T05:52:09.809Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Nonconformity and Electoral Sociology, 1867–1918

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

D. W. Bebbington
D. W. Bebbington
Affiliation:
University of Stirling
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Patterns of voting in Britain between the second Reform Act of 1867 and the Franchise Act of 1918 have to be scrutinized afresh in the light of Dr Dunbabin's recent suggestion that very little changed in the period. The electoral profile of the regions, he argues, remained fundamentally constant from well before the period until well afterwards. The basis of the cleavage between conservative and anti-conservative voters was deeply ingrained in regional character and was merely modified slowly by processes of social change, of which the chief was the sprawling growth of London. This is to challenge earlier views holding that there was a deep-seated shift in the allegiance of the electorate in the years before the first World War. Of such views the most carefully worked out is that of Dr Clarke. The cleavage between the conservative and the anti-conservative at the beginning of the period, according to Dr Clarke, was founded on the gulf between different communities of which the primary social bond was religion. The confrontation between conservative and liberal corresponded to, and was the political expression of, that between church and chapel. By the end of the period, however, the basis of cleavage was no longer religion but class. Conservative strength was sapped by a tendency to working-class solidarity which at first benefited the liberals more than the infant labour party and which explains the two liberal general election victories of 1910. The social base of the parties had been transformed so that the electoral conflict was no longer a matter of ‘cultural politics’ – a rivalry of contrasted, classless cultural units – but a matter of class politics. Dr Clarke asserts what Dr Dunbabin denies, that there is a sharp discontinuity between the characteristic pattern of nineteenth-century politics and the characteristic pattern of twentieth-century politics.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 27 , Issue 3 , September 1984 , pp. 633 - 656
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Dunbabin, J. P. D., ‘British elections in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries: a regional approach’, English Historical Review, xcv (1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Clarke, P. F., ‘Electoral sociology of modern Britain’, History, LVII (1972)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Pelling, Henry, Social geography of British elections, 1885–1910 (London, 1967)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Glaser, J. F., ‘English nonconformity and the decline of liberalism’, American Historical Review, LXIII (1958)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Koss, Stephen, Nonconformity in modern British politics (London, 1975)Google Scholar. Further evidence on the nonconformist-liberal link is offered in Bebbington, D. W., The nonconformist conscience: chapel and politics, 1870–1914 (1982)Google Scholar.

6 Birch, A. H., Small-town politics: a study of political life in Glossop (London, 1959), pp. 18–28, 176Google Scholar.

7 Yeo, Stephen, Religion and voluntary organisations in crisis (London, 1976), pp. 105Google Scholar f.

8 Meller, Helen, Leisure and the changing city, 1870–1914 (London, 1976), pp. 91 4Google Scholar.

9 Garrard, J. A., ‘Parties, members and voters after 1867: a local study’, The Historical Journal, XX (1977)Google Scholar.

10 Joyce, Patrick, Work, society and politics: the culture of the factory in later Victorian England (London, 1980), pp. 174–9, 240–50Google Scholar.

11 Bell, P. M. H., Disestablishment in Ireland and Wales (London, 1969), pp. 96–109Google Scholar. Simon, Alan, ‘Church disestablishment as a factor in the general election of 1885’, The Historical Journal, XVIII (1975)Google Scholar.

12 Hurt, J. S., Schooling and the working classes, 1860–1918 (London, 1979), pp. 75–98Google Scholar.

13 Cf. Joyce, , Work, society and politics, p. 206Google Scholar.

14 Minutes of the Shropshire Baptist Association, 13 and 14 June 1881.

15 Ibid. 5 and 6 June 1882, 6 and 7 Nov. 1882, 9 and 10 Nov. 1885.

16 The Freeman, 27 Nov. 1885, p. 791.

17 The Christian World, 12 Oct. 1893, p. 781.

18 Bebbington, D. W., ‘Baptist M.P.s in the nineteenth century’, The Baptist Quarterly, XXIX, 1 (01 1981), 8, 20–3Google Scholar.

19 The social world of nonconformity, at least in its upper echelons, is best illustrated by Binfield, Clyde, So down to prayers: studies in English nonconformity, 1780–1820 (London, 1977)Google Scholar.

20 Edwards, Maldwyn, Methodism and England: a study of methodism in its social and political aspects during the period 1850–1932 (London, 1943), p. 168Google Scholar.

21 Gowland, D. A., Methodist secessions: the origins of free methodism in three Lancashire towns (Manchester, 1979)Google Scholar.

22 Hempton, D. N., ‘The methodist crusade in Ireland, 1795–1845’, Irish Historical Studies, XXII (1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Ibid. pp. 45 f. Machin, G. I. T., Politics and the churches in Great Britain, 1832 to 1868 (Oxford, 1977), pp. 208–28Google Scholar.

24 Vincent, John, Pollbooks: how Victorians voted (Cambridge, 1967), p. 18Google Scholar.

25 Dr J. H. Rigg to W. E. Gladstone, 26 Mar. 1883; Telford, John, The life of James Harrison Rigg, D.D., 1821–1909 (London, 1909), pp. 292Google Scholar f.

