Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T17:02:52.513Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Macmillan and the wind of change in Africa, 1957–1960*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Ritchie Ovendale
Ritchie Ovendale
Affiliation:
University of Wales, Aberystwyth
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Based on the recently released documents in the Public Record Office, London, this article is concerned with examining the reasons behind the shift in the British approach towards decolonization in Africa signalled by Macmillan's ‘wind of change’ speech to the South African parliament on 3 February 1960. The documents suggest that the British decision to abdicate in Africa was partly due to international considerations, and to Cold War politics and the need to prevent Soviet penetration in Africa. The change from ‘multi-racialism’ to ‘non-racialism’ can be attributed to the influence of the commonwealth relations office under Lord Home, and an initiative from the leader of the Africa Capricorn society, David Stirling. The emphasis on the need for Britain to pursue the same policy in all of Africa can also be traced to the commonwealth relations office. Macmillan, himself was influenced by the ‘moral’ aspect, by the policies pursued by the Belgians in the Congo, but above all by the failure of French policy in Algeria.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 38 , Issue 2 , June 1995 , pp. 455 - 477
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 David, Goldsworthy, Colonial issues in British politics 1945–1961 (Oxford, 1971), pp. 360–3Google Scholar. Miller, J. D. B., Survey of commonwealth affairs. Problems of expansion and attrition (London, 1974), pp. 112–4Google Scholar, argues a similar case.

2 Robert, Holland, The pursuit of greatness. Britain and the world role, 1900–1970 (London, 1991), pp. 296–8Google Scholar; see also Robert, Holland, ‘The imperial factor in British strategies from Attlee to Macmillan, 1945–63’, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, XII (1984), 165–86Google Scholar;

3 Hargreaves, John D., Decolonization in Africa (London, 1988), pp. 186–7.Google Scholar

4 John, Darwin, Britain and decolonisation. The retreat from empire in the post-war world (London, 1988), p. 223Google Scholar; Porter, A. N. and Stockwell, A. J., British imperial policy and decolonization, II, 1951–64 (London, 1989), 29–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

5 Darwin, , Britain and decolonisation, pp. 222–78.Google Scholar

6 Holland, , The pursuit of greatness, pp. 295–6.Google Scholar

7 P. R. (56) 1, note by secretary of cabinet on cabinet policy review, secret, 4 June 1956, London, Public Record Office (P. R. O.), CAB. 134/1315.

8 P. R. (56)II, note by Eden on assumptions for future planning, top secret, 15 June 1956, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1315.

9 Minute from H. Poynton to Lennox-Boyd, 5 July 1956, P. R. O., CO. 1025/76.

10 C. M. (3)57, secret, 8 Jan. 1957, P. R. O. CAB. 128/30 pt. 2, fos. 788–91.

11 Jebb to Lloyd, tel. no. 102, confidential, 27 Apr. 1957 r. 28 Apr. 1957; de Zulueta to Macmillan, 29 May 1957, P. R. O., PREM. 11/1844.

12 WU 1072/288, Steel to Lloyd, tel. no. 188, confidential, 17 July 1957, P. R. O., PREM. 11/1844.

13 C. C. 22(57), secret, 22 Mar. 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 128/31 pt. 1, fo. 171.

14 C. C. 76(57)2, secret, 28 Oct. 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 128/31 pt. 2, fo. 526.

15 Cmnd. 124, Defence: outline of future policy (Apr. 1957).

16 British documents on the end of empire, series B, I, Ghana, pt. II, 1952–1957, Richard, Rathbone ed. (London, 1992), 346–50, 370–4.Google Scholar

17 C. P. C. (57)6, colonial policy committee and future constitutional development in the colonies, secret, 25 Feb. 1957, enclosing Macmillan to Salisbury, 28 Jan. 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1555; Morgan, D. J., The official history of colonial development, v, Guidance towards self-government in British colonies, 1941–1971 (London, 1980), 58–60, 96–7.Google Scholar

18 GEN. 174/012, future constitutional development in the colonies, colonial office print, secret, May 1957; C. P. (O)(57)2nd. mtg., cabinet official committee on colonial policy, secret, 5 June 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1552.

19 C. P. (O) (57)6, cabinet official committee on colonial policy, note by the secretaries on future constitutional development in the colonies, secret, 4 July 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1556.

20 C. P. C. (57)30(revise), report by chairman of the official committee on colonial policy to the colonial policy committee on future development in the colonies, secret, 6 Sept. 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1556.

21 C. C. 76(57), secret, 28 Oct. 1957, P. R. O., CAB. 128/31 pt. 2, fo. 525.

22 Home to Lloyd, top secret, 21 May 1958, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2689

23 P. M./59/72, Lloyd to Macmillan, secret, June 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2587.

24 A. F. (59) 1st. mtg., cabinet Africa official committee, secret, 14 Jan. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

25 A. F.(59)2nd. mtg., secret, 21 Jan. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

26 A. F.(59)5th. mtg., secret, 20 Feb. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

27 A. F.(59)6th. mtg., secret, 2 Mar. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

28 A. F.(59)7th. mtg., secret, 6 Mar. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

29 A. F.(59)6, note by commonwealth relations office for the Africa official committee on the next ten years in Africa, secret, 9 Jan. 1959; annex, memorandum, secret, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

30 A. F.(59)8th. mtg., secret, 7 Apr. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

31 A. F.(59)9th. mtg., secret, 9 Apr. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1353.

32 P. F. de Zulueta to T. J. Bligh, I July 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2587.

33 A. F.(59)37, comments by the chiefs of staff on ‘Africa: the next ten years’, secret, 10 July 1959, P. R. O, CAB. 134/1355.

