Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T18:38:30.871Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Dedominionization: the Anglo-Australian experience, 1939–1945

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Kosmas Tsokhas
Kosmas Tsokhas
Affiliation:
Australian National University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The role of decolonization in the decline of the British empire has received a great deal of attention. In comparison there has been little research or analysis of the process of dedominionization affecting Australia and the other dominions. During the Second World War economic ties were seriously weakened and there were substantial conflicts over economic policy between the British and Australian governments. Australia refused to reduce imports in order to conserve foreign exchange, thus contributing to the United Kingdom's debt burden. The Australian government insisted that the British guarantee Australia's sterling balances and refused to adopt the stringent fiscal policies requested by the Bank of England and the British treasury. Australia also took the opportunity to expand domestic manufacturing industry at the expense of British manufacturers. Economic separation and conflict were complemented by political and strategic differences. In particular, the Australian government realized that British military priorities made it impossible for the United Kingdom to defend Australia. This led the Australians towards a policy of cooperating with the British embargo on Japan, only to the extent that this would be unlikely to provoke Japanese military retaliation. In general, the Australians preferred a policy of compromise in the Far East to one of deterrence preferred by the British.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 37 , Issue 4 , December 1994 , pp. 861 - 883
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 John, Darwin, Britain and decolonisation: the retreat from empire in the post war world (London, 1988), pp. 44–7.Google Scholar

2 Hancock, W. K. and Gowing, M. M., British war economy (London, 1949), p. 103.Google Scholar

3 Ibid.

4 Beloff, Max, Wars and welfare (London, 1984), p. 254.Google Scholar

5 Meaney, N. K., A history of Australian defence and foreign policy (Sydney, 1976), pp. 2–3.Google Scholar

6 Schedvin, C. B., Australia and the great depression (Melbourne, 1988), p. 100.Google Scholar

7 T (treasury, Public Record Office, London) 160/1041/F16320/01. ‘Australia’ Kershaw.

8 T160/1041/F16320/01. Interview with Mr Casey, 23 Nov. 1939.

9 T160.1041/F16320/01. ‘24 Nov. 1939’.

10 Ibid.

11 Ibid.

12 T160/1041/F16320/01. Sir Frederick Phillips to B. G. Catterns, 30 Nov. 1939.

13 Ibid.

14 T160/1041/F16320/01. Sir Frederick Phillips, 2 Dec. 1939.

15 For this paragraph see Tsokhas, K., ‘S. M. Bruce, imperial relations and war finance, 1939–1943’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 49, 4 (1990), pp. 442–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

16 AA (Australian Archives, Canberra) A571, 39/2485, pt 1. Governor, Commonwealth Bank to S. G. McFarlane, 23 Oct. 1939.

17 AA A571, 39/2485, Pt 1. R. G. Menzies to high commissioner for the UK, 23 Oct. 1939.

18 Ibid.

19 T177/52. Note, F.P.

20 Ibid.

21 T177/52. Sir Frederick Phillips to S. D. Waley, 28 Feb. 1940.

22 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Sept. 1939. 21 Sept. 1939, Japan.

23 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Oct. 1939. R. A. Butler to S. M. Bruce, 14 Oct. 1939.

24 Ibid.

25 Ibid.

26 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Dec. 1939. The Rt. Hon. R. A. Butler, foreign office, 1 Dec. 1939.

27 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Dec. 1939. Telegram sent (in cypher) to Mr Bruce from the prime minister, Canberra, 7 Dec. 1939.

28 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Feb. 1940. Decypher of telegram received from the prime minister. Addressed to the high commissioner, 4 Mar. 1940.

29 DO (dominions office, Public Record Office, London) 35/1034. Minutes of meeting held at the ministry of economic warfare on 20 Mar. 1940.

30 DO 35/1034. Decypher, Sir R. Craigie, 26 Mar. 1940.

31 DO 35/1034. Extract from W.M. (40) 97th Conclusions, Minute 12, Friday 19 Apr.

32 Ibid.

33 DO 35/1034. Soviet German Trade; DO 35/1034. Note by Mr Holmes.

34 DO 35/1027. Sir Frederick Phillips to S. M. Bruce, 14 Feb. 1940.

35 DO 35/1027. Sir Geoffrey Whiskard to Viscount Caldecote, 27 Sept. 1940.

36 AA 1973/363, F39, Pt 1. Sir Frederick Philips to S. M. Bruce, 7 Mar. 1940.

37 T160/1343/F16. W. Fraser to J. R. Willis, 2 Dec. 1940.

38 Ibid.

39 Ibid.

40 For the above material including quotations see T160/1343/F16. C. F. Cobbold to S. D. Waley, 6 Dec. 1940.

41 T160/1343/F16775/2. Australia, Feb. 1941.

42 Ibid.

43 DO 35/1027. War Finances: Commonwealth Conversion of Commonwealth Stock.

44 Butlin, S. J., War economy, 1939–45 (Canberra, 1955), p. 430.Google Scholar

45 DO 35/1027. Decode of telegram from Dalton, Sydney, 4 Sept. 1941.

46 Tsokhas, , ‘S. M. Bruce’, pp. 450–3Google Scholar. In fact, for 1941–2 Australia's military spending was reduced to £217,000,000 of which £57,000,000 was spent overseas. This overseas expenditure was met without borrowing from the UK. Most of it was spent on resources provided by the UK. Simultaneously, Australia provided resources valued at £55,000,000 mainly for the US, thus resulting in a virtual balance, and Australia did not have to draw on its sterling balances. See Butlin, , War economy, p. 388.Google Scholar