26 Obelkevich, James, Religion and rural society: South Lindsey, 1825–1875 (Oxford, 1976, p. 211Google Scholar. Gowland, , Methodist secessions, p. 133Google Scholar.

27 The Daily Mews, 13 July 1886, p. 3.

28 Moore, Robert, Pit-men, preachers and politics: the effects of methodism in a Durham mining community (Cambridge, 1974), pp. 155–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29 Standard, 11 Nov. 1868, cited by Hanham, H. J., Elections and party management: politics in the time of Disraeli and Gladstone (London, 1959), p. 212Google Scholar.

30 Obelkevich, Religion and rural society, p. 151.

31 The Christian World, 26 Mar. 1891, p. 251.

32 [Hayes, Thomas], Methodism in 1879: impressions of the Wesleyan Church and its ministers (London, 1879), pp. 89–110Google Scholar.

33 Clarke, Lancashire and the new liberalism, pp. 402 ff.

34 Ibid. pp. 404 f.

35 Holden, Isaac and Hargreaves, J. R. to editor, The Daily News, 12 07 1886, p. 3Google Scholar. ‘An ardent Wesleyan’ to editor, ibid. 13 July 1886, p. 3. Isaac Holden and J. R. Hargreaves to W. E. Gladstone, 17 July 1886; Hargreaves to Gladstone, 22 July 1886, Add. MS 44498, fos. 225, 252, Gladstone papers, British Library.

36 The Daily News, 15 Apr. 1887, p. 2.

37 The Methodist Times, 7 Apr. 1887, enclosed in SirChubb, G. H. to Salisbury, Lord, 19 05 1887Google Scholar, Salisbury papers, Hatfield House.

38 SirChubb, G. H. to editor, The Times, 14 04 1887, p. 3Google Scholar.

39 The Times, 9 05 1887, p. 9Google Scholar. Cranfield, W. T. [‘Denis Crane’], The life-story of Sir Robert W. Perks, Bart., M.P. (London, 1909), p. 169Google Scholar.

40 Ibid. p. 99.

41 Sir G. H. Chubb to Lord Salisbury, 19 May 1887, Salisbury papers, Hatfield House.

42 The Times, 23 May 1887, p. 12.

43 The Times, 3 June 1887, p. 5.

44 Kent, John, The age of disunity (London, 1966)Google Scholar.

46 The Times, 3 June 1887, p. 5. Cutting from Truth, 3 June 1887, Chubb Collectanea, IX, 195 (by kind permission of Lord Hayter).

46 The Liberal Unionist, 27 Apr. 1887, p. 70.

47 The Times, 3 June 1887, p. 9.

48 Ibid. 3 June 1887, p. 5.

49 Who was Who, 1897–1916 (London, 1920), p. 73Google Scholar.

50 The Christian World, 10 Dec. 1885, p. 929.

51 The Liberal Unionist, Apr. 1890, p. 177; Apr. 1891, p. 179. The Times, 1 Feb. 1896, p. 9. The Daily News, 14 June 1892, p. 5. The Christian World, 16 June 1892, p. 490.

52 The British Weekly, 18 Mar. 1909, p. 645. The Christian World, 26 Sep. 1895, p. 728.

53 Hamer, D. A., Liberal politics in the age of Gladstone and Rosebery (Oxford, 1972), pp. 182 ffGoogle Scholar.

54 Bompas, H. M. to editor, The Times, 2 02 1894, p. 10Google Scholar.

55 Cutting from The Northern Whig, 21 May 1892, Chubb Collectanea, X, 36.

56 Bompas, to editor, The Times, 2 02 1894, p. 10Google Scholar.

57 Ibid.

58 The Times, 5 Dec. 1893, p. 10.

59 Hanham, Elections and party management, p. 225. Cf. Thompson, Paul, Socialists, liberals and labour: the struggle for London (London, 1967), p. 20Google Scholar.

60 Perkins, J. P. to editor, The British Weekly, 1 08 1895, p. 238Google Scholar.

61 The Christian World, 6 Nov. 1902, p. 22.

62 Blewett, Neal, The peers, the parties and the people (London, 1972), pp. 343–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Glaser, , ‘English nonconformity and the decline of liberalism’, American Historical Revievj, LXIII (1958), 360 fGoogle Scholar.

64 Yeo, Religion and voluntary organisations, pp. 106 f.

65 Joyce, Work, society and politics, pp. 339 f.

66 Ostrogorski, Moisei, Democracy and the organization of political parties, trans. Clarke, Frederick (London, 1902), 1, 621Google Scholar.

67 Perkins, J. P. to editor, The British Weekly, 1 08 1895, p. 238Google Scholar.

68 The Daily News, 27 May 1886, p. 6.

69 Wiener, C. Z., ‘The beleaguered isle: a study of Elizabethan and early Jacobean anti-catholicism’, Past and Present, LI (1971), 27–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 The Britisg Weekly, 18 Mar. 1909, p. 644.