34 This summary of ‘Africa; the next ten years’ is based on the versions given to the French and the Americans. See A. F.(59)41, secret, 30 Oct. 1959 attaching ‘Africa: the next ten years’, May 1959, for the version shown to the Americans which omitted two paragraphs and amended a further six out of 105, P. R. O, CAB. 134/1355. See also J1079/38, ‘Africa: the next ten years’, version handed to the French, secret, undated (file dated 8 Dec. 1959), P. R. O, F. O. 371/137974.

35 Brian, Lapping, End of Empire (London, 1985), pp. 478–83Google Scholar; Alistair, Home, Macmillan 1057–1086 (London, 1989), pp. 180–1.Google Scholar

36 T164/591 T. J. Bligh to D. L. Cole, 14 July 1959, enclosing note for record of mtg. between Macmillan, Lennox-Boyd, Perth, and Brook on 13 July 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2783.

37 Nigel, Fisher, Harold Macmillan (London, 1982), p. 218.Google Scholar

38 GEN. 688/2nd mtg., Kenya Hola detention camp, secret, 9 June 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 130/164; C. C. 43(59)1, secret, 20 July 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 128/33, fos. 278–80.

39 Fisher, , Harold Macmillan, p. 218Google Scholar; Porter and Stockwell British imperial policy and decolonization, II, 513; Kirkman, W. P., Unscrambling an empire. A critique of British colonial policy 1956–1966 (London, 1966), p. 51.Google Scholar

40 Harold, Macmillan, Pointing the way 1959–1961 (London, 1972), pp. 135–9Google Scholar; Horne, , Macmillan 1957–1986, PP. 182–3.Google Scholar

41 Harold, Macmillan, Riding the storm 1956–1959 (London, 1971), p. 748.Google Scholar

42 Horne, , Macmillan 1957–1986, p. 177.Google Scholar

43 Macleod to Macmillan, 25 May 1959; David Stirling to Macmillan, 26 May 1959 enclosing memorandum by Stirling on a policy for East and Central Africa, 20 May 1959; Note for record by T.J. Bligh, confidential, 10(?) June 1959 of mtg. between Macmillan, Home and Sterling, 11 June 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2583. See Alan, Hoe, David Stirling. The authorised biography of the founder of the SAS (London, 1992), pp. 284–8, 318–9.Google Scholar

44 38/59, Home to Macmillan, 29 May 1959; record by Home of conversation between Home and Nkrumah during Home's visit to Ghana, 1 June 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2588.

45 41/59, Home to Macmillan, 3 June 1959 enclosing outline of statement on colonial policy in Africa, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2588.

46 50/59, Home to Macmillan, 22 June 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2583; GEN. 688/5, memorandum by Home on constitutional development in Africa, 25 June 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 130/164.

47 Kenneth, Young, Sir Alec Douglas-Home (London, 1970), p. 113Google Scholar; Nigel, Fisher, Iain Macleod (London, 1973), pp. 141–2.Google Scholar

48 Goldsworthy, , Colonial issues in British politics, p. 362.Google Scholar

49 A. F. (M)(59)1, cabinet Africa committee, 21 Oct. 1959, P. R. O, CAB. 134/1362.

50 A. F. (M)(59)2, note by Home of a discussion with Whitehead on constitutional changes, 13 Nov. 1959, P. R. O, CAB. 134/1362.

51 C. C. 57(59)2, secret, 10 Nov. 1959, P. R. O, CAB. 128/33, fo. 359.

52 C. C. 60(59)8, secret, 26 Nov. 1959, P. R. O, CAB. 128/33, fos. 383–4.

53 Macmillan to Brook, I Nov. 1959, quoted by Horne, , Macmillan 1957–1986, p. 185.Google Scholar

54 A. F. (59)42, report on a visit to Washington and Ottawa to discuss African affairs, confidential, 21 Dec. 1959, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1355.

55 P. M. (59)65, Macleod to Macmillan, 29 Dec. 1959, P. R. O., PREM. 11/2586.

56 C. (60)66, note by Norman Brook on Macmillan's African tour, secret, 5 Apr. 1960, P. R. O, CAB. 129/100. Detailed accounts can be found in Macmillan, Pointing the way, pp. 116–77; Home, , Macmillan 1957–1986, pp. 186–200.Google Scholar

57 Macmillan, , Pointing the way, p. 156.Google Scholar

58 Fisher, , Harold Macmillan, p. 237.Google Scholar

59 C. P. C. (60)2nd mtg., secret, 18 Mar. 1960, P. R. O., CAB. 134/1559.