47 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Jun. 1940. Cablegram sent (recyphered) to External Affairs, 27 Jun. 1940.

48 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Jun. 1940. Telegram sent (in cypher) to External Affairs, 26 Jun. 1940.

48 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Jun. 1940. Cypher telegram to Department of External Affairs, 19 Jun. 1940.

50 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Jul. 1940. Telegram received (in cypher) from prime minister. Addressed to Bruce, Crotonate, 9 Jul. 1940.

51 Ibid.

52 AA CRS M100/XM1, item Mar. 1941. Cablegram received (recyphered) from Australian legation, Tokyo, 7 Mar. 1941.

53 DO 35/1035. Cypher telegram from the government, Commonwealth of Australia to the dominions office, 14 May 1941.

54 DO 35/1036. Cablegram received (recyphered) from Canberra addressed Bruce, Crotonate.

55 Ibid.

56 R. G. Casey, minister to the United Stated to R. G. Menzies, prime minister and to Sir Frederick Stewart, minister for external affairs, 9 Jul. 1941. Document 2 in Hudson, W. J. and Stokes, H. J. W. (eds.), Department of foreign affairs documents on Australian foreign policy, volume V (Canberra, 1982), pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

57 R. G. Casey, minister to the United States to department of external affairs, 26 Jul. 1941. Document 18 in Hudson and Stokes; Australian foreign policy, pp. 26–7.Google Scholar

58 Sir John Latham, minister to Japan to department of external affairs, 29 Jul. 1941. Document 22 in Hudson, and Stokes, , Australian foreign policy, pp. 35–6.Google Scholar

59 Ibid.

60 DO 35/1036. Cypher telegram from dominions office to governments of Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, 22 Jul. 1941.

61 DO 35/1936. Cypher telegram from government, Commonwealth of Australia to dominions office, 25 Jul. 1941.

62 Ibid.

63 Ibid.

64 Ibid.

65 Ibid.

66 DO 35/1036. Cypher telegram dominions office to Australia, 26 Jul. 1941.

67 Ibid.

68 BT (board of trade, Public Record Office, London) 11/1441. Minute sheet, 19 Jul. 1940.

69 BT 11.1478. Oliver Lyttleton to S. M. Bruce, 12 Dec. 1940.

70 BT 11/1441. Minute, 30 Apr. 1941.

71 AA A571, 39/2485. Pt 2. J. B. Brigden, secretary, department of supply and development to secretary, prime minister's department, 6 Feb. 1941.

72 For this paragraph see BT 11/1405. S. F. Ferguson to E. Raymond Street, 5 Aug. 1941.

73 BT 11/1397. Dalton, 25 Nov. 1941.

74 AA AS72, 39/2485, Pt 2. Decypher from secretary of state for dominion affairs, London, received 4 May 1941, and Sydney Morning Herald, 12 May 1941.

75 BT 11/2090. Dalton, 22 Mar. 1943.

76 Boehm, E. A., Twentieth-century economic development in Australia (Melbourne, 1979), pp. 166–7Google Scholar; and Walker, E. R., The Australian economy in war and reconstruction (New York, 1947), pp. 133–54.Google Scholar

77 For this paragraph including the quotations see BT 11/2090. Minute, 12 May 1944.

78 T177/58. Lord Keynes. Our prospective dollar balances, S.D.W. 1 Oct. 1942.

79 T177/58. Kingsley Wood to Henry Morgenthau, 3 Sept. 1943.

80 Ibid.

81 For the above material including quotations see T177/58. Keynes, 13 Mar. 1944.

82 Ibid.

83 AA AS72, 39/2485, Pt 4. Draft telegram to dominions office, 8 Aug. 1945.

84 AA A571, 41/915, Pt 8. Lend-Lease Discussions, H. C. Coombs, 8 Oct. 1945.

85 AA A571, 41/915, Pt 8. Notes of a meeting of the heads of British missions at the British embassy, Saturday, 15 Sept. 1945.

86 AA A571, 41/915A, Pt 10. Washington Discussions on Finance, Lend-lease and Commercial Policy, J. B. Chifley, 13/12/45.

87 Butlin, S. J. and Schedvin, C. B., War economy 1942–1945 (Canberra, 1977), pp. 591–601.Google Scholar