71 Minutes of the Methodist Conference 1886, p. 312.

72 The Times, 15 Nov. 1888, p. 6.

73 Lord Wolmer to W. E. Ball, 23 Oct. 1888, Nonconformist Unionist Association papers, Public Record Office of Northern Ireland, D 2396/1/15.

74 Balfour, : The Times, 9 05 1889, p. 10Google Scholar. Chamberlain, : The Times, 14 07 1892, p. 7Google Scholar.

75 Bebbington, Nonconformist conscience, pp. 102 f.

76 The British Weekly, 1 Aug. 1895, p. 227.

77 The British Weekly, 14 Apr. 1892, p. 408; 20 Sep. 1894, p. 339.

78 Lord Wolmer to W. E. Ball, 10 Oct. 1888, Nonconformist Unionist Association papers, Pùblic Record Office of Northern Ireland, D 2396/1/11.

79 The British Weekly, 7 Mar. 1907, p. 583.

80 The Christian World, 19 Jan. 1911, p. 1.

81 The British Weekly, 28 July 1898, p. 247.

82 Pelling, , Social geography, p. 163Google Scholar. Dr Pelling draws attention to the swing among nonconformist voters in Cornwall, though doubting whether it was a ‘nonconformist vote’ as such: ibid. p. 432.

83 Jalland, Patricia, The liberals and Ireland: the Ulster question in British politics to 1914 (Brighton, 1980), pp. 88 ffGoogle Scholar.

84 McCullagh, Thomas, Sir William McArthur, K.C.M.G. (London, 1891), p. 213Google Scholar.

85 Sir G. H. Chubb to Lord Salisbury, 19 May 1887, Salisbury papers, Hatfield House. The Christian World, 18 Apr. 1895, p. 294.

86 Caine, W. S. to editor, The Times, 20 05 1887, p. 5Google Scholar.

87 The Liberal Unionist, 25 May 1887, p. 136.

88 Chubb to Salisbury, 19 May 1887, Salisbury papers, Hatfield House.

89 National Liberal Club collection of election addresses (1892) II.

90 The Times, 10 July 1895, p. 8.

91 The Christian World, 27 Jan. 1910, p. 11.

92 Barrett, G. S., ‘The secularisation of the church’, Congregational Yearbook, 1895, pp. 45 ffGoogle Scholar.

93 Jacks, L. P., The confession of an octogenarian (London, 1942), p. 153Google Scholar.

94 The Christian World, 10 Mar. 1892, p. 187.

95 The British Weekly, 1 Apr. 1897, p. 426.

96 The British Weekly, 16 Feb. 1893, p. 273.

97 Thomas Richardson to Sir G. H. Chubb, 1 Dec. 1897, Lord Hayter's personal collectanea, 1893–1900, p. 188. The Christian World, 24 May 1900, p. 3. The British Weekly, 8 Aug. 1895, p. 246.

98 Wesleyan methodist church, Chislehurst, A.D. 1870–A.D. 1920 (Chislehurst, 1920)Google Scholar.

99 The Christian World, 11 Nov. 1909, p. 3.

100 Bebbington, , Nonconformist conscience, pp. 141Google Scholar, 147 ff.

101 Ibid. p. 113. Koss, Stephen, ‘Wesleyanism and empire’, The Historical Journal XVIII (1975)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 Harvie, Christopher, The lights of liberalism: university liberals and the challenge of democracy, 1860–86 (London, 1976)Google Scholar.

103 Shannon, R. T., Gladstone and the Bulgarian agitation 1876 (London, 1963), pp. 188 ffGoogle Scholar.

104 Hanham, , Elections and party management, pp. 103 f.Google Scholar, 325 ff.

105 Matthew, H. C. G. et al. ‘The franchise factor in the rise of the labour party’, English Historical Review, XCI (1976), 750 ffGoogle Scholar.

106 Clarke, P. F., ‘Liberals, labour and the franchise’, English Historical Review, XCI (1977), 584, 589Google Scholar.

107 Johnson, R. W., ‘The nationalisation of English rural politics: Norfolk South West, 1945–1970’, Parliamentary Affairs, XXVI (1972–1973)Google Scholar.

108 Bealey, Frank et al. , Constituency politics: a study of Newcastle-under-Lyme (London, 1965), p. 257Google Scholar. Jones, R. T., Congregationalism in England, 1662–1962 (London, 1962), p. 425nGoogle Scholar. Miller, W. L. and Raab, Gillian, ‘The religious alignment at English elections between 1918 and 1970’, Political Studies, XXV (1977), 231CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 Morgan, K. O., Rebirth of a nation: Wales, 1880–1980 (Oxford, 1981), p. 193Google Scholar.

110 I am grateful for critical comments on this article to Professor R. H. Campbell, Dr M. C. W. Hunter, Dr I. G. C. Hutchison and Mr J. P. Parry.